Scotts vs Vigoro Weed and Feed: Which Is Best for Your Lawn?
Tired of battling weeds and struggling to get a lush, green lawn? You’re not alone. Many homeowners face the same challenge, and the solution often lies in choosing the right weed and feed product. But with so many options available, it can be tough to know where to start.
This comparison dives deep into two popular contenders: Scotts Weed & Feed and Vigoro Weed & Feed. We’ll explore their key features, effectiveness, and overall value. This will help you make an informed decision for a healthier, more beautiful lawn.
Get ready to discover which product is the perfect fit for your specific needs. We’ll analyze everything from weed control capabilities to the impact on your grass. So, let’s get started and find out which weed and feed treatment reigns supreme for your yard!
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | scotts | vigoro |
|---|---|---|
| Weed Control Type | Broadleaf & Grassy Weeds | Broadleaf & Grassy Weeds |
| Fertilizer Type | Granular | Granular |
| Coverage Area | Up to 15,000 sq ft | Up to 5,000 sq ft |
| Application Method | Spreader | Spreader |
| Active Ingredients (Weed Control) | Multiple | Multiple |
| Active Ingredients (Fertilizer) | Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium | Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium |
| Weed Control Effectiveness | Excellent | Good |
| Fertilizer Formula | Controlled Release | Quick Release |
| Lawn Types | Various | Various |
| Rain Delay | Requires Rain Delay | Requires Rain Delay |
| Application Timing | Spring & Fall | Spring & Fall |
| Available Sizes | Multiple | Multiple |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Weed Control Effectiveness
- Scotts: Scotts Weed & Feed typically uses a combination of herbicides to target a broad spectrum of weeds. It’s often effective against common lawn weeds like dandelions and clover. However, effectiveness can vary depending on the specific weed species and the product’s formulation.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed also aims for broad-spectrum weed control, utilizing herbicides that are designed to kill or suppress weeds. The effectiveness may vary based on the specific weeds present and the product’s formulation. Some users report less effectiveness on certain weed types compared to other brands.
- Winner: Tie
Fertilizer Composition & Coverage
- Scotts: Scotts offers various formulations with different NPK (Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium) ratios, catering to different lawn needs. Coverage is usually clearly indicated on the packaging, specifying the area the product will treat.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed products also come in various NPK ratios. Coverage areas are stated on the packaging. The specific fertilizer blend may vary by product and is designed to provide nutrients to the lawn.
- Winner: Tie
Application Method & Ease of Use
- Scotts: Scotts products often come in granular form, applied using a spreader. Instructions are generally straightforward, making application relatively easy for most users. Some products also offer ready-to-spray options for convenience.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed is typically applied using a spreader. Application instructions are usually easy to follow. Products are available in both granular and liquid formulations for application ease.
- Winner: Tie
Safety Considerations
- Scotts: Scotts products contain herbicides, so it’s important to follow safety instructions, including wearing appropriate protective gear and keeping pets and children away from the treated area until it’s dry. Some formulations may be more environmentally friendly than others.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed also contains herbicides, requiring the same safety precautions as Scotts. Read and follow all label instructions to minimize any potential risk to humans, pets, and the environment.
- Winner: Tie
Longevity & Effectiveness Duration
- Scotts: Scotts Weed & Feed’s effects typically last for a few weeks to a couple of months, depending on the specific product and environmental conditions. Repeated applications may be necessary for season-long weed control.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed’s effectiveness generally lasts for a similar duration to Scotts, ranging from a few weeks to a couple of months. The longevity will depend on the product formulation and local conditions.
- Winner: Tie
Price & Value
- Scotts: Scotts products are often priced competitively, with variations depending on the size of the bag and the specific formulation. Value is often perceived based on the product’s effectiveness and coverage area.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed is generally priced competitively within the weed and feed market. Value is often determined by the cost per square foot treated and the perceived performance.
- Winner: Tie
Weed Spectrum Control
- Scotts: Scotts aims to control a broad spectrum of weeds, but the specific weeds controlled depend on the product’s formulation. Some formulations are better at controlling certain types of weeds than others.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed also aims for broad-spectrum weed control. The effectiveness against specific weeds will depend on the product’s formulation and the weeds present in your lawn.
- Winner: Tie
Environmental Impact
- Scotts: Scotts products, like any herbicide-based product, can have an environmental impact. It’s important to follow application instructions to minimize runoff and potential harm to beneficial insects and aquatic life. Some formulations contain more environmentally friendly ingredients.
- Vigoro Weed and Feed: Vigoro Weed & Feed products also have the potential for environmental impact. Proper application and adherence to safety guidelines are crucial to minimize any negative effects on the environment.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Coverage Area | scotts |
| Weed Control Effectiveness | scotts |
| Fertilizer Formula | scotts |
| Price | vigoro |
What They Have in Common:
- Broad Spectrum Weed Control: Both products are designed to kill a variety of common lawn weeds, including broadleaf and grassy weeds. This makes them versatile options for general lawn maintenance.
- Granular Application: Both scotts and vigoro weed and feed products are applied in granular form, making them easy to spread using a standard lawn spreader. This ensures even distribution across your lawn.
- Fertilizer Included: Both products combine weed control with fertilizer, providing essential nutrients to promote healthy grass growth while tackling unwanted weeds. This saves time and effort.
- Spring and Fall Application: Both products are generally recommended for application during the spring and fall seasons, when weeds are actively growing and temperatures are suitable for fertilizer uptake. This is key for effectiveness.
- Easy Application: The granular form and spreader application makes it easy for homeowners to apply without hiring professional help.
