Tesla Model 3 vs Model S: Which Tesla Reigns Supreme?
Torn between the sleek, futuristic allure of a Tesla? You’re not alone. The electric vehicle market is booming, and at the forefront of this revolution are two titans from Tesla: the Model 3 and the Model S. Choosing between these two exceptional cars can feel like a tough decision.
This in-depth comparison dives into the heart of the matter, dissecting the key differences and similarities to help you make the right choice. We’ll explore everything from performance and range to interior features and overall value. Get ready to discover which Tesla model best suits your needs and lifestyle.
Whether you prioritize affordability and efficiency or crave premium luxury and blistering speed, the Model 3 and Model S each offer a compelling electric driving experience. Let’s find out which one emerges as the ultimate champion for you, considering the details of both cars.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Tesla 3 | Tesla S |
|---|---|---|
| 0-60 mph | 3.1-5.8 s | 3.1-3.2 s |
| Range (est.) | 272-341 mi | 320-405 mi |
| Horsepower | 283-450 hp | 670-1020 hp |
| Top Speed | 125-162 mph | 163-200 mph |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 5-7 |
| Cargo Space (Rear) | 15 cu ft | 28 cu ft |
| Autopilot Features | Standard | Standard |
| Infotainment Screen | 15-inch | 17-inch |
| Supercharger Network | Compatible | Compatible |
| Over-the-Air Updates | Yes | Yes |
| Suspension | Comfort-tuned | Adaptive Air Suspension |
| Body Style | Sedan | Sedan/Liftback |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Price
- Tesla 3: The Model 3 is significantly more affordable, starting at a lower price point. This makes it a more accessible entry point into the Tesla lineup. However, higher trim levels can increase the price.
- S: The Model S is positioned as a premium vehicle with a higher starting price, reflecting its larger size, more luxurious features, and superior performance. This higher price point puts it in a different market segment.
- Winner: 3
Range
- Tesla 3: Offers a respectable range depending on the battery configuration, suitable for most daily commutes and occasional road trips. Real-world range may vary based on driving conditions.
- S: Generally provides a longer range compared to the Model 3, particularly in its long-range configurations. This makes it better suited for extended journeys and drivers prioritizing maximum driving distance.
- Winner: S
Performance
- Tesla 3: Offers brisk acceleration, especially in its Performance trim, providing an engaging driving experience. While not as powerful as the Model S, it still delivers impressive speed.
- S: Boasts blistering acceleration, especially in the Plaid trim, making it one of the quickest accelerating production cars available. The Model S offers superior handling due to its size and weight.
- Winner: S
Interior Space & Comfort
- Tesla 3: The interior offers a minimalist design with a focus on technology. While comfortable for passengers, the Model 3 has less rear passenger and cargo space compared to the Model S.
- S: The Model S provides a more spacious and luxurious interior, offering more legroom, headroom, and cargo capacity. The materials used are generally of higher quality.
- Winner: S
Technology & Features
- Tesla 3: Features Tesla’s Autopilot system, a large touchscreen interface, and over-the-air software updates. The features are modern and updated regularly.
- S: Includes all the features of the Model 3, with additional premium features such as a larger touchscreen, higher-quality audio system, and potentially more advanced driver-assistance features.
- Winner: S
Charging Speed
- Tesla 3: Supports Tesla’s Supercharging network and provides quick charging times, though not as fast as the Model S in some cases.
- S: Generally offers faster charging speeds at Supercharger stations, allowing for quicker top-ups and reducing time spent charging.
- Winner: S
Build Quality & Materials
- Tesla 3: While the build quality has improved over time, it may still have some inconsistencies compared to the Model S. The interior materials are more basic.
- S: Generally has a higher build quality with more premium materials used throughout the cabin, contributing to a more luxurious feel.
- Winner: S
Exterior Design
- Tesla 3: Features a sleek and modern design with a more compact and aerodynamic profile. Its design is more minimalistic.
- S: Boasts a more elegant and refined exterior design, with a longer and more imposing presence. Its styling is more premium.
- Winner: S
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Performance | Tesla S |
| Range | Tesla S |
| Luxury | Tesla S |
| Value | Tesla 3 |
| Efficiency | Tesla 3 |
| Technology | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Electric Powertrain: Both the Model 3 and Model S are fully electric vehicles, offering instant torque and zero tailpipe emissions.
- Supercharger Compatibility: Both models are compatible with Tesla’s extensive Supercharger network, providing convenient and fast charging options on the go.
- Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems: Both vehicles come standard with Tesla’s Autopilot features, including adaptive cruise control and lane keeping assist.
- Over-the-Air Updates: Both cars receive regular software updates over the air, improving features and performance over time.
- Spacious Interiors: Both cars offer comfortable and spacious interiors for passengers.
Tesla 3 Vs S Buying Guide
Price & Value
The Tesla Model 3 generally offers a more accessible entry point into the Tesla ownership experience. Its lower starting price makes it more appealing to budget-conscious buyers. However, the Model S, while significantly pricier, presents a greater value proposition for those seeking luxury and performance. Consider the features you prioritize, and how much you’re willing to invest upfront and over the vehicle’s lifespan, factoring in potential tax credits and long-term operating costs like maintenance and charging.
The Model 3 offers a compelling value, especially considering its performance capabilities and technology integration. The Model S offers a more luxurious experience with superior range and more space, making it a better value for some drivers.
