Crockett & Jones vs Allen Edmonds: Which Brand Wins?
Choosing the right pair of dress shoes can feel like navigating a minefield. With so many brands vying for your attention, it’s easy to get lost in the details. But what if you could narrow down your search to two of the most respected names in the business?
Today, we’re pitting Crockett & Jones against Allen Edmonds in a head-to-head comparison. Both brands boast a rich history and a reputation for quality craftsmanship. This evaluation will break down the key differences between these two iconic shoemakers to help you make an informed decision.
From construction methods to materials and overall value, we’ll delve into what sets Crockett & Jones and Allen Edmonds apart. Whether you’re a seasoned shoe aficionado or just starting to build your collection, this guide will provide the insights you need. Get ready to discover which brand reigns supreme!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Crockett & Jones | Allen Edmonds |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | Goodyear Welted | Goodyear Welted |
| Leather Quality | High-Grade Calfskin | High-Grade Calfskin |
| Sole Material | Leather or Rubber | Leather or Rubber |
| Country of Origin | England | USA |
| Style Variety | Wide Range of Classic Styles | Extensive Range of Styles |
| Last Shapes | Variety of Lasts for Different Fits | Variety of Lasts for Different Fits |
| Lining | Full Leather Lining | Full Leather Lining |
| Heel Construction | Stacked Leather Heels | Stacked Leather Heels |
| Toe Shape | Various Toe Shapes (Round, Chisel, etc.) | Various Toe Shapes (Round, Modified Cap-Toe, etc.) |
| Durability | Excellent, Long-Lasting | Excellent, Long-Lasting |
| Resole-ability | Easily Resoleable | Easily Resoleable |
| Branding | Subtle and Sophisticated | Classic and Recognizable |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Construction Quality
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones is renowned for its Goodyear welted construction, utilizing high-quality materials and meticulous craftsmanship. This results in durable, long-lasting shoes that can be resoled. The price point reflects this premium build, making them a significant investment.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds also primarily uses Goodyear welt construction, offering a good balance of quality and value. Their construction is generally robust, allowing for resoling and extending the lifespan of the shoes, although some feel the materials aren’t quite as premium as Crockett & Jones.
- Winner: Crockett & Jones
Leather Quality
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones often uses exceptionally fine leathers sourced from premium tanneries, contributing to the luxurious feel and appearance of their shoes. They are known for their use of calfskin, shell cordovan, and other high-grade materials. The quality translates to a more refined look and feel.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds utilizes good quality leathers, though generally not quite at the same level as Crockett & Jones. They offer a range of leathers, including calfskin and shell cordovan, but the overall selection and grading may vary. The leather quality is still very good for the price.
- Winner: Crockett & Jones
Styling and Design
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones is known for its classic, elegant designs with a strong British heritage. Their styles often feature a refined aesthetic, emphasizing clean lines and understated sophistication. They lean towards more traditional and conservative styles.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds offers a wider variety of styles, ranging from classic to more contemporary designs, with a more American sensibility. They have a broader range of styles, potentially appealing to a wider audience with more casual options.
- Winner: Tie
Comfort
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones shoes are often praised for their comfort, particularly after the break-in period. The high-quality leathers and careful construction contribute to a comfortable fit, although some models can be slightly stiffer initially.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds shoes are generally comfortable, offering a good fit and feel. They are known for their various width options, making it easier to find a shoe that fits well. Break-in periods can vary.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones shoes are positioned at a higher price point, reflecting their premium materials, craftsmanship, and brand prestige. They are an investment piece.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds shoes are generally more affordable than Crockett & Jones, offering a good value for the quality. They often have sales and promotions.
- Winner: Allen Edmonds
Availability and Retail Presence
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones has a more limited retail presence, primarily focused on their own boutiques and select high-end retailers. This exclusivity contributes to the brand’s premium image.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds has a more widespread retail presence, including their own stores, department stores, and online retailers. This makes their shoes more accessible to a wider audience.
- Winner: Allen Edmonds
Resoleability
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones, with their Goodyear welt construction, are designed to be resoled multiple times, extending the lifespan of the shoes significantly. This is a key advantage for longevity.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds also uses Goodyear welt construction, allowing for resoling and extending the life of the shoes, although the quality of the resoling and materials may depend on the cobbler.
- Winner: Tie
Brand Reputation and Prestige
- Crockett and Jones: Crockett & Jones enjoys a strong reputation for luxury and quality, especially within the menswear community. They are a well-regarded brand with a long history and a loyal following.
- Allen Edmonds: Allen Edmonds is a well-respected brand with a long history in American shoemaking, offering a good reputation and recognition. They are known for their quality and value.
- Winner: Crockett & Jones
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Overall Quality | Crockett & Jones |
| Style Variety | Allen Edmonds |
| Value for Money | Allen Edmonds |
| Exclusivity | Crockett & Jones |
| Construction Quality | Tie |
| Brand Heritage | Crockett & Jones |
What They Have in Common
- Construction: Both Crockett & Jones and Allen Edmonds shoes are constructed using the Goodyear welt method, ensuring durability and the ability to be resoled.
- Leather Quality: Both brands utilize high-quality calfskin leather for their uppers, contributing to the shoes’ comfort and longevity.
- Full Leather Lining: Both brands commonly feature full leather linings, enhancing breathability and comfort for the wearer.
- Sole Options: Both brands offer a choice of leather or rubber soles, providing versatility in terms of style and wear.
- Resole-Ability: Both Crockett & Jones and Allen Edmonds shoes are designed to be resoled, extending their lifespan significantly.
- Heel Construction: Both brands use stacked leather heels, adding to the shoe’s overall quality and durability.
