Model X vs S: Which Reigns Supreme? A Head-to-Head
Choosing between two top contenders can be a daunting task. You’ve narrowed it down, but the final decision remains elusive. This comparison dives deep into the battle between Model X and S, breaking down the key aspects to help you make the right choice.
We’ll explore performance, features, and value, leaving no stone unturned. Whether you prioritize speed, luxury, or practicality, this guide will provide the insights you need. Get ready to discover which vehicle truly shines.
Model X and S both bring impressive capabilities to the table, but they cater to different needs and preferences. This comparison aims to highlight those differences, ensuring you’re well-informed before making your decision. Let’s see how these two titans stack up against each other.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | model x | s |
|---|---|---|
| 0-60 mph | 3.1s | 3.8s |
| Range (EPA est.) | 333 mi | 375 mi |
| Horsepower | 670 hp | 670 hp |
| Cargo Space (Rear Seats Up) | 26.3 cu ft | 26.3 cu ft |
| Infotainment Screen Size | 17-inch | 17-inch |
| Autopilot Features | Standard | Standard |
| Supercharger Network Access | Yes | Yes |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 5 |
| Body Style | SUV | Sedan |
| Drag coefficient | 0.24 Cd | 0.208 Cd |
| Weight | 4,800 lbs | 4,400 lbs |
| Warranty (Basic) | 4 years / 50,000 miles | 4 years / 50,000 miles |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Performance (Acceleration)
- Model X: Boasts blistering acceleration, often achieving 0-60 mph in under 3 seconds in its top-tier trims. This translates to exhilarating off-the-line performance, but can come at a significant price premium.
- S: Offers similarly impressive acceleration capabilities, rivaling the Model X in many configurations. Acceleration times are competitive, providing a thrilling driving experience, but can vary depending on the specific model and battery configuration.
- Winner: Tie
Range
- Model X: Provides a substantial range, allowing for long-distance travel. However, real-world range can be affected by factors like driving style and weather conditions.
- S: Generally offers a slightly longer range than the Model X, making it a strong contender for those prioritizing distance. The efficiency of the S contributes to its impressive range figures.
- Winner: s
Seating Capacity & Cargo Space
- Model X: Offers available seating for up to seven passengers, a unique advantage with its falcon-wing doors. Cargo space is generous, especially with rear seats folded, but the unconventional door design can be a drawback in tight spaces.
- S: Provides seating for up to five passengers, or seven with the optional third row. Cargo capacity is still ample, but less than the Model X in many configurations.
- Winner: model x
Exterior Design
- Model X: Features a distinctive design, highlighted by its falcon-wing doors, which offer a dramatic entrance but can be challenging in certain parking situations. The overall aesthetic is more SUV-like.
- S: Presents a sleek, aerodynamic design, and its conventional doors provide easier access and usability. Its more traditional sedan profile appeals to those who prefer a more understated look.
- Winner: s
Interior & Technology
- Model X: Includes a spacious interior with a large touchscreen display and advanced technology features. The minimalist design is characteristic of Tesla, but some may find the lack of physical buttons a disadvantage.
- S: Offers a similar minimalist interior with a large touchscreen and advanced tech. The experience is largely the same, but may be considered a bit more luxurious in some configurations.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Model X: Generally carries a higher starting price than the Model S. The Model X’s additional features, particularly its falcon-wing doors, contribute to its increased cost.
- S: Typically comes with a more accessible price point than the Model X. The S provides a compelling value proposition, making it a popular choice for those seeking premium electric performance.
- Winner: s
Charging Speed
- Model X: Supports Tesla’s Supercharger network for rapid charging. Charging times are comparable to the Model S, but vary depending on the charging rate and battery size.
- S: Utilizes the Supercharger network, offering similar rapid charging capabilities. Tesla’s infrastructure ensures convenient access to charging stations across a wide geographic area.
- Winner: Tie
Handling & Ride Quality
- Model X: Offers a comfortable ride, but the higher center of gravity can slightly affect handling compared to the Model S. The air suspension system helps to smooth out road imperfections.
- S: Known for its sporty handling and composed ride, the Model S delivers a more engaging driving experience. Its lower center of gravity enhances stability.
- Winner: s
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Cargo Space | model x |
| Range | s |
| Acceleration | model x |
| Aerodynamics | s |
| Design | (Subjective) |
| Handling | s |
What They Have in Common
- Performance: Both vehicles deliver exceptional acceleration and performance, making them thrilling to drive.
- Technology: Both models share advanced technology features, including a large touchscreen interface and over-the-air software updates.
- Charging Network: Both cars have access to Tesla’s Supercharger network, ensuring convenient and fast charging on the road.
- Safety Features: Both vehicles are equipped with a comprehensive suite of safety features, including advanced driver-assistance systems.
- Spacious Interior: Both cars offer a comfortable and spacious interior for passengers and cargo, providing a premium driving experience.
- Autopilot: Both models come standard with Autopilot features, enhancing driver convenience and safety on highways.
Model X Vs S Buying Guide
Performance
The Model X and Model S both deliver exhilarating performance, but their strengths differ. The Model S offers blistering acceleration, especially in the Plaid trim, making it one of the quickest accelerating production cars. The Model X, while also very quick, prioritizes practicality with its larger size and weight. Its acceleration is still impressive, providing a thrilling driving experience, but it might not match the raw speed of the Model S. Consider your need for speed and how often you’ll utilize it when making your choice. Both cars benefit from instant electric torque, ensuring swift response in any situation.
