Echo 5 vs 8: Which Amazon Smart Speaker Reigns Supreme?
Are you looking to upgrade your smart home setup? Choosing between smart speakers can be tricky, but we’re here to help you navigate the options. Today, we’re diving deep into a head-to-head comparison to help you decide which Amazon Echo device is the perfect fit for your needs.
We’re putting the Amazon Echo 5th Generation up against the Amazon Echo 8th Generation. These popular smart speakers offer a range of features, from music playback and voice control to smart home integration. Understanding the differences between these two models is crucial for making an informed decision.
This comparison will cover everything from sound quality and design to features and pricing. We’ll explore the strengths and weaknesses of each device, so you can determine which one best suits your lifestyle and budget. Get ready to discover which Echo device will become the heart of your smart home!
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | echo 5 | 8 |
|---|---|---|
| Screen Size | 5.5-inch | 8-inch |
| Speaker Size | 1.6-inch | 2.0-inch |
| Camera Resolution | 2MP | 13MP |
| Processor | Unknown | More Powerful |
| Video Calling | Yes | Yes |
| Smart Home Control | Yes | Yes |
| Bluetooth | Yes | Yes |
| Wi-Fi | Yes | Yes |
| Built-in Zigbee Hub | Yes | Yes |
| Audio Output | 3.5 mm Jack | 3.5 mm Jack |
| Microphone Array | 3 mics | 4 mics |
| Physical Buttons | Volume, Mute | Volume, Mute |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Audio Quality
- Echo 5: Offers improved audio quality compared to previous Echo models, with better bass and clearer vocals. It typically includes a single 1.6-inch driver. A potential drawback is that it might not fill larger rooms as effectively as larger speakers.
- 8: Provides a more powerful and richer sound experience due to its larger size and typically dual 2-inch drivers and a woofer. This results in a fuller sound, better bass response, and the ability to fill larger spaces. However, the larger size can be less convenient.
- Winner: 8
Smart Home Hub Capabilities
- Echo 5: Functions as a basic smart home hub, supporting Zigbee devices, allowing control of lights, thermostats, and other compatible devices. Its hub functionality is somewhat limited compared to dedicated hubs.
- 8: Includes a built-in smart home hub with Zigbee, Matter, and Thread support. This provides broader compatibility with a wider range of smart home devices, enhancing its versatility and future-proofing the device.
- Winner: 8
Screen Size & Display
- Echo 5: Features a smaller display, typically around 5.5 inches. This makes it suitable for bedside tables or areas where space is limited. The smaller screen limits the visual experience.
- 8: Boasts a larger display, usually 8 inches. The bigger screen is better for video calls, displaying more information at a glance, and generally improving the visual experience. It does, however, take up more space.
- Winner: 8
Camera Quality & Features
- Echo 5: Often includes a camera for video calls, but the resolution and field of view may be more limited compared to the Echo 8.
- 8: Generally features a higher-resolution camera with a wider field of view, making video calls more immersive and allowing for better framing.
- Winner: 8
Processing Power & Speed
- Echo 5: Generally has adequate processing power for its size and intended use, handling voice commands and basic tasks effectively.
- 8: Usually comes with more powerful processing capabilities, leading to faster response times, smoother performance, and the ability to handle more complex tasks.
- Winner: 8
Design & Aesthetics
- Echo 5: Usually offers a compact and space-saving design, making it suitable for smaller spaces and bedside tables. It might have a more minimalistic design.
- 8: Typically features a larger design with a more prominent screen. This may be more aesthetically pleasing for some, but takes up more space.
- Winner: 8
Connectivity Options
- Echo 5: Typically offers standard connectivity options such as Wi-Fi and Bluetooth.
- 8: Offers the same connectivity options as the Echo 5, but might also include enhanced Wi-Fi support (e.g., Wi-Fi 6) or additional ports like a 3.5mm audio output.
- Winner: 8
Price
- Echo 5: Generally more affordable, making it a good option for budget-conscious buyers or those looking for a basic smart display.
- 8: Priced higher due to its larger size, improved features, and enhanced performance, making it a more premium offering.
- Winner: echo 5
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Screen Size | 8 |
| Audio Quality | 8 |
| Camera Quality | 8 |
| Portability | 5 |
| Value | Tie |
| Video Calling Experience | 8 |
What They Have in Common:
- Voice Assistant: Both devices utilize Amazon’s Alexa voice assistant for a wide range of tasks.
- Smart Home Integration: Both Echo devices seamlessly integrate with smart home devices.
- Music Streaming: Both support music streaming services.
- Video Calling: Both devices support video calling.
- Bluetooth Connectivity: Both offer Bluetooth connectivity for audio streaming.
- Wi-Fi Connectivity: Both connect to your home Wi-Fi network.
Echo 5 vs 8 Buying Guide
Echo 5: A Compact Smart Home Hub
The Echo 5, with its 5.5-inch screen, is an excellent choice for bedrooms, kitchens, or any space where desk space is at a premium. Its compact size makes it unobtrusive, while still offering a vibrant display for viewing videos, checking news, and managing your smart home devices. Its primary focus is on providing a seamless and accessible smart home experience through a user-friendly interface. The Echo 5 is great for basic functions.
