Echo Show 8 2nd vs 3rd Gen: Which Smart Display Reigns?
Struggling to decide between the Echo Show 8 2nd vs 3rd gen? You’re not alone! These smart displays from Amazon promise to be the center of your connected home, but choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. We’ll break down the key differences to help you make the perfect choice.
The Echo Show 8 series has consistently delivered a solid smart home experience. Both the 2nd and 3rd generation models offer a vibrant display, seamless Alexa integration, and a range of features designed to simplify your daily life. But are the upgrades in the newer model worth the extra cost?
This in-depth comparison will explore the design, features, and performance of the Echo Show 8 (2nd generation) and the Echo Show 8 (3rd generation). We’ll cover everything from sound quality and screen clarity to camera capabilities and smart home control. Get ready to discover which Echo Show 8 is the best fit for your needs!
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | echo show 8 2nd | 3rd gen |
|---|---|---|
| Display Size | 8-inch | 8-inch |
| Processor | Unknown | Unknown |
| Camera Resolution | 13MP | 13MP |
| Speakers | Stereo | Stereo |
| Bluetooth | Yes | Yes |
| Wi-Fi | 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac | 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac |
| Zigbee Hub | Yes | Yes |
| Motion Detection | Yes | Yes |
| Color Options | Charcoal, Glacier White | Charcoal, Glacier White |
| Built-in Privacy Features | Physical shutter, Mic mute | Physical shutter, Mic mute |
| Adaptive Sound | No | Yes |
| Built-in Smart Home Hub | Yes | Yes |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Design
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Features a similar design to the original, with a fabric-covered back and a slightly angled display. It offers a clean and modern aesthetic. Some may find the design a bit dated compared to the newer generation.
- 3rd Gen: Boasts a refreshed design with a more rounded shape and a floating display appearance. The design feels more modern and premium. Some users may prefer the more traditional look of the 2nd gen.
- Winner: 3rd gen
Display
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Has an 8-inch HD display, which is adequate for video calls and content consumption. The picture quality is good but not exceptional.
- 3rd Gen: Maintains the 8-inch HD display, but often features improved screen technology for better contrast and color accuracy. It may offer a slightly enhanced visual experience.
- Winner: 3rd gen
Audio Quality
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Provides decent audio quality with stereo speakers. It’s suitable for listening to music and podcasts in a small to medium-sized room. The bass response might be limited.
- 3rd Gen: Often features improved audio with enhanced bass and clearer vocals. The sound is generally fuller and more immersive.
- Winner: 3rd gen
Processor & Performance
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Likely uses an older processor, which means slower response times and potentially more lag when running demanding apps or multitasking.
- 3rd Gen: Typically includes a newer, more powerful processor, leading to faster performance, smoother navigation, and quicker app launches.
- Winner: 3rd gen
Camera
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Equipped with a camera for video calls. The resolution is usually sufficient for calls, but not top-of-the-line.
- 3rd Gen: May feature an improved camera with a wider field of view and potentially better image quality, offering a superior video calling experience.
- Winner: 3rd gen
Smart Home Integration
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Offers comprehensive smart home integration with support for various smart home devices and protocols. It works well with Alexa.
- 3rd Gen: Maintains excellent smart home compatibility and often includes updated features for managing smart home devices.
- Winner: Tie
User Interface & Features
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Features the standard Alexa interface, with access to skills, routines, and other Alexa features.
- 3rd Gen: Likely has the latest Alexa interface, potentially with added features or improvements to the user experience.
- Winner: 3rd gen
Price
- Echo Show 8 2nd: Generally available at a lower price point, making it a more budget-friendly option.
- 3rd Gen: Typically priced higher due to its updated features and design.
- Winner: echo show 8 2nd
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Overall Value | Tie |
| Display Quality | Tie |
| Camera Quality | Tie |
| Audio Quality | 3rd gen |
| Smart Home Features | Tie |
| Design | Tie |
| Additional Features | 3rd gen |
What They Have in Common:
- Display: Both devices feature an 8-inch touchscreen display, offering a similar visual experience for video calls, viewing content, and interacting with Alexa.
- Camera: Both generations include a 13MP camera, ensuring high-quality video calls and photo capture.
- Speakers: Both models have stereo speakers, providing a richer and more immersive audio experience.
- Smart Home Integration: They both integrate with other smart home devices and offer the same level of control over your smart home ecosystem.
- Connectivity: Both devices support Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, providing options for audio streaming and internet connectivity.
- Privacy Features: Both generations offer built-in privacy features like a physical camera shutter and a microphone mute button.
Echo Show 8 2nd vs 3rd Gen Buying Guide
Display and Design
The display is a crucial element when choosing a smart display. The Echo Show 8 2nd Gen and 3rd Gen share the same 8-inch HD display, offering vibrant visuals for video calls, watching videos, and displaying photos. However, the design sees some evolution. The 3rd Gen often boasts a slightly more modern aesthetic, with potentially thinner bezels or updated color options. Consider where you’ll place the device and which design better complements your space. Design preferences can vary, so evaluate both models visually.
