Choosing between Samsung’s smartwatches can be a tough decision, especially when comparing two popular models like the Gear S3 and the Galaxy Watch Active2. Both offer a compelling blend of fitness tracking, smart features, and stylish design, but they cater to slightly different user needs and preferences.
The Gear S3, a veteran in the smartwatch arena, boasts a classic watch aesthetic and robust functionality. It was a flagship device that set a high bar for its predecessors and successors. On the other hand, the Galaxy Watch Active2 represents a more modern approach, focusing on streamlined design and advanced health monitoring.
If you’re wondering which of these Samsung powerhouses is the right fit for your wrist, you’ve come to the right place. We’ll dive deep into their features, performance, and overall user experience to help you make an informed choice.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Gear S3 | Active 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Display Size | 1.3-inch | 1.4-inch (44mm), 1.2-inch (40mm) |
| Display Type | Super AMOLED | Super AMOLED |
| Processor | Dual-core 1.0 GHz | Exynos 9110 Dual-core 1.15 GHz |
| RAM | 768 MB | 768 MB |
| Internal Storage | 4 GB | 4 GB |
| Operating System | Tizen OS | Tizen OS |
| Water Resistance | IP68 | IP68, 5ATM |
| GPS | Yes | Yes |
| NFC | Yes | Yes |
| Heart Rate Sensor | Yes | Yes |
| ECG | No | Yes |
| Battery Capacity | 380 mAh | 340 mAh (44mm), 247 mAh (40mm) |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Display
- Gear S3: Features a 1.3-inch Super AMOLED display with a resolution of 360 x 360 pixels. This provides a vibrant and clear viewing experience, with good brightness even in sunlight. The rotating bezel offers a unique and intuitive way to navigate menus.
- Active 2: Boasts a 1.4-inch Super AMOLED display with a resolution of 360 x 360 pixels, offering a slightly larger screen area. It also features an edge-to-edge design for a more immersive look. The touch bezel provides a touch-sensitive ring around the screen for navigation, which can be less tactile than the physical bezel.
- Winner: Active 2
Design and Build
- Gear S3: Available in two distinct styles: the classic Frontier and the more refined Classic. Both are built with durable materials, offering a more traditional watch aesthetic. The larger size might be less comfortable for some wrists.
- Active 2: Offers a sleeker, more modern, and sportier design with a focus on customization. It’s lighter and generally more comfortable for extended wear and workouts. The aluminum casing is less premium than the stainless steel options on the Gear S3.
- Winner: Active 2
Operating System and Performance
- Gear S3: Runs on Samsung’s Tizen OS. While functional and optimized for Samsung devices, app support is more limited compared to Wear OS. Performance is generally smooth for its age.
- Active 2: Also runs on Tizen OS, but benefits from software optimizations and a more powerful processor. This results in snappier performance and a smoother user experience. App availability remains a Tizen limitation, though it’s slightly better with newer models.
- Winner: Active 2
Health and Fitness Tracking
- Gear S3: Includes basic fitness tracking features like step counting, heart rate monitoring, and sleep tracking. It offers GPS for outdoor activities. However, it lacks some of the more advanced health sensors found in newer devices.
- Active 2: Significantly enhances health tracking with features like ECG (electrocardiogram) for heart rhythm analysis, fall detection, and advanced sleep tracking. It also offers a wider range of workout modes and more detailed performance metrics.
- Winner: Active 2
Battery Life
- Gear S3: Typically offers around 2-3 days of battery life on a single charge, depending on usage. This is a solid performance for a smartwatch of its generation.
- Active 2: Battery life is generally similar, ranging from 1 to 2 days with moderate use. However, the more advanced features and larger display can drain the battery faster, especially with always-on display enabled.
- Winner: Gear S3
Connectivity and Smart Features
- Gear S3: Offers Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and optional LTE connectivity. It supports NFC for Samsung Pay. Notifications and basic app interactions are well-handled.
- Active 2: Provides similar connectivity options including Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and LTE. It also supports NFC for Samsung Pay and boasts improved Bluetooth connectivity for a more stable connection. It offers more refined notification management and deeper integration with Samsung’s ecosystem.
- Winner: Active 2
Durability and Water Resistance
- Gear S3: Rated for IP68 water and dust resistance, meaning it can withstand submersion in shallow water for a limited time. It’s also MIL-STD-810G certified for ruggedness.
- Active 2: Also rated for IP68 water and dust resistance, making it suitable for swimming and other water-based activities. It’s built to withstand daily wear and tear.
- Winner: Gear S3
Price and Availability
- Gear S3: Being an older model, the Gear S3 is generally available at a significantly lower price point, often found on the used market or through clearance sales. Availability may be limited to older stock.
- Active 2: As a newer device, the Active 2 is typically more expensive, though prices have decreased since its launch. It’s widely available from major retailers and online.
