Tesla Model 3 vs Model S: Which Tesla Should You Buy?
Choosing between electric vehicles can be a daunting task, especially when considering the powerhouse that is Tesla. With the sleek design and innovative technology, it’s no surprise that many are drawn to the brand. But with multiple models to choose from, where do you even begin?
This comparison focuses on two of Tesla’s most popular offerings: the Tesla Model 3 and the Tesla Model S. These two vehicles, while sharing the Tesla DNA, cater to different needs and budgets. We’ll delve into the key differences and similarities to help you make an informed decision.
The Model 3 is often considered the more accessible option, while the Model S represents Tesla’s flagship sedan. We’ll explore everything from performance and range to features and price, assisting you in navigating the world of electric vehicles. By the end, you’ll have a clearer picture of which Tesla best suits your lifestyle.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Tesla 3 | Tesla S |
|---|---|---|
| 0-60 mph | 3.1-5.8 seconds | 1.9-3.1 seconds |
| Range (EPA est.) | 272-341 miles | 320-405 miles |
| Horsepower | 283-450 hp | 670-1020 hp |
| Cargo Space (Rear) | 23 cu. ft. | 28 cu. ft. |
| Supercharger Network | Yes | Yes |
| Autopilot Features | Standard | Standard |
| Touchscreen Display | 15-inch | 17-inch |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 5-7 |
| Body Style | Sedan | Sedan |
| Weight | 3,864-4,065 lbs | 4,561-4,833 lbs |
| All-Wheel Drive | Available | Available |
| Top Speed | 125-162 mph | 149-200 mph |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Price
- Tesla 3: Significantly more affordable, making it accessible to a wider audience. Offers a lower starting price and overall cost of ownership. Cons: Fewer premium features than the Model S.
- Tesla S: Premium price point reflects its luxury features and performance. Offers higher-end materials, advanced technology, and a more spacious interior. Cons: Higher initial investment.
- Winner: tesla 3
Range
- Tesla 3: Offers competitive range options, with the Long Range variant providing impressive mileage. Range varies depending on the battery configuration chosen. Cons: Range can be lower than Model S depending on configuration.
- Tesla S: Boasts a longer range, especially in the Plaid configuration. Provides greater peace of mind on long journeys. Cons: Higher price for extended range.
- Winner: tesla s
Acceleration
- Tesla 3: Performance models offer impressive acceleration, rivaling many sports cars. Offers quick off-the-line performance for daily driving. Cons: Plaid Model S is significantly faster.
- Tesla S: The Plaid configuration offers blistering acceleration, making it one of the quickest accelerating production cars available. Provides an exhilarating driving experience. Cons: Extremely high performance comes at a premium.
- Winner: tesla s
Interior Space
- Tesla 3: Offers a comfortable interior with ample space for passengers. Although smaller than the Model S, it still provides a practical cabin. Cons: Smaller than Model S.
- Tesla S: Provides a more spacious interior, with more legroom and headroom for passengers. Offers a more luxurious and comfortable experience. Cons: Larger footprint.
- Winner: tesla s
Technology
- Tesla 3: Features Tesla’s advanced technology, including Autopilot and a large touchscreen display. Offers a streamlined and user-friendly interface. Cons: Fewer premium tech features than Model S.
- Tesla S: Equipped with the latest Tesla technology, including a larger touchscreen, advanced driver-assistance systems, and optional features like yoke steering. Provides a more immersive and cutting-edge experience. Cons: Can be more complex.
- Winner: tesla s
Build Quality & Materials
- Tesla 3: Generally good build quality and uses a mix of materials. Interior design is minimalist, focusing on functionality. Cons: Some users report issues with build quality compared to other vehicles in its price range.
- Tesla S: Features higher-quality materials and a more refined build. Offers a more premium feel and aesthetic. Cons: Can still experience occasional build quality issues.
- Winner: tesla s
Charging Speed
- Tesla 3: Supports Tesla’s Supercharger network, offering fast charging capabilities. Charging speeds vary depending on the battery configuration and charger used. Cons: Peak charging speeds may be slightly slower than Model S.
- Tesla S: Supports Tesla’s Supercharger network with higher charging speeds. Offers the potential for faster charging times, reducing overall charging duration. Cons: Requires a compatible Supercharger.
- Winner: tesla s
Exterior Design
- Tesla 3: Sleek and modern design with a focus on aerodynamics. Offers a streamlined appearance with a minimalist aesthetic. Cons: Design may be considered less distinctive than the Model S.
- Tesla S: Features a more distinctive and premium design, with a more elegant and refined appearance. Offers a more luxurious presence. Cons: Larger size may be less practical for some.
- Winner: tesla s
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| 0-60 mph | Tesla S |
| Range | Tesla S |
| Price | Tesla 3 |
| Interior Luxury | Tesla S |
| Cargo Space | Tesla S |
| Value | Tesla 3 |
What They Have in Common
- Electric Powertrain: Both vehicles are fully electric, offering instant torque and zero tailpipe emissions.
- Supercharger Access: Both the Model 3 and Model S can utilize Tesla’s extensive Supercharger network for fast and convenient charging on the go.
- Autopilot Capabilities: Both cars come standard with Tesla’s Autopilot features, including adaptive cruise control and lane keeping assist, enhancing driver safety and convenience.