Performance & Range
Model S boasts superior performance figures, excelling in acceleration and top speed. Its higher-end trims deliver exhilarating power and a more refined driving experience. The Model 3, especially the Performance variant, still provides brisk acceleration and impressive handling, making it engaging to drive. The Model S also typically offers a greater range on a single charge, allowing for longer trips without needing to recharge.
Range is a critical factor for EV buyers. The Model S’s extended range provides peace of mind on long journeys. Both vehicles leverage Tesla’s Supercharger network for convenient charging, but the longer range of the S offers an additional layer of convenience.
Interior & Features
The Model S offers a more spacious and luxurious interior, with premium materials and advanced features. It boasts a larger touchscreen display and enhanced audio systems. The Model 3 provides a minimalist interior design, emphasizing simplicity and technological integration. While the Model 3 features a well-equipped cabin, the Model S provides a more upscale experience with more refined materials and a greater array of features.
The user experience is different. The Model S offers more space and feels more premium, while the Model 3 is modern and functional. Consider what kind of feel you’re going for when making your decision.
Technology & Safety
Both vehicles are equipped with Tesla’s advanced technology suite, including Autopilot and over-the-air software updates. The Model S often incorporates the latest advancements and features, such as more advanced driver-assistance systems and enhanced connectivity options. The Model 3 continues to improve with software updates, ensuring a cutting-edge technological experience. Tesla’s commitment to safety is evident in both models, with high safety ratings and a comprehensive suite of safety features.
Tesla’s technological advantage is a key selling point. Both cars offer the latest in safety and technology. Model S often gets the newest features first, though, and has more advanced driver-assistance systems.
Exterior Design & Styling
The Model S presents a sleek, aerodynamic design with a distinctive fastback profile, exuding a sense of elegance and sophistication. The Model 3 has a more compact and streamlined design, with clean lines and a modern aesthetic. Both vehicles share a minimalist aesthetic, emphasizing functionality and efficiency. The exterior design preferences are subjective, and the choice depends on personal style.
The Model S has a more premium design, while the Model 3 is more practical. The Model S is larger, which contributes to its more premium design. The Model 3 is more compact, making it easier to maneuver.
Charging & Infrastructure
Both models benefit from Tesla’s extensive Supercharger network, offering convenient and reliable charging options for long-distance travel. Home charging is also a convenient option for both vehicles, with Tesla offering various charging solutions. The charging times and speeds are comparable, depending on the charger used and battery capacity. Tesla’s commitment to expanding its charging infrastructure ensures ease of ownership.
Tesla’s charging network is a major advantage. Both cars have access to it. Home charging solutions are also available for both cars. Charging speeds depend on the charger and the car’s battery capacity.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Tesla 3 If…
- You want a more affordable Tesla.
- You prioritize efficiency and a smaller footprint.
- You primarily need a car for daily commuting and city driving.
- You prefer a more agile and sporty driving experience.
Buy Tesla S If…
- You want the highest performance and acceleration.
- You prioritize a longer range and more luxurious features.
- You need more cargo space or the option for a third row.
- You value the latest technology and premium materials.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the price difference between the Model 3 and Model S?
The Model S is significantly more expensive than the Model 3. The price difference depends on the trim level and options selected for each vehicle. The Model 3 offers a more affordable entry point into the Tesla lineup, while the Model S caters to those seeking a more luxurious experience. Additional features and options can further increase the price of both vehicles.
How does the range compare between the Model 3 and Model S?
The Model S generally offers a greater range than the Model 3, allowing for longer trips on a single charge. The specific range varies depending on the battery configuration and driving conditions. The Model S’s longer range provides added convenience for drivers who frequently travel long distances, while the Model 3 still offers impressive range for everyday use.
Which car has a more spacious interior?
The Model S has a more spacious interior compared to the Model 3. The Model S offers more legroom and headroom for both front and rear passengers, as well as a larger cargo area. The Model 3’s interior is still comfortable and functional, but the Model S provides a more luxurious and spacious experience, especially for passengers and cargo.
What are the performance differences between the two models?
The Model S generally offers superior performance figures, including faster acceleration and a higher top speed. The Model 3 Performance variant provides impressive acceleration, but the Model S’s top trims deliver even more exhilarating power. Both models provide a sporty driving experience, but the Model S caters to those who prioritize raw power and performance.
Which car offers more advanced technology features?
Both models are equipped with Tesla’s advanced technology suite, but the Model S often incorporates the latest advancements and features first. The Model S may include more advanced driver-assistance systems, enhanced connectivity options, and a larger touchscreen display. However, the Model 3 continues to improve with software updates, ensuring a cutting-edge technological experience.
How does the charging experience differ between the two vehicles?
The charging experience is relatively similar for both vehicles, as they both utilize Tesla’s Supercharger network and home charging solutions. The charging speeds and times are comparable, depending on the charger used and battery capacity. The primary difference is the battery capacity, with the Model S often having a larger battery, which can affect the overall charging time.
Which model is better for long-distance travel?
The Model S is generally better suited for long-distance travel due to its longer range and more spacious interior. The extended range of the Model S provides peace of mind on long journeys, reducing the frequency of charging stops. While the Model 3 is also capable of long-distance travel, the Model S offers a more comfortable and convenient experience for extended trips.
Final Verdict
The Tesla Model S emerges as the winner, offering a superior combination of performance, range, luxury, and features. While the Model 3 presents a compelling value proposition, the Model S provides a more premium ownership experience for those seeking the ultimate in electric vehicle technology and comfort. The Model S’s enhanced range and spacious interior provide a more relaxed long-distance travel experience.
Winner: Tesla Model S