Tesla Model S vs X: Which Electric Vehicle Reigns Supreme?
Choosing between electric vehicles can be a thrilling yet daunting experience. The market is booming with options, but two titans often rise to the top of the conversation: the Tesla Model S and the Tesla Model X. Both offer the promise of zero-emission driving and cutting-edge technology, but they cater to slightly different needs and preferences.
This comparison dives deep into the heart of these two electric marvels. We’ll explore their key differences, from performance and range to features and practicality. The goal is to provide you with a clear understanding of which Tesla best suits your lifestyle and driving requirements. Get ready to discover which electric vehicle emerges victorious in the Tesla Model S vs X showdown!
Whether you prioritize sleek sedan styling or the spaciousness of an SUV, this guide will help you navigate the nuances of each model. We’ll cover everything from acceleration and handling to charging capabilities and interior comfort. Prepare to make an informed decision and electrify your driving experience with the perfect Tesla for you.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Model S | Model X |
|---|---|---|
| 0-60 mph | As low as 1.9s | As low as 2.3s |
| Range (EPA est.) | Up to 405 miles | Up to 348 miles |
| Seating Capacity | Up to 5 | Up to 7 |
| Cargo Space (Rear Seats Up) | 28 cu ft | 26 cu ft |
| Cargo Space (Rear Seats Down) | 60 cu ft | 66 cu ft |
| Supercharger Network | Yes | Yes |
| Autopilot Features | Standard | Standard |
| Screen Size | 17-inch | 17-inch |
| Drive Train | Dual Motor or Tri Motor | Dual Motor or Tri Motor |
| Top Speed | Up to 200 mph | Up to 163 mph |
| Body Style | Sedan | SUV |
| Falcon Wing Doors | No | Yes |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Range
- Tesla Model S: Offers a long range, varying by trim, with some models exceeding 400 miles on a single charge. This makes it suitable for long-distance travel, but range can be affected by driving conditions and battery degradation.
- X: Also provides a substantial range, comparable to the Model S depending on the configuration. The heavier weight of the Model X due to its larger size and features may slightly impact its overall range compared to the Model S.
- Winner: S
Acceleration
- Tesla Model S: Known for its blistering acceleration, especially in the Plaid trim, which can achieve 0-60 mph times in under 2 seconds. This offers an exhilarating driving experience, but can also lead to increased tire wear and higher energy consumption.
- X: While also quick, the Model X’s acceleration is slightly slower than the Model S due to its heavier weight. However, it still offers impressive performance for an SUV and provides a thrilling experience.
- Winner: S
Seating Capacity
- Tesla Model S: Primarily offers seating for up to 5 adults. Its sleek design prioritizes aerodynamic efficiency and a lower profile, resulting in a more spacious interior for the occupants.
- X: Offers flexible seating configurations, including seating for up to 7 adults with the optional third row. This makes it a great choice for families with more passengers or those needing extra cargo capacity.
- Winner: X
Cargo Space
- Tesla Model S: Provides a generous trunk space with a front trunk (frunk) for additional storage. This offers ample room for luggage and other cargo.
- X: Offers even greater cargo capacity, especially with the rear seats folded down. The larger SUV body provides significantly more space for luggage, equipment, or larger items.
- Winner: X
Falcon Wing Doors
- Tesla Model S: Does not feature Falcon Wing doors.
- X: Equipped with distinctive Falcon Wing doors, which open upwards. These doors offer easy access to the rear seats, even in tight parking spaces, but can be slower to open and close.
- Winner: X
Price
- Tesla Model S: Generally has a higher starting price than the Model X, especially in its higher-performance trims.
- X: The Model X is generally less expensive than the Model S.
- Winner: X
Handling and Ride Quality
- Tesla Model S: Known for its sporty handling and responsive steering, offering a more engaging driving experience. Its lower center of gravity contributes to better stability and cornering.
- X: Provides a comfortable ride, but its larger size and higher center of gravity may result in a less agile feel compared to the Model S.
- Winner: S
Charging Speed
- Tesla Model S: Supports fast charging at Tesla Supercharger stations, allowing for rapid battery replenishment. Charging times vary depending on the Supercharger and battery state.
- X: Also supports fast charging at Tesla Supercharger stations with similar charging speeds.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Range | Model S |
| Cargo Space | Model X |
| Seating Capacity | Model X |
| Performance (Acceleration) | Model S |
| Styling | (Subjective) |
| Versatility | Model X |
What They Have in Common
- Electric Powertrain: Both vehicles are fully electric, offering instant torque and zero tailpipe emissions. This provides a smooth and quiet driving experience.
- Supercharging Capability: Both the Model S and Model X are compatible with Tesla’s Supercharger network, allowing for fast and convenient charging on the go.
- Advanced Technology: Both vehicles feature Tesla’s advanced Autopilot system, large touchscreen displays, and over-the-air software updates. This ensures a cutting-edge driving experience.
- Performance: Both vehicles offer impressive acceleration and performance capabilities, even in their base configurations, making them fun to drive.
- Premium Interior: Both models offer a luxurious interior with high-quality materials and a focus on minimalist design. They provide a comfortable and stylish environment for passengers.
Tesla Model S Vs X Buying Guide
Performance & Range
Both the Tesla Model S and Model X boast impressive performance, with Ludicrous Mode available on some trims, providing blistering acceleration. However, the Model S generally offers slightly better range due to its more aerodynamic design and lighter weight. The Model S is often the preferred choice for drivers prioritizing maximizing range for long-distance travel, while the Model X offers a balance of performance and practicality.
