Tesla Model X vs Model S: Which Tesla Should You Buy?
Choosing your first or next electric vehicle can be a thrilling yet daunting experience, especially when you’re looking at top-tier options like those from Tesla. The brand has revolutionized the automotive industry, and two of its most popular models often top the list: the Tesla Model X and the Tesla Model S.
Both offer incredible performance, cutting-edge technology, and the undeniable appeal of zero-emission driving. But which one is right for you? This comparison dives deep to explore the key differences and similarities between the Model X and Model S, helping you make an informed decision.
We’ll examine everything from their design and features to their performance capabilities and pricing. Whether you prioritize space and versatility or sleek design and blistering speed, this guide on the Tesla Model X vs Model S will provide valuable insights.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Model X | Model S |
|---|---|---|
| Body Style | SUV | Sedan |
| Seating Capacity | 5, 6, or 7 passengers | 5 passengers |
| 0-60 mph (Performance) | 2.5-3.8 seconds (depending on configuration) | 1.9-3.1 seconds (depending on configuration) |
| Range (EPA est.) | 269-335 miles (depending on configuration) | 320-394 miles (depending on configuration) |
| Cargo Space (Behind 2nd Row) | 37.1 cu ft | 28 cu ft |
| Autopilot Features | Standard | Standard |
| Infotainment Screen | 17-inch touchscreen | 17-inch touchscreen |
| Supercharger Network | Compatible | Compatible |
| Suspension | Adaptive Air Suspension | Adaptive Air Suspension |
| Falcon Wing Doors | Yes | No |
| Frunk (Front Trunk) | Yes | Yes |
| Drag Coefficient | 0.24 Cd | 0.208 Cd |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Seating Capacity
- Tesla Model X: Offers seating for up to seven passengers with optional third-row seating. Provides ample space for families and a more versatile interior layout. However, the third row can be a bit cramped for adults.
- Model S: Typically seats five passengers, with an optional rear-facing child seat configuration in older models. More focused on passenger comfort and rear legroom than maximum capacity.
- Winner: Model X
Cargo Space
- Tesla Model X: Features a large cargo area with the rear seats folded down, and a front trunk (frunk). Offers significantly more cargo volume overall, making it ideal for hauling luggage and larger items.
- Model S: Also includes a trunk and a frunk, but with less overall cargo capacity than the Model X. The focus is on a sleek design, so cargo capacity is sacrificed.
- Winner: Model X
Falcon Wing Doors
- Tesla Model X: Equipped with distinctive Falcon Wing doors that open upwards. Provide easy access to the second and third rows, especially in tight parking spaces. However, they can be slow to open and close and may have issues in certain weather conditions.
- Model S: Has traditional doors. Offers a more conventional and arguably simpler door system.
- Winner: Model S
Acceleration
- Tesla Model X: Depending on the trim, offers impressive acceleration, but often slightly slower than the Model S due to its heavier weight. Still delivers exhilarating performance.
- Model S: Known for its blistering acceleration, especially in the Plaid trim. Consistently one of the fastest accelerating production cars on the market.
- Winner: Model S
Range
- Tesla Model X: Generally has a lower range compared to the Model S due to its larger size and weight. Range varies depending on the battery configuration.
- Model S: Offers a longer driving range, especially in the Long Range trim. Provides greater distance on a single charge, ideal for road trips.
- Winner: Model S
Price
- Tesla Model X: Typically has a higher starting price than the Model S due to its larger size, unique features, and more complex manufacturing.
- Model S: Usually comes with a lower starting price, making it a more accessible option for some buyers.
- Winner: Model S
Handling and Ride Quality
- Tesla Model X: While still agile, the Model X’s higher center of gravity and weight can make it feel less sporty than the Model S. The ride is comfortable but can feel a bit more boat-like.
- Model S: Offers a more planted and responsive driving experience. Provides superior handling and a sportier feel.
- Winner: Model S
Aerodynamics
- Tesla Model X: The larger size and unique door design may compromise aerodynamic efficiency. This can impact range and energy consumption.
- Model S: Designed with a focus on aerodynamics, resulting in a sleeker profile and reduced drag. Contributing to improved efficiency and range.
- Winner: Model S
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Cargo Space | Model X |
| Seating Capacity | Model X |
| Performance (Acceleration) | Model S |
| Range | Model S |
| Aerodynamics | Model S |
| Unique Features | Model X (Falcon Wing Doors) |
What They Have in Common
- Electric Powertrain: Both vehicles are fully electric, eliminating tailpipe emissions and offering instant torque.
- Supercharger Compatibility: Both the Model X and Model S are compatible with Tesla’s Supercharger network for fast and convenient charging on the go.
- Advanced Technology: Both vehicles boast Tesla’s advanced Autopilot features, including adaptive cruise control, lane keeping, and automatic emergency braking, alongside a large central touchscreen.
- Over-the-Air Updates: Both cars receive regular over-the-air software updates, improving features and performance over time.
- Premium Interior: Both models offer premium interior materials and a minimalist design aesthetic, focusing on a driver-centric experience.
Tesla Model X Vs Model S Buying Guide
Performance and Range
Both the Tesla Model X and Model S offer exceptional performance, but with some key differences. The Model S generally boasts quicker acceleration in its top-tier trims, making it a thrill to drive. The Model X, being heavier due to its SUV design, might experience slightly slower acceleration, although it still provides impressive speed. Regarding range, both vehicles offer competitive distances on a single charge. However, the exact range varies depending on the battery configuration and driving conditions. The Model S often has a slight edge in range due to its more aerodynamic design, potentially leading to fewer charging stops on long journeys.
