Tesla Model 3 vs S: Which Tesla Reigns Supreme?
Choosing between electric vehicles can be a thrilling but complex decision. The automotive world has been revolutionized by Tesla, and the choice often boils down to two of their most popular models. This comparison dives deep into the heart of the debate: the Tesla Model 3 versus the Tesla Model S.
Both cars offer cutting-edge technology and impressive performance, but they cater to different needs and budgets. The Tesla Model 3 has become synonymous with accessible electric luxury, while the Model S continues to represent Tesla’s flagship, offering a blend of performance and premium features.
We’ll examine key aspects like range, performance, interior features, and pricing to help you determine which Tesla best suits your lifestyle. Get ready to explore the nuances that separate these two exceptional electric vehicles and discover which one deserves a spot in your garage. Let’s find out which Tesla is the ultimate winner in this exciting head-to-head!
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Model 3 | Model S |
|---|---|---|
| 0-60 mph | 3.1-5.8 seconds | 1.9-3.1 seconds |
| Range (EPA est.) | 272-341 miles | 348-405 miles |
| Motor | Single or Dual Motor | Dual or Tri Motor |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 5-7 |
| Supercharger Network | Yes | Yes |
| Autopilot | Standard | Standard |
| Infotainment Screen | 15-inch Touchscreen | 17-inch Touchscreen |
| Cargo Space | 15-23 cu ft | 28 cu ft |
| Suspension | Coil Spring | Adaptive Air Suspension |
| Body Style | Sedan | Sedan/Liftback |
| Warranty | 4 years/50,000 miles (basic) | 4 years/50,000 miles (basic) |
| Over-the-Air Updates | Yes | Yes |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Price
- Tesla Model 3: Significantly more affordable starting price compared to the Model S. Offers a more accessible entry point into the Tesla brand, but can still be pricey depending on configuration.
- S: Higher starting price, reflecting its premium positioning. Offers more luxurious features and potentially better performance, but comes with a larger initial investment.
- Winner: Model 3
Range
- Tesla Model 3: Offers competitive range depending on the trim level, with long-range models approaching and sometimes exceeding 300 miles. Range can vary based on driving conditions and battery size.
- S: Generally offers a longer range compared to the Model 3, particularly in its higher-end configurations. This makes it suitable for longer trips and reduces range anxiety.
- Winner: S
Performance
- Tesla Model 3: Offers impressive acceleration, particularly in the Performance trim. Provides a sporty driving experience, but may not match the raw power of the Model S.
- S: Known for its blistering acceleration, especially in the Plaid trim. Delivers exceptional performance and handles well for its size.
- Winner: S
Interior and Features
- Tesla Model 3: Features a minimalist interior with a large central touchscreen. Offers essential features but may lack some of the luxury appointments found in the Model S.
- S: Boasts a more luxurious interior with premium materials and advanced features like yoke steering. Provides a more spacious cabin and a higher level of refinement.
- Winner: S
Cargo Space
- Tesla Model 3: Offers good cargo space with a trunk and a frunk. Practical for everyday use, but cargo capacity is less than the Model S.
- S: Provides more cargo space compared to the Model 3, including a larger trunk and frunk. Offers greater versatility for transporting luggage and other items.
- Winner: S
Charging Speed
- Tesla Model 3: Supports Tesla’s Supercharger network and offers fast charging capabilities. Charging speed varies depending on the battery pack and Supercharger version.
- S: Also supports Tesla’s Supercharger network and benefits from the latest charging technology. May offer slightly faster charging speeds in some configurations.
- Winner: S
Technology
- Tesla Model 3: Includes Tesla’s Autopilot system and a central touchscreen control panel. Features over-the-air software updates for continuous improvements.
- S: Offers advanced technology features, including a larger and more feature-rich touchscreen, and potentially a more advanced version of Autopilot.
- Winner: S
Size and Handling
- Tesla Model 3: Smaller and more agile, making it easier to maneuver in urban environments. Offers a sporty driving experience with responsive handling.
- S: Larger and heavier, providing a more comfortable ride on the highway. Handling is still good for its size, but not as nimble as the Model 3.
- Winner: Model 3
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Value | Model 3 |
| Performance | Model S |
| Range | Model S |
| Interior Space | Model S |
| Technology | Tie |
| Driving Experience | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Electric Powertrain: Both vehicles are fully electric, contributing to zero tailpipe emissions and a smooth, quiet driving experience.
- Supercharger Network Access: Both cars can utilize Tesla’s extensive Supercharger network for convenient and fast charging on the go.
- Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems: Both models come standard with Tesla’s Autopilot features, including adaptive cruise control and lane keeping assist.
- Over-the-Air Software Updates: Both cars receive regular over-the-air software updates, improving performance, adding new features, and fixing bugs.
- Minimalist Interior Design: Both cars feature Tesla’s signature minimalist interior design, with a large central touchscreen controlling most vehicle functions.
- High Safety Ratings: Both the Model 3 and Model S consistently receive high safety ratings from organizations like the IIHS and NHTSA.
Tesla Model 3 Vs S Buying Guide
Performance & Range
The Tesla Model 3 offers impressive performance, particularly in its higher-end trims, with rapid acceleration. Its range is also respectable, making it suitable for daily commutes and longer trips. The Model S, however, takes performance to another level. With its Plaid configuration, it boasts blistering acceleration and significantly greater range, making it a top choice for those prioritizing raw power and extended travel capabilities. The Model S is also known for its superior handling and overall driving dynamics, offering a more refined experience.
