Brita vs Pur Plus: Which Water Filter Is Right for You?
Tired of questionable tap water? You’re not alone! Many of us are looking for a simple, affordable way to improve our water quality. The market is flooded with options, but two names consistently rise to the top: Brita and PUR Plus. But which one reigns supreme?
This comparison delves deep into the features, benefits, and drawbacks of both Brita and PUR Plus water filters. We’ll explore everything from filter lifespan and ease of use to the overall impact on your water’s taste and clarity. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which filter best suits your needs.
Whether you’re a seasoned water filter user or just starting your research, this guide will provide you with the insights you need to make an informed decision. Get ready to discover the truth behind Brita vs PUR Plus and find the perfect solution for cleaner, better-tasting water in your home.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Brita | PUR Plus |
|---|---|---|
| Filter Type | Activated Carbon | Activated Carbon, Ion Exchange |
| Filter Life (Gallons) | 40-120 | 40-100 |
| Filter Change Indicator | Electronic/Manual | Electronic |
| Lead Reduction | Yes | Yes |
| Chlorine Taste & Odor Reduction | Yes | Yes |
| Sediment Reduction | Yes | Yes |
| Contaminant Reduction | Varies by filter | Varies by filter |
| Filter Material | Activated Carbon and other media | Activated Carbon, Ion Exchange Resin, and other media |
| BPA Free | Yes | Yes |
| Pitcher Capacity (Typical) | Varies | Varies |
| Automatic Shut-Off | No | Some Models |
| Replacement Filter Cost | Varies | Varies |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Filtration Method
- Brita: Brita uses a granular activated carbon filter and an ion exchange resin to reduce chlorine taste and odor, as well as contaminants like copper, mercury, and cadmium. The filters typically last for about 40 gallons, but can vary. A common con is that the filtration can be slower compared to some other methods.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus filters also utilize activated carbon, but often incorporate other filtration media like sediment filters. This allows for removal of more contaminants, including lead, pesticides, and industrial pollutants. The filter life is generally comparable to Brita, around 40 gallons, and a pro is its enhanced contaminant removal.
- Winner: PUR Plus
Filter Life Indicator
- Brita: Brita pitchers and dispensers often have a basic electronic or mechanical filter change indicator to remind users when to replace the filter. This can be helpful, but sometimes inaccurate.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus frequently incorporates more advanced filter life indicators, such as electronic indicators that measure water usage or pressure. This allows for a more accurate assessment of filter life.
- Winner: PUR Plus
Filter Cost
- Brita: Brita filters are generally more affordable on a per-filter basis than PUR Plus filters, especially when purchasing in multi-packs. This can make them a more economical choice in the long run.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus filters are often slightly more expensive than Brita filters. However, this may be offset by the longer filter life and more thorough filtration.
- Winner: Brita
Filter Availability
- Brita: Brita filters are widely available in most retail stores and online, making it easy to find replacements. This widespread availability is a significant advantage.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus filters are also readily available, though the selection may be slightly less expansive than Brita. Availability is still generally good.
- Winner: Brita
Pitcher Design & Capacity
- Brita: Brita offers a wide range of pitcher designs and capacities, from compact models to large dispensers. This allows consumers to select a pitcher that fits their needs and refrigerator space.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus also provides various pitcher designs, but the selection may be slightly less diverse than Brita’s lineup. Consider the available options when making your choice.
- Winner: Brita
Contaminant Reduction
- Brita: Brita filters effectively reduce chlorine, taste, and odor, but their ability to remove other contaminants like lead or pesticides is limited compared to PUR Plus.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus filters, particularly those certified by NSF International, often provide broader contaminant reduction, including lead, pesticides, and certain industrial chemicals.
- Winner: PUR Plus
Water Taste
- Brita: Brita filters generally improve the taste of tap water by removing chlorine and sediment, resulting in a cleaner and fresher taste.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus filters also improve water taste, and their more comprehensive filtration may result in an even cleaner and more refreshing taste, especially in areas with poor water quality.
- Winner: PUR Plus
Ease of Use
- Brita: Brita pitchers are generally easy to fill and use. The filter replacement process is also straightforward.
- Pur Plus: PUR Plus pitchers are also designed for easy use. Filter replacement may be slightly more involved depending on the model, but is generally not difficult.
- Winner: Brita
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Filter Variety | Brita |
| Contaminant Reduction (Overall) | PUR Plus |
| Ease of Use | Tie |
| Filter Life (Gallons) | Brita (depending on filter) |
| Availability | Brita |
What They Have in Common
- Water Filtration: Both Brita and PUR Plus are designed to filter tap water, improving its taste and reducing contaminants.
- Ease of Use: Both brands offer pitchers and faucet-mounted filters that are relatively easy to set up and use.
- Contaminant Reduction: Both Brita and PUR Plus filters are designed to reduce chlorine taste and odor, as well as other common contaminants found in tap water.
- Convenience: Both offer a convenient way to have filtered water readily available at home, eliminating the need to buy bottled water.
- Environmental Benefits: Both help reduce the use of plastic water bottles, contributing to a more sustainable lifestyle.
Brita Vs Pur Plus Buying Guide
Filtration Performance
Both Brita and PUR PLUS water filter pitchers utilize activated carbon filters to remove impurities from tap water. Brita filters are generally effective at reducing chlorine taste and odor, as well as some heavy metals. PUR PLUS, often boasts a slightly more advanced filtration system, sometimes including a filter that can remove a broader range of contaminants, including lead, pesticides, and certain pharmaceuticals. The specific filtration capabilities can vary depending on the filter model used by each brand, so it is important to check the product specifications.