Scotts Vs Vigoro Weed And Feed Buying Guide
Coverage Area
Understanding the coverage area is crucial when choosing a weed and feed product. Scotts often provides detailed information about how much area a single bag can treat, making it easier to calculate the amount needed for your lawn. Vigoro also specifies its coverage, but it’s essential to compare the sizes to ensure you’re getting the best value for your money and that you purchase enough product to treat your entire lawn. Consider any overlapping needed to ensure complete coverage. This prevents any missed spots.
Weed Control Spectrum
The range of weeds that a product effectively controls is a significant factor. Scotts and Vigoro typically target common lawn weeds like dandelions, clover, and crabgrass. However, they may differ in their effectiveness against specific weed types. Carefully review the product labels to identify which weeds are listed as controlled. Consider the specific weeds present in your lawn to select the most appropriate product for your needs. Some weeds may require a product with a broader spectrum of control.
Fertilizer Composition
The fertilizer component of a weed and feed product is essential for promoting healthy grass growth. Both Scotts and Vigoro offer various fertilizer formulations, typically including nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium (NPK) in different ratios. Examine the NPK ratio on the product label to determine if it suits your lawn’s specific needs. Consider your soil test results and the type of grass you have when choosing a fertilizer. A balanced fertilizer will provide the nutrients your lawn needs.
Application Timing
Proper application timing is crucial for the effectiveness of weed and feed products. Scotts and Vigoro products generally recommend application during specific seasons, usually spring and fall. The best time to apply is when weeds are actively growing, and the grass is also actively growing. Follow the instructions on the product label carefully, as timing can vary based on the specific formulation and the climate. Incorrect timing can reduce the product’s effectiveness and potentially harm your lawn.
Safety Precautions
Safety is paramount when using weed and feed products. Always read and follow the safety instructions provided on the product label. This includes wearing appropriate protective gear, such as gloves and a mask, and keeping children and pets away from the treated area until it is dry. Be mindful of the wind conditions to prevent drift and avoid applying the product near water sources. Store the product in a safe place, out of reach of children and pets.
Price and Value
Compare the price of Scotts and Vigoro weed and feed products to determine which offers the best value. Consider the coverage area, the fertilizer composition, and the weed control spectrum when evaluating the price. Sometimes, a slightly more expensive product may offer better performance and coverage, resulting in a better value in the long run. Also, look for sales and promotions to save money. Evaluate how much product is needed and the cost per square foot of treatment.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy scotts If…
- You have a larger lawn and need broader coverage.
- You prefer controlled-release fertilizer for longer-lasting feeding.
- You are looking for a product with a proven track record for weed control effectiveness.
- You value a well-known brand with a wide range of product options.
Buy vigoro weed and feed If…
- You have a smaller lawn area to treat.
- You prefer a quick-release fertilizer for faster greening.
- You are looking for a more budget-friendly option.
- You prefer a product available at your local home improvement store.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference between Scotts and Vigoro weed and feed products?
The primary difference lies in their formulations and the specific weeds they target. Scotts often offers a wider range of products tailored to different grass types and weed problems, while Vigoro provides effective solutions for common lawn weeds. Both brands utilize different active ingredients and fertilizer blends, so it is important to check the product label for specifics. Consider the type of grass and weeds present on your lawn to select the correct product.
Are Scotts and Vigoro weed and feed products safe for pets and children?
Both products are generally safe when used according to the manufacturer’s instructions. It is crucial to keep pets and children away from the treated area until the product is completely dry. Always read and follow the safety precautions on the product label. This includes wearing protective gear during application. Take extra precautions to prevent drift onto areas where pets and children play.
How often should I apply Scotts or Vigoro weed and feed?
The frequency of application depends on the specific product and the condition of your lawn. Typically, a single application in the spring and potentially another in the fall is sufficient. However, it’s vital to follow the product label’s instructions, as the timing and frequency may vary. Consider factors like the specific weeds you are targeting and the type of grass on your lawn. Do not exceed the recommended application rates.
Can I use Scotts or Vigoro weed and feed on all types of grass?
Not all weed and feed products are suitable for all grass types. Some products are formulated for specific grass varieties, such as fescue, bluegrass, or Bermuda grass. Always read the product label to ensure it is compatible with your lawn’s grass type. Using an incompatible product can damage your lawn. If unsure, test a small area first to observe the effects.
What should I do if it rains after applying weed and feed?
If rain occurs shortly after application, it may reduce the product’s effectiveness. Most products require a certain amount of time to be absorbed by the weeds and the grass. Check the product label for specific instructions. Some products may need to be reapplied if heavy rain occurs within a few hours of application, while others may be more resistant to wash-off. The label provides the most accurate information.
How long after applying weed and feed can I water my lawn?
The waiting period before watering your lawn after applying weed and feed varies depending on the product. Generally, it is best to avoid watering for at least 24-48 hours to allow the product to be absorbed. This allows the weed control and fertilizer components to work effectively. Refer to the product label for specific instructions. The label will provide the precise waiting time.
How do I store Scotts or Vigoro weed and feed products?
Store weed and feed products in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and out of reach of children and pets. Keep the product in its original container and ensure the lid is tightly sealed to prevent moisture and contamination. Proper storage helps maintain the product’s effectiveness and prevents accidental exposure or misuse. Follow the storage instructions on the product label.
Final Verdict
Both Scotts and Vigoro offer effective weed and feed solutions for lawn care. While both brands control a wide variety of weeds and provide essential nutrients, the best choice depends on your specific lawn needs and the weeds you are facing. Consider factors like the grass type, the weeds present, and the fertilizer composition to determine the optimal product for your lawn.
Winner: [Winning Product Name]