Sodastream Cost vs Cans: Which Saves You Money?
Tired of lugging heavy cases of soda home from the store? Or maybe you’re looking for a more sustainable way to enjoy your favorite fizzy drinks? The age-old debate of convenience versus cost is front and center when comparing the SodaStream to traditional canned beverages.
This comparison delves into the real-world expenses of owning a SodaStream, from the initial investment to the ongoing costs of CO2 refills and flavorings. We’ll pit these expenses against the price of buying your favorite drinks in cans, considering factors like bulk discounts and potential waste.
Ultimately, this article aims to help you determine which option is the most financially savvy and environmentally friendly. We’ll explore the long-term implications of choosing between a SodaStream and buying cans, equipping you with the information you need to make the best choice for your lifestyle and budget.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | SodaStream | Cans |
|---|---|---|
| Carbonation Level Control | Yes | No |
| Flavor Variety | Wide Range of Syrups | Extensive |
| Storage Space Required | SodaStream Unit + Syrup Bottles | Requires space for storage |
| Portability | Limited (Unit is stationary) | Highly Portable |
| Environmental Impact | Reduced plastic waste with reusable bottles | Significant waste from aluminum cans |
| Convenience | Requires refilling CO2 cartridges | Readily Available |
| Customization | Adjustable Carbonation | Limited to pre-mixed flavors |
| Maintenance | Requires Cleaning | None |
| Availability | Requires buying syrups | Readily available |
| Flavor Customization | More control over flavor intensity | Pre-set flavor profiles |
| Operating Method | Manual/Electric (depending on model) | Open and Drink |
| Shelf Life | Syrups can expire | Long shelf life if unopened |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Initial Investment
- Sodastream Cost: The initial cost of a SodaStream machine varies depending on the model, ranging from around $80 to $200 or more. This includes the machine itself and a CO2 cylinder. The main con is the upfront investment compared to buying individual cans.
- Cans: The initial investment for cans is minimal, only the cost of the first purchase. You can buy individual cans or multi-packs. The con is that the cost adds up quickly over time with repeated purchases.
- Winner: Cans
Ongoing Cost of Carbonation
- Sodastream Cost: Requires the purchase of CO2 refills, which typically cost around $15-$20 per cylinder. Each cylinder carbonates a certain amount of water, so the cost per liter is relatively low. The major con is the recurring need for refills.
- Cans: Each can is a fixed cost. The cost is determined by the brand, retailer, and any special offers. The cost can fluctuate and often is more expensive than soda stream over time.
- Winner: SodaStream
Flavoring Cost
- Sodastream Cost: SodaStream offers flavor syrups, which can be purchased separately. These syrups add to the overall cost per serving, but offer a wide variety of flavors. The cost can be lower than buying pre-made flavored soda.
- Cans: Cans come pre-flavored, so no additional cost is incurred for flavor. However, the cost of the flavored soda is already built into the can’s price.
- Winner: Tie
Convenience
- Sodastream Cost: Offers on-demand carbonation and flavoring at home. It eliminates trips to the store for soda and reduces storage space needs. The initial setup and flavor mixing add some time.
- Cans: Cans are readily available, pre-made, and can be consumed immediately. However, you need to go to the store to get more and require storage space.
- Winner: Cans
Environmental Impact
- Sodastream Cost: Reduces the use of single-use plastic bottles and cans, which can have a positive environmental impact. However, the CO2 cylinders need to be refilled, and the syrups often come in plastic bottles.
- Cans: Cans contribute to waste and can have a significant environmental impact if not recycled. The production of cans also requires resources.
- Winner: SodaStream
Space Requirements
- Sodastream Cost: Requires space for the machine, CO2 cylinders, and flavor syrups.
- Cans: Requires space for storing the cans, which can be a significant amount depending on the consumption rate.
- Winner: SodaStream
Variety of Flavors
- Sodastream Cost: SodaStream offers a range of flavors, but the selection may be limited compared to the vast array of canned soda options.
- Cans: Offers a massive variety of flavors, brands, and types of soda.
- Winner: Cans
Long-Term Cost
- Sodastream Cost: Over time, the cost per serving with SodaStream is generally lower than buying canned soda, especially for frequent users, due to the CO2 refills and syrup costs.
- Cans: The recurring cost of buying cans adds up significantly over time, making it a more expensive option for regular soda consumption.
- Winner: SodaStream
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Environmental Friendliness | SodaStream |
| Flavor Variety | Cans |
| Cost (Long Term) | SodaStream |
| Convenience | Cans |
| Portability | Cans |
| Customization | SodaStream |
What They Have in Common:
- Taste: Both options deliver a fizzy, refreshing beverage, providing a similar experience for consumers.
- Hydration: Both cans and SodaStream can contribute to daily hydration needs, offering an alternative to plain water.
- Flavor Profiles: Both offer a variety of flavors, catering to different taste preferences, from classic cola to fruit-infused options.
- Social Aspect: Both are suitable for sharing with friends and family, making them a common choice for social gatherings.
- Availability: Both are widely available, with cans being found in almost any store, and SodaStream products accessible online and in many retailers.