Audio Performance
Sound quality is a key differentiator. The 3rd Gen usually improves upon the audio capabilities of its predecessor. Expect enhanced bass response, clearer vocals, and potentially a wider soundstage in the 3rd Gen. The 2nd Gen still provides decent audio for everyday use, but the 3rd Gen offers a more immersive listening experience. Consider your typical usage: are you primarily listening to music, podcasts, or using it for video calls? Audiophiles will likely appreciate the 3rd Gen’s improvements.
Camera and Video Calling
The camera is essential for video calls. The 3rd Gen often upgrades the camera resolution and features. Look for improved image quality, potentially a wider field of view, and smart framing capabilities that keep you centered in the frame. The 2nd Gen’s camera is still adequate, but the 3rd Gen’s enhancements provide a better video calling experience. If video calls are a priority, closely compare the camera specifications and consider the lighting in your typical call environment to optimize clarity.
Processing Power and Performance
Faster processing leads to a smoother user experience. The 3rd Gen typically features a more powerful processor, resulting in quicker response times for voice commands, faster app loading, and improved overall performance. The 2nd Gen remains responsive, but the 3rd Gen provides a more fluid and less laggy experience. If you frequently use multiple apps or perform complex tasks, the 3rd Gen’s performance advantage will be noticeable. Consider how you’ll interact with the device to evaluate the processing power differences.
Smart Home Integration
Both generations excel in smart home control. They seamlessly integrate with a wide range of smart home devices, allowing you to control lights, thermostats, and other devices using voice commands. Both versions support Zigbee and other common smart home protocols. Check the compatibility with your existing smart home ecosystem to ensure seamless integration. The 3rd Gen might offer slightly faster response times when controlling smart home devices, but both will provide a solid experience.
Pricing and Value
Price is a significant factor. The 2nd Gen is typically available at a lower price point, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers. The 3rd Gen, with its improved features and performance, will naturally command a higher price. Compare the features you need against the price difference to determine the best value. Consider sales and promotions, as both generations are often discounted. Evaluate your budget and usage needs to determine which offers the best overall value for your needs.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy echo show 8 2nd If…
- You find it at a significantly lower price.
- You don’t need Adaptive Sound technology.
- You are happy with current features.
Buy 3rd gen If…
- You want the latest model.
- You want the best possible audio experience.
- You prioritize Adaptive Sound.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the primary differences between the Echo Show 8 2nd and 3rd Gen?
The 3rd Gen often boasts improved audio, a potentially better camera for video calls, and a more powerful processor resulting in faster performance. Design changes and minor software tweaks are also usually present. The 2nd Gen is still a capable device, but the 3rd Gen offers enhancements across several key areas, particularly audio and processing.
Does the 3rd Gen have a better display than the 2nd Gen?
No, both generations share the same 8-inch HD display. While the design of the device may differ, the fundamental screen technology is largely unchanged. Focus on other improvements like audio and processing when deciding between the two, as the visual experience on both devices is consistent.
Are the smart home features different between the two models?
Both models offer excellent smart home integration. They both support a wide range of smart home devices and protocols, allowing voice control of lights, thermostats, and other compatible devices. The 3rd Gen might have slightly faster response times, but the core functionality is the same.
Which Echo Show 8 has a better camera?
Generally, the 3rd Gen has a superior camera. The 3rd Gen often includes a higher resolution camera, which results in better video quality during video calls. It may also include features like a wider field of view or smart framing. The 2nd Gen still provides a functional camera, but the 3rd Gen’s camera is an upgrade.
Is the audio quality significantly better on the 3rd Gen?
Yes, the audio quality typically sees a notable improvement in the 3rd Gen. The 3rd Gen often boasts enhanced bass response, clearer vocals, and a wider soundstage, resulting in a more immersive audio experience compared to the 2nd Gen. This makes the 3rd Gen a better choice for music and entertainment.
Is the 3rd Gen Echo Show 8 worth the extra cost?
That depends on your needs and budget. If audio quality, camera performance, and overall speed are priorities, the 3rd Gen is likely worth the extra cost. If you primarily use the device for basic tasks and are on a tighter budget, the 2nd Gen remains a great value. Evaluate your needs to determine which best suits you.
Can I still use the same skills on both devices?
Yes, you can use the same Alexa skills on both the 2nd and 3rd Gen Echo Show 8 devices. The Alexa ecosystem is consistent across devices, so you’ll have access to the same vast library of skills regardless of which generation you choose. The experience of using the skills might be slightly faster on the 3rd Gen.
Final Verdict
While both the 2nd and 3rd generation Echo Show 8 devices offer a solid smart home experience, the 3rd generation emerges as the superior choice due to its enhanced audio performance, improved camera, and faster processing capabilities. The improvements in these key areas justify the typically higher price tag for those seeking the best overall experience. The 2nd Gen remains a viable option for budget-conscious consumers.
Winner: Echo Show 8 3rd Gen