Xbox One S vs Xbox One X: Which Console Reigns Supreme?
Choosing the right Xbox can be a tough decision, especially when comparing two powerhouses like the Xbox One S and the Xbox One X. Both consoles offer access to a vast library of games and entertainment, but their capabilities differ significantly. This comparison dives deep into the specifications, performance, and features of each console to help you make an informed choice.
The Xbox One S, known for its sleek design and affordability, is a great entry point into the Xbox ecosystem. It offers a solid gaming experience with support for HDR and 4K Blu-ray playback. However, the Xbox One X, often touted as the most powerful console ever made at the time, takes things to another level.
The Xbox One X boasts significantly enhanced processing power, resulting in superior graphics, faster loading times, and a smoother overall gaming experience. This comparison aims to explore the key differences between the Xbox One S and the Xbox One X, helping you determine which console best suits your gaming needs and budget. Let’s find out which one is the ultimate champion!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Xbox 1S | Xbox 1X |
|---|---|---|
| CPU | 8-core 1.75 GHz | 8-core 2.3 GHz |
| GPU | AMD Radeon 914 MHz | AMD Radeon 1.172 GHz |
| RAM | 8GB GDDR3 | 12GB GDDR5 |
| Storage | 500GB, 1TB, or 2TB HDD | 1TB HDD |
| 4K Blu-ray Player | Yes | Yes |
| HDR Support | Yes | Yes |
| Native 4K Gaming | No | Yes |
| Video Output | Up to 4K | Up to 4K |
| Audio Output | Dolby Atmos, DTS:X | Dolby Atmos, DTS:X |
| Dimensions | Slimmer Design | Larger Design |
| Wi-Fi | 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac | 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac |
| Controller | Xbox Wireless Controller | Xbox Wireless Controller |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Processing Power (CPU/GPU)
- Xbox 1s: Features a slightly underclocked version of the Xbox One’s CPU and a less powerful GPU. This results in generally lower frame rates and resolution compared to the Xbox One X. It’s a solid entry-level console.
- 1x: Boasts a significantly more powerful custom AMD CPU and GPU, delivering a substantial increase in processing power. This enables native 4K gaming and improved performance in many titles, with higher frame rates and better visual fidelity.
- Winner: 1x
Graphics Resolution
- Xbox 1s: Primarily targets 1080p resolution for gaming, with some games utilizing dynamic resolution scaling. While it can upscale to 4K for video playback, it doesn’t natively render games in 4K.
- 1x: Designed for native 4K gaming, offering a significantly sharper and more detailed image on 4K displays. Many games also benefit from enhanced textures, improved lighting, and other visual upgrades.
- Winner: 1x
HDR Support
- Xbox 1s: Supports HDR (High Dynamic Range) for both gaming and video playback, providing a wider range of colors and improved contrast on compatible displays. This enhances visual fidelity.
- 1x: Also supports HDR, offering the same benefits as the Xbox One S, with the added advantage of higher resolution and visual fidelity due to its more powerful hardware, which enhances the HDR experience.
- Winner: 1x
Disc Drive
- Xbox 1s: Includes a 4K UHD Blu-ray drive, allowing for playback of 4K Blu-ray discs and standard Blu-ray discs, as well as game discs.
- 1x: Also includes a 4K UHD Blu-ray drive, offering the same functionality as the Xbox One S in terms of disc playback.
- Winner: Tie
RAM
- Xbox 1s: Equipped with 8GB of GDDR3 RAM, which is sufficient for running games at its target resolutions but can sometimes be a bottleneck for more demanding titles.
- 1x: Also has 8GB of GDDR5 RAM, providing faster memory access and improved performance compared to the Xbox One S. This allows the 1X to handle more complex game worlds and textures.
- Winner: 1x
Price
- Xbox 1s: Generally more affordable than the Xbox One X, making it a good option for budget-conscious gamers. Prices vary depending on bundles and sales.
- 1x: More expensive than the Xbox One S due to its superior hardware. The price reflects its enhanced performance and 4K capabilities.
- Winner: xbox 1s
Storage
- Xbox 1s: Typically comes with either 500GB or 1TB internal storage, which is adequate for installing games, but may require external storage solutions for larger game libraries.
- 1x: Typically comes with 1TB internal storage, providing ample space for games, apps, and media. Users can still expand storage with external drives.
- Winner: Tie
Design and Size
- Xbox 1s: Slimmer and more compact than the original Xbox One, with a white aesthetic. It has a built-in power supply, making it easier to set up.
- 1x: Slightly larger than the Xbox One S, but still relatively compact. It features a sleek, dark gray design and a built-in power supply.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Performance | Xbox One X |
| Graphics | Xbox One X |
| Value | Xbox One S |
| 4K Gaming | Xbox One X |
| Storage (Default) | Xbox One S (based on available models) |
What They Have in Common
- Game Library: Both consoles can play the same extensive library of games available on the Xbox platform, including access to Xbox Game Pass.
- Xbox Services: Both offer access to Xbox Live services, including online multiplayer, cloud saves, and the Xbox store.
- 4K Blu-Ray: Both consoles feature an integrated 4K Blu-ray player, allowing users to watch 4K movies.
- Hdr Support: Both the Xbox One S and Xbox One X support High Dynamic Range (HDR) for enhanced visuals in games and movies.
