Pur vs Brita Filter: Which Water Filter Is Best?
Tired of questionable tap water? You’re not alone. Many of us are turning to water filters for cleaner, better-tasting hydration. But with so many options, how do you choose the right one? The decision often boils down to a head-to-head battle: the PUR vs Brita filter.
Both brands are household names, promising to remove impurities and improve water quality. They offer a range of products, from pitchers to faucet-mounted filters, catering to different needs and budgets. This comparison will dive deep into the key differences, helping you determine which filter is the perfect fit for your home.
We’ll explore factors like filtration performance, ease of use, cost, and filter replacement. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of both PUR and Brita filters. Get ready to discover which water filter reigns supreme in the quest for pure, refreshing water!
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | pur | Brita Filter |
|---|---|---|
| Filter Type | Activated Carbon | Activated Carbon |
| Filter Life | Up to 2 months | Up to 2 months |
| Capacity | Varies by model | Varies by model |
| Removes Lead | Yes | Yes |
| Removes Chlorine | Yes | Yes |
| Removes Mercury | Yes (select models) | Yes (select models) |
| Removes Benzene | Yes (select models) | Yes (select models) |
| NSF Certification | Select models | Select models |
| Installation | Faucet-mounted, Pitcher, or Dispenser | Pitcher or Faucet-mounted |
| Ease of Use | Varies by model | Generally easy |
| Filter Replacement Indicator | Some models | Some models |
| Water Taste | Improved | Improved |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Filtration Performance
- Pur: PUR filters often use activated carbon and sometimes include sediment filters. They are effective at removing chlorine, lead, and some pesticides. However, the exact filtration capabilities vary depending on the specific model. Pros include decent filtration for common contaminants; cons can include inconsistent performance across different models.
- Brita Filter: Brita filters primarily use activated carbon and ion exchange resins. They are designed to reduce chlorine taste and odor, as well as remove copper, cadmium, and mercury. Brita filters are generally considered effective for improving taste but may not filter out as many contaminants as some PUR models. Pros: widely available and easy to use; cons: filtration capabilities may be more limited than PUR.
- Winner: PUR
Filter Lifespan
- Pur: PUR filters typically last for around 1-3 months, or filtering about 40-100 gallons, depending on the model and water quality. Filter life is usually indicated by a light or electronic indicator. Pros: Longer lifespan than some competitors; Cons: Replacement filters can add up over time.
- Brita Filter: Brita filters generally need to be replaced every 2 months, or after filtering about 40 gallons. Most Brita pitchers include electronic indicators to remind you. Pros: Easy to understand replacement schedule; Cons: Shorter lifespan compared to some PUR models.
- Winner: PUR
Filter Cost
- Pur: PUR filter replacements can vary in price, but generally are competitive. Bundles and multi-packs often offer cost savings. The long-term cost needs to be considered along with filter lifespan. Pros: Competitive pricing; Cons: Costs can add up with frequent replacements.
- Brita Filter: Brita filter replacements are relatively affordable and widely available. The cost is often a significant factor in their popularity. Pros: Very affordable; Cons: Long term cost may be higher if you need to replace them more often.
- Winner: Brita Filter
Filter Types and Models
- Pur: PUR offers a variety of filter types, including faucet filters, pitcher filters, and refrigerator filters. Some models are NSF certified for contaminant reduction. Pros: Variety of options; Cons: Model selection can be overwhelming.
- Brita Filter: Brita primarily offers pitcher filters, faucet filters, and water bottles with filters. They have a more streamlined product line. Pros: Simple product line; Cons: Fewer specialized options.
- Winner: PUR
Ease of Use and Installation
- Pur: PUR faucet filters are generally easy to install, attaching directly to most faucets. Pitcher filters are also straightforward. Pros: Easy to install and use; Cons: Faucet filters may not fit all faucets.
- Brita Filter: Brita pitchers are very easy to use; simply fill and pour. Faucet filters are also simple to attach. Pros: Extremely easy to use; Cons: Limited faucet filter compatibility.
