Brooks vs New Balance: Which Running Shoe Reigns Supreme?
Choosing the right running shoe can feel like navigating a maze. With so many brands and models vying for your attention, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. Two titans in the running world, Brooks and New Balance, consistently top the charts, but which one is right for you?
This comparison dives deep into the heart of the matter, pitting Brooks against New Balance in a head-to-head battle. We’ll explore their key features, technologies, and what makes each brand unique. Get ready to discover which brand aligns best with your running style and needs.
Whether you’re a seasoned marathoner or a casual jogger, understanding the nuances of Brooks and New Balance is crucial. We’ll examine factors like cushioning, support, durability, and fit. By the end, you’ll have all the information needed to make an informed decision and upgrade your running game.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Brooks | New Balance |
|---|---|---|
| Cushioning | DNA LOFT | Fresh Foam |
| Midsole | BioMoGo DNA | Fresh Foam X |
| Upper Material | Engineered Mesh | Synthetic Mesh |
| Outsole | Rubber | Blown Rubber |
| Heel Drop | Varies | Varies |
| Support | Neutral/Support | Neutral/Support |
| Weight (oz) | Varies | Varies |
| Best Use | Running | Running/Walking |
| Durability | High | High |
| Flexibility | Good | Good |
| Breathability | Good | Good |
| Arch Support | Varies | Varies |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Cushioning
- Brooks: Brooks often utilizes DNA LOFT cushioning, known for its soft feel and responsiveness. They also incorporate technologies like GuideRails for added support. However, some models might feel less durable compared to other brands.
- New Balance: New Balance employs Fresh Foam, FuelCell, and other proprietary cushioning technologies, offering a range from plush to firm. FuelCell is very responsive. Some models can feel less stable for neutral runners.
- Winner: Brooks
Support & Stability
- Brooks: Brooks provides a variety of stability shoes, often using GuideRails to align your foot and reduce excess motion. Their support can be excellent for overpronators. Some stability models can feel rigid.
- New Balance: New Balance offers stability models with technologies such as medial posts and rollbar for motion control. They cater to a wide range of support needs. Stability features may add weight and stiffness.
- Winner: Brooks
Fit & Sizing
- Brooks: Brooks generally offers a consistent fit, with various widths available. Their shoes tend to run true to size. Some runners find the toe box too narrow.
- New Balance: New Balance is renowned for its wide variety of widths and sizes, offering a more personalized fit. Their sizing can sometimes vary between models.
- Winner: New Balance
Durability
- Brooks: The durability of Brooks shoes varies depending on the specific model and materials used. Some models, especially those with softer cushioning, may show wear and tear more quickly.
- New Balance: New Balance shoes are generally known for their good durability, especially the outsoles. The uppers are robust.
- Winner: New Balance
Breathability
- Brooks: Brooks utilizes engineered mesh uppers in many models, providing good breathability. Ventilation can vary depending on the specific shoe design.
- New Balance: New Balance incorporates breathable materials in their uppers, ensuring good airflow. The breathability can be more pronounced in certain performance models.
- Winner: Brooks
Weight
- Brooks: Brooks offers a range of weights across their models, from lightweight trainers to more supportive options. The overall weight can vary depending on the features included.
- New Balance: New Balance also offers a variety of weights. Some models, especially those with advanced cushioning, can be heavier.
- Winner: Brooks
Price
- Brooks: Brooks shoes are generally priced in the mid-range to high-end of the running shoe market. The price can vary depending on the model and technology.
- New Balance: New Balance shoes are also priced in the mid to high-end range. Pricing is generally competitive.
- Winner: Tie
Aesthetics
- Brooks: Brooks shoes often have a classic and understated design aesthetic. They focus on function with a clean look.
- New Balance: New Balance shoes are known for their more diverse and sometimes bolder designs, with a focus on color and style. The brand has a strong heritage in fashion.
- Winner: New Balance
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Cushioning | Tie |
| Stability | Brooks |
| Versatility | New Balance |
| Style | New Balance |
| Support | Tie |
| Durability | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Durability: Both brands are known for producing running shoes with durable outsoles and quality materials, ensuring a longer lifespan.
- Comfort: Both Brooks and New Balance prioritize comfort, using cushioned midsoles and breathable uppers to enhance the running experience.
- Variety: Both brands offer a wide range of models catering to different foot types, running styles, and preferences.
- Technology: Both incorporate innovative technologies in their midsoles and outsoles to provide cushioning, support, and responsiveness.
- Support: Both brands offer shoes with varying levels of support to accommodate runners with different pronation needs.
- Breathability: Both utilize breathable upper materials to keep the feet cool and dry during runs.
Brooks Vs New Balance Buying Guide
Brooks Buying Guide
Brooks is renowned for its focus on comfort and cushioning, making it a favorite among runners prioritizing a plush feel. Their DNA LOFT cushioning technology provides a soft yet responsive ride, ideal for long-distance runs and everyday training. Brooks shoes often feature a wider toe box, accommodating various foot shapes and preventing blisters. Consider your foot strike – Brooks offers models for neutral, pronated, and supinated runners. Before purchasing, consider the type of running you do, the terrain you frequent, and your personal preference for cushioning and support. Brooks shoes often excel in durability, designed to withstand rigorous use.
