Choosing the right budget carrier can be a game-changer for your monthly expenses. When comparing prepaid options, two names often rise to the top: Cricket Wireless and Straight Talk. Both offer attractive plans designed to save you money, but which one truly delivers the best value?
In 2017, the landscape of no-contract mobile plans was particularly competitive. We’re diving deep into a head-to-head comparison of Cricket vs Straight Talk 2017 to help you make an informed decision. Get ready to explore their network coverage, plan details, customer service, and overall cost-effectiveness.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | cricket | straight talk 2017 |
|---|---|---|
| Network Type | 4G LTE | 4G LTE |
| Data Speeds | Up to 15 Mbps (on 5G Nationwide) | Up to 8 Mbps on 4G LTE |
| Data Deprioritization | Yes, after 100GB | Yes, after 25GB |
| Hotspot | Yes, limited | No |
| International Roaming | Limited | Limited |
| Unlimited Data | Yes | Yes |
| Unlimited Talk & Text | Yes | Yes |
| VoLTE Support | Yes | Yes |
| Wi-Fi Calling | Yes | Yes |
| 5G Access | Yes | No |
| Coverage | AT&T Network | Verizon Network |
| Plan Options | Multiple tiers | Limited options |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Network Coverage
- Cricket: Cricket Wireless utilizes the AT&T network, offering extensive 4G LTE coverage across the United States. This generally translates to reliable service in most populated areas.
- Straight Talk 2017: Straight Talk Wireless offers a unique model by allowing customers to choose between AT&T, T-Mobile, or Verizon networks, depending on the SIM card purchased. This can provide flexibility and potentially better coverage in specific regions if you choose the right network.
- Winner: Straight Talk 2017
Data Speeds
- Cricket: Cricket Wireless generally offers good 4G LTE speeds, sufficient for most daily tasks like browsing, social media, and streaming. However, speeds can be deprioritized during network congestion.
- Straight Talk 2017: Data speeds with Straight Talk can vary significantly depending on the underlying network you select. While some networks offer high-speed 4G LTE, others might be slower, and deprioritization is also a possibility.
- Winner: Cricket
Plan Pricing
- Cricket: Cricket Wireless typically offers competitive pricing, especially for multi-line plans, making it an attractive option for families. Their plans are generally straightforward with no hidden fees.
- Straight Talk 2017: Straight Talk is known for its budget-friendly plans, often providing unlimited talk and text with a substantial data allotment for a lower monthly cost. Their pricing structure is generally very appealing for cost-conscious users.
- Winner: Straight Talk 2017
Data Allotment (Unlimited Plans)
- Cricket: Cricket’s “unlimited” plans often come with a high-speed data cap (e.g., 100GB) before speeds are significantly reduced. This is usually more than enough for most users.
- Straight Talk 2017: Straight Talk’s unlimited plans also have a high-speed data threshold before throttling occurs. The specific amount can vary by plan and year, but they generally offer a generous amount of high-speed data for the price.
- Winner: Straight Talk 2017
International Calling/Texting
- Cricket: Cricket Wireless offers add-on packages for international calling and texting to select countries. These are typically separate purchases and can increase the monthly bill.
- Straight Talk 2017: Straight Talk often includes some international calling and texting features within certain plans or offers affordable add-ons. This can be a significant advantage for users who frequently communicate with people abroad.
- Winner: Straight Talk 2017
Hotspot Capability
- Cricket: Cricket Wireless plans generally include mobile hotspot functionality, allowing you to share your data connection with other devices. The amount of data usable for hotspot can vary by plan.
- Straight Talk 2017: Hotspot usage on Straight Talk plans can be inconsistent and may depend on the chosen network. Some plans might offer it, while others might restrict it or have separate charges.
- Winner: Cricket
Customer Service
- Cricket: Cricket Wireless offers customer support through phone, online chat, and in-store locations. While generally helpful, experiences can be mixed, as with most carriers.
- Straight Talk 2017: Straight Talk’s customer service is primarily online and via phone, with no physical retail stores. This can sometimes lead to longer wait times or less personalized support compared to carriers with brick-and-mortar presence.
- Winner: Cricket
Device Selection
- Cricket: Cricket Wireless offers a decent selection of budget-friendly to mid-range smartphones, often with deals and promotions. They also allow you to bring your own unlocked device.
- Straight Talk 2017: Straight Talk also provides a range of phones, from basic to more advanced models, and importantly, they are very compatible with bringing your own unlocked device, often across multiple network options.
- Winner: Straight Talk 2017
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| 5G Access | cricket |
| Mobile Hotspot | cricket |
| Network Coverage (Verizon) | straight talk 2017 |
| Network Coverage (AT&T) | cricket |
| Data Deprioritization Threshold | cricket |
| Plan Variety | cricket |
| Overall Value (for basic needs) | straight talk 2017 |
What They Have in Common
- Unlimited Talk & Text: Both cricket and Straight Talk 2017 offer unlimited talk and text messaging to all domestic numbers within the United States, ensuring you can communicate freely without worrying about overage charges.
- 4g Lte Network: Both carriers utilize the 4G LTE network for their data services, providing reliable and generally fast internet speeds for browsing, streaming, and app usage.
- Volte Support: Voice over LTE (VoLTE) is supported by both, which means your voice calls will be routed over the 4G LTE data network, potentially offering clearer call quality and faster call setup times.
- Wi-Fi Calling: Both services enable Wi-Fi calling, a crucial feature for areas with weak or no cellular signal, allowing you to make and receive calls and texts over a Wi-Fi connection.
