S&w Shield vs Glock 43: Which Subcompact Reigns?
Choosing a concealed carry handgun can feel overwhelming, but two titans consistently top the list: the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield and the Glock 43. Both offer impressive performance in a compact package, making them ideal for everyday carry. But which one is the right choice for you?
This comparison dives deep into the features, pros, and cons of the S&W Shield and the Glock 43. We’ll explore everything from ergonomics and handling to reliability and accuracy. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which pistol better suits your needs and preferences.
Whether you’re a seasoned shooter or new to concealed carry, understanding the nuances of the S&W Shield vs. Glock 43 is crucial. Prepare to discover which subcompact pistol will become your trusted companion.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Shield | G43 |
|---|---|---|
| Caliber | 9mm, .40 S&W, .380 ACP | 9mm |
| Capacity | 6-8 rounds (9mm), 6 rounds (.40 S&W), 7 rounds (.380 ACP) | 6 rounds |
| Weight (Unloaded) | 19-20.8 oz | 17.95 oz |
| Overall Length | 6.1-6.45 inches | 6.26 inches |
| Height | 4.6-4.8 inches | 4.25 inches |
| Width | 0.9 inches | 1.06 inches |
| Barrel Length | 3.1-3.3 inches | 3.41 inches |
| Action | Striker-fired | Striker-fired |
| Sights | Steel, 3-dot | Polymer, 3-dot |
| Safety | Thumb safety (optional), trigger safety, drop safety | Trigger safety, drop safety |
| Frame Material | Polymer | Polymer |
| Grip | Textured Polymer | Textured Polymer |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Size and Weight
- S&W Shield: The S&W Shield is slightly larger and heavier than the Glock 43, offering a more substantial grip. This can improve handling for some shooters but may make it slightly less concealable. It weighs around 20 ounces loaded.
- Glock 43: The Glock 43 is known for its compact size and light weight, making it exceptionally easy to conceal and carry. Its smaller frame and lighter weight, around 18 ounces loaded, contribute to its discreetness.
- Winner: Glock 43
Caliber and Capacity
- S&W Shield: The Shield is available in 9mm and .40 S&W. The 9mm version typically holds 7 or 8 rounds in the magazine. The .40 S&W version holds fewer rounds.
- Glock 43: The Glock 43 is chambered in 9mm and holds 6 rounds in its standard magazine, with extended magazine options available.
- Winner: S&W Shield
Trigger
- S&W Shield: The Shield’s trigger generally has a slightly better feel and a more defined reset compared to the Glock 43, though this is subjective. It’s often considered a bit more user-friendly.
- Glock 43: Glock’s trigger is known for its simplicity and consistency, though it can feel a bit mushy to some shooters. It’s a Glock trigger, which is a known quantity.
- Winner: S&W Shield
Ergonomics and Grip
- S&W Shield: The Shield often feels better in the hand for shooters with smaller hands due to its narrower grip. However, the grip may be too narrow for some.
- Glock 43: The Glock 43’s grip is slightly thicker than the Shield’s, providing a more secure grip for some shooters. It’s still a small gun, so those with larger hands may find it less comfortable.
- Winner: Tie
Sights
- S&W Shield: The Shield comes with basic, functional sights that can be easily upgraded. Aftermarket options are readily available.
- Glock 43: The Glock 43 also features basic sights, and like the Shield, they can be upgraded. Glock sights are easy to find and install.
- Winner: Tie
Aftermarket Support
- S&W Shield: The Shield has a good level of aftermarket support, though slightly less than the Glock 43. Holsters, accessories, and upgrades are available.
- Glock 43: The Glock 43 benefits from extensive aftermarket support. There are countless holsters, accessories, and customization options available.
- Winner: Glock 43
Price
- S&W Shield: The Shield is generally more affordable than the Glock 43, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers.
- Glock 43: The Glock 43 typically has a slightly higher price point compared to the Shield.
- Winner: S&W Shield
Reliability
- S&W Shield: Both the Shield and the Glock 43 are known for their reliability. The Shield has a strong track record of consistent performance.
- Glock 43: Glock is famous for its reliability and the Glock 43 is no exception. It is known for its ruggedness and ability to function in various conditions.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Concealability | Glock 43 |
| Ergonomics | Tie |
| Capacity | S&W Shield (with extended magazines) |
| Trigger | Tie |
| Aftermarket Support | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Concealability: Both the S&W Shield and Glock 43 are designed for concealed carry, making them ideal for everyday use. Their compact sizes and slim profiles contribute to their ease of concealment.
- Striker-Fired Action: Both pistols utilize a striker-fired action, which contributes to a consistent trigger pull and overall simplicity in design and operation. This design also helps with ease of maintenance.
- Polymer Frame: Both handguns feature a polymer frame, which makes them lightweight and durable. This also aids in absorbing recoil.
- Magazine Release: Both guns have a magazine release button in the same location.
- Aftermarket Support: Both the Shield and G43 benefit from extensive aftermarket support, allowing for customization and upgrades such as sights, triggers, and grips.
S&W Shield Vs Glock 43 Buying Guide
Concealability
Both the S&W Shield and Glock 43 excel in concealed carry due to their compact size and slim profiles. The Shield, slightly thinner, might offer a marginal advantage for deep concealment, particularly in appendix carry. The Glock 43, while slightly wider, still remains exceptionally easy to conceal. Choosing between them often comes down to personal preference and body type. Consider your preferred carry position and clothing style when making your decision. Both guns are easily concealed under a t-shirt or light jacket.
