Asics vs New Balance Running Shoes: Which Brand Wins?
Ready to upgrade your running game? Choosing the right running shoes can feel like navigating a maze. With countless options, where do you even begin? This comparison dives headfirst into a classic rivalry: asics vs new balance running shoes.
Both Asics and New Balance are titans in the running shoe industry, each boasting a loyal following and a reputation for quality. But which brand reigns supreme? We’ll break down the key differences, from cushioning and support to fit and style.
Whether you’re a seasoned marathoner or a casual jogger, understanding the nuances of each brand is crucial. We’ll explore the technologies, designs, and overall performance of Asics and New Balance running shoes to help you make an informed decision and find the perfect pair for your feet.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Asics | New Balance |
|---|---|---|
| Cushioning | Gel Technology | Fresh Foam |
| Stability | Typically More Stable | Good Stability Options |
| Pronation Control | Often Features Guidance Systems | Variety of Support Levels |
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | Ranges from 8-13mm | Ranges, varies by model |
| Upper Material | Engineered Mesh | Breathable Mesh |
| Midsole Material | FlyteFoam, FF Blast | Fresh Foam X, FuelCell |
| Outsole | AHAR Rubber | Durable Rubber |
| Weight | Varies by Model | Varies by Model |
| Arch Support | Good for Various Arch Types | Offers Neutral to High Arch Support |
| Toe Box | Generally Standard | Varied, some wider options |
| Best For | Daily Training, Stability | Neutral Runners, Versatility |
| Durability | Generally Durable | Good Durability |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Cushioning
- Asics: ASICS often utilizes GEL technology in their midsoles for shock absorption and cushioning. This provides a responsive feel, suitable for various running styles. However, some models might feel less bouncy compared to other brands.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance employs Fresh Foam and FuelCell technologies, offering a range from soft, plush cushioning to more responsive and energetic rides. The variety allows for better customization based on runner preference. Some models can feel less durable.
- Winner: New Balance
Stability
- Asics: ASICS is known for its stability shoes, featuring technologies like DuoMax and Guidance Line to control pronation and support the foot. This is excellent for overpronators. Some stability features can make the shoe feel less flexible.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance offers stability options with technologies such as medial posts and guide rails. They also cater to neutral runners. The designs are well-engineered, but the stability features might add weight.
- Winner: asics
Fit & Comfort
- Asics: ASICS shoes generally offer a snug fit, particularly in the heel, providing a secure feel. The uppers are often well-padded, enhancing comfort. Some runners find the toe box to be a bit narrow.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance is known for offering various widths (narrow to extra wide), catering to a wider range of foot shapes. This improves comfort and reduces the risk of blisters. The sizing can sometimes vary between models.
- Winner: new balance running shoes
Durability
- Asics: ASICS shoes are generally known for their durability, with robust outsoles and materials that withstand wear and tear. This makes them a good investment for high-mileage runners. Some models can feel stiff initially.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance shoes also offer good durability, but it can vary depending on the specific model and the technologies used. The longevity is generally good. Some lighter models might show wear faster.
- Winner: asics
Responsiveness
- Asics: ASICS uses technologies like FlyteFoam in some models to enhance responsiveness, offering a more energetic feel. This improves the overall running experience. The responsiveness can vary depending on the model.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance utilizes FuelCell in many of their models, offering a highly responsive and energetic ride. This makes the shoes suitable for speed work and racing. The responsiveness might compromise some cushioning for some runners.
- Winner: new balance running shoes
Weight
- Asics: ASICS shoes can vary in weight, with some stability models being heavier due to added support features. The weight is generally average. Lighter models are available for race day.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance offers a wider variety of weights, with some models being exceptionally light. This makes them ideal for speed work and racing. Heavier models are available for added stability.
- Winner: new balance running shoes
Breathability
- Asics: ASICS often incorporates breathable mesh uppers, promoting airflow and keeping the feet cool. The breathability varies based on the specific design. Some models may not be ideal for very hot conditions.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance also uses breathable mesh uppers, providing good ventilation. The breathability is generally good. Some models might prioritize other features over breathability.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Asics: ASICS offers a range of price points, with some models being moderately priced and others being higher-end. This caters to various budgets. The cost can be a factor for some runners.
- New Balance Running Shoes: New Balance also offers a variety of price points, with options for different budgets. The pricing is generally competitive. The higher-end models can be expensive.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Stability | Asics |
| Cushioning | Tie |
| Variety | New Balance |
| Price | Tie |
| Innovation | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Comfort: Both brands prioritize comfort in their running shoes, utilizing advanced cushioning technologies to provide a comfortable experience for runners of all levels.
- Breathability: Both Asics and New Balance shoes incorporate breathable mesh uppers, designed to keep your feet cool and dry during runs, enhancing overall comfort.
- Durability: Both brands are known for producing durable running shoes, utilizing high-quality materials in the outsole and other key areas to withstand the rigors of regular running.
- Variety: Both offer a wide range of models catering to different running styles, foot types, and preferences, ensuring there’s a suitable option for almost every runner.
- Technology: Both brands consistently integrate innovative technologies into their shoes, such as advanced cushioning systems and stability features, to enhance performance.
- Versatility: Many models from both brands are suitable for various activities, including running, walking, and general fitness, providing versatility for everyday use.
Asics Vs New Balance Running Shoes Buying Guide
Cushioning and Support
Both Asics and New Balance offer excellent cushioning and support, but they often cater to different preferences. Asics is known for its Gel cushioning technology, providing a plush and responsive feel, particularly in their high-cushioning models. New Balance, on the other hand, often utilizes Fresh Foam and FuelCell technologies, offering a more balanced approach with a focus on both cushioning and energy return. Consider your running style and foot type. If you need maximum impact absorption, Asics might be ideal. If you prefer a more energetic ride, New Balance could be the better choice. Both brands offer models for neutral, pronated, and supinated runners.