- Over-the-Air Updates: Both models receive regular over-the-air software updates, improving performance, adding new features, and fixing bugs.
- Spacious Interiors: Both cars offer comfortable and spacious interiors, though the Model S generally offers more luxurious appointments.
Tesla 3 Vs Tesla S Buying Guide
Performance and Range
The Tesla Model 3 excels in acceleration and provides a compelling driving experience. Its compact size contributes to agile handling, making it fun to drive on winding roads. The Model 3’s range is impressive, offering several configurations to suit different needs. The Model S, however, often surpasses the Model 3 in raw power and range, boasting higher top speeds and extended travel capabilities. Its larger battery pack allows for longer journeys without requiring a recharge, making it ideal for frequent long-distance travel. The Model S also benefits from advanced suspension for an even smoother ride.
Interior and Features
The Model 3 offers a minimalist interior with a large central touchscreen controlling most vehicle functions. This sleek design provides a clean and modern aesthetic. The Model S has a more luxurious interior, featuring premium materials and more refined details. The Model S often includes features like a larger touchscreen, a more advanced audio system, and more spacious rear seating. Both cars provide access to Tesla’s Supercharger network and over-the-air software updates, ensuring a constantly evolving user experience.
Price and Value
The Tesla Model 3 generally offers a more accessible price point, making it a great entry point into the Tesla ownership experience. Its lower cost allows it to compete with a wider range of vehicles in the market. The Model S, being a flagship model, commands a higher price tag, reflecting its superior performance, luxury, and advanced features. Consider the long-term running costs, including potential savings on fuel and maintenance, when evaluating the overall value proposition of each vehicle.
Charging and Infrastructure
Both the Model 3 and Model S can utilize Tesla’s extensive Supercharger network, providing convenient and rapid charging on the go. The Supercharger network’s widespread availability makes long-distance travel easier. Home charging is also a convenient option for both models, with various charging solutions available. Consider your typical driving patterns and access to charging infrastructure to determine which car best suits your charging needs. Tesla continues to expand its charging network globally.
Technology and Safety
Both vehicles are equipped with advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) and offer a suite of safety features. Tesla’s Autopilot system provides features like adaptive cruise control, lane keeping assist, and automatic emergency braking. The Model S often features enhanced ADAS capabilities, including features like summon and automatic lane changes. Both vehicles regularly receive over-the-air software updates that improve their safety and functionality. Consider the specific safety features and technology packages that are most important to you.
Practicality and Space
The Model 3 provides ample space for passengers and cargo, with a practical trunk and frunk. Its compact size makes it easier to maneuver in urban environments. The Model S offers more generous interior space, especially in the rear seats and trunk. This makes it a more comfortable option for families or those who frequently transport passengers or cargo. The Model S’s hatchback design also adds to its practicality, providing easy access to the cargo area. Consider your cargo needs and passenger capacity requirements.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Tesla 3 If…
- You want a more affordable entry point into the Tesla ownership experience.
- You prioritize efficiency and a balanced blend of performance and range.
- You prefer a more compact and agile vehicle for city driving.
- You value the latest technology and a minimalist interior design.
Buy Tesla S If…
- You desire superior performance, including quicker acceleration and a higher top speed.
- You prioritize a longer range for extended road trips.
- You want a more luxurious and spacious interior with premium features.
- You need more cargo space or the option for a third row of seating.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference in performance?
The Model S usually has superior performance with higher top speeds and quicker acceleration, especially in the Plaid configuration. The Model 3 is still quick, but the Model S offers a noticeable step up in power and driving dynamics. Consider your need for blistering acceleration and track-ready performance.
How does the range compare?
The Model S generally offers a longer range compared to the Model 3, especially in the Long Range configurations. This makes the Model S better suited for long-distance travel without frequent charging stops. Battery technology and efficiency contribute to the range differences.
What about interior luxury?
The Model S boasts a more luxurious interior, featuring premium materials, upgraded trims, and enhanced comfort features. The Model 3 offers a minimalist design with a focus on functionality and technology. If interior refinement is a priority, the Model S is the clear choice.
What are the price differences?
The Model 3 typically has a lower starting price, making it a more accessible option for many buyers. The Model S commands a higher price tag, reflecting its superior performance, luxury features, and larger battery pack. Consider your budget and the features you desire.
How does charging work?
Both models are compatible with Tesla’s Supercharger network and home charging options. The Model S might have a slightly faster charging rate due to its larger battery capacity. Consider your charging habits and access to charging infrastructure when choosing between the two vehicles.
Which car is better for families?
The Model S generally provides more space for passengers and cargo, making it a better option for families, particularly those with children or needing to transport large items. Its larger dimensions offer enhanced comfort and practicality. The Model 3 is still practical but smaller.
What about Autopilot and safety?
Both vehicles are equipped with Tesla’s Autopilot system and advanced safety features. The Model S often includes additional features within the Autopilot suite. Both vehicles regularly receive over-the-air updates improving safety features. Both offer excellent safety ratings.
Final Verdict
The Tesla Model 3 excels in value and provides a compelling entry point into the electric vehicle market, offering great performance and range for its price. The Model S, however, offers superior performance, range, and luxury, making it a top choice for those seeking the ultimate Tesla experience. The best choice depends on your specific needs and budget.
Winner: Tesla Model S