Google Nest vs Simplisafe: Which Home Security Is Best?
Are you ready to fortify your home and protect your loved ones? Choosing the right home security system can feel overwhelming. With so many options available, how do you decide which one is the perfect fit for your needs and budget?
Two popular contenders in the home security arena are Google Nest and SimpliSafe. Both offer comprehensive protection, but they cater to different preferences and priorities. This comparison will delve into their features, pricing, and overall value to help you make an informed decision.
We’ll explore the strengths and weaknesses of Google Nest and SimpliSafe, examining everything from their equipment and monitoring plans to their smart home integration capabilities. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which system aligns best with your security requirements and lifestyle.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Google Nest | Simplisafe |
|---|---|---|
| Professional Monitoring | Yes | Yes |
| DIY Installation | Yes | Yes |
| Smart Home Integration | Google Assistant | Limited |
| Video Doorbell | Yes | Yes |
| 24/7 Professional Monitoring | Yes | Yes |
| Cellular Backup | Yes | Yes |
| Environmental Sensors | Yes | Yes |
| Two-Way Talk | Yes | Yes |
| Mobile App Control | Yes | Yes |
| Activity Zones | Yes | Yes |
| Local Storage Option | No | No |
| Warranty | 1-Year | 3-Year |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Professional Monitoring
- Google Nest: Google Nest offers professional monitoring through a subscription, providing 24/7 security with emergency dispatch. This includes cellular backup for reliable connectivity. However, the subscription can be relatively expensive compared to competitors.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe is known for its affordable professional monitoring plans, also offering 24/7 coverage and emergency dispatch. They provide cellular and battery backup for consistent protection. SimpliSafe’s plans generally offer more budget-friendly options.
- Winner: SimpliSafe
Equipment Costs
- Google Nest: Google Nest equipment, including cameras and security systems, often comes with a higher upfront cost. The hardware is known for its sleek design and advanced features, but this translates to a premium price tag.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe’s equipment is typically more affordable, with frequent sales and customizable packages. This makes it a good option for those on a budget. However, the hardware design may not be as aesthetically pleasing as Nest.
- Winner: SimpliSafe
Smart Home Integration
- Google Nest: Google Nest seamlessly integrates with other Google products and services, such as Google Assistant and smart displays. This allows for voice control, automation, and a connected home ecosystem. It may not integrate as smoothly with other non-Google smart home devices.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe offers integration with some smart home platforms like Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, but the compatibility is not as extensive as Google Nest. Its focus is primarily on security, and therefore integration with smart home ecosystems is not its strongest point.
- Winner: google nest
Camera Quality & Features
- Google Nest: Google Nest cameras are known for their excellent video quality, advanced features like person/package detection, and a wide field of view. They often feature built-in smart capabilities. However, cloud storage is subscription-based.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe cameras offer decent video quality and basic features. They are more focused on security and less on advanced video analytics. The camera offerings are more focused on the basics.
- Winner: google nest
Installation
- Google Nest: Google Nest devices are generally easy to install, with many being DIY-friendly. The setup process is streamlined, and the app provides clear instructions. Some more advanced systems may require professional installation.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe is designed for easy DIY installation, with a simple setup process. There is no need for professional installation. This simplifies the process for those who are not tech-savvy.
- Winner: simplisafe
Contract Requirements
- Google Nest: Google Nest’s professional monitoring service is subscription-based, but may not require a long-term contract. This offers flexibility for users. Terms and conditions should be checked.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe offers both contract and no-contract options for professional monitoring. This provides flexibility, allowing users to choose the plan that best suits their needs.
- Winner: simplisafe
System Customization
- Google Nest: Google Nest offers customizable security systems, allowing users to select the sensors and devices they need. However, the options may be more limited compared to dedicated security systems.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe provides a high degree of system customization, with a wide range of sensors and accessories to choose from. This enables users to tailor the system to their specific needs and home layout.
- Winner: simplisafe
Monthly Subscription Costs
- Google Nest: Google Nest’s monthly subscription costs can be higher, especially when factoring in cloud storage for multiple cameras and professional monitoring. The pricing can become expensive.
- Simplisafe: SimpliSafe generally offers more affordable monthly subscription plans, making it a budget-friendly option for professional monitoring. They offer different tiers to cater to a range of needs.
- Winner: simplisafe
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Smart Home Integration | Google Nest |
| Ease of Use | SimpliSafe |
| Video Features | Google Nest |
| Affordability | SimpliSafe |
What They Have in Common
- Professional Monitoring: Both systems offer professional monitoring services, providing 24/7 protection and emergency response. This ensures that help is on the way if an alarm is triggered.
- Diy Installation: Both Google Nest and SimpliSafe are designed for easy, do-it-yourself installation, eliminating the need for professional installers and saving you money.
- Mobile App Control: You can control and monitor your security system from anywhere using a smartphone app, receiving alerts and managing settings remotely.
- Cellular Backup: Both systems include cellular backup, ensuring your system continues to function even if your internet or power goes down.
- Environmental Monitoring: Both can monitor for environmental hazards like smoke, carbon monoxide, and water leaks, providing early warnings.