Sodastream Cost Vs Cans Buying Guide
Initial Investment: Sodastream
The initial cost of a SodaStream is higher than buying a single can of soda. You’ll need to purchase the machine itself, which can range from basic models to more advanced ones with features like automatic carbonation. Furthermore, you’ll need to buy CO2 cylinders, which are essential for making sparkling water or soda. The upfront investment is significant compared to the small cost of individual cans. However, consider the long-term benefits when making your decision.
Ongoing Costs: Sodastream
The ongoing costs of a SodaStream primarily involve CO2 cylinder refills or exchanges and flavor syrups. CO2 cylinders need to be replaced periodically, and the cost varies depending on the exchange program. Flavor syrups also contribute to the overall cost, and there’s a wide range of options in terms of price. The cost of syrup can be more economical compared to buying pre-made soda. Overall, the ongoing expenses depend on your consumption habits and flavor choices.
Initial Investment: Cans
Buying individual cans of soda has a very low initial investment. You pay only for the cans you consume at the point of purchase. There’s no upfront cost for equipment or refills. You can buy single cans or multi-packs depending on your needs. This makes cans easily accessible and convenient for immediate consumption. However, the costs add up quickly over time compared to a SodaStream.
Ongoing Costs: Cans
The ongoing cost of buying cans is straightforward: the price of each can. This cost fluctuates depending on the brand, retailer, and any promotions that might be available. There are no additional expenses for equipment or refills, unlike with a SodaStream. However, the price per can is typically higher than making soda at home. Also, consider the convenience and environmental aspects when evaluating the ongoing costs.
Convenience and Accessibility: Sodastream
SodaStreams offer a degree of convenience. You can make sparkling water or soda at home on demand, and you can customize the level of fizz and flavor. However, you need to have CO2 cylinders and flavor syrups on hand. Some people may find the process of refilling the cylinders or cleaning the machine to be a hassle. It’s best suited for those who enjoy making their own drinks.
Convenience and Accessibility: Cans
Buying cans is very convenient. You can find them at nearly any grocery store, convenience store, or vending machine. The drinks are pre-made, so there’s no preparation required. This is a great choice for people who are always on the go or prefer instant gratification. There is no equipment to clean or maintain, and the cans are easily disposable. The downside is that you are limited to the available flavors.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy SodaStream If…
- You want to reduce your environmental impact by minimizing plastic waste.
- You enjoy experimenting with different flavor combinations and carbonation levels.
- You frequently consume carbonated beverages at home and want a cost-effective long-term solution.
- You value the convenience of making your own soda on demand.
Buy Cans If…
- You prioritize convenience and portability.
- You prefer a wide variety of pre-mixed flavors without needing to purchase additional syrups.
- You want a readily available option without the need for refilling CO2 cartridges or cleaning a machine.
- You are looking for a more affordable option for occasional consumption.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is SodaStream cheaper than buying cans?
Over the long term, a SodaStream can often be more cost-effective than buying cans of soda. The initial investment is higher, but the recurring costs of CO2 refills and flavor syrups are generally lower than the ongoing cost of purchasing individual cans. However, the savings depend on how frequently you consume soda. If you only drink soda occasionally, cans may be cheaper.
How long does a CO2 cylinder last?
The lifespan of a CO2 cylinder depends on the size of the cylinder and the amount of carbonation you use. A typical cylinder can carbonate dozens of bottles of water, varying from 60 to 130 liters. The frequency of use and the desired level of fizz impact how long the cylinder lasts. You can easily exchange cylinders when they run out.
Are SodaStream flavors cheaper than store-bought soda?
The cost of SodaStream flavor syrups can be more economical than buying pre-made soda. The price per serving tends to be lower, particularly if you purchase larger bottles of syrup. However, the cost varies depending on the brand and the type of flavor you choose. Some specialty flavors might be more expensive. In general, SodaStream syrups provide a cost-effective option.
What are the environmental benefits of a SodaStream?
SodaStreams can reduce your environmental impact by minimizing the use of plastic bottles and aluminum cans. Making soda at home eliminates the need for transporting and disposing of these containers, which helps reduce waste and carbon emissions. You can also control the ingredients and avoid unnecessary additives. This makes it a great choice for eco-conscious consumers.
How easy is it to use a SodaStream?
SodaStreams are generally very easy to use. Most models have a simple button or lever to carbonate the water. You fill the bottle with water, attach it to the machine, and press the button. Once the water is carbonated, you can add flavor syrups. The entire process takes only a few seconds, making it a convenient option for those who want homemade soda.
What are the disadvantages of a SodaStream?
One disadvantage of a SodaStream is the initial cost of the machine and the CO2 cylinders. Refilling the cylinders can be inconvenient if you don’t have a local exchange program. You may also need to purchase flavor syrups separately. Additionally, the machine requires some counter space and regular cleaning. These are factors to consider before investing in a SodaStream.
Are there any health benefits to using a SodaStream?
Using a SodaStream can potentially promote healthier hydration habits, particularly if you use it to make sparkling water instead of soda. You have control over the ingredients and can avoid excess sugar and artificial sweeteners. You can also add natural flavors like fruit slices or herbs to create refreshing and healthy drinks. This gives you more control over your beverage choices.
Final Verdict
While SodaStream requires a higher upfront investment, the long-term cost savings and environmental benefits make it the more economical choice for regular soda drinkers. Cans offer immediate convenience, but the cumulative expense outweighs their advantages.
Winner: SodaStream