- Winner: Brita Filter
Contaminant Removal Capabilities
- Pur: PUR filters are often certified to remove a wider range of contaminants, including lead, mercury, and certain pesticides, depending on the model and NSF certification. Pros: Broad contaminant removal; Cons: Filtration effectiveness varies by model.
- Brita Filter: Brita filters are primarily designed to reduce chlorine taste and odor and remove contaminants like copper, cadmium, and mercury. They may not remove as many contaminants as some PUR models. Pros: Effective for common taste issues; Cons: Limited contaminant removal compared to PUR.
- Winner: PUR
Water Flow Rate
- Pur: PUR faucet filters typically offer a faster flow rate than Brita pitcher filters, providing immediate access to filtered water. The flow rate may vary based on faucet pressure. Pros: Faster flow for faucet filters; Cons: Pitcher flow is slower.
- Brita Filter: Brita pitcher filters have a slower flow rate than faucet filters, requiring you to wait for the water to filter. This is often a trade-off for convenience and ease of use. Pros: Easy to use; Cons: Slower flow.
- Winner: PUR
Aesthetics and Design
- Pur: PUR offers various designs, and faucet filters are often more discreet than pitchers. The aesthetics can vary depending on the model. Pros: Variety of designs; Cons: Faucet filter design can be bulky.
- Brita Filter: Brita pitchers come in various designs and colors. Their designs are generally modern and functional. Pros: Stylish and functional designs; Cons: Pitcher design can take up fridge space.
- Winner: Brita Filter
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Variety of Models | pur |
| Availability | Brita Filter |
| Lead Reduction | Tie |
| Chlorine Reduction | Tie |
| Ease of Use (Pitcher) | Brita Filter |
| Faucet-Mounted Options | pur |
What They Have in Common:
- Filter Type: Both pur and Brita filters primarily utilize activated carbon to reduce contaminants in tap water. This commonality ensures a similar level of basic filtration performance.
- Lead Reduction: Both brands offer filters that are designed to reduce lead. This is a crucial feature for ensuring safe drinking water, especially in older homes.
- Chlorine Reduction: Both filter types effectively reduce chlorine, improving the taste and odor of tap water. This leads to a more pleasant drinking experience.
- Ease of Use: Both brands offer filters that are relatively easy to use and install, making them accessible to a wide range of consumers. They are designed for user-friendly operation.
- Filter Life: Both pur and Brita filters generally have a filter life of around two months, depending on usage and water quality. This necessitates regular filter replacement.
Pur Vs Brita Filter Buying Guide
Cost and Value
When considering cost, both PUR and Brita filters offer affordable options. PUR filters, particularly those designed for faucet mounting, often have a slightly higher initial cost. However, the long-term value depends on filter replacement costs and the lifespan of the filter itself. Brita filters, especially pitcher filters, tend to be more budget-friendly upfront. Evaluating your water usage and the frequency of filter replacement needed for each brand will help you determine the best value for your needs. Consider the total cost of ownership over a year or more.
Filtration Performance
Both PUR and Brita filters are designed to reduce contaminants in your tap water. However, the specific filtration capabilities can vary between models. PUR filters are generally known for their effectiveness in removing lead, while Brita filters often excel at reducing chlorine taste and odor. Researching the specific contaminants you’re concerned about, such as sediment, pesticides, or other chemicals, is crucial. Look for certifications from organizations like NSF International to verify the filter’s performance claims. Consider the type of filter and its overall effectiveness.
Filter Types and Installation
Both brands offer different filter types, including pitcher filters, faucet-mounted filters, and refrigerator filters. Brita is primarily known for its pitcher filters, which are easy to install and require no plumbing. PUR offers a wider range of faucet-mounted filters, which provide filtered water on demand. Installation is generally straightforward for both brands, with clear instructions provided. Evaluate your needs and the convenience of installation. Consider the space available in your kitchen and the ease of filter replacement.
Filter Lifespan and Maintenance
The lifespan of filters varies depending on the brand and model. Typically, PUR faucet filters may last for several months, while Brita pitcher filters usually need replacement every few weeks or months, depending on usage. Regularly monitoring your filter’s performance and replacing it as recommended is crucial for maintaining water quality. Both brands offer filter replacement reminders and indicators. Keeping track of filter replacements is important. Make sure to buy extra filters when purchasing your system.