New Balance Buying Guide
New Balance boasts a diverse range of running shoes, catering to a wider audience with various technologies and styles. They are celebrated for their good fit and a wide variety of widths, ensuring a comfortable fit for diverse foot types. New Balance offers innovative technologies, like Fresh Foam, for cushioning and energy return. Consider the type of running and the distance – New Balance offers shoes for speed work, trail running, and everyday training. Research the specific models and read reviews to determine which best suits your needs, considering aspects like breathability, stability, and responsiveness. New Balance provides numerous options, from minimalist to maximum cushioning.
Brooks: Key Features
Brooks shoes are generally known for their focus on comfort and a smooth ride. Their DNA LOFT cushioning is a staple, providing a responsive and plush feel that’s great for long runs. Brooks often offers a more generous fit, particularly in the toe box, which can be beneficial for runners who prefer extra space. Stability features, such as GuideRails, are designed to support and guide the foot, suitable for pronation. Brooks’ focus is on a consistent and comfortable experience.
New Balance: Key Features
New Balance shines with its versatility and wide range of models. They offer innovative cushioning technologies, such as Fresh Foam, to enhance the running experience. New Balance excels at providing various widths, ensuring a more personalized fit. They cater to a broad spectrum of runners, from minimalist to maximalist, and offer shoes for various activities. Consider your pronation, running style, and the type of terrain when selecting a New Balance shoe. New Balance’s range covers all kinds of running.
Brooks: Pros and Cons
Brooks’ primary advantage is its exceptional comfort and cushioning, making it great for high-mileage training. GuideRails technology is a boon for stability. However, they can sometimes be more expensive. Also, the focus on comfort might mean that some models lack the responsiveness required for speed work. The overall feel leans towards a softer, more cushioned ride, which may not appeal to all runners. Consider price and intended use.
New Balance: Pros and Cons
New Balance’s strength lies in its variety, catering to many needs. The availability of different widths is a significant plus. They also offer a range of technologies, like Fresh Foam, that enhance performance. The sheer number of models can be overwhelming. Some models might not provide the same degree of plush cushioning as Brooks. Consider the specific features you prioritize, such as responsiveness, stability, and fit. Research the specific model you’re buying.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Brooks If…
- You prefer a consistent cushioning experience.
- You are looking for a shoe with a focus on stability.
- You prioritize a wide variety of models for different foot types.
- You enjoy a softer feel underfoot.
Buy New Balance If…
- You enjoy a versatile shoe that can be used for running and walking.
- You prefer a more responsive feel.
- You want a shoe with a modern design and style options.
- You are looking for a wider toe box.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference in cushioning technology?
Brooks uses DNA LOFT, known for its soft, responsive cushioning, delivering a comfortable ride. New Balance uses Fresh Foam, known for its lightweight feel and energy return. Both aim to absorb impact, but they offer distinct experiences. DNA LOFT often feels plusher, while Fresh Foam may provide a more energetic response. The difference is in the feel during your run.
Which brand is better for wide feet?
New Balance is generally recognized for its wider range of widths, making it easier to find a comfortable fit for wide feet. Brooks also offers some models in wide sizes, but New Balance’s selection is typically more extensive. Always check the specific shoe model’s availability in different widths before purchasing. Finding the right fit is crucial for avoiding blisters and discomfort.
Which brand is better for stability?
Both brands offer stability shoes. Brooks’ GuideRails technology is a key feature in some models, helping to guide the foot and prevent excessive pronation. New Balance also offers shoes with features designed for stability, such as medial posts and firmer midsoles. Consider your pronation and research specific models.
Which brand is better for trail running?
Both brands offer trail running shoes. New Balance’s trail running shoes often feature aggressive outsoles for enhanced grip and protection. Brooks also has a line of trail shoes, known for their durability and cushioning. The best brand depends on your preferred features for trail running.
Which brand is more durable?
Durability varies by model for both brands, but both Brooks and New Balance produce durable running shoes. Brooks is often noted for the longevity of its midsoles, and New Balance uses durable materials in its uppers and outsoles. Read reviews and consider the materials used in the specific model you choose.
Which brand is better for beginners?
Both brands offer excellent options for beginners. Brooks often emphasizes comfort, which can be beneficial for new runners. New Balance’s diverse range and variety of widths can help beginners find a good fit. Choose the brand whose models best meet your comfort and support needs.
Which brand is better for speed work?
Both brands offer shoes designed for speed work. New Balance often provides more options geared towards speed, featuring lighter materials and responsive cushioning. Brooks also has speed-focused shoes. Research and select a model with the features needed for your speed work goals.
Final Verdict
Both Brooks and New Balance offer excellent running shoes, each with unique strengths. Brooks excels in comfort and cushioning, ideal for long distances, while New Balance provides a wider selection and customizable fit. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences, running style, and foot type. Consider your needs and prioritize the features that match your running goals.
Winner: [Brooks]