The small form factor is combined with a surprisingly good speaker for its size, delivering clear audio for music, podcasts, and audiobooks. It’s ideal for those who prioritize portability and ease of use. It is easy to set up and get started right away. The Echo 5 is a versatile and affordable entry point into the world of smart home technology.
Echo 8: A More Immersive Experience
The Echo 8 boasts an 8-inch HD screen, offering a more immersive visual experience for video calls, streaming content, and displaying photos. Its larger screen is a significant advantage if you frequently watch videos or want a clearer view of your smart home controls. The Echo 8’s speaker system is also enhanced, providing richer and louder audio.
The device is better suited for living rooms, offices, or any area where you want a more prominent smart home hub. This model is ideal for those who want a better quality sound and video experience. It is the perfect choice for users who want to make video calls and stream content. Its features also include better smart home capabilities.
Echo 5: Design and Aesthetics
The Echo 5 has a sleek and modern design, with a fabric-covered exterior that blends seamlessly into various home decor styles. Its compact footprint ensures it doesn’t clutter your space. The design is simple and elegant, focusing on functionality and ease of use. The color options typically include neutral tones that complement a variety of interiors.
The device’s small size allows it to be placed on a nightstand, countertop, or desk without taking up too much room. The Echo 5 is designed to be visually appealing, making it a stylish addition to any room. Its design prioritizes accessibility and user-friendliness, making it a great choice for all.
Echo 8: Design and Aesthetics
The Echo 8 features a slightly larger footprint compared to the Echo 5, but maintains a modern and stylish design. It also often features a fabric-covered exterior. The Echo 8 is designed to integrate seamlessly into your living space, with a focus on both aesthetics and functionality. It offers a premium look.
The device is available in a variety of colors, allowing you to choose one that best matches your decor. The Echo 8’s design is focused on providing a premium experience, with a larger display and improved audio capabilities. Its presence is more noticeable, making it a focal point in any room.
Echo 5: Features and Functionality
The Echo 5 offers all the core Alexa features, including voice control for music, news, weather updates, and smart home device management. It is designed to provide a simple and intuitive user experience. The device also supports video calls and the ability to stream content from popular streaming services.
It is equipped with a built-in camera for video calls, and a clear display for viewing information and content. The Echo 5 excels at providing a compact and accessible smart home experience. It is also designed for portability, making it easy to move it from room to room.
Echo 8: Features and Functionality
The Echo 8 offers all the features of the Echo 5, plus the advantages of a larger display and enhanced audio. It provides an immersive experience when watching videos or making video calls. The larger screen makes it easier to view information and control smart home devices.
The Echo 8 provides a richer audio experience for listening to music, podcasts, and audiobooks. The device also has a built-in camera for video calls. The Echo 8 is a great choice for those who prioritize visual and audio quality in their smart home experience.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy echo 5 If…
- You want a compact device that fits well in smaller spaces.
- You prioritize affordability.
- You primarily use your device for basic tasks.
- You want a good balance of features and price.
Buy 8 If…
- You want a larger screen for better video viewing.
- You want improved audio quality.
- You want better camera resolution for video calls.
- You want the latest features and improved performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Echo 5 and Echo 8?
The primary difference lies in the screen size and audio quality. The Echo 8 has an 8-inch screen and improved speakers, offering a more immersive experience compared to the Echo 5’s 5.5-inch screen and smaller speakers. The Echo 8 offers enhanced audio and visual clarity compared to the Echo 5.
Which Echo device is better for video calls?
The Echo 8 is generally better for video calls due to its larger screen and better audio. The larger display makes it easier to see the other person, and the improved speakers provide clearer audio. Although both devices offer video calling, the Echo 8 provides a better experience.
Is the Echo 5 good for music?
The Echo 5 is suitable for listening to music, but the Echo 8 offers a better audio experience. The Echo 8’s larger speakers deliver richer and louder sound. The Echo 5 is still good for podcasts and casual listening in smaller spaces.
Which device is easier to set up?
Both devices are very easy to set up, usually taking just a few minutes through the Alexa app on your smartphone. The setup process is very similar for both devices, making it simple for anyone to get started. The setup process is intuitive and user-friendly.
Can I use both Echo devices to control my smart home?
Yes, both Echo 5 and Echo 8 can control your smart home devices. They both support the same smart home protocols and offer the same features for controlling lights, thermostats, and other connected devices. Both devices function as smart home hubs.
Which Echo device is more affordable?
The Echo 5 is typically more affordable than the Echo 8. The price difference reflects the smaller screen and less powerful speaker. The Echo 5 is a great value for its features. It makes it a great entry level device for smart home features.
Which Echo device is better for a kitchen?
Both devices can be used in the kitchen, but the Echo 8 might be better if you frequently watch cooking videos or need a larger display. The Echo 5 is also a good option if space is limited. Both devices are great additions to a kitchen.
Final Verdict
Both the Echo 5 and Echo 8 offer compelling features for smart home integration. The Echo 8 stands out with its larger screen and superior audio, making it ideal for media consumption and video calls. However, the Echo 5 remains a strong contender, offering a compact and affordable option for those prioritizing portability and space-saving design. The choice hinges on your specific needs and preferences.
Winner: Echo 8