Google Nest Vs SimpliSafe Buying Guide
Installation and Setup
Google Nest systems typically offer a more straightforward, DIY installation process, especially for their cameras and doorbells, often relying on existing wiring or simple plug-in setups. Their integration with the Google ecosystem provides easy access to setup guides and troubleshooting. SimpliSafe, while also DIY-friendly, can involve more steps depending on the complexity of your system, including placing sensors and setting up the base station. Both offer professional monitoring options, but Nest’s focus is on ease of use. SimpliSafe offers a more comprehensive security solution, with a wider range of sensors.
Features and Functionality
Google Nest excels in smart home integration, offering seamless compatibility with Google Assistant and other Google products, allowing voice control and automation. They also offer advanced features like facial recognition and person detection, which help minimize false alerts. SimpliSafe prioritizes core security features, offering a robust set of sensors for doors, windows, and motion detection. It also provides 24/7 professional monitoring and cellular backup. It lacks some of the smart home integration Nest offers, but their system is customizable to fit your needs.
Monitoring and Subscription Plans
Google Nest’s subscription plans are focused on video storage and advanced features, like person detection and activity zones. They do not have a free plan and rely on users paying for additional storage. SimpliSafe’s monitoring plans are more traditional, including professional monitoring, cellular backup, and access to advanced features. They offer a basic plan that can be free. SimpliSafe’s plans are typically more affordable than Nest’s, especially if you require professional monitoring.
Equipment and Hardware
Google Nest offers a range of cameras, doorbells, and smart home devices designed to work together. Their hardware is known for its sleek design and integration with other Google products. SimpliSafe offers a more traditional security system hardware, including sensors, keypads, and a base station. The equipment is generally reliable. Both systems offer a variety of sensors. SimpliSafe’s equipment is available in pre-packaged bundles or customizable configurations.
Smart Home Integration
Google Nest’s strength lies in its tight integration with the Google ecosystem. It works seamlessly with Google Assistant, allowing voice control and automation. You can view your camera feeds on smart displays and control your system through the Google Home app. SimpliSafe, while improving its smart home compatibility, is not as deeply integrated. It works with integrations like Amazon Alexa and IFTTT, but its focus is primarily on security features. Nest’s integration is superior.
Pricing and Value
Google Nest’s upfront costs can be lower, especially if you’re only purchasing a camera or two. However, the ongoing subscription costs for video storage and advanced features can add up. SimpliSafe’s initial cost can be higher, depending on the number of sensors and equipment. SimpliSafe’s monitoring plans are often more budget-friendly. Both systems offer good value for their respective features, but the best choice depends on your needs. Consider your subscription needs.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Google Nest If…
- You’re already invested in the Google ecosystem and want seamless integration with other Google smart home devices.
- You prioritize advanced video features, such as facial recognition and activity zones.
- You want a system that is easy to manage from a single app.
Buy SimpliSafe If…
- You want a more affordable system with flexible monitoring plans.
- You prefer a system with a longer warranty.
- You prioritize a simple and user-friendly experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Google Nest and SimpliSafe?
The primary difference lies in their focus: Google Nest prioritizes smart home integration and video surveillance, offering advanced features like facial recognition and seamless Google Assistant compatibility. SimpliSafe concentrates on core security, offering a wider range of sensors, professional monitoring, and cellular backup. Nest is great for smart homes, while SimpliSafe is designed for complete security needs.
Which system is easier to install?
Both systems are designed for DIY installation. Google Nest generally has a slightly easier setup process, especially for cameras and doorbells, often relying on simpler setups. SimpliSafe is also DIY-friendly, but the setup of the base station and sensor placement might involve a few more steps. Both offer easy to use apps.
Does Google Nest require a subscription?
Yes, Google Nest requires a subscription, called Nest Aware, to access features like video recording history, person detection, and activity zones. Without a subscription, you typically only get live video streaming. The subscription cost can vary depending on the features and storage you choose. These plans are priced monthly.
Does SimpliSafe require a subscription?
SimpliSafe offers several monitoring plans, including professional monitoring, cellular backup, and access to advanced features. You can use SimpliSafe without a subscription, but you will not have the professional monitoring or cellular backup. A subscription is recommended to take full advantage of SimpliSafe’s security features.
Which system offers better smart home integration?
Google Nest excels in smart home integration, offering seamless compatibility with Google Assistant and other Google products. You can control your system with voice commands and integrate it with other smart home devices. SimpliSafe offers integration with Amazon Alexa and IFTTT, but it is not as deeply integrated into the smart home ecosystem. Nest offers the better integration.
Which system is more affordable?
SimpliSafe’s monitoring plans are typically more affordable, especially if you require professional monitoring. Google Nest’s upfront costs can be lower, but the ongoing subscription costs for video storage and advanced features can add up. Both systems offer varying price points depending on the features you want. The cost varies based on your needs.
Which system is better for renters?
Both systems are suitable for renters, as they are both DIY-friendly and don’t require professional installation. SimpliSafe is often a better choice, as it’s easy to move and reconfigure. Google Nest is also easy to move, but the subscription costs can add up. Consider your needs and requirements before deciding.
Final Verdict
Google Nest offers excellent smart home integration and easy setup, with a focus on video surveillance and advanced features. SimpliSafe excels in core security, offering a comprehensive system with professional monitoring and a wide range of sensors. While Nest is great for its smart home features, SimpliSafe’s affordability and comprehensive security make it the better overall choice for most users.
Winner: SimpliSafe