- Winner: Gear S3
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Design & Build | Active 2 (Sleeker, more modern) |
| Display | Active 2 (Slightly larger, brighter) |
| Performance | Active 2 (Slightly faster processor) |
| Health Features | Active 2 (ECG, fall detection) |
| Battery Life | Gear S3 (Generally longer-lasting) |
| Value for Money | Gear S3 (More affordable) |
| Overall | Active 2 |
What They Have in Common
- Display Technology: Both smartwatches feature vibrant Super AMOLED displays, offering excellent color reproduction and deep blacks for clear visibility in various lighting conditions.
- Operating System: They both run on Samsung’s Tizen OS, providing a familiar and intuitive user interface with access to a range of apps and watch faces.
- Connectivity: Both devices support essential connectivity features like Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, enabling seamless pairing with smartphones and other devices for notifications and data transfer.
- Built-in Gps: For accurate tracking of outdoor activities like running and cycling, both the Gear S3 and Active 2 come equipped with integrated GPS sensors.
- Nfc for Payments: Contactless payments are supported on both watches thanks to integrated NFC technology, allowing for convenient transactions using Samsung Pay.
- Durability: Both smartwatches offer robust build quality and water resistance ratings (IP68), making them suitable for everyday wear and even swimming.
Gear S3 Vs Active 2 Buying Guide
For the Classic Watch Enthusiast
If you appreciate a more traditional watch aesthetic with a rotating bezel for intuitive navigation, the Samsung Gear S3 Frontier or Classic is a compelling choice. Its larger display and robust build lend themselves to a classic timepiece feel. The Gear S3 offers a familiar smartwatch experience for those who value established design principles and a tactile interface. (See Also: Iphone 12 Vs 13 )
For the Fitness-Focused User
The Samsung Galaxy Active2 excels for individuals prioritizing fitness tracking and a sleeker, more modern design. Its lighter weight and more compact form factor make it comfortable for all-day wear and intense workouts. With advanced health sensors and a focus on active lifestyles, the Active2 is built to keep pace with your fitness journey.
For Smartwatch Ecosystem Integration
Both watches integrate well with Samsung’s ecosystem, but the Active2, being newer, benefits from more recent software updates and potentially better long-term support. If you’re heavily invested in Samsung phones and services, either will offer a seamless experience. However, the Active2’s current platform ensures it remains at the forefront of Samsung’s wearable technology.
For Budget-Conscious Buyers
The Gear S3, being an older model, can often be found at a more attractive price point. This makes it an excellent option for those looking for a capable smartwatch without breaking the bank. While it may lack some of the latest features, its core functionalities remain robust and offer great value for money. (See Also: Vvs Moissanite Vs Diamond )
Who Should Buy What?
Buy gear s3 If…
- You prefer a classic watch design with a rotating bezel for navigation.
- You’re looking for a more budget-friendly smartwatch option.
- You prioritize a slightly larger display for easier interaction.
- You don’t need advanced health features like ECG.
Buy active 2 If…
- You want the latest health tracking features, including ECG and fall detection.
- You prefer a more modern and sleek design with a touch bezel.
- You need enhanced water resistance for more rigorous water activities.
- You value a slightly more compact and lighter feel on the wrist.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which watch has better battery life?
Generally, the Samsung Gear S3 is known for its superior battery life, often lasting two full days or more on a single charge with moderate use. The Active2, while improved over its predecessor, typically hovers around a day to a day and a half of battery life, especially with continuous use of its advanced fitness tracking features and always-on display.
Does the Active2 have a rotating bezel?
No, the Samsung Galaxy Active2 does not feature a physical rotating bezel like the Gear S3. Instead, it utilizes a touch-sensitive bezel around the screen for navigation. While this offers a sleeker look, some users prefer the tactile feedback and intuitive control provided by the Gear S3’s physical bezel.
Which watch is more comfortable for workouts?
The Samsung Galaxy Active2 is generally considered more comfortable for workouts due to its lighter weight and more compact, streamlined design. Its smoother edges and less bulky profile make it less obtrusive during physical activity. The Gear S3, while still wearable, can feel a bit more substantial on the wrist during intense exercise. (See Also: Dell Inspiron Vs Xps Desktop )
Can I make calls on both watches?
Yes, both the Samsung Gear S3 and the Galaxy Active2 support making and receiving calls, provided they are connected to a compatible smartphone. Some models of both watches also offer LTE connectivity, allowing you to make calls independently of your phone when you have a cellular plan.
Which watch has a better display?
Both watches feature vibrant AMOLED displays. The Active2’s display is slightly larger and can achieve higher brightness levels, making it more legible in direct sunlight. While the Gear S3’s display is still excellent, the Active2 offers a marginally more refined visual experience, particularly in outdoor conditions.
Final Verdict
The Samsung Galaxy Active2 emerges as the superior choice for most users, offering a modern design, enhanced fitness tracking, and a more refined user experience. While the Gear S3 remains a solid option for those who prioritize battery life and a classic rotating bezel, the Active2’s updated features and sleeker profile make it the better investment for current smartwatch needs.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Active2