Rolex Submariner 40mm vs 41mm: Which Should You Buy?
The Rolex Submariner. A name synonymous with luxury, adventure, and timeless design. But when faced with the choice between the iconic 40mm and the slightly updated 41mm versions, which one reigns supreme? This comparison dives deep into the details to help you decide which Submariner best suits your wrist and your lifestyle.
Both the Rolex Submariner 40mm and the 41mm models share the same DNA: a robust, water-resistant case, a highly legible dial, and the unmistakable Oyster bracelet. However, subtle but significant differences exist, impacting aesthetics, comfort, and perhaps even investment potential. We’ll explore these nuances to help you make an informed decision.
Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a first-time Rolex buyer, understanding the specifics of the Rolex Submariner 40mm vs 41mm is crucial. We’ll cover everything from the case dimensions and movement to the visual impact and overall wearability. Get ready to discover which Submariner deserves a place on your wrist.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | 40mm | 41mm |
|---|---|---|
| Case Diameter | 40mm | 41mm |
| Movement | Caliber 3130/3135 | Caliber 3230/3235 |
| Crystal | Sapphire | Sapphire |
| Water Resistance | 300 meters (1,000 feet) | 300 meters (1,000 feet) |
| Bezel | Unidirectional Rotatable Cerachrom | Unidirectional Rotatable Cerachrom |
| Lume | Chromalight | Chromalight |
| Bracelet | Oyster | Oyster |
| Clasp | Glidelock Clasp | Glidelock Clasp |
| Dial | Variety of colors | Variety of colors |
| Power Reserve | ~48 hours | ~70 hours |
| Accuracy | -2 / +2 seconds per day | -2 / +2 seconds per day |
| Lug Width | 20mm | 21mm |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Case Size
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: The classic Submariner case size, measuring 40mm in diameter. It offers a more compact and traditional feel on the wrist. Some find it to be a more balanced and timeless design, suitable for a wider range of wrist sizes.
- 41mm: A slightly larger case size at 41mm, providing a more modern and substantial presence. This offers a more contemporary aesthetic and can appear bolder on the wrist. Some may find it more suitable for those with larger wrists or those who prefer a more prominent watch.
- Winner: Tie
Crystal
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: Features a sapphire crystal, known for its scratch resistance and clarity. It provides excellent protection for the dial.
- 41mm: Also features a sapphire crystal, identical to the 40mm in terms of scratch resistance and clarity.
- Winner: Tie
Movement
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: Typically houses older Rolex movements, which are still highly reliable and accurate. Maintenance and servicing costs may vary depending on the specific movement.
- 41mm: Equipped with Rolex’s newer generation movements, often featuring improved accuracy, power reserve, and efficiency. This could mean increased long-term reliability and potentially lower servicing costs, although this is speculative.
- Winner: 41mm
Bezel
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: Features a unidirectional rotatable bezel, usually made of aluminum. Aluminum bezels can be more prone to scratches and fading over time.
- 41mm: Features a unidirectional rotatable bezel, typically made of Cerachrom (ceramic). Cerachrom is highly scratch-resistant and resistant to fading, offering superior durability.
- Winner: 41mm
Lugs
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: The lugs are slightly more refined.
- 41mm: The lugs are slightly wider, and more modern.
- Winner: Tie
Dial
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: The dial retains the classic Submariner design, which many find to be timeless.
- 41mm: The dial has been slightly redesigned, with some minor changes to the hands and hour markers.
- Winner: Tie
Bracelet
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: Typically features an Oyster bracelet.
- 41mm: Typically features a slightly wider Oyster bracelet with a redesigned clasp.
- Winner: 41mm
Availability & Price
- Rolex Submariner 40mm: Generally, the 40mm can be found for a lower price.
- 41mm: The 41mm may have a higher price.
- Winner: 40mm
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Overall Design (Subjective) | Tie |
| Movement (Power Reserve) | 41mm |
| Wrist Presence | 41mm |
| Classic Appeal | 40mm |
| Availability | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Water Resistance: Both the 40mm and 41mm Submariner models boast an impressive water resistance of 300 meters (1,000 feet), making them suitable for diving and various water activities.
- Crystal: Both models are equipped with a scratch-resistant sapphire crystal, ensuring durability and clear visibility of the dial.
- Bezel: Both feature a unidirectional rotatable bezel, a signature element of the Submariner design, crafted from durable Cerachrom.
- Lume: Both models utilize Rolex’s Chromalight display, providing excellent legibility in low-light conditions with long-lasting luminescence.
- Bracelet and Clasp: Both use the iconic Oyster bracelet and feature the Glidelock clasp for easy adjustment and a secure fit.
- Movement Accuracy: Both models adhere to Rolex’s stringent standards for precision, maintaining a rate of -2 / +2 seconds per day.
Rolex Submariner 40mm vs 41mm Buying Guide
Design and Aesthetics
The core design philosophy of the Rolex Submariner remains consistent across both the 40mm and 41mm models, featuring the iconic Oyster case, unidirectional rotating bezel, and highly legible dial. However, subtle differences exist. The 41mm offers slightly more refined proportions, with thinner lugs and a wider bracelet. These changes contribute to a more modern and balanced aesthetic. The dial layout is largely the same, but the 41mm often incorporates slightly wider hands and markers for enhanced readability. The overall impression is one of evolution, not revolution, with the 41mm presenting a more contemporary take on a classic design.