The choice hinges on your priorities. If you value a balance of performance and efficiency at a more accessible price point, the Model 3 is a strong contender. If you crave unparalleled performance, extended range, and a more luxurious driving experience, the Model S is the clear winner.
Interior & Features
Both models feature minimalist interiors, dominated by large touchscreen displays that control most vehicle functions. The Model 3’s interior is functional and modern, with a focus on simplicity. The Model S elevates the experience with higher-quality materials, more spaciousness, and additional premium features like a larger touchscreen and a more refined audio system. The Model S often includes features not available in the Model 3.
Consider your preference for interior aesthetics and features. The Model 3 provides a clean and efficient cabin. The Model S indulges with a more luxurious and spacious environment. Assess which features are essential for your driving needs and comfort.
Technology & Autopilot
Tesla vehicles are renowned for their advanced technology, including Autopilot and over-the-air software updates. Both the Model 3 and Model S offer similar Autopilot capabilities, providing features like adaptive cruise control and lane keeping. The Model S sometimes includes more advanced hardware that may provide access to future autonomous driving features. Tesla regularly updates its software, enhancing both models’ capabilities.
While both cars are technologically advanced, the Model S might offer a slightly more advanced platform for future autonomous driving upgrades due to its superior hardware. The Model 3 still provides a comprehensive suite of features. Evaluate your reliance on advanced driver-assistance systems and future-proofing when making your decision.
Pricing & Value
The Tesla Model 3 is generally more affordable than the Model S, making it a more accessible entry point into the Tesla ownership experience. The Model S commands a higher price tag, reflecting its superior performance, luxury features, and larger size. Considering the features and performance of each car, the value proposition differs, depending on your needs.
Assess your budget and prioritize what you value most in a car. The Model 3 offers excellent value for its performance and features. The Model S justifies its higher price with its superior luxury and performance. Compare the features and range that each model offers against your budget.
Charging & Infrastructure
Tesla has built an extensive Supercharger network, providing convenient and fast charging options for both the Model 3 and Model S. The charging speed and availability are largely the same for both cars. Home charging is also a convenient option for both models, allowing you to charge overnight.
Consider your typical driving habits and charging needs. The Supercharger network makes long-distance travel easy for both models. Home charging provides convenience. The charging infrastructure supports both cars equally, making this factor less of a differentiator.
Ownership & Maintenance
Tesla’s ownership experience is known for its simplicity and minimal maintenance requirements. Both the Model 3 and Model S benefit from the same streamlined service process, which can be done via app. Tesla offers comprehensive warranties for both cars, providing peace of mind. Both cars have lower maintenance costs than traditional gasoline cars.
Consider the long-term cost of ownership, including potential repair needs. Tesla’s electric powertrains require less maintenance than internal combustion engines. Research Tesla’s service network in your area. Both models share similar ownership experiences.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Model 3 If…
- You want a more affordable Tesla.
- You prefer a smaller, more maneuverable car.
- You don’t need the extra space of the Model S.
- You prioritize efficiency and a lower purchase price.
Buy Model S If…
- You desire the ultimate in performance and acceleration.
- You need more range for longer trips.
- You want a more luxurious and spacious interior.
- You require the extra cargo capacity.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the range of the Tesla Model 3?
The range of the Tesla Model 3 varies depending on the trim level. The base models typically offer around 272 miles of range, while the Long Range and Performance models can achieve over 333 miles. Real-world range may vary based on driving conditions, speed, and climate. Tesla continuously improves battery technology, so range figures are subject to change with software updates and new models.
What is the range of the Tesla Model S?
The Tesla Model S boasts impressive range capabilities. The Long Range model can exceed 400 miles on a single charge. The Plaid model, while focusing on performance, still offers a substantial range, making it suitable for long-distance travel. The actual range will depend on driving habits, temperature, and other factors. Tesla continues to refine battery technology to improve efficiency.
How do the performance figures compare?
The Model 3 offers brisk acceleration, with the Performance trim achieving a 0-60 mph time in around 3.1 seconds. The Model S, especially in the Plaid configuration, delivers phenomenal acceleration, reaching 60 mph in under 2 seconds. The Model S Plaid is one of the quickest accelerating production cars available. The Model S offers a more powerful experience.
What are the key differences in interior design?
Both models feature a minimalist interior design with a focus on a large touchscreen. The Model S incorporates higher-quality materials, a more spacious cabin, and additional premium features like a larger display. The Model 3 has a more functional interior. The Model S offers a more luxurious and refined cabin experience.
How does Autopilot compare between the two models?
Both models offer Tesla’s Autopilot system, including adaptive cruise control and lane keeping. The Model S may have more advanced hardware, potentially enabling future autonomous driving capabilities. Both cars receive frequent over-the-air software updates that enhance Autopilot features. The Model S might have a slight advantage in hardware.
What are the charging options for both cars?
Both the Model 3 and Model S can utilize Tesla’s Supercharger network for fast charging. They also support home charging with a Tesla Wall Connector or a standard outlet. The charging infrastructure is the same for both models. Both options provide convenient charging solutions. Tesla has an extensive Supercharger network.
Which car is better for long trips?
The Tesla Model S is generally better for long trips due to its longer range and more comfortable interior. The Model 3 is still capable of long trips, thanks to the Supercharger network, but may require more frequent charging stops. The Model S offers a more relaxed and luxurious experience for extended journeys. The Model S has a superior range.
Final Verdict
Choosing between the Tesla Model 3 and Model S depends on your priorities. The Model 3 provides excellent value and performance for its price, making it a great entry point. The Model S elevates the experience with superior performance, luxury, and range, catering to those who desire the best. Consider your budget and needs to decide.
Winner: Tesla Model S