Brooks vs New Balance Running Shoes: Which Brand Reigns?
Ready to lace up and find your perfect running partner? Choosing between running shoes can feel like navigating a maze, especially with giants like Brooks and New Balance vying for your attention. Both brands have a long and storied history of crafting high-quality footwear, but which one is the ultimate champion for your feet?
This in-depth comparison of Brooks vs New Balance running shoes will break down everything you need to know. We’ll explore key features, performance characteristics, and ideal uses to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re a seasoned marathoner or just starting your running journey, understanding the differences is crucial.
We will delve into factors like cushioning, support, fit, and durability. Get ready to discover which brand aligns best with your individual running style and needs. By the end, you’ll be equipped to confidently select the pair that propels you towards your fitness goals.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Brooks | New Balance |
|---|---|---|
| Cushioning | DNA LOFT, DNA FLASH | Fresh Foam X, FuelCell |
| Stability | GuideRails technology | Various stability features |
| Best Use | Road Running, Training | Road Running, Training |
| Heel Drop | Varies by model | Varies by model |
| Upper Material | Engineered Mesh | Engineered Mesh, Knit |
| Midsole Material | Various foam blends | Various foam blends |
| Outsole Material | Rubber | Rubber |
| Weight | Varies by model | Varies by model |
| Arch Support | Neutral, Support | Neutral, Support |
| Durability | Generally good | Generally good |
| Breathability | Good | Good |
| Popular Models | Ghost, Glycerin, Adrenaline GTS | Fresh Foam X 880, FuelCell Rebel, 1080 |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Cushioning
- Brooks: Brooks often utilizes their DNA LOFT cushioning technology, known for its soft and responsive feel. This provides excellent shock absorption and comfort, making them suitable for long-distance runs. However, some models might feel less firm for runners who prefer a more ground-feel experience.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance employs Fresh Foam and FuelCell technologies, offering a range of cushioning options from plush to firm. FuelCell provides a highly energetic and responsive ride, while Fresh Foam offers a balanced blend of cushioning and support. The variety allows for different preferences, but finding the right one can require some research.
- Winner: Tie
Stability
- Brooks: Brooks offers a range of stability shoes, often incorporating GuideRails technology. This system helps to align the foot and reduce excessive pronation, providing support for overpronators. However, some stability features might add weight and feel less flexible for neutral runners.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance provides stability options through features like medial posts and structured uppers. These features help control pronation and offer a secure feel. Similar to Brooks, added stability can sometimes compromise flexibility and natural foot movement.
- Winner: Tie
Fit and Sizing
- Brooks: Brooks shoes are known for their consistent fit and true-to-size sizing. They offer various widths to accommodate different foot shapes. Some runners find the toe boxes spacious and comfortable.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance is praised for its wide range of widths and sizes, catering to diverse foot shapes. They often have a more generous fit, which can be beneficial for those with wider feet. However, the variety can sometimes lead to inconsistent sizing across different models.
- Winner: New Balance
Durability
- Brooks: Brooks shoes are typically durable, with uppers and outsoles designed to withstand regular use. The quality of materials often translates to a longer lifespan, making them a good investment for frequent runners.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance shoes also offer good durability, with robust outsoles and well-constructed uppers. The lifespan can vary depending on the specific model and running conditions.
- Winner: Tie
Responsiveness
- Brooks: Brooks utilizes technologies like DNA Flash and DNA AMP in some models to enhance responsiveness and energy return. This can provide a more energetic and efficient running experience. The responsiveness level can vary across different models.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance’s FuelCell technology is particularly known for its high responsiveness, offering a propulsive feel that can enhance speed and performance. Different FuelCell formulations offer varying levels of responsiveness.
- Winner: New Balance
Weight
- Brooks: Brooks shoes vary in weight depending on the model and the features incorporated. Some models are designed with lightweight materials, while others may be heavier due to added support or cushioning.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance offers a wide range of weights, from lightweight racing flats to more substantial trainers. They have models designed to be very light, but the weight can increase with added features.
- Winner: Tie
Breathability
- Brooks: Brooks often incorporates breathable mesh uppers in their shoes to promote airflow and prevent overheating. The breathability levels can vary across different models.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance uses breathable mesh uppers in many of their models, providing good ventilation and keeping the feet cool. The breathability can be optimized for different running conditions.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Brooks: Brooks shoes typically fall within a mid-range to premium price point, depending on the model and features. The price reflects the quality of materials and technology used.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance shoes offer a wide price range, from more affordable options to premium models. There are choices available for different budgets.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Stability | Brooks |
| Cushioning | Tie |
| Variety of Models | New Balance |
| Overall Comfort | Tie |
| Innovative Technology | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Versatile Use: Both brands offer running shoes suitable for various types of runs, from daily training to long distances.
- Comfortable Uppers: Both Brooks and New Balance utilize engineered mesh uppers designed to provide a comfortable and breathable fit.
- Durable Outsoles: Both brands’ shoes typically feature durable rubber outsoles, offering good traction and longevity.
- Wide Range of Models: Both brands offer a wide range of models to cater to different foot types, running styles, and preferences.
- Midsole Technology: Both brands invest heavily in midsole technologies to provide cushioning and responsiveness.
Brooks Vs New Balance Running Shoes Buying Guide
Cushioning and Support
Both Brooks and New Balance offer excellent cushioning and support, but they cater to slightly different preferences. Brooks often focuses on a plush, cushioned feel, ideal for runners seeking maximum comfort on long distances. Their DNA LOFT and BioMoGo DNA foams are renowned for shock absorption. New Balance, on the other hand, provides a range of cushioning options, from firmer, more responsive foams for speed work to softer options for everyday training. The Fresh Foam series is a popular choice, known for its balance of cushioning and energy return. Consider your running style and the type of cushioning you prefer when making your choice.
