Stihl vs Husqvarna Chainsaw – Which Should You Buy?
Choosing the right chainsaw matters because power, size, and usability directly affect safety and productivity. The Husqvarna 460 is a larger and more advanced professional grade chainsaw designed for demanding work. The Stihl MS 170 is an older but well proven entry level model focused on simplicity and affordability. Each model targets a very different type of user and workload. This comparison will break down specifications, features, and real world use so you can clearly decide which chainsaw suits your needs best.
🏆 Quick Verdict:
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Husqvarna 460 | Stihl MS 170 |
| Engine displacement | 60.3 cc | 30.1 cc |
| Horsepower | 3.6 hp | 1.7 hp |
| Recommended bar length | 20 to 24 inches | 12 to 16 inches |
| Maximum cutting capacity | Large hardwood logs | Small to medium branches |
| Torque output | High torque for heavy loads | Low to moderate torque |
| Chain speed | Faster professional grade | Slower consumer grade |
| Fuel tank capacity | Large for extended runtime | Smaller for short sessions |
| Oil tank capacity | High capacity adjustable | Basic fixed flow |
| Engine technology | X Torq fuel efficient system | Conventional two stroke |
| Anti vibration system | Advanced LowVib system | Basic vibration damping |
| Chain compatibility | Multiple professional chain types | Limited low profile chains |
| Weight without bar | Heavy duty build | Lightweight compact body |
| Intended user | Professional and heavy use | Homeowners and beginners |
| Maintenance level | Moderate with tuning options | Very low and simple |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Engine displacement (cc):
- The Husqvarna 460 has a 60.3 cc engine for handling large diameter logs and sustained heavy cutting tasks in demanding conditions.
- Stihl MS 170 uses a 30.1 cc engine.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Horsepower:
- The Husqvarna 460 features a 3.6 horsepower output for maintaining cutting speed under high load and dense wood.
- Stihl MS 170 has approximately 1.7 horsepower.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Cutting capacity:
- The Husqvarna 460 comes with support for 20 to 24 inch guide bars for cutting large trees and thick hardwood sections.
- Stihl MS 170 comes with shorter bar compatibility.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Torque:
- The Husqvarna 460 includes high torque output for reducing engine bog during deep and continuous cuts.
- Stihl MS 170 has lower torque levels.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Chain speed:
- The Husqvarna 460 supports faster chain speeds for improving cutting efficiency and productivity on large jobs.
- Stihl MS 170 features a slower chain speed.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Fuel tank capacity:
- The Husqvarna 460 has a larger fuel tank for longer runtime between refueling during extended work sessions.
- Stihl MS 170 comes with a smaller fuel tank.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Oil tank:
- The Husqvarna 460 includes a higher capacity adjustable oil tank for consistent chain lubrication across different cutting conditions.
- Stihl MS 170 has a fixed output oil tank.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Engine tech (X-Torq / fuel efficiency):
- The Husqvarna 460 features X-Torq engine technology for improved fuel efficiency and reduced exhaust emissions during operation.
- Stihl MS 170 uses a conventional two stroke engine design.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
LowVib anti-vibration:
- The Husqvarna 460 includes LowVib anti vibration technology for reducing operator fatigue during prolonged use.
- Stihl MS 170 features basic vibration damping.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Chain compatibility:
- The Husqvarna 460 supports multiple professional grade chain types for adapting to different cutting applications.
- Stihl MS 170 has limited low profile chain compatibility.
- Winner: Husqvarna 460
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Engine displacement | Husqvarna 460 |
| Horsepower | Husqvarna 460 |
| Cutting capacity | Husqvarna 460 |
| Torque | Husqvarna 460 |
| Chain speed | Husqvarna 460 |
| Fuel tank | Husqvarna 460 |
| Oil tank | Husqvarna 460 |
| Engine efficiency | Husqvarna 460 |
| Vibration control | Husqvarna 460 |
| Chain compatibility | Husqvarna 460 |
Who Should Buy What?Buy the Husqvarna 460 if you:
Check Husqvarna 460 Best Price Buy the Stihl MS 170 if you:
|
What They Have in Common
- Manual chain brake: Both chainsaws include a chain brake that stops the chain during kickback. This feature improves safety for users of all experience levels. It is essential for reducing injury risk during sudden movements.
