New Balance vs Asics Running Shoes: Which Brand Wins?
Ready to upgrade your running game? Choosing the right running shoes can feel overwhelming, but it’s a crucial decision. The right pair can make all the difference in comfort, performance, and injury prevention. Today, we’re diving deep into a head-to-head comparison to help you find your perfect fit.
We’re putting two titans of the running world to the test: New Balance and ASICS. Both brands boast impressive legacies and loyal followings. They offer a vast array of models designed for various foot types, running styles, and terrains.
This comparison will break down the key features, technologies, and performance aspects of each brand. We’ll explore everything from cushioning and support to durability and style. Get ready to discover which brand, New Balance or ASICS, is the ultimate champion for your running needs.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | New Balance | ASICS |
|---|---|---|
| Cushioning | Typically offers a variety of cushioning options, from plush to firm. | Known for GEL technology, providing excellent shock absorption. |
| Stability | Offers a range of stability features for overpronation. | Often incorporates features for pronation control. |
| Weight | Varies, with options for lightweight and heavier trainers. | Generally offers a range of weights, depending on the model. |
| Breathability | Utilizes various mesh technologies for breathability. | Employs breathable uppers to keep feet cool. |
| Durability | Generally durable, with quality materials used. | Known for durable outsoles and materials. |
| Arch Support | Offers shoes with varying levels of arch support. | Provides options for different arch types. |
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | Ranges from low to high, catering to different running styles. | Offers a variety of heel-to-toe drops. |
| Midsole Technology | Employs technologies like Fresh Foam and FuelCell. | Uses technologies like FlyteFoam and GEL. |
| Upper Material | Uses a variety of materials, including mesh and synthetic overlays. | Employs engineered mesh and other breathable materials. |
| Outsole Grip | Provides good grip on various surfaces. | Offers reliable grip for road and trail running. |
| Fit | Often offers multiple width options. | Provides a comfortable fit for a variety of foot shapes. |
| Style/Aesthetics | Offers a wide range of styles and colors. | Known for a classic and performance-oriented aesthetic. |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Cushioning
- New Balance: New Balance often utilizes Fresh Foam, FuelCell, or other proprietary cushioning technologies. They typically offer a balanced cushioning experience, providing both impact absorption and responsiveness. Some models may feel firmer than others.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS is renowned for its GEL cushioning, offering excellent shock absorption, particularly in the heel. They also incorporate FlyteFoam and other cushioning materials. ASICS shoes often provide a plusher, more cushioned feel, which can be beneficial for longer runs.
- Winner: ASICS
Stability
- New Balance: New Balance offers a range of stability shoes, often incorporating medial posts or other technologies to control pronation. They are known for providing good support for runners who need it, but some models can feel a bit rigid.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS also excels in stability shoes, featuring technologies like Dynamic Duomax and LiteTruss. They provide excellent support for overpronators, but some models can feel heavier than neutral shoes.
- Winner: ASICS
Fit and Sizing
- New Balance: New Balance is well-known for offering shoes in a variety of widths, catering to a wider range of foot shapes. Their sizing tends to be consistent, but it’s always recommended to try them on.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS generally offers a more standard fit, with less emphasis on multiple widths. They often run true to size, but the fit can vary slightly depending on the model.
- Winner: new balance
Weight
- New Balance: New Balance offers a wide range of weights, from lightweight racing flats to more substantial trainers. The weight varies significantly depending on the model and intended use.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS also offers a variety of weights. Generally, their stability models tend to be slightly heavier than some New Balance counterparts, but they have lighter options for racing and speedwork.
- Winner: new balance
Durability
- New Balance: New Balance shoes generally offer good durability, with uppers and outsoles built to withstand regular use. The lifespan can vary based on the model and running conditions.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS shoes are known for their durability, with tough outsoles and robust construction. They often last for a significant number of miles, making them a good investment.
- Winner: ASICS
Breathability
- New Balance: New Balance uses various upper materials, including engineered mesh, to provide breathability. The level of breathability varies depending on the specific model and its intended use.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS incorporates breathable mesh uppers in most of their shoes, allowing for good airflow. Some models may prioritize weather resistance over maximum breathability.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- New Balance: New Balance shoes are generally priced competitively, with options available at various price points. They offer a good balance of features and value.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS shoes are often priced slightly higher than some New Balance models, reflecting their focus on technology and durability.
- Winner: new balance
Aesthetics
- New Balance: New Balance has a classic and often understated design aesthetic. They offer a variety of colorways and styles, catering to different preferences.
- Asics Running Shoes: ASICS often features bold designs and color combinations, with a distinct visual identity. They are known for their modern and sporty look.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Cushioning | ASICS |
| Stability | Tie |
| Variety of Widths | New Balance |
| Pronation Control | ASICS |
| Lifestyle Aesthetic | New Balance |
| Durability | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Comfort: Both brands prioritize comfort, using technologies designed to provide a pleasant running experience.
- Durability: Both New Balance and ASICS produce running shoes built to withstand the rigors of regular use.
- Breathability: Both incorporate breathable materials in their uppers to keep feet cool and dry.
- Variety: Both brands offer a wide range of models catering to different running styles and needs.
- Cushioning Technology: Both brands utilize advanced cushioning technologies to absorb impact and enhance comfort.
- Performance Focus: Both brands are dedicated to producing shoes that enhance running performance.