Fit and Sizing
Fit is crucial for running shoes, and both brands offer various widths and sizes. Brooks tends to have a more consistent fit across their models, making it easier to find a shoe that fits well. They often have a generous toe box, accommodating runners with wider feet. New Balance is celebrated for its extensive range of widths, including narrow, standard, wide, and extra-wide. This allows runners with unique foot shapes to find a comfortable and supportive fit. Always try on shoes in person, or consult the brand’s size charts and reviews, to ensure the best fit for your feet.
Durability and Materials
The durability of running shoes depends on the materials and construction used. Brooks shoes are generally known for their robust construction, using high-quality materials that withstand regular use. The outsoles often feature durable rubber compounds designed to handle various running surfaces. New Balance also uses durable materials, but the specific lifespan can vary depending on the model and intended use. Both brands typically offer shoes that can handle hundreds of miles of running. Regular care, such as cleaning and proper storage, can extend the lifespan of your running shoes.
Pronation and Stability
Understanding your pronation, or how your foot rolls inward, is vital for choosing the right running shoe. Brooks offers a range of stability shoes designed to provide support for overpronators. Their GuideRails technology is a notable feature, helping to guide the foot and reduce excessive motion. New Balance also provides stability shoes with features like medial posts and firmer midsoles to control pronation. They offer a spectrum of support levels to suit different needs. If you’re unsure about your pronation, consider getting a gait analysis at a specialty running store.
Performance and Purpose
Consider the intended purpose of your running shoes. Brooks is often favored for its comfort-focused designs, making it a good choice for everyday training and long runs. They also have performance models for racing and speed work. New Balance offers a broader range of performance shoes, catering to various running styles and distances. They have lightweight racing flats, responsive tempo trainers, and versatile options for different types of workouts. Think about the types of runs you’ll be doing and choose a shoe that aligns with your goals.
Price and Value
Both Brooks and New Balance shoes are available at various price points. Brooks shoes are often positioned in the mid to high price range, reflecting their quality materials and advanced technologies. New Balance provides options at different price points, allowing runners to find a shoe that fits their budget. Consider the features and technologies offered, as well as the expected lifespan of the shoe, when evaluating value. Look for sales and discounts, especially during seasonal promotions, to get the best deal on your preferred running shoes.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Brooks If…
- You prioritize stability features, especially if you overpronate.
- You prefer a consistent fit and feel across different models.
- You are looking for a shoe with GuideRails technology.
- You enjoy a more traditional running shoe feel.
Buy New Balance Running Shoes If…
- You are looking for a wider variety of styles and designs.
- You prefer a shoe with a more modern aesthetic.
- You want to explore different midsole technologies like FuelCell.
- You’re looking for shoes with a variety of widths.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which brand is better for beginners?
Both brands are great for beginners. However, Brooks might be slightly more appealing due to the often softer cushioning and more forgiving fit, making them feel comfortable right away. New Balance offers a wider variety of models, meaning beginners can find a shoe that caters to their foot shape and pronation needs. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences and foot type. Try both to see which feels better.
Which brand is better for long-distance running?
Brooks is often preferred for long-distance running due to the focus on cushioning and comfort. Models like the Glycerin and Ghost are popular choices for their plush feel and long-lasting support. However, New Balance also has excellent options for long runs, such as the Fresh Foam More, which provides ample cushioning. It really comes down to individual preference and the feel you are looking for.
Which brand offers better stability shoes?
Both brands offer excellent stability shoes. Brooks’ GuideRails technology is highly regarded for guiding the foot and reducing excessive motion. New Balance also provides a range of stability shoes with features like medial posts and firmer midsoles. The best choice depends on the level of stability needed and individual preferences. Getting a gait analysis can help determine which brand’s stability features best suit your needs.
Are Brooks shoes generally more durable than New Balance?
Both brands use durable materials, but the lifespan can vary depending on the specific model and running conditions. Brooks is generally known for its robust construction, potentially leading to slightly longer lifespans for certain models. However, New Balance also offers durable options. Proper care, like cleaning and rotating shoes, can extend the lifespan of both brands.
Which brand has a wider variety of models?
New Balance typically offers a wider variety of models compared to Brooks. They provide options catering to various running styles, foot shapes, and preferences, including numerous widths. This broad selection allows runners to find a shoe that perfectly matches their needs. Brooks, while offering excellent quality, focuses on fewer core models with consistent features.
Do both brands offer wide sizes?
Yes, both Brooks and New Balance offer shoes in wide sizes. New Balance is particularly known for its extensive range of widths, including narrow, standard, wide, and extra-wide. Brooks also provides wide options in many of their models, accommodating runners with wider feet. Always check the specific model’s availability for different widths.
Which brand is better for trail running?
Both brands offer trail running shoes. Brooks’ Cascadia is a popular choice, known for its durable construction and rugged outsole. New Balance also has excellent trail options, like the Fresh Foam Hierro, with features designed for off-road terrain. The best choice depends on the trail conditions and personal preference. Consider the grip, protection, and cushioning needed for your typical trail runs.
Final Verdict
Both Brooks and New Balance excel in the running shoe market, offering quality, comfort, and performance. Brooks often focuses on a plush, cushioned feel, while New Balance provides a wider variety of models and widths. The ideal choice depends on individual needs, running style, and foot shape. Consider your priorities, try on different models, and choose the shoe that best fits your requirements.
Winner: [This can vary based on individual needs, but for this example, let’s say Brooks]