Range & Charging
Range and charging capabilities are crucial considerations for electric vehicle owners. Both the Model X and Model S boast impressive ranges, but the specific figures vary depending on the trim level and battery configuration. The Model S often offers slightly more range due to its more aerodynamic design. Charging is straightforward with Tesla’s Supercharger network, providing rapid charging on the go. Home charging is also convenient, allowing you to top up overnight. Analyze your typical driving distances and access to charging infrastructure to determine which car best suits your needs.
Interior & Features
The interiors of both vehicles are characterized by minimalist design and cutting-edge technology. The Model S offers a more traditional sedan layout with a focus on luxury and refined materials. The Model X, with its unique falcon-wing doors, provides a distinctive and spacious interior, particularly for rear passengers. Both models feature large touchscreen displays that control most vehicle functions. Consider your preference for interior aesthetics, passenger space, and the novelty of the falcon-wing doors when evaluating these features. Both vehicles also offer advanced driver-assistance systems.
Practicality & Space
The Model X excels in practicality due to its SUV body style and larger cargo capacity. The falcon-wing doors offer easy access to the rear seats, even in tight parking spaces. The Model S, being a sedan, provides a more streamlined profile but offers less cargo space and less headroom for taller passengers. Think about your lifestyle and how often you’ll need to transport passengers and cargo. If you frequently carry bulky items or need extra seating, the Model X is the clear winner. The Model S is better for those who value a sleek design.
Price & Value
The Model S and Model X are premium electric vehicles, and their prices reflect their advanced technology and features. The Model S generally has a slightly lower starting price than the Model X, making it potentially more accessible. However, the price difference can vary depending on trim levels and options. Evaluate the value proposition by comparing the features, performance, and practicality offered by each model against their respective price tags. Consider your budget and long-term ownership costs, including potential tax credits and maintenance expenses. Research the current market for used models as well.
Design & Aesthetics
The Model S and Model X have distinct design philosophies. The Model S embodies a sleek and aerodynamic sedan design, with a focus on performance and efficiency. The Model X, with its SUV profile and falcon-wing doors, makes a bold statement and prioritizes practicality and space. Personal preference plays a significant role in this aspect. Consider which design best aligns with your taste and lifestyle. Do you prefer the sporty elegance of the Model S or the distinctive and functional design of the Model X? Both vehicles feature a modern and minimalist aesthetic that is typical of Tesla.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy model x If…
- You need the extra cargo space and versatility of an SUV.
- You prefer the distinctive look and functionality of Falcon Wing doors.
- You frequently transport passengers and value a spacious interior.
- You prioritize a higher seating position and improved visibility.
Buy s If…
- You prefer the sleek and sporty design of a sedan.
- You prioritize a slightly longer driving range.
- You desire enhanced aerodynamics and efficiency.
- You want a vehicle that offers exceptional performance and handling.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between the Model X and Model S?
The primary difference lies in their body styles and intended use. The Model S is a sedan, prioritizing performance, sleek design, and a slightly higher range. The Model X is an SUV, offering more passenger space, cargo capacity, and the unique falcon-wing doors for enhanced accessibility. The Model X is a more practical option for families or those needing extra space.
Which car has better acceleration?
Generally, the Model S offers quicker acceleration, especially in its Plaid trim. The Model S Plaid can achieve 0-60 mph in under 2 seconds, making it one of the fastest accelerating production cars in the world. The Model X is still very quick, with impressive acceleration, but it typically lags slightly behind the Model S due to its larger size and weight.
How do the charging times compare?
Charging times are largely dependent on the charging infrastructure and the battery size of each vehicle. Both the Model S and Model X utilize Tesla’s Supercharger network, allowing for rapid charging. However, the exact charging times can fluctuate slightly depending on the specific battery configuration and charging station output. Generally, they charge at about the same rate given similar battery capacity.
Which car is better for families?
The Model X is generally considered better for families due to its larger interior space, including more headroom and legroom, and its impressive cargo capacity. The falcon-wing doors provide easy access to the rear seats, which is especially useful for loading and unloading children. The Model S can accommodate a family, but it may feel more cramped, especially with multiple passengers and cargo.
What about Autopilot and driver-assistance features?
Both the Model S and Model X are equipped with Tesla’s Autopilot system and a suite of advanced driver-assistance features, including adaptive cruise control, lane keeping assist, and automatic emergency braking. The specific features and their performance are very similar across both models, although updates and improvements are constantly implemented through over-the-air software updates.
How does the range compare between the two models?
The Model S typically boasts a slightly longer range compared to the Model X, particularly in certain trim levels. This is largely due to the Model S’s more aerodynamic design. However, the actual range can vary depending on driving conditions, speed, and other factors. It is essential to check the official EPA ratings for the specific trim levels you are considering.
Which car offers a better driving experience?
The “better” driving experience is subjective and depends on individual preferences. The Model S excels in performance and offers a sporty driving feel. The Model X provides a comfortable and spacious ride, with a focus on practicality and a commanding view of the road. Test drives are crucial to determining which car better suits your driving style and needs.
Final Verdict
The Model S prioritizes raw performance, a sleek design, and slightly more range, while the Model X emphasizes practicality, space, and a distinctive appearance with its falcon-wing doors. Both vehicles are excellent electric cars with advanced technology, but the choice depends on your specific needs. If you prioritize maximum performance and a more traditional sedan experience, the Model S is a great choice. If you value space, practicality, and a unique design, the Model X is the better option.
Winner: [Model X]