New Balance Vs Asics Running Shoes Buying Guide
Cushioning and Comfort
Both New Balance and Asics are renowned for their focus on comfort. New Balance often utilizes Fresh Foam and FuelCell technologies, offering a plush and responsive feel, well-suited for runners prioritizing a softer ride. Asics, on the other hand, is famous for its Gel cushioning system, known for its shock absorption and stability. The choice here often depends on personal preference: those seeking maximum softness might lean towards New Balance, while those needing stability and impact protection could prefer Asics. Consider your foot type and running style when making your decision, as both brands provide a range of cushioning levels to cater to different needs.
Stability and Support
Stability is a key consideration, especially for overpronators. Asics frequently incorporates technologies like DuoMax and Guidance Line, providing excellent support and correcting excessive inward rolling of the foot. New Balance also offers stability shoes, often featuring medial posts and firmer midsoles, though their offerings might be slightly less extensive in certain categories compared to Asics. Evaluate your pronation level and consult with a running specialist to determine the level of stability you require. Both brands offer models for neutral runners as well, with features designed to promote a natural gait.
Fit and Sizing
Fit is paramount to a comfortable run. New Balance is celebrated for its wide range of widths, catering to various foot shapes. This makes it a great choice for runners with wider feet or those who struggle to find shoes that fit properly. Asics generally offers a more standard fit, but still provides options within their range. Try on shoes from both brands in a store to assess the fit and ensure adequate space in the toe box. Consider getting your feet measured professionally, as your shoe size can change over time, and the fit can vary between brands and models.
Durability and Materials
The lifespan of your running shoes depends on the materials and construction. Both New Balance and Asics utilize durable materials, but the specific models and technologies employed can influence longevity. Asics is often praised for the durability of its outsoles, which can withstand significant wear and tear. New Balance also uses robust materials, but the specific lifespan may vary depending on the model and the frequency of use. Consider the surfaces you run on, the weight of the runner, and the overall usage when evaluating durability. Always inspect your shoes regularly for signs of wear and tear.
Performance and Technology
Both brands incorporate cutting-edge technologies to enhance performance. New Balance’s FuelCell and Fresh Foam technologies provide responsive cushioning and energy return, ideal for speed work and longer runs. Asics’ Gel cushioning and FlyteFoam technology focus on shock absorption and a balanced ride, suitable for various running styles. The specific performance benefits will vary depending on the model, so research the intended use of the shoe and the technologies it incorporates. Consider the type of running you do most frequently and choose the brand that best aligns with your performance goals.
Price and Value
The price of running shoes varies based on the model and the technologies used. Both New Balance and Asics offer a range of price points, from budget-friendly options to premium performance models. Consider your budget and the features you prioritize when making your decision. While higher-priced shoes often incorporate advanced technologies, more affordable options can still provide excellent performance and value. Look for sales and discounts, and read reviews to determine which shoes offer the best value for your money. Remember that the best shoe is the one that fits your needs and budget.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy New Balance If…
- You prefer a wider range of width options.
- You value a variety of cushioning technologies like Fresh Foam or FuelCell.
- You are looking for a shoe with a more lifestyle-oriented aesthetic.
- You are new to running and want comfortable all-around performance.
Buy ASICS Running Shoes If…
- You prioritize GEL cushioning for shock absorption.
- You need shoes with features for pronation control.
- You prefer a classic, performance-driven design.
- You are a long-distance runner seeking durability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which brand is better for beginners?
Both brands are great for beginners. Asics often receives praise for its stability-focused models, which can be beneficial for runners who may not yet have perfect form. New Balance, with its diverse width options, is an excellent choice for those needing a more customized fit. Ultimately, the best brand depends on individual foot shape and running style.
Which brand is better for marathon training?
Both New Balance and Asics offer excellent shoes for marathon training. Asics’ cushioned models with good stability are well-suited for long distances, providing comfort and support throughout the training regime. New Balance, with its responsive midsole options, can also be a strong choice, especially for those who prefer a more energetic feel during their runs. Consider the cushioning, support, and responsiveness based on your running style.
Which brand is better for flat feet?
Asics generally excels for runners with flat feet, offering several models with excellent stability features, like DuoMax, which provides pronation control. New Balance also has stability shoes, but Asics may have a slightly broader range of options specifically designed for flat feet. Consult with a running specialist for the best fit.
Which brand is better for wide feet?
New Balance is often the preferred choice for runners with wide feet. They are known for offering a wide variety of widths, ensuring a comfortable fit for those who struggle to find shoes that accommodate their foot shape. Asics offers some wider options, but New Balance’s range is typically more extensive in this regard.
Which brand is better for pronation control?
Asics has a strong reputation for pronation control, with technologies like DuoMax and Guidance Line designed to correct overpronation. New Balance offers stability models with medial posts, but Asics tends to lead in this area. Assess your pronation level and consider a shoe designed for that type of support.
Which brand is better for trail running?
Both brands offer trail running shoes. Asics usually has a strong focus on durability and grip for tackling various terrains. New Balance also creates trail shoes, often with a balance of cushioning and protection. The best choice depends on the specific trail conditions and the runner’s preferences for cushioning, support, and outsole grip.
Are the sizing of New Balance and Asics the same?
Sizing can vary slightly between brands and even between different models within the same brand. It’s always best to try on shoes from both brands to assess the fit. Consider your foot shape and any special needs, such as wider feet or high arches. Getting your feet professionally measured is highly recommended.
Final Verdict
Both New Balance and Asics offer excellent running shoes, each with unique strengths. New Balance excels in comfort, fit customization, and responsive cushioning, while Asics shines in stability, support, and durability. The ideal choice depends on individual needs, foot type, and running style. Assess your priorities and try on shoes from both brands to find the perfect fit.
Winner: [This is a tie]