Tired of vacuuming? The dream of a self-cleaning home is closer than ever, and iRobot’s Roomba series is leading the charge. But with so many options, choosing the right one can be tricky. Today, we’re diving deep into a head-to-head battle: the Roomba i5 vs i5+.
Both the Roomba i5 and i5+ promise to take the chore of vacuuming off your hands. They share many core features, like powerful cleaning and smart navigation. However, there’s a key difference that could sway your decision, depending on your lifestyle and cleaning needs.
We’ll explore the similarities and differences, from cleaning performance to convenience features. By the end of this comparison, you’ll know which Roomba is the perfect fit for your home and whether the extra investment in the i5+ is worth it.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | roomba i5 | i5+ |
|---|---|---|
| Navigation | iAdapt 2.0 | iAdapt 2.0 |
| Smart Mapping | No | No |
| Automatic Dirt Disposal | No | Yes |
| Coverage | Up to 900 sq ft | Up to 900 sq ft |
| Runtime | Up to 90 minutes | Up to 90 minutes |
| Recharge and Resume | Yes | Yes |
| Wi-Fi Connectivity | Yes | Yes |
| Voice Assistant Compatibility | Yes (Alexa, Google Assistant) | Yes (Alexa, Google Assistant) |
| Brush System | Dual Multi-Surface Rubber Brushes | Dual Multi-Surface Rubber Brushes |
| Filter Type | High-Efficiency Filter | High-Efficiency Filter |
| Dirt Detection | Yes | Yes |
| Control Method | App, Voice, Buttons | App, Voice, Buttons |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Navigation System
- Roomba I5: Utilizes iRobot’s iAdapt 2.0 Navigation with Reactive Sensor Technology. This system navigates logically in straight lines and avoids obstacles, but may occasionally miss spots. Pros include efficient cleaning and cons include possible missed areas.
- I5+: Employs the same iAdapt 2.0 Navigation with Reactive Sensor Technology as the i5. This results in the same logical cleaning patterns and obstacle avoidance, with similar potential for occasional missed spots. Pros and cons are the same as the i5.
- Winner: Tie
Suction Power
- Roomba I5: Features a powerful suction system, great for picking up dirt, debris, and pet hair from hard floors and carpets. Performance is good, but can be less effective on thicker carpets. The i5 utilizes the standard iRobot suction design.
- I5+: Offers the same suction power as the i5. This means consistent cleaning performance across different floor types, but may struggle slightly on particularly thick carpets.
- Winner: Tie
Dustbin Capacity
- Roomba I5: Has a standard-sized dustbin that needs to be manually emptied after each cleaning session. This requires user interaction, but allows for direct visual inspection of the debris collected.
- I5+: Comes with a larger dustbin and includes the Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal system. This system automatically empties the robot’s dustbin into a larger bag, reducing the need for frequent emptying.
- Winner: i5+
Automatic Dirt Disposal
- Roomba I5: Does not include an automatic dirt disposal system. The user must manually empty the dustbin after each cleaning session.
- I5+: Includes the Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal system. This feature automatically empties the robot’s dustbin into a larger bag, requiring less user intervention.
- Winner: i5+
Mapping and Smart Features
- Roomba I5: Does not feature smart mapping capabilities. It cleans in a more random pattern, and doesn’t remember where it has cleaned. Uses iRobot Home app for basic control.
- I5+: Does not have Smart Mapping. It cleans in a more random pattern, and doesn’t remember where it has cleaned. Uses iRobot Home app for basic control.
- Winner: Tie
Coverage and Cleaning Area
- Roomba I5: Cleans an average-sized home well, but may require more frequent recharges and the user may need to manually move it to cover larger spaces.
- I5+: Offers the same cleaning coverage area as the i5. This may require multiple cleaning cycles for larger homes, but the automatic dirt disposal base allows for more unattended cleaning.
