Extra Space Storage vs Public Storage: Which Is Best?
Are you staring at overflowing closets, a cluttered garage, or maybe even a house overflowing with stuff? You’re not alone! Many of us face the ongoing challenge of managing our belongings. Luckily, the self-storage industry offers solutions, but deciding between options can feel overwhelming.
Two of the biggest players in the self-storage game are Extra Space Storage and Public Storage. Both offer a variety of unit sizes and convenient features. However, their approaches to pricing, accessibility, and overall customer experience can differ significantly.
This comparison dives deep into the pros and cons of Extra Space Storage versus Public Storage. We’ll explore everything from unit availability and security to cost-effectiveness and ease of use. By the end, you’ll be equipped to choose the perfect storage solution to fit your specific needs and budget, making your life a little less cluttered.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Extra Space Storage | Public Storage |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 24/7 Access (Varies) | Limited Access Hours |
| Security | Variable, often higher | Surveillance, Gated |
| Climate Control | Often Available | Sometimes Available |
| Location | On-Site or Nearby | Centralized Locations |
| Size Options | Customizable, Flexible | Standard Unit Sizes |
| Contract Length | Flexible, Short-Term | Typically Monthly or Longer |
| Convenience | Easy to Access | May Require Travel |
| Moving Assistance | Often Provided | Rarely Provided |
| Insurance | May be Included | Required for Some |
| Privacy | High | Moderate |
| Ease of Packing | Can load directly | Requires transfer to vehicle |
| Loading Dock | May or May not have | Typically Available |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Cost
- Extra Space Storage: Generally, extra space storage options can be more expensive initially due to the cost of purchasing or renting the extra space. However, they may offer long-term cost savings by avoiding recurring storage fees. The cost is often tied to the size and location of the space.
- Public Storage: Public storage facilities typically involve monthly rental fees, which can vary widely based on unit size, location, and demand. While offering flexibility, these fees can accumulate over time, potentially exceeding the cost of owning or renting extra space.
- Winner: Depends
Accessibility
- Extra Space Storage: Accessibility depends on the location of the extra space. It could be in your home, yard, or a separate building. This can be very convenient if the space is easily accessible, but less so if it requires travel or is difficult to reach.
- Public Storage: Public storage facilities offer defined access hours, which may be restricted, and could require travel to and from the facility. This can be a drawback if you need frequent access or have an unpredictable schedule.
- Winner: extra space storage
Security
- Extra Space Storage: Security varies greatly. It depends on the location and the security measures in place (locks, alarms, etc.). If it’s in your home, it may be inherently safer, but exterior spaces are vulnerable.
- Public Storage: Public storage facilities often have security measures like gated access, surveillance cameras, and on-site staff. This can provide a higher level of security compared to some extra space options.
- Winner: public storage
Flexibility
- Extra Space Storage: The flexibility of extra space storage depends on the type and nature of the space. If it’s a spare room, it’s very flexible, but if it is a rigid shed, it’s less so. It may be easier to adapt to changing storage needs.
- Public Storage: Public storage offers flexibility in terms of unit size and rental terms. You can often easily adjust the size of the unit or terminate your rental agreement as needed.
- Winner: public storage
Climate Control
- Extra Space Storage: Extra space storage usually lacks climate control unless the space is part of your home or is a climate-controlled building. This can be problematic for items sensitive to temperature and humidity.
- Public Storage: Many public storage facilities offer climate-controlled units, protecting items from extreme temperatures and humidity. This is a significant advantage for storing valuable or sensitive belongings.
- Winner: public storage
Insurance
- Extra Space Storage: Insurance coverage for items stored in extra space may fall under your homeowner’s or renter’s insurance, but coverage details and limitations should be carefully reviewed. You may need to purchase additional coverage.
- Public Storage: Public storage facilities often offer insurance options or require proof of insurance, providing some protection against loss or damage. This can add an extra layer of security for your belongings.
- Winner: public storage
Convenience
- Extra Space Storage: Convenience depends on the location and accessibility of the extra space. If it’s a dedicated area at your home, it can be very convenient. If it’s a separate building, it is less convenient.
- Public Storage: Public storage can be convenient if the facility is conveniently located near your home or work. However, the travel time and access restrictions could decrease the convenience.
- Winner: Depends
Size and Capacity
- Extra Space Storage: The size and capacity of extra space storage vary significantly depending on the available space. It could be a spare closet, a garage, or a separate building. This can be tailored to specific needs.
- Public Storage: Public storage facilities provide a wide range of unit sizes, from small lockers to large units, allowing you to choose the space that best fits your storage needs.
- Winner: public storage
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Convenience | Extra Space Storage |
| Security | Extra Space Storage |
| Price | Public Storage |
| Accessibility | Extra Space Storage |
| Flexibility | Extra Space Storage |
What They Have in Common
- Purpose: Both offer solutions for storing personal belongings, providing a secure space away from your primary living area.
- Protection: Both aim to protect stored items from theft and the elements, though the level of protection can vary.
- Rental Agreement: Both services operate on a rental basis, requiring a contract and monthly payments.
- Accessibility Restrictions: Both may have limitations on when you can access your stored items, although private storage has more flexibility.
- Liability: Both typically have some form of liability coverage, although it may be limited and require additional insurance.
- Management: Both require management and maintenance to ensure security and cleanliness of the storage area.
