Maybelline Sky High vs Lash Sensational: Which Reigns?
Tired of short, lackluster lashes? You’re not alone! The quest for the perfect mascara is a never-ending journey, and Maybelline has thrown two contenders into the ring: the beloved Maybelline Sky High and the iconic Lash Sensational.
Both mascaras promise to transform your lashes, but which one truly delivers the dramatic results we crave? This comparison dives deep into the world of Maybelline, exploring the differences in formula, wand design, and overall performance.
We’ll analyze everything from application ease to longevity, helping you decide which Maybelline mascara is the ultimate lash enhancer for your specific needs. Get ready to discover whether Maybelline Sky High or Lash Sensational will become your new holy grail!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Sky High | Lash Sensational |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Mascara | Mascara |
| Brush Type | Flex Tower Brush | Curved, plastic bristles |
| Volume | Increased Volume | Defined Lashes |
| Length | Increased Length | Increased Length |
| Clump-Free | Yes | Yes |
| Waterproof Option | Yes | Yes |
| Easy Removal | Yes | Yes |
| Smudge-Proof | Yes | Yes |
| Ophthalmologist Tested | Yes | Yes |
| Suitable for Sensitive Eyes | Yes | Yes |
| Color Options | Black, Brownish Black | Blackest Black, Very Black, Brownish Black |
| Availability | Widely Available | Widely Available |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Brush Type
- Maybelline Sky High: Features a flexible, plastic brush with a slim, conical shape designed to reach every lash. Its design aims for length and lift. Some users find it can clump if too much product is applied at once.
- Lash Sensational: Boasts a curved, bristle brush with multiple lash-catching bristles. The design intends to fan out lashes and provide volume. The curved shape can be difficult for beginners to maneuver.
- Winner: Sky High
Formula Consistency
- Maybelline Sky High: Generally has a thinner, more buildable formula that allows for layering to achieve desired length. It can be prone to flaking for some users.
- Lash Sensational: Tends to have a slightly thicker formula, aimed at delivering volume and fullness. It can sometimes be prone to clumping if applied heavily.
- Winner: Sky High
Length & Lift
- Maybelline Sky High: Known for its ability to provide significant length and lift, giving a “sky high” effect. It excels at lengthening even short lashes.
- Lash Sensational: Focuses more on providing volume and fanning out lashes, though it does offer some length. Not as dramatic in length compared to Sky High.
- Winner: Sky High
Volume & Thickness
- Maybelline Sky High: While providing length, it offers less in terms of dramatic volume compared to Lash Sensational. It is more focused on individual lash separation.
- Lash Sensational: Designed to provide noticeable volume and thickness, creating a fuller lash look. It can be more effective at building volume.
- Winner: Lash Sensational
Smudge Resistance
- Maybelline Sky High: Smudge resistance can vary depending on the individual. Some users experience smudging, particularly in humid conditions.
- Lash Sensational: Generally offers decent smudge resistance, but may smudge slightly on some users, particularly on oily eyelids.
- Winner: Lash Sensational
Ease of Application
- Maybelline Sky High: The slim brush is generally easier to apply for beginners and can reach inner and outer lashes easily.
- Lash Sensational: The curved brush can require a bit more practice for those new to mascara, but the curved design makes it easier to fan out lashes.
- Winner: Sky High
Removal
- Maybelline Sky High: Removal can be relatively easy with makeup remover, though some users find it requires more effort to remove all traces.
- Lash Sensational: Generally easy to remove with makeup remover. It doesn’t cling to lashes as much as some other mascaras.
- Winner: Tie
Price & Availability
- Maybelline Sky High: Widely available at drugstores and online retailers at an affordable price point.
- Lash Sensational: Also widely available at drugstores and online retailers, offering a similar price point.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Overall Length and Lift | Sky High |
| Lash Definition and Separation | Lash Sensational |
| Ease of Application | Tie |
| Clump-Free Formula | Tie |
| Availability | Tie |
What They Have in Common
- Application: Both mascaras are applied using a wand, making the application process relatively simple and quick.
- Availability: Both are widely available at drugstores and online retailers. This accessibility makes them convenient choices for most consumers.
- Smudge-Proof Formulas: Both mascaras are designed to resist smudging, ensuring a clean look throughout the day.
- Ophthalmologist Tested: Both formulas have been tested by ophthalmologists, which means they are suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
- Easy Removal: Both mascaras can be easily removed with makeup remover, which is a significant advantage.
Maybelline Sky High Vs Lash Sensational Buying Guide
Price and Availability
Both Maybelline Sky High and Lash Sensational are readily available and budget-friendly mascaras. You can find them at most drugstores, supermarkets, and online retailers. Sky High tends to be slightly more expensive than Lash Sensational, though the difference is usually minimal. Availability is generally excellent for both, with widespread distribution ensuring easy access for consumers. Consider checking for sales and promotions to get the best deal, as discounts are common for both products.
