Sandisk Extreme vs Ultra Plus: Which Sd Card Wins?
Choosing the right SD card can be a headache. With so many options, it’s easy to get lost in the specs. Today, we’re putting two popular contenders head-to-head: the SanDisk Extreme and the SanDisk Ultra Plus.
Both cards promise to store your precious photos, videos, and files, but which one is the better choice for you? We’ll dive deep into their performance, features, and value to help you make an informed decision. This comparison will help you navigate the features.
Whether you’re a casual photographer or a professional videographer, understanding the differences between these two SD cards is crucial. Get ready to discover which SanDisk card reigns supreme in this detailed comparison of the SanDisk Extreme vs. Ultra Plus!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Extreme | Ultra Plus |
|---|---|---|
| Sequential Read Speed | Up to 190 MB/s | Up to 160 MB/s |
| Sequential Write Speed | Up to 130 MB/s | Up to 100 MB/s |
| Interface | UHS-I | UHS-I |
| Form Factor | SD Card | SD Card |
| Video Speed Class | V30 | V30 |
| Application Performance Class | A2 | A1 |
| Durability | Waterproof, Temperature Proof, Shockproof, X-ray Proof | Waterproof, Temperature Proof, Shockproof, X-ray Proof |
| Operating Temperature | -25°C to 85°C | -25°C to 85°C |
| Storage Capacities | 32GB – 256GB | 32GB – 512GB |
| Ideal Use | DSLR Cameras, 4K UHD Video Recording | DSLR Cameras, Full HD Video Recording |
| Warranty | Lifetime Limited | Lifetime Limited |
| Included Software | RescuePRO Deluxe data recovery software (download offer) | RescuePRO Deluxe data recovery software (download offer) |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Read Speed
- Sandisk Extreme: Boasts impressive read speeds, often exceeding 150MB/s, allowing for quick file access and system responsiveness. However, real-world performance can vary depending on the specific model and file types.
- Ultra Plus: Offers decent read speeds, typically around 100MB/s, making it suitable for general use. While not as fast as the Extreme, it still provides a noticeable performance boost over traditional hard drives.
- Winner: Extreme
Write Speed
- Sandisk Extreme: Excels in write speed, enabling faster file transfers and video editing workflows. Its write speed is significantly higher than the Ultra Plus, making it ideal for content creators.
- Ultra Plus: Provides adequate write speeds for everyday tasks, but it’s noticeably slower than the Extreme. This can lead to longer wait times when saving large files or transferring data.
- Winner: Extreme
Durability
- Sandisk Extreme: Designed for rugged use, with shock and vibration resistance. It’s built to withstand harsher environments, making it suitable for professionals who work outdoors.
- Ultra Plus: Offers a degree of durability, but it’s not as robust as the Extreme. It’s generally suitable for everyday use but may not be the best choice for extreme conditions.
- Winner: Extreme
Capacity Options
- Sandisk Extreme: Available in a wide range of capacities, catering to diverse storage needs. Offers ample space for storing large media files, applications, and operating systems.
- Ultra Plus: Usually available in a more limited range of capacities compared to the Extreme. May not have the same variety of large-capacity options.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Sandisk Extreme: Generally priced higher than the Ultra Plus due to its superior performance and features. The increased cost reflects the enhanced read/write speeds and durability.
- Ultra Plus: More budget-friendly than the Extreme, making it an attractive option for users on a tight budget. Provides good value for its performance level.
- Winner: Ultra Plus
Warranty
- Sandisk Extreme: Typically comes with a longer warranty period, reflecting the manufacturer’s confidence in its durability and reliability. Provides peace of mind for the user.
- Ultra Plus: Often has a shorter warranty period compared to the Extreme. This may be a factor to consider for long-term usage.
- Winner: Extreme
Target User
- Sandisk Extreme: Designed for professionals and enthusiasts who require top-tier performance and durability. Ideal for photographers, videographers, and users who handle large files regularly.
- Ultra Plus: Best suited for everyday users who need a performance boost over a traditional hard drive without breaking the bank. Good for general computing tasks and light content creation.
- Winner: Tie
Power Consumption
- Sandisk Extreme: Typically consumes a moderate amount of power. While generally energy-efficient, the increased performance may slightly impact battery life in laptops.
- Ultra Plus: Generally more power-efficient than the Extreme, leading to slightly longer battery life in laptops. This can be a significant advantage for mobile users.
- Winner: Ultra Plus
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Sequential Read Speed | Extreme |
| Sequential Write Speed | Extreme |
| Application Performance Class | Extreme |
| Video Recording (4K) | Extreme |
| Value | Ultra Plus |
| Storage Capacity Options | Ultra Plus |
What They Have in Common
- Interface: Both cards utilize the UHS-I interface, ensuring compatibility with a wide range of devices and offering decent transfer speeds.
- Durability: Both the SanDisk Extreme and Ultra Plus SD cards are built to withstand harsh conditions, offering protection against water, temperature extremes, shocks, and X-rays.
- Warranty: Both cards are backed by a lifetime limited warranty, providing users with peace of mind regarding their investment.
- Rescue Software: Both cards include a download offer for RescuePRO Deluxe data recovery software, helping users recover accidentally deleted files.
- Operating Temperature: Both cards share the same operating temperature range, allowing them to function reliably in various climates.
