Tesla Model S Plaid vs P100d: Which Ev Reigns Supreme?
The electric vehicle landscape has been revolutionized by Tesla, and within its lineup, two titans have emerged: the Tesla Model S Plaid and the P100D. Both represent peak performance, but they cater to different needs and budgets. Choosing between them can be a tough decision for any prospective buyer looking for a high-performance electric sedan.
The Model S Plaid is the current king of the hill, boasting mind-blowing acceleration and cutting-edge technology. The P100D, on the other hand, was once the pinnacle of Tesla performance, still offering impressive speed and a luxurious experience. This comparison will delve into their key differences.
We will examine their performance metrics, range capabilities, interior features, and overall value proposition. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which Tesla, the Model S Plaid or the P100D, is the better choice for you. Get ready to discover which one comes out on top!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Tesla Model S Plaid | Tesla Model S P100D |
|---|---|---|
| 0-60 mph | 1.99 seconds | 2.4 seconds |
| Top Speed | 200 mph | 155 mph |
| Horsepower | 1,020 hp | 778 hp |
| Range (EPA est.) | 396 miles | 337 miles |
| Drivetrain | Tri-Motor All-Wheel Drive | Dual-Motor All-Wheel Drive |
| Weight | 4,766 lbs | 4,941 lbs |
| Wheels | 19″ or 21″ | 19″ or 21″ |
| Infotainment Screen | 17-inch touchscreen | 17-inch touchscreen |
| Autopilot Features | Enhanced Autopilot / Full Self-Driving Capability | Enhanced Autopilot / Full Self-Driving Capability |
| Supercharging Speed | Up to 250 kW | Up to 150 kW |
| Cargo Space (rear) | 28 cu ft | 26 cu ft |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 5 |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Acceleration (0-60 mph)
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Officially, 0-60 mph in ~1.99 seconds (with rollout). Boasts incredible off-the-line performance, making it one of the quickest accelerating production cars ever. The sheer speed can be overwhelming for some drivers and requires careful handling.
- P100d: Achieves 0-60 mph in approximately 2.4 seconds in Ludicrous mode. Still incredibly fast by any standard, offering a thrilling driving experience. While quick, it’s notably slower than the Plaid.
- Winner: Plaid
Top Speed
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Capable of reaching up to 200 mph with the right tires and conditions. Offers a higher top speed, contributing to its performance-oriented design. Requires specific tires to achieve the maximum speed.
- P100d: Has a top speed of around 155 mph. Still a respectable top speed but significantly lower than the Plaid.
- Winner: Plaid
Range (EPA Estimated)
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Offers an EPA-estimated range of around 396 miles. Provides excellent range for long-distance travel, reducing range anxiety. Real-world range may vary depending on driving conditions.
- P100d: Has an EPA-estimated range of around 337 miles. A good range for most drivers, but noticeably less than the Plaid.
- Winner: Plaid
Horsepower & Torque
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Produces over 1,020 horsepower. Delivers immense power and torque across a wide power band. This results in breathtaking acceleration and performance.
- P100d: Generates around 778 horsepower in Ludicrous mode. Still offers significant power and acceleration. It’s a powerful car, but it’s not at the level of the Plaid.
- Winner: Plaid
Motor Configuration
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Utilizes a tri-motor configuration (one in the front, two in the rear) for optimal power distribution and torque vectoring. Offers enhanced handling and responsiveness, especially during acceleration and cornering.
- P100d: Employs a dual-motor configuration (one in the front, one in the rear). Provides all-wheel drive and good performance, but not as sophisticated as the tri-motor setup.
- Winner: Plaid
Price (MSRP, approximate)
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Starts at a higher price point, reflecting its superior performance and technology. It is a premium vehicle with a premium price.
- P100d: Typically available at a lower price point, especially on the used market. Offers a more affordable entry into high-performance Tesla ownership.
- Winner: P100d
Technology & Features
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Comes equipped with the latest Tesla technology, including updated Autopilot hardware, a more powerful infotainment system, and features like Track Mode. Offers the most up-to-date Tesla experience.
- P100d: Features the technology available during its production run, including Autopilot (though potentially outdated), and a well-equipped interior. Lacks the newest features found in the Plaid.
- Winner: Plaid
Track Performance
- Tesla Model S Plaid: Designed with track performance in mind, featuring Track Mode for optimized handling and battery management. Built for performance on and off the road.
- P100d: Can be driven on a track but isn’t specifically engineered for it. Lacks the advanced track-focused features of the Plaid.
- Winner: Plaid
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Acceleration | Tesla Model S Plaid |
| Top Speed | Tesla Model S Plaid |
| Range | Tesla Model S Plaid |
| Technology Features | Tesla Model S Plaid |
| Value | Tesla Model S P100D (considering used market) |
What They Have in Common
- Electric Powertrain: Both vehicles are fully electric, offering instant torque and zero tailpipe emissions.
- Spacious Interior: Both models provide a comfortable and spacious interior, accommodating passengers and cargo with ease.
- Supercharger Network Access: Both the Plaid and P100D benefit from access to Tesla’s extensive Supercharger network, providing convenient and fast charging options.
- Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems: Both cars are equipped with advanced driver-assistance systems, including Autopilot features designed to enhance safety and convenience.
- Over-the-Air Software Updates: Both vehicles receive over-the-air software updates, allowing for continuous improvements and new features to be added remotely.
- Large Touchscreen Interface: Each car features a large touchscreen display for controlling vehicle functions and accessing infotainment features.
Tesla Model S Plaid Vs P100D Buying Guide
Performance Comparison
The Tesla Model S Plaid reigns supreme in raw performance. Its tri-motor setup unleashes incredible acceleration, reaching 0-60 mph in a mere 1.99 seconds, a feat the P100D cannot match. The P100D, while still remarkably quick with its dual-motor configuration, lags behind with a 0-60 mph time of around 3.0 seconds. This difference is noticeable in real-world driving scenarios. The Plaid offers a significantly faster and more thrilling experience.
Range and Efficiency
The Model S Plaid boasts a commendable range, exceeding the P100D. While range depends on driving style and conditions, the Plaid generally provides more miles on a single charge. The P100D’s range, though still respectable, is noticeably lower. The Plaid’s superior efficiency contributes to its extended range capabilities. This will be an important factor for long trips.
Technology and Features
The Plaid benefits from Tesla’s advancements in technology. It includes updated features, a more modern user interface, and potential for future software updates. The P100D, being an older model, lacks some of these advancements. Though the P100D still offers a good infotainment system and Autopilot capabilities, the Plaid represents the latest iteration of Tesla’s technology.
Interior and Comfort
Both models provide a luxurious interior, but the Plaid might come with slightly updated materials and design elements. The Plaid also features a yoke steering wheel, which some drivers love, and others don’t. The P100D’s interior, while comfortable, might feel slightly dated compared to the Plaid. Both offer ample space for passengers and cargo.
Charging Infrastructure
Tesla’s Supercharger network supports both vehicles. However, the Plaid’s ability to charge at a higher rate could mean faster charging times. The P100D still benefits from the extensive Supercharger network, but it might take slightly longer to reach a full charge. Access to a robust charging infrastructure is a significant advantage for both models.
Price and Value
The Model S Plaid is considerably more expensive than a used P100D. The price difference reflects the Plaid’s superior performance, updated technology, and newer features. The P100D offers excellent value for its performance and luxury, especially in the used car market. The best choice depends on your budget and desired level of performance and features.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Tesla Model S Plaid If…
- You prioritize blistering acceleration and track-ready performance.
- You want the highest top speed available in a production sedan.
- You desire the latest technology and features offered by Tesla.
- You frequently travel long distances and want the longest available range.
Buy Tesla Model S P100D If…
- You are looking for a more affordable high-performance Tesla.
- You still want impressive acceleration and performance without the Plaid’s extreme capabilities.
- You value a well-equipped and luxurious electric sedan.
- You are satisfied with a slightly lower range and top speed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the 0-60 mph time for the Model S Plaid?
The Model S Plaid accelerates from 0 to 60 mph in approximately 1.99 seconds. This incredibly rapid acceleration is one of its defining features. This blistering speed puts it in a class of its own in the world of production cars. The Plaid sets a new standard for electric vehicle performance.
How fast is the P100D?
The P100D accelerates from 0 to 60 mph in around 3.0 seconds. While not as quick as the Plaid, it’s still exceptionally fast. The P100D offers impressive performance for daily driving and provides a thrilling experience. It remains a very quick and capable vehicle.
What is the range of the Model S Plaid?
The Model S Plaid boasts a range of over 396 miles on a single charge, depending on driving conditions and settings. This extended range allows for longer journeys and reduces the need for frequent charging stops. The Plaid’s range is a significant advantage for long-distance travel.
What is the range of the P100D?
The P100D offers a range of approximately 315 miles on a single charge, dependent on driving style and conditions. While slightly less than the Plaid, this range is still very usable for everyday driving and occasional road trips. It provides ample range for most daily commutes.
Does the Plaid have Autopilot?
Yes, the Model S Plaid comes equipped with Tesla’s Autopilot system. This includes features like adaptive cruise control, lane keeping, and automatic lane changes. The enhanced Autopilot or Full Self-Driving Capability (optional) can further augment these features. Autopilot significantly enhances the driving experience.
Does the P100D have Autopilot?
Yes, the P100D also features Tesla’s Autopilot. It provides similar functionalities to the Plaid’s Autopilot, including adaptive cruise control and lane keeping. The level of Autopilot functionality may vary slightly depending on the software version. Autopilot adds convenience and safety to the driving experience.
Which car is better for daily driving?
Both cars are excellent for daily driving. The P100D offers a more affordable entry point and still provides exhilarating performance. The Plaid, with its faster acceleration and updated technology, enhances the driving experience further. The best choice depends on the buyer’s priorities and budget. Both cars offer a comfortable and practical experience.
Final Verdict
The Tesla Model S Plaid undeniably surpasses the P100D in terms of performance, range, and cutting-edge technology. While the P100D remains a compelling option, particularly in the used market, the Plaid represents the pinnacle of Tesla’s engineering. Its superior acceleration and advanced features make it the clear winner for those seeking the ultimate electric vehicle experience.
Winner: Tesla Model S Plaid