Fit and Sizing
Fit is crucial for running comfort and injury prevention. Asics and New Balance offer a variety of widths, from narrow to extra-wide, to accommodate different foot shapes. Asics tends to run true to size, but it’s always recommended to try shoes on before purchasing, or consult online reviews for specific model sizing advice. New Balance is also generally true to size, but some runners find that they need to size up or down depending on the model. Consider the shape of your foot, and whether you need extra room in the toe box. Always measure your feet before buying new shoes.
Durability and Materials
The durability of running shoes depends on the materials and construction. Asics shoes are generally built with durable outsoles and uppers, designed to withstand regular wear and tear. They often utilize high-abrasion rubber in the outsole for enhanced longevity. New Balance also employs robust materials, but the specific lifespan can vary depending on the model and the type of running you do. Consider the type of terrain you run on, and how frequently you run. Both brands offer a good level of durability, but model-specific reviews can provide insight into the expected lifespan.
Performance and Technology
Both brands incorporate advanced technologies to enhance performance. Asics’ Gel technology provides excellent shock absorption. They also use other technologies like FlyteFoam for lightweight cushioning and Duomax support for pronation control. New Balance offers Fresh Foam for cushioning and FuelCell for energy return, making for a more responsive ride. They utilize technologies like Hypoknit for breathable uppers and T-Beam for midfoot stability. Consider your goals, whether you are running for speed or for long distance, and choose a shoe that suits your needs.
Price and Value
The price of Asics and New Balance running shoes varies depending on the model and features. Both brands offer shoes at different price points, from entry-level options to premium models. Asics and New Balance are typically priced similarly, so the value depends on the features and performance offered by each model. Consider your budget and the features you need. Read reviews to find out if the shoes offer good value for money. Both brands offer a good value proposition for a variety of runners with different needs and financial means.
Popular Models and Comparisons
Both Asics and New Balance have popular models. For example, Asics’ Gel-Kayano is well-known for stability, and the Gel-Nimbus for neutral cushioning. New Balance’s 880 is a popular neutral trainer, and the Fresh Foam X 1080v13 offers a great cushioning experience. Comparing specific models is crucial for choosing the right shoe. Read online reviews and compare the features, support, and cushioning of different models. Consider your running style and needs when making your decision. Consider the terrain you will be running on and the type of training you will be doing.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy asics If…
- You need a shoe with excellent stability features to help control overpronation.
- You prefer a shoe with a focus on impact absorption and cushioning, especially for longer runs.
- You are looking for a shoe with a reliable and consistent fit.
- You prioritize models with structured support features.
Buy new balance running shoes If…
- You prefer a more flexible and lightweight running shoe.
- You’re looking for a wider toe box or a more accommodating fit.
- You want a shoe with a modern design and a focus on versatility.
- You are looking for a shoe that offers a variety of cushioning options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Asics and New Balance shoes?
The main difference lies in the technologies and overall feel. Asics often emphasizes Gel cushioning for impact absorption, while New Balance focuses on a blend of cushioning and energy return with technologies like Fresh Foam and FuelCell. Asics is frequently considered to have a more stable feel, while New Balance shoes can feel lighter and more responsive. Both brands offer a wide range of models to suit different running styles and needs.
Which brand is better for pronation control?
Both brands offer excellent options for pronation control. Asics’ Gel-Kayano is a long-standing favorite for overpronators, providing medial support and stability. New Balance also offers models with medial posts and other stability features, such as the 860. The best brand for pronation control depends on the specific shoe model and the degree of pronation.
Do Asics or New Balance shoes fit wider feet better?
Both brands offer shoes in a variety of widths, including wide and extra-wide. New Balance is often praised for offering a wider range of widths across many of their models. Asics also provides wide sizes, but the selection might be slightly more limited. It is important to try on shoes to ensure a proper fit. Consider the shape of your feet when selecting a shoe.
Are Asics shoes good for beginners?
Yes, Asics shoes are often recommended for beginners. Many Asics models, such as the Gel-Contend series, are designed to provide a comfortable and supportive experience. The Gel cushioning helps absorb impact, making them suitable for new runners. However, it’s essential for beginners to choose a shoe that fits their foot type and running style.
Are New Balance shoes good for long-distance running?
Yes, New Balance shoes are excellent for long-distance running. Models like the Fresh Foam X 1080v13 provide ample cushioning and comfort for extended runs. The FuelCell technology in some models offers energy return to help you conserve energy over longer distances. It is important to consider the shoe’s breathability and stability.
How often should I replace my running shoes?
Generally, you should replace your running shoes every 300-500 miles. This can vary depending on your weight, running style, and the terrain you run on. Monitor the wear and tear on your shoes. If you notice a loss of cushioning, or the outsole is worn, it’s time to replace them. Consider tracking your mileage to ensure you don’t overuse your shoes.
Which brand offers the best value for money?
Both Asics and New Balance offer good value for money. The best value depends on your specific needs and budget. Consider the features, technologies, and durability of each model. Read reviews to see what other runners think of the shoe’s performance and lifespan. The price may be similar, so the best value is the shoe that meets your needs.
Final Verdict
Both Asics and New Balance offer high-quality running shoes, each with unique strengths. Asics excels in cushioning and stability, while New Balance often provides a more responsive and versatile feel. The best choice depends on individual preferences, foot type, and running goals. Consider trying on several models from both brands to find the perfect fit and feel.
Winner: [This is a tie]