Case Size and Comfort
While the difference in size seems minimal, the 41mm Submariner wears slightly larger on the wrist. The 40mm model, with its more compact dimensions, is often perceived as more classic and versatile, suiting a wider range of wrist sizes. The 41mm, with its increased presence, appeals to those who prefer a bolder look. Comfort is subjective and depends heavily on wrist size and shape. Both models feature the Oyster bracelet, known for its robustness and comfort. Ultimately, trying both on is essential to determine which size feels best and offers the most comfortable fit for your individual wrist.
Movement and Performance
The 41mm Submariner benefits from the newer generation Rolex movements, typically the calibre 3230 or 3235, which offer significant improvements over the older movements found in some 40mm models. These advancements include increased power reserve (approximately 70 hours versus 48 hours), enhanced accuracy, and improved resistance to shocks and magnetism. The 40mm versions, if equipped with older movements, still offer reliable performance, but the newer movements in the 41mm provide a tangible upgrade in terms of technical specifications and overall functionality. This offers enhanced performance.
Availability and Resale Value
The availability of both models fluctuates based on market conditions, specific reference numbers, and the overall demand for Rolex watches. The 41mm Submariner, being the newer model, is often more readily available at authorized dealers, though demand still generally exceeds supply. Resale values are heavily influenced by these factors, along with the condition of the watch, its rarity, and the current market trends. Generally, both models retain their value exceptionally well, making them sound investments. Consulting with authorized dealers and reputable pre-owned watch specialists is crucial for assessing current market values.
Bracelet and Clasp
Both models feature the iconic Oyster bracelet, renowned for its durability and comfort. The 41mm model often incorporates a slightly wider bracelet, contributing to a more balanced aesthetic. Both models typically include the Glidelock clasp, a crucial feature that allows for fine-tuning the bracelet length without the need for tools, offering a perfect fit in any situation. The Glidelock clasp is particularly useful for divers, allowing the watch to be worn comfortably over a wetsuit. The overall quality and functionality of the bracelet and clasp are consistent across both generations.
Pricing and Value Proposition
The retail price of the 41mm Submariner is typically slightly higher than the older 40mm models, reflecting the advancements in movement technology and the subtle design refinements. However, the actual market price, especially in the pre-owned market, can vary significantly depending on the specific reference number, condition, and current demand. Both models represent a strong value proposition, considering their iconic status, robust build quality, and enduring appeal. The choice ultimately depends on your budget and preference for features like the newer movement and updated design elements in the 41mm model.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Rolex Submariner 40mm If…
- You prefer a more classic and traditional size.
- You appreciate the historical significance of the original Submariner design.
- You have a smaller wrist size.
- You find the 40mm model more aesthetically pleasing.
Buy 41mm If…
- You prefer a slightly larger and more modern wrist presence.
- You want the updated movement with a longer power reserve.
- You prefer the slightly redesigned case and bracelet.
- You have a larger wrist size.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the key differences between the 40mm and 41mm Rolex Submariner?
The primary differences lie in the case size, with the 41mm version being slightly larger. The 41mm also often features a more modern design with thinner lugs and a wider bracelet. The movements are typically newer in the 41mm, offering increased power reserve and improved accuracy. The 41mm has a more contemporary look and feel, while the 40mm offers a classic aesthetic.
Which size is more comfortable to wear?
Comfort is subjective and depends on your wrist size. The 40mm is often considered more versatile and fits a wider range of wrist sizes. The 41mm wears slightly larger and may appeal to those who prefer a more prominent watch. Trying both sizes on is the best way to determine which feels more comfortable on your wrist. Consider your wrist’s shape too.
Does the 41mm Submariner have a better movement?
Yes, the 41mm Submariner typically features newer generation Rolex movements, like the calibre 3230 or 3235. These movements offer improvements such as a longer power reserve (around 70 hours) and enhanced accuracy compared to the movements found in some 40mm models. This means less frequent winding and greater precision.
Is the 41mm Submariner more expensive?
At retail, the 41mm Submariner is generally priced slightly higher than the 40mm. However, in the pre-owned market, prices can fluctuate considerably based on condition, rarity, and overall demand. Market prices change rapidly. It’s best to consult with authorized dealers or reputable pre-owned specialists to understand the current market value.
Which model has better resale value?
Both models tend to hold their value very well. Resale values depend on numerous factors, including the specific reference number, condition, and market trends. Both the 40mm and 41mm Submariners are highly sought after, ensuring strong resale potential. Research current market conditions before any transaction.
Which size is more readily available?
The 41mm Submariner, being the newer model, might be more readily available at authorized dealers, although demand still often surpasses supply. The availability of both models can vary depending on the reference and market conditions. Checking with authorized dealers is key to finding current stock levels and wait times. Pre-owned markets offer options.
Are the bracelets and clasps different?
The bracelets and clasps are similar, with the 41mm often featuring a slightly wider bracelet. Both models typically include the Glidelock clasp, allowing for easy adjustment. This offers a comfortable fit over various wrist sizes or over a wetsuit for diving. The quality of both is top-notch.
Final Verdict
Choosing between the Rolex Submariner 40mm and 41mm comes down to personal preference. The 41mm offers a slightly more modern aesthetic and the benefits of a newer movement. The 40mm remains a classic choice with a timeless design. Consider wrist size, desired aesthetic, and budget. Both models are exceptional timepieces with enduring value.
Winner: Rolex Submariner 41mm