Crockett And Jones Vs Allen Edmonds Buying Guide
Construction & Quality
Crockett & Jones is renowned for its exceptional construction, utilizing Goodyear welting and premium materials. Their shoes often feature hand-finishing and meticulous attention to detail, resulting in superior durability and longevity. Allen Edmonds, while also employing Goodyear welting, can vary slightly in the consistency of its craftsmanship across different models. Crockett & Jones generally uses higher-grade leathers and provides a more refined finish, contributing to a more luxurious feel and enhanced lifespan. This dedication to quality translates to shoes that can withstand the test of time and maintain their aesthetic appeal.
Materials & Leather
Crockett & Jones typically uses the finest calfskin, cordovan, and suede, sourced from reputable tanneries. Their leather selection is often more carefully curated, contributing to a richer texture and a more supple feel. Allen Edmonds offers a wide range of leathers, including calfskin and shell cordovan, but the overall consistency and quality can sometimes be less uniform. The leather quality significantly impacts both the appearance and the comfort of the shoes, with Crockett & Jones often providing a more luxurious experience from the outset, requiring less break-in time.
Style & Design
Crockett & Jones shoes are often associated with a classic, refined British aesthetic, characterized by elegant lines and understated elegance. Their designs lean towards traditional styles, emphasizing timeless appeal and versatility. Allen Edmonds offers a broader range of styles, including more contemporary and casual designs. While both brands cater to a sophisticated clientele, Allen Edmonds provides more options for those seeking bolder designs or a wider variety of styles to fit different occasions. The choice depends on personal preferences.
Fit & Comfort
Crockett & Jones shoes are known for their meticulous fit, offering a range of lasts and sizes to accommodate different foot shapes. Their shoes often require a slightly longer break-in period but reward the wearer with a custom-like feel. Allen Edmonds also provides a variety of lasts, but sizing can be less consistent. The comfort level is highly dependent on the individual foot shape and the chosen last. It’s crucial to try on different sizes and lasts from both brands to find the optimal fit for long-lasting comfort.
Price & Value
Crockett & Jones shoes generally command a higher price point, reflecting the superior materials, construction, and hand-finishing. While expensive, the investment is often justified by the durability and longevity of their shoes. Allen Edmonds offers a more accessible price point, making them a more budget-friendly option for those seeking quality footwear. While the initial cost may be lower, the overall value is determined by the lifespan and the cost per wear. Comparing the cost over time is important.
Brand Reputation & Heritage
Crockett & Jones has a long and esteemed history, established in 1879, and is synonymous with British shoemaking excellence. Their reputation is built on generations of craftsmanship and a commitment to quality. Allen Edmonds, founded in 1922, has a strong reputation in the American market. Both brands have a loyal following. The choice depends on preference for British vs American heritage and design sensibilities. Both brands have a strong legacy.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Crockett & Jones If…
- You prioritize a higher level of exclusivity and heritage.
- You value subtle branding and understated elegance.
- You prefer shoes made in England, with a focus on traditional craftsmanship.
- You are willing to invest in a premium product with a higher price point.
Buy Allen Edmonds If…
- You are looking for a wider variety of styles and designs.
- You appreciate shoes made in the USA.
- You prefer a brand with a more accessible price point.
- You want a brand with a strong reputation and readily available customer service.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Goodyear welting?
Goodyear welting is a construction method that involves stitching the upper, insole, and welt together, creating a durable and water-resistant bond. This construction allows for easy resoling, extending the lifespan of the shoes. Both Crockett & Jones and Allen Edmonds often employ Goodyear welting in their higher-end models, ensuring lasting quality and value. This is a sign of quality.
How do I care for my leather shoes?
Regular care is essential to maintain leather shoes. This includes cleaning with a damp cloth, applying shoe cream or polish, and using shoe trees to retain the shape and absorb moisture. Protecting them from excessive moisture and sunlight will also preserve their quality. Properly caring for your shoes will significantly extend their lifespan and maintain their appearance over time. This is a must.
Which brand offers a better selection of styles?
Allen Edmonds generally offers a broader selection of styles, including a wider range of designs, colors, and casual options. Crockett & Jones tends to focus on classic and traditional styles, with a more limited but equally refined selection. The choice depends entirely on your personal style preference and the specific occasions for which you need shoes. Consider your needs.
Are Crockett & Jones shoes worth the higher price?
Crockett & Jones shoes are a significant investment, but the superior materials, construction, and hand-finishing often justify the higher price. They tend to last longer and maintain their appearance better than Allen Edmonds shoes. The value lies in their durability and the luxurious experience they provide. It depends on your budget.
How do the fit and sizing compare?
Both brands offer a variety of lasts, but sizing can vary. It’s highly recommended to try on shoes from both brands before purchasing, as fit can vary depending on the last. Crockett & Jones is known for their meticulous fit, while Allen Edmonds can be less consistent. Consult the brand’s sizing guide.
Which brand is better for casual wear?
Allen Edmonds has a wider selection of casual shoe styles, including sneakers, loafers, and boat shoes. Crockett & Jones primarily focuses on dress shoes. If you’re looking for casual options, Allen Edmonds generally offers a better selection. Both brands can be worn casually, depending on the style.
Where are these shoes made?
Crockett & Jones shoes are made in Northampton, England, renowned for its shoemaking heritage. Allen Edmonds shoes are primarily made in the United States. The location of manufacture often influences the construction methods, materials, and overall aesthetic of the shoes. These are important for customers.
Final Verdict
Both Crockett & Jones and Allen Edmonds offer high-quality footwear, each with its own strengths. Crockett & Jones excels in craftsmanship, materials, and a timeless aesthetic, making it an excellent investment for those prioritizing longevity and refined style. Allen Edmonds provides a broader range of styles and a more accessible price point. The ultimate choice depends on individual preferences and budget.
Winner: Crockett & Jones