Convenience and Ease of Use
Convenience is a key factor when choosing a water filter. Brita pitcher filters are very convenient to use, as you simply fill the pitcher and wait for the water to filter. PUR faucet filters provide instant access to filtered water, which is convenient for cooking and drinking. The ease of filter replacement also contributes to convenience. Consider your daily water consumption habits and how often you need filtered water. Choose a system that fits your lifestyle. Consider the convenience of refilling the filter.
Environmental Impact
Both PUR and Brita filters contribute to reducing plastic waste compared to bottled water. However, the filters themselves need to be replaced and disposed of. Brita filters are often made with recyclable materials, while PUR has some filters that are also recyclable. Consider the environmental impact of filter replacement and disposal. Some companies offer recycling programs for their filters. Look for brands that are committed to sustainable practices and reducing their environmental footprint. Consider the eco-friendliness of filter replacement.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy pur If…
- You want a faucet-mounted filter option.
- You are looking for a brand with a variety of models.
- You prioritize specific contaminant removal, depending on the model.
- You want a filter with a visual filter-life indicator (on some models).
Buy Brita Filter If…
- You prefer a pitcher-style filter for ease of use.
- You want a well-known, widely available brand.
- You want a filter with a simple, straightforward design.
- You’re looking for a cost-effective water filtration solution.
Frequently Asked Questions
What contaminants do these filters remove?
Both PUR and Brita filters are designed to remove common contaminants found in tap water, such as chlorine, sediment, and some heavy metals. PUR filters often excel at lead removal. Brita filters focus on reducing chlorine taste and odor. It’s essential to check the specific filter model’s certification to know the range of contaminants it removes. Both will improve water quality significantly.
How often do I need to replace the filters?
Filter replacement frequency varies. Brita pitcher filters typically need replacing every 40 gallons or about every two months, depending on usage. PUR faucet filters generally last longer, often up to 100 gallons or three months. Always follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for optimal performance and water quality. Monitor water flow to check for replacement.
Are these filters compatible with all faucets/pitchers?
PUR faucet filters are generally designed to fit most standard faucets. However, it’s essential to check the compatibility of the specific filter model with your faucet type. Brita pitcher filters are designed to fit their respective pitcher models only. Check product descriptions for compatibility. Some faucet filters may need an adaptor. Consider the filter’s attachment mechanism.
Do these filters remove fluoride?
Standard PUR and Brita filters do not typically remove fluoride. If fluoride removal is a concern, you’ll need to look for a specialized filter designed for this purpose. These filters usually employ a different filtration technology. Always check the product description or contact the manufacturer to confirm whether a filter removes fluoride. Consider your water’s fluoride content.
How do I know when to replace the filter?
Both brands provide indicators to help you determine when to replace the filter. Brita pitchers often have electronic or manual indicators. PUR faucet filters usually have a light that changes color. These indicators are based on usage and filter life. Always pay attention to these indicators and replace your filter promptly for best results. Consider the indicator’s accuracy.
Can I use these filters with well water?
While PUR and Brita filters can improve the taste and odor of well water, they may not be sufficient for treating all well water contaminants. Well water often contains a wider range of potential pollutants. It’s advisable to test your well water and consider a filter specifically designed for well water treatment if needed. Consult a water treatment specialist.
Are these filters NSF certified?
Many PUR and Brita filter models are certified by NSF International (or similar organizations). NSF certification verifies that the filter has been tested and meets specific standards for contaminant reduction and material safety. Look for the NSF certification on the product packaging or website. Certification ensures the filter’s performance claims are accurate. Always look for NSF certifications.
Final Verdict
Both PUR and Brita filters offer effective water filtration solutions. While Brita excels in pitcher filter convenience and cost-effectiveness, PUR provides superior lead removal with its faucet filters. Considering ease of use, filtration performance, and long-term value, the better choice depends on individual needs. Both significantly improve water quality.
Winner: PUR