- Controller Compatibility: Both consoles use the same Xbox Wireless Controller, ensuring a consistent gaming experience.
Xbox 1S Vs 1X Buying Guide
Performance and Graphics
The Xbox One X boasts significantly superior performance and graphics capabilities compared to the Xbox One S. The One X features a more powerful GPU and CPU, enabling native 4K gaming and enhanced visual fidelity. This results in sharper images, smoother frame rates, and more detailed textures. The One S, while capable of HDR, primarily targets 1080p gaming, making it a less visually impressive experience. Consider your display setup; a 4K TV will benefit greatly from the One X’s capabilities.
Price and Availability
The Xbox One S is generally the more affordable option, often available at a lower price point than the Xbox One X. This makes it a great choice for budget-conscious gamers or those new to the Xbox ecosystem. The One X, being the premium console, comes with a higher price tag. Availability may fluctuate, but the One S is typically easier to find. Consider the cost alongside your budget and desired features to make the best decision.
Game Library and Compatibility
Both the Xbox One S and Xbox One X share the same game library, offering access to the vast selection of titles available on the Xbox platform. This includes both physical discs and digital downloads. However, games run and look better on the Xbox One X. The One X can play games optimized for its enhanced hardware. There are also backward compatibility features, allowing you to play games from previous Xbox generations on both consoles.
Storage and Features
Both consoles come with varying storage options, typically starting at 500GB or 1TB. You can expand the storage of both consoles using external hard drives. The Xbox One X offers a slight advantage in terms of features, including a built-in 4K Blu-ray player. The Xbox One S also includes a Blu-ray player, but it is not 4K. Both consoles support HDR (High Dynamic Range) for enhanced color and contrast on compatible TVs.
Design and Size
The Xbox One S features a slimmer and more compact design compared to the original Xbox One. The Xbox One X, while powerful, is only slightly larger than the One S. Both consoles have a sleek and modern aesthetic. Consider the space you have available for your console and your preference for design when making your choice. Both consoles fit nicely in most entertainment centers.
Future-Proofing and Longevity
The Xbox One X offers a more future-proof gaming experience due to its superior hardware. As games become more demanding, the One X will likely maintain smoother performance and better visuals compared to the One S. However, the One S will still be supported with new game releases for years to come. Consider how long you plan to use the console and your expectations for visual fidelity over time when making your decision.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Xbox One S If…
- You’re on a budget and looking for an affordable entry point into the Xbox ecosystem.
- You don’t have a 4K TV or don’t prioritize native 4K gaming.
- You want a console that’s smaller and more compact.
- You primarily play games casually and aren’t as concerned about top-tier performance.
Buy Xbox One X If…
- You own a 4K TV and want the best possible visual experience.
- You prioritize performance and want faster loading times and higher frame rates.
- You want to experience games at their highest graphical settings.
- You’re willing to invest more for the ultimate Xbox gaming experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between the Xbox One S and Xbox One X?
The primary difference lies in their processing power and graphics capabilities. The Xbox One X offers significantly more powerful hardware, enabling native 4K gaming and enhanced visual fidelity. The Xbox One S is designed for 1080p gaming, although it supports HDR. The One X provides a superior visual experience. The One S offers a more affordable entry point.
Does the Xbox One X require a 4K TV?
While the Xbox One X can benefit from a 4K TV, it doesn’t strictly require one. The console can still upscale games to 4K on a 1080p TV, improving image quality. However, the full impact of the One X’s capabilities is best realized on a 4K display, where you can experience native 4K resolution and HDR.
Are games cross-compatible between the Xbox One S and Xbox One X?
Yes, all games are cross-compatible between the Xbox One S and Xbox One X. You can play the same games on both consoles. The main difference is how the games look and perform. Games optimized for the Xbox One X will run with higher resolution, improved textures, and smoother frame rates on the more powerful console.
Does the Xbox One X have a built-in 4K Blu-ray player?
Yes, the Xbox One X includes a built-in 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray player. This allows you to watch 4K Blu-ray discs in addition to playing games. The Xbox One S also has a Blu-ray player, but it does not support 4K. This is one of the key differences in features between the two consoles.
Is the Xbox One S a good console for beginners?
Yes, the Xbox One S is an excellent console for beginners. It’s more affordable, making it a great entry point into the Xbox ecosystem. It offers access to the same vast game library as the One X, and it’s easy to set up and use. It provides a solid gaming experience without breaking the bank.
Can I upgrade the storage on both consoles?
Yes, you can upgrade the storage on both the Xbox One S and Xbox One X. Both consoles support external hard drives connected via USB. This allows you to easily expand the storage capacity and store more games and media. This is especially useful as game sizes continue to grow.
Which console is better for HDR gaming?
Both the Xbox One S and Xbox One X support HDR (High Dynamic Range) for enhanced color and contrast on compatible TVs. However, the Xbox One X offers a superior HDR experience due to its more powerful hardware. The One X can render HDR content with greater detail and accuracy, resulting in a more vibrant and immersive visual experience.
Final Verdict
The Xbox One X is the clear winner for gamers seeking the best possible visual experience. Its superior processing power and 4K capabilities offer a significant upgrade over the Xbox One S. While the One S remains a solid budget-friendly option, the One X delivers a more future-proof gaming experience, especially for those with 4K TVs. The One S is still a great console for those on a budget or those not prioritizing the best graphics.
Winner: Xbox One X