- Winner: Tie
Battery Life and Charging
- Roomba I5: Offers a decent battery life, typically enough for one cleaning cycle in an average-sized home. Automatically returns to its charging dock when the battery is low.
- I5+: Provides the same battery life as the i5. It will automatically return to the Clean Base for charging, then resume cleaning where it left off.
- Winner: Tie
Pricing
- Roomba I5: Generally more affordable due to the lack of the Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal system. Great for those on a budget.
- I5+: Priced higher than the i5 due to the inclusion of the Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal system, which adds convenience but increases the overall cost.
- Winner: roomba i5
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Automatic Dirt Disposal | i5+ |
| Overall Value | roomba i5 |
| Ease of Maintenance | i5+ |
| Features | i5+ |
| Cleaning Performance | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Navigation: Both the i5 and i5+ utilize the iAdapt 2.0 navigation system to move around your home effectively. They use sensors to navigate and avoid obstacles, ensuring comprehensive cleaning coverage.
- Cleaning System: Both models feature the Dual Multi-Surface Rubber Brushes, designed to flex and adapt to different floor types, effectively capturing dirt, debris, and pet hair.
- Wi-Fi Connectivity: Both robots connect to your home’s Wi-Fi network, enabling control and scheduling through the iRobot HOME app. This allows for convenient operation from anywhere.
- Voice Assistant Compatibility: Both are compatible with voice assistants like Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, allowing for hands-free control and cleaning initiation.
- Dirt Detection: Both robots use Dirt Detect technology to identify areas with concentrated dirt, prompting them to clean those spots more thoroughly.
Roomba i5 vs i5+ Buying Guide
i5 and i5+ Features Comparison
The Roomba i5 and i5+ share core cleaning features, including the three-stage cleaning system and reactive sensor technology to avoid obstacles. They both offer smart navigation, learning your home layout over time. The key differentiator is the Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal system. The i5 requires manual emptying of the dustbin, while the i5+ automatically empties its bin into the Clean Base, offering hands-free convenience for weeks. This is a significant factor in deciding which model suits your lifestyle and cleaning preferences, especially for those with allergies or busy schedules. Consider your tolerance for manual maintenance.
Cleaning Performance and Navigation
Both Roomba i5 models deliver solid cleaning performance, effectively removing dirt and debris from various floor types. The i5 series utilizes iRobot’s patented three-stage cleaning system, which includes edge-sweeping brushes, dual multi-surface rubber brushes, and powerful suction. Their smart navigation allows for methodical cleaning in straight lines, covering your home efficiently. They learn your home’s layout and adjust cleaning patterns. Keep in mind that while both offer strong performance, the i5+’s auto-empty feature adds to its overall convenience and ease of use. (See Also: Nest Cam Vs Ring )
Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal (i5+ Advantage)
The Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal system is the standout feature of the i5+. This system automatically empties the robot’s dustbin into a sealed bag, eliminating the need for frequent manual emptying. This is particularly beneficial for users with pets or allergies, as it reduces exposure to dust and allergens. The Clean Base can hold weeks’ worth of debris, allowing you to enjoy a hands-free cleaning experience for an extended period. This feature is a significant convenience upgrade, making the i5+ a more user-friendly option for many households. The i5 lacks this feature.
Ease of Use and Maintenance
Both models are easy to set up and control through the iRobot app. You can schedule cleaning sessions, customize cleaning preferences, and monitor the robot’s progress. The primary maintenance difference lies in the dustbin. The i5 requires regular emptying, cleaning, and filter replacements. The i5+ reduces maintenance with its automatic dirt disposal, requiring only occasional bag replacements in the Clean Base. Consider the time you want to spend on maintenance when choosing. The i5+ simplifies the process.