Brush and Application
The brush design significantly impacts the application experience. Sky High features a flexible, plastic wand with a conical shape, designed for lengthening and reaching every lash. Lash Sensational boasts a curved, bristled brush with multiple lash-catching bristles. The curved design aims to fan out lashes for a fuller look. The choice between the brushes depends on personal preference; those seeking length might prefer Sky High, while those desiring volume might favor Lash Sensational. Experimenting with both is recommended.
Formula and Ingredients
Both mascaras have unique formulas. Sky High often focuses on lengthening and lift due to its fiber-infused formula. Lash Sensational’s formula may prioritize volume and definition, with ingredients that build up lashes. Check the ingredient lists for any potential allergens or sensitivities. Both products typically contain ingredients like waxes and polymers for hold and pigment for color. Consider water-resistance levels based on your lifestyle and environmental conditions.
Performance and Results
The results differ based on the mascara’s focus. Sky High is known for its impressive lengthening capabilities, creating a more dramatic, fanned-out effect. Lash Sensational excels at adding volume and creating a fuller lash line. The performance, however, depends on your natural lashes and the desired look. Consider layering the mascara for a more intense effect, but be mindful of clumping. Evaluate the wear time and how well it holds throughout the day.
Longevity and Wearability
The longevity of the mascara is crucial for all-day wear. Assess how well each mascara holds up against smudging, flaking, and general wear. Consider your activities and the climate. Both mascaras typically offer decent wear time, but individual experiences may vary. Sky High has a reputation for being long-lasting, while Lash Sensational is also generally reliable. Conduct a wear test to determine which performs best under your typical conditions.
Removal and Ease of Use
Ease of removal is a key consideration. Choose a makeup remover suitable for waterproof mascara if you opt for a water-resistant formula. Both mascaras are typically designed to be removed with standard makeup removers. Test the removal process to ensure it’s gentle and effective without causing irritation or leaving residue. Consider using a cleansing balm or micellar water for effective removal. A good removal process maintains lash health.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Maybelline Sky High If…
- You want dramatic length and a lifted effect.
- You prefer a flexible brush that can reach every lash.
- You’re looking for a mascara that offers a full, fluttery look.
- You want a mascara that is easy to remove.
Buy Lash Sensational If…
- You want a mascara that defines and separates lashes.
- You prefer a more classic, separated lash look.
- You want a mascara with a curved brush for easy application.
- You want a mascara that is easy to remove.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which mascara is better for lengthening lashes?
Maybelline Sky High is generally considered superior for lengthening lashes. Its formula and brush design work synergistically to provide impressive length and lift, creating a noticeable, extended effect. The fiber-infused formula coats each lash, contributing to the lengthening effect. For optimal results, apply a couple of coats, focusing on the tips of your lashes.
Which mascara is better for adding volume?
Lash Sensational is often favored for adding volume. The unique curved brush and formula are designed to grab and coat each lash, creating a fuller, more voluminous appearance. The bristle arrangement helps to separate and define lashes, adding to the overall effect. Apply multiple coats for enhanced volume and a more dramatic look.
Are these mascaras waterproof?
Both mascaras offer waterproof versions. They provide water-resistant formulas that withstand humidity, tears, and light rain. Always check the packaging to confirm if the specific product is waterproof. Waterproof formulas are excellent for all-day wear and are especially useful during activities that may cause smudging. Use a dedicated makeup remover designed for waterproof mascara for complete removal.
Can I use these mascaras with contact lenses?
While both mascaras are generally considered safe for contact lens wearers, exercise caution. Avoid getting the mascara in your eyes. If you experience any irritation, discontinue use immediately. Opt for the non-waterproof versions of each mascara, which might be easier to remove. Always prioritize eye health and consult an ophthalmologist if you have any concerns.
Are there different shades available?
Yes, both mascaras are available in various shades, including black, brown, and sometimes, a very dark black. Check the product packaging or online retailers for the full range of colors. Consider your eye color and desired look when selecting a shade. Black is a classic choice, while brown can provide a softer, more natural appearance.
How long does the mascara last?
Mascara typically lasts for about three months after opening. After this period, the formula can dry out or become a breeding ground for bacteria. Discard the mascara after this time to maintain eye health. Replace your mascara regularly for optimal performance and hygiene. Always store mascara properly, closed tightly, and away from extreme temperatures.
Where can I buy these mascaras?
Both Maybelline Sky High and Lash Sensational are widely available at drugstores, supermarkets, and online retailers like Amazon and Ulta. Check your local stores and online shopping platforms. Availability is generally good, and you can often find them on sale. Consider comparing prices from different retailers to get the best deal, and always check for authentic products.
Final Verdict
Both Maybelline Sky High and Lash Sensational offer excellent value and performance. Sky High excels at lengthening and lifting, while Lash Sensational provides volume and definition. The best choice depends on your individual lash preferences. For those prioritizing length, Sky High is the winner; for those seeking volume, Lash Sensational is a strong contender. Ultimately, both are highly recommended.
Winner: Maybelline Sky High