Sandisk Extreme Vs Ultra Plus Buying Guide
Performance Needs
Consider your primary use case. The SanDisk Extreme generally offers faster read and write speeds, making it ideal for professional photographers and videographers who require quick file transfers and 4K video recording capabilities. If you’re primarily using the card for casual photography or Full HD video recording, the Ultra Plus might suffice. Think about the size of the files you’ll be working with. Larger video files and RAW photos demand higher performance.
Storage Capacity
Assess your storage requirements. Both the Extreme and Ultra Plus are available in various capacities. Determine how much storage you realistically need based on the number of photos and videos you typically capture. Consider future needs as well. It’s often better to opt for a larger capacity card to avoid running out of space, especially when shooting in higher resolutions or for extended periods. Both cards are available in a wide range of capacities.
Durability and Reliability
Evaluate the importance of durability. The SanDisk Extreme is often built with a more rugged design, offering better resistance to extreme temperatures, water, shock, and X-rays. This makes it a preferred choice for outdoor adventures or harsh environments. The Ultra Plus generally offers decent durability, but may not be as robust. If you’re concerned about data loss due to environmental factors, the Extreme provides added peace of mind. Check the warranty information.
Price Comparison
Compare the prices of the Extreme and Ultra Plus for the specific capacity you need. The Ultra Plus is typically more affordable, making it a budget-friendly option. The Extreme, with its higher performance and added durability, comes at a premium. Determine if the performance and durability benefits of the Extreme justify the higher cost for your specific needs. Look for sales and promotions to get the best deal. Consider the cost per gigabyte.
Compatibility Considerations
Ensure compatibility with your devices. Both cards use the SD card format and are generally compatible with most cameras, camcorders, and other devices that support SD cards. However, always check the specifications of your devices to ensure they support the card’s speed class (e.g., UHS-I or UHS-II) and capacity. Using a card that is not compatible with your device will result in slower speeds or the card not working at all. Consult your device’s manual for details.
Warranty and Support
Consider the warranty and support offered by SanDisk. SanDisk provides a warranty for both the Extreme and Ultra Plus cards. Review the warranty terms and conditions, including the duration and coverage. SanDisk also offers customer support resources, such as online FAQs, email support, and phone support. Choosing a card with a good warranty and readily available support can provide added assurance in case of any issues. Check for product registration.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Extreme If…
- You require faster write speeds for continuous shooting or 4K video recording.
- You need an SD card with higher application performance.
- You prioritize the fastest possible transfer speeds for moving large files.
- You plan on using the card in professional or demanding environments.
Buy Ultra Plus If…
- You primarily shoot Full HD video or take photos and don’t need the absolute fastest speeds.
- You prioritize a card with a broader range of available storage capacities.
- You’re looking for a reliable card for everyday use in a variety of devices.
- You want a balance of performance and value.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between SanDisk Extreme and Ultra Plus?
The primary difference lies in performance. The SanDisk Extreme offers significantly faster read and write speeds compared to the Ultra Plus. This results in quicker file transfers, faster burst shooting, and smoother 4K video recording. The Extreme is also built with a more rugged design. The Ultra Plus is generally a more affordable option, suitable for less demanding tasks.
Which card is better for 4K video recording?
The SanDisk Extreme is the better choice for 4K video recording. Its higher write speeds ensure that the video data is captured smoothly and without dropped frames. The Ultra Plus may be adequate for some 4K recording, but it might struggle with higher bitrates or longer recording times. Ensure your device supports the card’s speed class for optimal performance.
Is the SanDisk Extreme more durable than the Ultra Plus?
Yes, the SanDisk Extreme is generally more durable than the Ultra Plus. It’s often designed to withstand extreme temperatures, water, shock, and X-rays, making it more reliable in harsh environments. The Ultra Plus still offers decent durability, but it might not be as robust. Consider your usage environment when deciding which card is best.
Which card is better for general photography?
The SanDisk Extreme is a better choice for professional photography and for photographers who shoot in RAW format or require fast burst shooting. The Ultra Plus is suitable for casual photography and for those who primarily shoot in JPEG format. Consider the speed of your camera and your shooting style when making your decision.
Does the Ultra Plus support UHS-I or UHS-II?
The SanDisk Ultra Plus typically supports UHS-I. This means it offers faster speeds than older SD cards but is not as fast as UHS-II cards. Check the specific product specifications to confirm the exact speed class. Your device must also support UHS-I to take advantage of the faster speeds. Make sure to check your device’s compatibility.
What is the warranty period for these cards?
SanDisk offers a limited warranty for both the Extreme and Ultra Plus cards. The warranty period can vary depending on the specific product and region. Check the packaging or the SanDisk website for the exact warranty terms and conditions. The warranty typically covers manufacturing defects and provides for replacement or repair of the card.
Which card is better for transferring large files?
The SanDisk Extreme is significantly better for transferring large files due to its faster read and write speeds. This results in quicker transfer times when moving files to and from your computer or other devices. The Ultra Plus is slower, so transferring large files will take longer. Consider the time you spend transferring files.
Final Verdict
The SanDisk Extreme offers superior performance and durability, making it the better choice for professional use and demanding tasks like 4K video recording. The Ultra Plus is a more affordable option that is still suitable for casual photography and general use. The Extreme’s faster speeds and rugged design justify the higher price for those who need it.
Winner: SanDisk Extreme