- Two stroke engine design: Both models use two stroke engines that rely on a fuel oil mixture. This design keeps the engines compact and powerful. It also simplifies mechanical construction.
- Gas powered operation: Each chainsaw runs on gasoline rather than electricity. This allows unrestricted movement and outdoor use. It also makes them suitable for remote locations.
- Air cooled engines: Both use air cooling to manage engine temperature. This eliminates the need for liquid cooling systems. It keeps maintenance straightforward.
- Automatic chain lubrication: Each model automatically oils the chain during operation. This reduces wear and improves cutting efficiency. It also extends chain and bar life.
- Side mounted chain tensioning: Both chainsaws allow chain adjustment from the side. This improves convenience and safety during maintenance. It helps users maintain proper chain tension easily.
- Rear handle design: Both feature a rear handle layout for better control. This design supports balanced handling during cutting. It is standard for general purpose chainsaws.
- Front hand guard: Each model includes a front hand guard for added protection. It helps shield the user during kickback. This is a key safety component.
- Centrifugal clutch: Both chainsaws use a centrifugal clutch system. This allows the chain to stop spinning at idle. It improves safety and reduces wear.
- Steel cutting chain: Each chainsaw uses a hardened steel chain. This ensures durability and consistent cutting performance. It is suitable for wood cutting tasks.
- Tool based maintenance: Both require basic tools for maintenance tasks. This keeps ownership simple and affordable. It also avoids proprietary systems.
- Outdoor use focus: Each chainsaw is designed specifically for outdoor cutting tasks. They handle wood, limbs, and logs effectively. Weather resistant materials support this use.
- Mechanical throttle control: Both use a mechanical throttle system. This provides predictable power delivery. It also improves reliability.
- Brand service networks: Both brands offer wide service and parts availability. This makes repairs and maintenance easier long term. It adds value for owners.
- Proven reliability: Both models are known for dependable operation within their intended use. They have strong reputations among users. Reliability remains a shared strength.
FAQ (Quick Answers)
Is the Husqvarna 460 suitable for professional logging work?
Yes, the Husqvarna 460 is well suited for professional or semi professional logging tasks. Its large engine displacement and high horsepower allow it to handle thick hardwood and long cutting sessions without overheating or losing power. The durable construction and advanced vibration control also make it practical for frequent, demanding use.
Is the Stihl MS 170 designed for beginners?
Yes, the Stihl MS 170 is commonly recommended for beginners and casual users. Its lighter weight, lower power output, and simple controls make it easier to handle safely. It is designed for basic cutting tasks rather than complex or high risk operations.
Which chainsaw is better for cutting large trees?
The Husqvarna 460 is significantly better for cutting large trees. It supports longer guide bars and delivers higher torque, which helps maintain cutting speed in thick wood. The Stihl MS 170 is not intended for trees with large diameters.
Can the Stihl MS 170 handle firewood cutting?
The Stihl MS 170 can handle small to medium firewood cutting tasks. It works well for cutting branches, small logs, and prepared firewood sections. However, it may struggle with dense hardwood or oversized logs.
Which model has better fuel efficiency?
The Husqvarna 460 has better fuel efficiency due to its X-Torq engine technology. This system reduces fuel consumption while maintaining power output. The Stihl MS 170 uses a traditional engine design that consumes more fuel relative to its output.
Is the Husqvarna 460 heavy to operate?
Yes, the Husqvarna 460 is heavier than entry level chainsaws. The extra weight comes from its larger engine and reinforced build. While this improves stability and durability, it may cause fatigue for inexperienced users.