The Model S excels in straight-line speed, particularly in its top-tier Plaid configuration. The Model X, while still incredibly quick, sacrifices a bit of that performance due to its larger size and heavier build. This impacts the overall efficiency of the vehicles.
Interior & Features
The interiors of both vehicles are modern and minimalist, featuring large touchscreen displays that control most vehicle functions. The Model S offers a sleek, sedan-like interior with a focus on driver comfort and a sportier feel. The Model X, on the other hand, provides a more spacious and versatile interior, especially in the second and optional third rows.
Both models come equipped with advanced technology features, including Autopilot and over-the-air software updates. The Falcon Wing doors of the Model X are a unique feature, offering convenient access to the rear seats, although they can be a bit cumbersome in tight parking situations. Interior configurations and material choices offer a premium experience.
Cargo Space & Practicality
The Model X excels in practicality, offering significantly more cargo space than the Model S, thanks to its SUV body style. The Falcon Wing doors provide easy access to the second and third-row seats, making it ideal for families. The Model S, while having a decent amount of cargo space, is more limited by its sedan design.
The Model X’s higher ride height provides a better view of the road and allows for easier entry and exit. The Model S offers a more streamlined profile that can be beneficial for highway driving and parking in tight spaces. Think about your cargo needs, as it’s a huge factor.
Pricing & Value
The pricing of both models varies depending on the trim level and options selected. Generally, the Model S is slightly more affordable than the Model X, particularly in the base configurations. However, the Model X’s added features, such as the Falcon Wing doors and increased cargo space, may justify the higher price for some buyers.
Consider the long-term cost of ownership, including factors like charging costs, maintenance, and potential resale value. Researching incentives, rebates, and tax credits that may be available in your area is also crucial to determining the best value.
Charging & Infrastructure
Tesla has built an extensive Supercharger network, making it convenient to charge both the Model S and Model X on long trips. Both vehicles are compatible with the Supercharger network, providing fast and reliable charging. Charging at home is also a popular option, with both vehicles supporting Level 2 charging.
The charging speeds and availability of Superchargers can impact the overall ownership experience, so it’s important to consider these factors when making your decision. Tesla is constantly expanding its charging network to improve its charging capabilities.
Safety & Driver Assistance
Both the Model S and Model X are equipped with advanced safety features, including Autopilot, which provides driver assistance on highways. Both models have received high safety ratings from regulatory agencies. The Model X, due to its larger size and higher ride height, may offer a slightly enhanced sense of security.
Consider the specific safety features that are important to you, such as blind-spot monitoring, automatic emergency braking, and lane-keeping assist. Tesla’s continuous software updates often improve safety features and driver assistance capabilities.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Model S If…
- You prioritize maximum range and want the longest driving distance available in a Tesla.
- You prefer the sleek and sporty design of a sedan.
- You value the highest possible performance and top speed.
- You don’t need the extra cargo space or passenger capacity of an SUV.
Buy Model X If…
- You need the extra space and versatility of an SUV, including more cargo capacity and the option for third-row seating.
- You want the unique and eye-catching Falcon Wing doors.
- You frequently transport multiple passengers or require more family-friendly features.
- You value a taller ride height and better visibility.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference in range between the Model S and Model X?
The Model S generally offers a slightly longer range than the Model X, due to its more aerodynamic design and lighter weight. The specific range varies depending on the trim level and battery pack, but the Model S tends to be more efficient. The range difference can be significant on longer journeys, impacting the charging frequency required.
How do the Falcon Wing doors on the Model X work?
The Falcon Wing doors on the Model X open upwards, providing easy access to the second and third-row seats, even in tight parking spaces. Sensors prevent the doors from opening if they detect an obstruction. The doors are powered by electric motors and can be controlled via the touchscreen or a smartphone app. They’re a unique feature of the Model X.
Which car is better for families?
The Model X is generally considered the better choice for families, due to its larger cargo space, versatile seating configurations, and easy access to the rear seats provided by the Falcon Wing doors. The Model S offers less space but can still be suitable for families with fewer children or smaller cargo needs. The Model X’s interior feels much more spacious.
What is the acceleration like on the Model S and Model X?
Both the Model S and Model X offer impressive acceleration, with top-tier trims capable of blistering speeds. The Model S, particularly in its Plaid configuration, often has a slight edge in straight-line acceleration due to its lighter weight. Acceleration times vary depending on the specific model and battery configuration.
How does the Supercharger network impact ownership?
Tesla’s Supercharger network provides fast and convenient charging for both the Model S and Model X, making long-distance travel easier. The availability and speed of Superchargers can impact the overall ownership experience, reducing range anxiety. Tesla is continuously expanding its network, improving charging speeds, and enhancing the ownership experience.
Which car is more expensive?
The Model X typically has a higher starting price compared to the Model S. The exact price difference depends on the trim levels and options selected, but the Model X often carries a premium due to its larger size, Falcon Wing doors, and added features. Consider your budget and the features you need.
What are the key differences in interior design?
The Model S features a sleek, sedan-like interior with a focus on driver comfort and a sportier feel. The Model X offers a more spacious and versatile interior, with the Falcon Wing doors adding unique access to the second and optional third rows. Both models have minimalist designs dominated by large touchscreen displays.
Final Verdict
Both the Tesla Model S and Model X are exceptional electric vehicles, each catering to different needs. The Model S excels in performance and range, while the Model X prioritizes practicality and spaciousness. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual priorities, such as cargo space, family needs, and budget. The Model X is the winner if space is a priority.
Winner: Tesla Model X