Extra Space Storage Vs Public Storage Buying Guide
Location Considerations
When choosing between Extra Space Storage and Public Storage, location is paramount. Consider the proximity to your home, office, and frequently visited areas. Both companies offer a wide network of facilities, but availability varies by region. Evaluate accessibility, including traffic patterns and ease of loading and unloading. Research the safety and security of the surrounding neighborhood for both locations. Think about the convenience factor and how it aligns with your storage needs. Is it easy to get to, and how much time will it take?
Unit Size and Availability
Assess your storage needs meticulously to determine the appropriate unit size. Both Extra Space Storage and Public Storage provide a variety of sizes, from small lockers to large spaces for entire households. Understand the dimensions of your belongings and estimate the required cubic footage. Check availability at different locations, as popular sizes may be in high demand. Consider the possibility of future storage needs and select a unit that offers flexibility. Some units have climate control, which may be a need depending on the items.
Pricing and Promotions
Compare the pricing structures of Extra Space Storage and Public Storage, including monthly rent, move-in fees, and insurance costs. Both companies frequently offer promotions and discounts, such as introductory rates or seasonal specials. Carefully review the terms and conditions of any promotions before committing. Inquire about price increases and understand the billing cycle. Consider the overall value, taking into account the unit size, features, and location in relation to the price. Is it worth the cost?
Security Features and Amenities
Evaluate the security measures implemented by each storage facility. Look for features such as gated access, surveillance cameras, and on-site managers. Determine if the facility offers climate-controlled units to protect sensitive items from extreme temperatures and humidity. Consider the availability of amenities like moving carts, elevators, and wide aisles for easy maneuvering. Assess the overall cleanliness and maintenance of the facility, as it reflects the attention to detail and care provided. Is it a safe place?
Lease Terms and Flexibility
Review the lease terms and conditions carefully, paying attention to the minimum rental period and cancellation policies. Understand the process for extending or terminating your lease. Consider the flexibility offered by each company, such as the ability to change unit sizes or transfer locations. Inquire about late payment fees and other penalties. Ensure that the lease terms align with your anticipated storage duration and potential needs. Always know what you are signing!
Customer Reviews and Reputation
Research customer reviews and ratings for both Extra Space Storage and Public Storage. Read online reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, and Trustpilot. Pay attention to feedback regarding customer service, cleanliness, and security. Consider the overall reputation of each company within your local community. Look for patterns in the reviews, highlighting common strengths and weaknesses. Use the reviews to gauge the overall customer experience and make an informed decision. Do they care about their customers?
Who Should Buy What?
Buy extra space storage If…
- You need immediate access to your belongings at any time.
- You want to store items close to your home or business.
- You require a highly secure and private storage solution.
- You want flexible rental terms.
Buy public storage If…
- You have a limited budget.
- You do not need frequent access to your belongings.
- You are comfortable with standard unit sizes.
- You prioritize convenience of a centralized location.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main differences between Extra Space Storage and Public Storage?
The primary differences lie in pricing, location availability, unit size options, and specific amenities. Public Storage often boasts a larger network with potentially more competitive rates. Extra Space Storage may offer more specialized services like climate-controlled units in certain areas. Both provide secure facilities, but the specific features and customer service experiences can vary based on location and management. Consider your specific needs and location.
How do I determine the right unit size for my needs?
Estimate the volume of your belongings by calculating the cubic footage required. Consider the size of furniture, boxes, and other items you plan to store. Both companies provide online size guides and unit size calculators to assist you. It’s usually better to overestimate than underestimate, leaving room for future additions. If you are unsure, consider renting a larger unit than initially anticipated.
What security measures are typically in place?
Both companies typically employ gated access, surveillance cameras, and on-site managers. Some facilities also offer individual unit alarms and climate-controlled environments. Security measures can vary by location, so it’s important to inquire about the specific features at the facility you are considering. Review the security protocols and ensure they meet your comfort level before renting a unit. They are a great way to protect your items.
Are there any hidden fees I should be aware of?
Be sure to inquire about move-in fees, administrative fees, and late payment penalties. Review the lease agreement carefully to understand all potential charges. Some facilities may have extra charges for insurance or other services. Ask questions upfront to avoid any surprises. Always clarify all fees before signing the contract. Do your research to be certain.
What is the lease duration and cancellation policy?
Lease durations typically range from month-to-month to longer-term agreements. Review the cancellation policy carefully, including any notice requirements and potential fees. Understand the process for terminating your lease and any penalties for early termination. Be certain you understand the terms and conditions before renting a unit. Always read the fine print.
How do I pay for my storage unit?
Most facilities accept various payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, checks, and online payments. Inquire about automatic payment options and late payment policies. Understand the billing cycle and due dates to avoid late fees. Many companies offer online portals for easy payment and account management. Be sure to know how you will pay, and set reminders.
What happens if my belongings are damaged or stolen?
Both companies typically offer insurance options to protect your belongings. Review your lease agreement and inquire about coverage options and claims processes. Consider the value of your stored items and the level of insurance needed. Understand the facility’s liability in case of damage or theft. Insurance is always a good idea, and it gives you peace of mind.
Final Verdict
Both Extra Space Storage and Public Storage are reputable storage solutions, each with its own advantages. The choice depends on individual needs, location, and budget. Public Storage often presents a broader network and potentially lower prices, while Extra Space Storage may offer more specialized features. Careful consideration of these factors will help determine the best fit.
Winner: Tie