How long can each chainsaw run on a full tank?
The Husqvarna 460 can run longer because it has a larger fuel tank and better efficiency. It is designed for extended work sessions without frequent refueling. The Stihl MS 170 has a smaller tank and is better suited for short tasks.
Which chainsaw produces less vibration?
The Husqvarna 460 produces less vibration thanks to its advanced LowVib anti vibration system. This reduces strain on the hands and arms during long cutting sessions. The Stihl MS 170 has basic vibration control that is adequate for short use.
Is maintenance difficult on the Husqvarna 460?
Maintenance on the Husqvarna 460 is moderate but manageable. It requires regular chain sharpening, air filter cleaning, and periodic tuning. Users with some mechanical familiarity will find it straightforward.
Is the Stihl MS 170 easy to maintain?
Yes, the Stihl MS 170 is very easy to maintain. Its simple engine design and minimal adjustments make routine maintenance quick. This simplicity is one reason it is popular among homeowners.
Which chainsaw is safer for casual users?
The Stihl MS 170 is generally safer for casual users. Its lower power output reduces kickback risk and makes control easier. The Husqvarna 460 requires more experience due to its higher power.
Can both chainsaws be used for limbing?
Yes, both chainsaws can be used for limbing. The Stihl MS 170 is especially good for small branches due to its lightweight design. The Husqvarna 460 can limb efficiently but may feel bulky for fine work.
Which chainsaw supports more bar length options?
The Husqvarna 460 supports more bar length options. It can handle longer guide bars suitable for large cuts. The Stihl MS 170 is limited to shorter bars for light duty tasks.
Are replacement parts easy to find for both models?
Yes, replacement parts are easy to find for both chainsaws. Both brands have strong dealer networks and wide aftermarket support. This makes long term ownership more convenient.
Which model is better for occasional yard work?
The Stihl MS 170 is better for occasional yard work. It is lighter, less expensive, and simpler to operate. The Husqvarna 460 may be excessive for light and infrequent tasks.
Does the Husqvarna 460 require professional servicing?
Professional servicing is recommended but not always required for the Husqvarna 460. Routine maintenance can be done by the owner. Periodic professional inspection helps maintain peak performance.
How loud are these chainsaws during operation?
Both chainsaws are loud and require hearing protection. The Husqvarna 460 produces more noise due to its larger engine. The Stihl MS 170 is slightly quieter but still exceeds safe noise levels.
Which chainsaw is more durable long term?
The Husqvarna 460 is more durable for long term heavy use. Its reinforced components and higher quality materials are designed for demanding workloads. The Stihl MS 170 is durable within its intended light use range.
Can the Stihl MS 170 cut hardwood effectively?
The Stihl MS 170 can cut hardwood in small sizes. It is not ideal for thick or dense hardwood logs. Prolonged heavy cutting may strain the engine.
Is chain adjustment easy on both models?
Yes, chain adjustment is straightforward on both chainsaws. They use side mounted tensioning systems that improve safety. This allows quick adjustments during work.
Which chainsaw is better for extended daily use?
The Husqvarna 460 is better for extended daily use. Its fuel capacity, power, and vibration reduction support long workdays. The Stihl MS 170 is not designed for continuous operation.
Do both chainsaws have automatic chain lubrication?
Yes, both chainsaws feature automatic chain lubrication. This ensures consistent oil flow to the chain during operation. Proper lubrication helps extend chain and bar life.
Which model is more cost effective overall?
The Stihl MS 170 is more cost effective for light use. Its lower purchase price and simple maintenance reduce ownership costs. The Husqvarna 460 justifies its higher cost through performance and durability.
Can these chainsaws be used in cold weather?
Yes, both chainsaws can be used in cold weather with proper fuel mixture and maintenance. The Husqvarna 460 handles cold starts more efficiently due to better engine design. The Stihl MS 170 may require extra care in very low temperatures.