Filter Lifespan & Cost
The lifespan of a water filter is a crucial factor to consider. Brita filters typically need to be replaced every 40 gallons, which translates to about two months for average users. PUR PLUS filters often have a similar lifespan, though some models may last a bit longer. The cost of replacement filters is another key aspect. Both brands offer filters at competitive prices. However, the exact cost can vary depending on the retailer, the filter type, and any promotional offers that may be available at the time of purchase.
Pitcher Design & Capacity
The design and capacity of the water filter pitcher are important for convenience and ease of use. Brita pitchers come in a wide range of sizes and designs, from compact models that fit in the refrigerator door to larger versions suitable for families. PUR PLUS also offers various pitcher designs, often with features like a pour spout for easier filling. Consider the size of your household and the amount of water you consume daily to choose a pitcher with an appropriate capacity and design that fits your needs.
Ease of Use & Maintenance
Ease of use is a significant factor in choosing a water filter pitcher. Both Brita and PUR PLUS pitchers are generally easy to use, with simple filter replacement mechanisms. Brita often features an electronic filter indicator to remind you when to change the filter. PUR PLUS often integrates a similar filter change indicator. Regular cleaning of the pitcher is important to maintain hygiene and prevent the build-up of bacteria. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for cleaning and maintenance.
Water Taste & Quality
The primary goal of a water filter pitcher is to improve the taste and quality of your tap water. Both Brita and PUR PLUS are designed to remove impurities that can affect the taste and odor of water. Brita filters generally improve the taste by removing chlorine and sediment, resulting in cleaner and better-tasting water. PUR PLUS often claims to offer a more noticeable improvement in water taste, thanks to its more advanced filtration capabilities, which can remove a wider range of contaminants.
Environmental Impact
Consider the environmental impact of your water filtration choice. Both Brita and PUR PLUS pitchers help reduce the use of plastic water bottles, contributing to a more sustainable lifestyle. Both brands offer filter recycling programs to minimize waste. However, the filters themselves are generally made of plastic, so it’s important to dispose of them responsibly. Choosing a reusable water bottle and using the filtered water can further reduce your environmental footprint.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Brita If…
- You prefer a wider variety of filter options and pitcher designs.
- You are looking for a filter with a longer lifespan (depending on the model).
- You prioritize brand recognition and widespread availability.
- You prefer manual filter change indicators.
Buy PUR Plus If…
- You want a filter that often removes more contaminants.
- You prefer filters with electronic filter change indicators.
- You are looking for a filter that has better sediment reduction capabilities.
- You value the potential for higher flow rates in some models.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the key differences between Brita and PUR PLUS?
The main differences lie in their filtration capabilities. PUR PLUS often boasts a more advanced filtration system, potentially removing a wider range of contaminants, including lead and pesticides, compared to Brita. However, both brands effectively reduce chlorine taste and odor, improving water quality. Filter lifespans and pitcher designs are generally comparable, but costs can vary. The choice often depends on specific filtration needs.
Do Brita and PUR PLUS remove lead from water?
Brita filters are designed to reduce lead, but the effectiveness can vary depending on the specific filter model. PUR PLUS filters, particularly those with lead-reducing capabilities, often provide more robust lead removal. Always check the filter’s certification and performance claims to ensure it meets your specific needs. The filter’s ability to remove lead is crucial for health and safety.
How often should I replace the filters in Brita and PUR PLUS pitchers?
Both Brita and PUR PLUS filters typically need to be replaced every 40 gallons, which translates to approximately two months for average users. However, this can vary depending on the water quality and the frequency of use. Most pitchers include an indicator to remind you when it’s time to replace the filter. Following the manufacturer’s recommendations ensures optimal filtration performance.
Are Brita and PUR PLUS filters recyclable?
Yes, both Brita and PUR PLUS offer filter recycling programs. You can often mail your used filters back to the manufacturer for recycling. This helps to reduce waste and minimize the environmental impact of using water filter pitchers. Check the manufacturer’s website for specific details on how to participate in their recycling program. It’s a great way to stay green.
Which brand offers better-tasting water?
Both Brita and PUR PLUS improve water taste by removing chlorine and other impurities. However, PUR PLUS, with its potentially more advanced filtration, often boasts slightly better-tasting water. The actual difference in taste is subjective and can depend on the user’s sensitivity and the initial quality of the tap water. Both brands provide a noticeable improvement over unfiltered water.
What are the costs associated with using Brita and PUR PLUS pitchers?
The costs include the initial purchase of the pitcher and the ongoing cost of replacement filters. The price of filters varies depending on the retailer and the specific filter type. Consider the filter lifespan, cost per filter, and the frequency of replacement when evaluating the overall cost. Both brands offer competitive pricing, making them affordable options.
Are there any health benefits to using a water filter pitcher?
Yes, using a water filter pitcher can contribute to your health by reducing exposure to potential contaminants in tap water, such as lead, chlorine, and other impurities. Drinking filtered water may also improve hydration and overall well-being. By removing contaminants, these pitchers contribute to a healthier lifestyle by providing cleaner, better-tasting water for drinking and cooking.
Final Verdict
Both Brita and PUR PLUS offer effective water filtration solutions. While Brita provides reliable filtration and a wide range of pitcher options, PUR PLUS often delivers a slightly more advanced filtration, potentially removing a broader range of contaminants. The choice depends on individual needs and priorities, with both brands providing significant improvements to water taste and quality.
Winner: PUR PLUS