Price Comparison and Value
The Roomba i5+ typically costs more than the i5 due to the inclusion of the Clean Base. However, the added convenience of the automatic dirt disposal system often justifies the price difference. Assess your budget and cleaning needs to determine which model offers the best value. If you prioritize convenience and are willing to pay extra for a hands-free experience, the i5+ is worth considering. If budget is a key concern and you don’t mind emptying the dustbin, the i5 offers excellent cleaning performance at a lower price point. Compare current prices.
Connectivity and Smart Home Integration
Both Roomba i5 models offer smart home integration, allowing you to control and monitor the robot through the iRobot app. They are compatible with voice assistants like Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, enabling voice commands for starting, stopping, and scheduling cleaning tasks. You can also create cleaning schedules and customize cleaning zones through the app. The i5 and i5+ provide a seamless smart home experience. Consider your existing smart home ecosystem and how you want to integrate your robot vacuum into it. Both offer similar functionality. (See Also: Lose It Vs Weight Watchers )
Who Should Buy What?
Buy roomba i5 If…
- You want a reliable, entry-level Roomba that delivers solid cleaning performance.
- You don’t need the convenience of automatic dirt disposal.
- You are on a tighter budget and want to save money.
- You prefer a robot that requires less initial investment.
Buy i5+ If…
- You want the convenience of a self-emptying dustbin.
- You want to minimize the need for manual maintenance.
- You have a larger home or a home with lots of pet hair.
- You’re willing to pay more for added convenience and less hands-on maintenance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference between the Roomba i5 and i5+?
The main difference is the Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal system included with the i5+. This feature allows the i5+ to automatically empty its dustbin into a sealed bag, reducing the need for manual emptying. The i5 lacks this feature, requiring you to empty its bin regularly. This adds convenience and reduces maintenance for the i5+.
Does the i5+ have better cleaning performance than the i5?
No, the cleaning performance is virtually identical between the two models. Both utilize the same three-stage cleaning system and smart navigation technology. The i5+’s advantage lies in its automatic dirt disposal, which enhances convenience. They both effectively clean various floor types, offering comparable suction and brush performance.
How often do I need to replace the Clean Base bag on the i5+?
The Clean Base bag on the i5+ typically needs to be replaced every few months, depending on your cleaning frequency and the amount of debris your robot collects. iRobot recommends checking the bag regularly and replacing it when it’s full. The iRobot app may also send you alerts. This is far less frequent than emptying the i5’s bin.
Can I control the Roomba i5 models with my smartphone?
Yes, both Roomba i5 models are fully compatible with the iRobot app. This allows you to schedule cleaning sessions, customize cleaning preferences, monitor the robot’s progress, and receive maintenance alerts. The app provides comprehensive control and monitoring capabilities for both the i5 and i5+ models. (See Also: Bose Quiet Comfort Vs Airpods Pro )
Are the i5 and i5+ compatible with voice assistants?
Yes, both models are compatible with voice assistants like Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant. You can use voice commands to start, stop, pause, and schedule cleaning tasks. This allows for hands-free control and integration with your existing smart home ecosystem. Voice control enhances the overall user experience.
How do the i5 and i5+ navigate my home?
Both Roomba i5 models use smart navigation technology to learn your home’s layout and clean in methodical rows. They avoid obstacles and adapt to different floor types. They create a map of your home over time. This ensures efficient and thorough cleaning coverage. The navigation is effective for both models.
Is the i5+ worth the extra cost?
Whether the i5+ is worth the extra cost depends on your priorities and budget. If convenience and hands-free operation are important, and you’re willing to pay more, the i5+ is a great choice. If budget is a primary concern, or you don’t mind emptying the dustbin regularly, the i5 still offers excellent cleaning performance. Consider the trade-offs.
Final Verdict
The Roomba i5 and i5+ offer strong cleaning performance and smart features. The i5 provides great value, while the i5+ offers the added convenience of automatic dirt disposal. The choice depends on your budget and preferred level of hands-off operation. For those seeking the ultimate in convenience, the i5+ is the better choice.
Winner: Roomba i5+