- Data Deprioritization: While the thresholds differ, both carriers reserve the right to slow down or deprioritize your data speeds during times of network congestion once you exceed a certain data usage limit.
- Customer Service: Both cricket and Straight Talk 2017 aim to provide customer support, though the availability and quality of this support can vary.
Cricket Vs Straight Talk 2017 Buying Guide
Network Coverage and Reliability
When choosing between Cricket and Straight Talk, network coverage is paramount. Both providers utilize the AT&T network, which generally offers strong nationwide coverage. However, it’s crucial to check specific coverage maps for your typical locations, as minor differences can exist in rural or less populated areas. Consider where you spend most of your time – at home, work, or commuting – and research the signal strength of AT&T in those specific spots to ensure consistent service for both Cricket and Straight Talk.
Plan Features and Data Allowances
Both Cricket and Straight Talk offer a variety of plans with different data allowances and features. Cricket typically provides unlimited talk and text on all its plans, with data varying from 2GB to unlimited. Straight Talk also offers a range of plans, often with unlimited talk and text and tiered data options. Carefully compare the data caps, whether data slows down after reaching a certain limit, and if hotspot usage is permitted on plans that interest you. Prioritize a plan that aligns with your monthly data consumption habits to avoid overages or insufficient data. (See Also: Demeyere 5 Plus Vs Atlantis )
Pricing and Hidden Fees
Price is a significant factor, and both Cricket and Straight Talk aim to be budget-friendly. Cricket often promotes discounts for auto-pay and multi-line plans, which can further reduce monthly costs. Straight Talk also has competitive pricing, but it’s essential to look beyond the advertised monthly fee. Investigate potential activation fees, SIM card costs, and any other miscellaneous charges that might not be immediately apparent. Comparing the total cost over several months, including all associated fees, will give you a clearer picture of which provider offers better long-term value.
Customer Service and Support
While both companies strive for good customer service, experiences can vary. Consider the accessibility and responsiveness of their support channels. Do they offer phone support, online chat, or physical retail stores? Reading customer reviews and testimonials can provide insights into common issues and how effectively each provider resolves them. If you anticipate needing frequent assistance or prefer in-person support, this aspect could be a deciding factor between Cricket and Straight Talk.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy cricket If…
- You want access to 5G speeds and are within cricket’s 5G coverage areas.
- You need a mobile hotspot for occasional internet access on other devices.
- You prefer plans that offer more flexibility with multiple data tiers.
- You are looking for a carrier that uses the AT&T network.
Buy straight talk 2017 If…
- You primarily need reliable service on the Verizon network.
- You don’t require a mobile hotspot and are not interested in 5G access.
- You are comfortable with a more straightforward plan structure with a lower data deprioritization threshold.
- You are looking for a budget-friendly option with unlimited talk and text.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which carrier has better international calling options?
Both Cricket and Straight Talk offer international calling add-ons, but the specifics and costs can differ. Cricket’s international plans often include calling and texting to select countries. Straight Talk also provides international services, which might be bundled or available as separate packages. It’s best to check the latest international rates and included countries directly from each provider’s website to determine which offers the most cost-effective and comprehensive solution for your specific international communication needs. (See Also: Nikon 50 1 8 Vs 1 4 )
Are there any data throttling differences between Cricket and Straight Talk?
While both providers utilize the AT&T network, there can be subtle differences in how they manage data usage. Cricket, on its unlimited plans, may de-prioritize data traffic during times of network congestion or limit video streaming quality to a certain resolution. Straight Talk’s plans might have similar provisions, though the exact thresholds and policies can vary. It’s always advisable to review the Terms of Service for each provider to understand their specific data management practices and potential throttling scenarios.
Can I bring my own phone to Cricket or Straight Talk?
Yes, both Cricket and Straight Talk are MVNOs (Mobile Virtual Network Operators) that allow you to bring your own compatible device. Generally, phones that are unlocked and compatible with AT&T’s network will work on both providers. You’ll need to check their respective compatibility checkers on their websites to ensure your specific phone model is supported and to obtain a SIM card. This can be a significant cost-saving measure.
What are the differences in their unlimited data plans?
While both offer “unlimited” data, the actual experience can vary. Cricket’s unlimited plans typically include a high-speed data allowance before potentially slowing down speeds. Straight Talk’s unlimited plans also operate similarly, with a set amount of high-speed data available. The key differences lie in the specific data caps for high-speed usage, video streaming resolutions, and potential deprioritization policies during peak network times. Always check the fine print for these details. (See Also: Samsung Pro Vs Evo 850 )
Which provider is better for families or multi-line discounts?
Both Cricket and Straight Talk offer discounts for adding multiple lines, making them attractive options for families. Cricket is often recognized for its straightforward multi-line discounts, where the cost per line decreases significantly as you add more lines. Straight Talk also provides family plans or multi-line savings. It’s recommended to compare the total monthly cost for the desired number of lines and data needs across both providers to determine which offers the most compelling family plan deal.
Final Verdict
Both Cricket and Straight Talk offer compelling value on the AT&T network, making them excellent choices for budget-conscious consumers. Cricket often shines with its user-friendly multi-line discounts and a generally consistent experience. Straight Talk, while also strong, can sometimes offer slightly more flexible plan options and competitive pricing, especially for single lines. The ultimate decision often hinges on specific coverage needs in your area and the precise features of their current plans.
Winner: Cricket