Ergonomics and Handling
The Shield’s grip is known for its comfortable feel, particularly for those with smaller hands. Its textured grip provides a secure hold. The Glock 43, with its more squared-off grip, might feel less natural to some. The Glock’s familiar Glock grip angle is loved by many. Both guns benefit from aftermarket grip enhancements. Dry firing each gun will help determine which feels best in your hand and allows for better handling. Proper grip is crucial for accurate shooting.
Trigger Performance
The Shield’s trigger generally offers a smoother pull than the Glock 43’s, often favored by those seeking a more refined shooting experience. The Glock 43’s trigger is known for its simplicity and reliability, though it can feel a bit gritty or mushy to some shooters. Aftermarket trigger upgrades are widely available for both models, allowing shooters to customize the trigger feel to their liking. Consider the trigger feel as a key factor in your decision. Trigger pull weight is also important.
Reliability and Durability
Both the S&W Shield and Glock 43 are renowned for their reliability and durability, built to withstand harsh conditions. Glock’s reputation for reliability is legendary, with a proven track record. The Shield, particularly the M&P Shield series, has also earned a solid reputation for its dependable operation. Regular maintenance and proper cleaning are essential for both firearms to ensure their longevity. Both guns are built to last and can handle extensive use.
Capacity and Magazines
The standard magazine capacity is relatively similar, with both guns offering a few rounds in their base configurations. The Shield typically holds 7 or 8 rounds in its standard magazines, while the Glock 43 holds 6 rounds. Extended magazines are available for both models, increasing capacity. Consider the availability and cost of magazines when making your choice. Higher capacity magazines may alter the concealability. Magazine reliability is also important.
Price and Availability
The S&W Shield often has a slightly lower price point than the Glock 43, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers. The Glock 43, however, holds its value well and can often be found at competitive prices. Both guns are widely available at most gun stores and online retailers. The cost of accessories, such as holsters and sights, should also be considered in your overall budget. Compare prices before making a decision.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy s&w shield If…
- You prefer the option of a manual thumb safety.
- You want to consider other calibers like .40 S&W or .380 ACP.
- You prefer a slightly wider grip.
- You want a slightly lower price point.
Buy glock 43 If…
- You prefer a slimmer profile for easier concealment.
- You are already familiar with the Glock platform.
- You prioritize a slightly lighter weight.
- You want a slightly longer barrel for potentially increased accuracy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which gun is easier to conceal?
Both the Shield and Glock 43 are very concealable. The Shield, being slightly thinner, might offer a marginal advantage for some carry methods, like appendix carry. The Glock 43, while a bit wider, still remains easy to conceal. It often comes down to personal preference and body type, with the best choice depending on your specific needs and carry style. Both are popular for concealed carry.
Which gun has a better trigger?
Many shooters find the S&W Shield’s trigger to have a smoother pull compared to the Glock 43’s trigger. The Glock 43’s trigger is known for its simplicity and reliability, but it can sometimes feel a bit gritty. Aftermarket trigger upgrades are readily available for both guns, allowing for customization. Ultimately, it comes down to individual preference. Try both to determine which feels best.
Which gun is more accurate?
Accuracy depends more on the shooter than the gun itself. Both the Shield and Glock 43 are capable of excellent accuracy. Factors like grip, trigger control, and sight picture play a larger role. Practice with both guns to discover which one you shoot more accurately. The inherent accuracy of both guns is more than sufficient for self-defense purposes.
Which gun is more reliable?
Both the S&W Shield and Glock 43 are known for their reliability. Glock has a long-standing reputation for dependability, and the Shield has also proven to be a reliable firearm. Both guns are well-built and designed to function consistently under various conditions. Regular maintenance is key to ensuring continued reliability. Choose based on features you like.
What is the magazine capacity of each gun?
The standard S&W Shield typically holds 7 or 8 rounds in its magazines. The Glock 43 holds 6 rounds in its standard magazines. Extended magazines are available for both models, increasing the capacity. Consider the availability and cost of magazines. The magazine capacity may influence your decision. Capacity may vary slightly based on specific models.
Which gun is better for beginners?
Both guns are suitable for beginners. The Shield’s ergonomics and trigger might feel more comfortable to some new shooters. The Glock 43’s simplicity can also be appealing. Consider handling both guns and firing them if possible. Proper training is essential regardless of the firearm chosen. Both guns are easy to learn to operate. Safety training is important.
What are the common aftermarket accessories for each gun?
Both the Shield and Glock 43 have a wide array of aftermarket accessories available. These include holsters, sights, trigger upgrades, extended magazines, and grip enhancements. The availability of accessories is similar for both models. Research the available options to customize your gun. Consider the cost of accessories when making your decision. There’s a wide variety of accessories.
Final Verdict
Both the S&W Shield and Glock 43 are excellent choices for concealed carry, each with its own strengths. The Shield offers a slightly slimmer profile and a potentially more comfortable grip for some. The Glock 43 boasts Glock’s legendary reliability and a simple, user-friendly design. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences regarding ergonomics, trigger feel, and overall handling. Both guns are highly regarded and reliable.
Winner: [Tie]