Interior and Comfort
The interiors of the Model X and Model S are both luxurious and technologically advanced, featuring minimalist designs and large touchscreen displays. The Model X offers a more spacious cabin, particularly in the rear, with the option of a third row of seats, making it a better choice for larger families or those needing extra passenger capacity. The Model S, while comfortable, prioritizes a sleeker, more streamlined interior. Both vehicles provide premium materials and a comfortable ride. Consider how much passenger space and cargo capacity you require when deciding between the two.
Technology and Features
Tesla is renowned for its cutting-edge technology, and both the Model X and Model S are packed with advanced features. Both vehicles include Autopilot and Full Self-Driving capabilities, offering advanced driver-assistance systems. The large central touchscreen controls most vehicle functions, providing a seamless and intuitive user experience. The Model X introduces the unique Falcon Wing doors, which are a defining feature that provides ease of access, especially in tight parking spaces. The Model S offers a more conventional door design, favoring practicality in certain situations. Both cars also feature over-the-air software updates.
Practicality and Utility
The Model X excels in practicality due to its SUV body style. The Falcon Wing doors provide easy access to the second and third rows, and the larger cargo area offers more storage space, making it ideal for families and those needing to haul cargo. The Model S, while still practical, is a sedan, so it offers less cargo capacity and requires more effort to load larger items. The Model S’s lower profile might be advantageous in terms of handling and maneuverability in urban environments. Consider your daily needs and how you plan to use the vehicle when assessing practicality.
Charging and Infrastructure
Tesla’s Supercharger network is a significant advantage for both the Model X and Model S. The extensive network of fast-charging stations makes long-distance travel relatively convenient. Both vehicles can charge at Supercharger stations, and the charging times are comparable. Home charging is also an option, allowing you to charge your vehicle overnight. The availability of charging infrastructure, both public and at home, is a key factor to consider when buying an electric vehicle. Tesla continues to expand its Supercharger network, improving the charging experience for all its vehicles.
Price and Value
The Model S and Model X are both premium vehicles, and their prices reflect their advanced technology, performance, and features. The Model X typically comes with a higher price tag due to its SUV design and additional features like the Falcon Wing doors. The Model S provides a slightly more affordable entry point into the Tesla experience. When evaluating value, consider the features, performance, and practicality that best align with your needs and budget. Both vehicles offer excellent value for their performance and the benefits of the Tesla ecosystem, including access to the Supercharger network.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Model X If…
- You need the versatility of a larger vehicle with more cargo space.
- You require seating for more than five passengers.
- You value the unique and eye-catching Falcon Wing doors.
- You frequently transport passengers and need easy access to the second and third rows.
Buy Model S If…
- You prioritize performance and handling.
- You prefer the sleek, aerodynamic design of a sedan.
- You want a longer driving range.
- You desire a slightly more efficient vehicle in terms of energy consumption.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the key differences between the Model X and Model S?
The primary differences lie in their body styles and intended uses. The Model X is an SUV with Falcon Wing doors, offering more interior space and cargo capacity, while the Model S is a sedan prioritizing performance and a sleeker design. The Model S often has slightly better range and acceleration in some configurations. Both vehicles share Tesla’s advanced technology and access to the Supercharger network.
Which car is better for families?
The Model X is generally a better choice for families. Its SUV design provides more passenger space, especially in the second and third rows, and the larger cargo area is ideal for luggage and gear. The Falcon Wing doors offer easy access to the rear seats, which is particularly helpful when loading children or car seats. The Model S is suitable for families, but it offers less space.
How does the range compare between the two models?
The range varies depending on the specific battery configuration and driving conditions. Generally, the Model S might have a slight advantage in range due to its more aerodynamic design. However, the differences are often minimal. Always check the EPA estimates for the specific model and trim you are considering for the most accurate information.
What about performance and acceleration?
Both models offer impressive performance and acceleration. The Model S often boasts quicker acceleration in its top-tier trims, making it a thrilling driving experience. The Model X, due to its heavier weight, might have slightly slower acceleration, though it is still very fast. The performance depends on the trim and motor setup.
Are the Falcon Wing doors practical?
The Falcon Wing doors of the Model X are a distinctive feature, offering unique advantages. They provide easy access to the second and third rows, even in tight parking spaces. They can be less convenient in areas with low ceilings. The doors are a statement and add to the vehicle’s personality but may not be as practical in all situations.
What about charging infrastructure?
Both models benefit from Tesla’s Supercharger network, offering convenient fast-charging options. The widespread availability of Supercharger stations makes long-distance travel relatively easy. You can also charge both vehicles at home using a standard outlet or a dedicated wall connector. The Supercharger network is constantly expanding, improving accessibility.
Which car is more expensive?
The Model X typically commands a higher price tag than the Model S. The price difference reflects the SUV body style, the Falcon Wing doors, and the larger interior space. The Model S provides a slightly more affordable entry point into the Tesla experience while still offering premium features and performance. Consider your budget and the features you value most.
Final Verdict
Choosing between the Tesla Model X and Model S depends heavily on individual needs and priorities. The Model X offers superior practicality, especially for families, with its spacious interior and Falcon Wing doors. The Model S prioritizes performance and a sleeker design, often with a slightly longer range. Both vehicles provide exceptional technology and access to the Supercharger network. Consider your needs for passenger space, cargo capacity, and driving preferences.
Winner: Model X