Apple Watch 3 vs 5: Which Apple Watch Should You Buy?
Struggling to decide between the Apple Watch Series 3 and the Apple Watch Series 5? You’re not alone. Both smartwatches offer a compelling blend of features, fitness tracking, and seamless integration with the Apple ecosystem, but significant differences exist.
This comparison dives deep into the key aspects that matter most, from performance and display quality to health features and overall value. We’ll explore the strengths and weaknesses of each model, helping you determine which Apple Watch best fits your needs and budget.
Whether you’re a first-time smartwatch buyer or looking to upgrade, our detailed analysis of the Apple Watch 3 vs 5 will provide the insights you need to make an informed decision. Get ready to discover which Apple Watch reigns supreme!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Apple Watch 3 | Apple Watch 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Display | Retina Display | Always-On Retina Display |
| Processor | S3 SiP with dual-core processor | S5 SiP with dual-core processor |
| GPS | Yes | Yes |
| Cellular | Optional | Optional |
| Water Resistance | Swimproof | Swimproof |
| Heart Rate Sensor | Optical Heart Sensor | Optical Heart Sensor, Electrical Heart Sensor |
| ECG App | No | Yes |
| Fall Detection | No | Yes |
| Compass | No | Yes |
| Storage | 8GB/16GB | 32GB |
| Speaker and Microphone | Yes | Yes |
| Operating System | watchOS | watchOS |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Display
- Apple Watch 3: Features a smaller display with thicker bezels compared to the Series 5. It uses an OLED Retina display, which is still vibrant, but lacks the always-on functionality of the newer models. This can be a drawback for quickly glancing at the time or notifications.
- 5: Boasts a significantly larger display with thinner bezels and the innovative Always-On Retina display. This allows you to see the time and complications at a glance without raising your wrist. This enhances usability and convenience.
- Winner: 5
Processor
- Apple Watch 3: Equipped with the S3 SiP (System in Package) with a dual-core processor. While it’s relatively responsive, it can feel sluggish compared to newer models, especially when opening apps or switching between tasks.
- 5: Powered by the S5 SiP with a dual-core processor, which is noticeably faster than the S3. This results in smoother performance, quicker app loading times, and a more responsive overall experience.
- Winner: 5
GPS & Cellular
- Apple Watch 3: Available in both GPS and GPS + Cellular models. GPS functionality allows for tracking outdoor workouts, while the cellular version enables phone calls, texts, and streaming without your iPhone nearby.
- 5: Also offers GPS and GPS + Cellular options. The GPS is generally more accurate. Cellular models offer the same benefits as the Series 3, plus international emergency calling.
- Winner: 5
ECG & Fall Detection
- Apple Watch 3: Lacks advanced health features like ECG (electrocardiogram) and fall detection.
- 5: Includes an ECG app for taking an electrocardiogram and fall detection, which can automatically call for help if it detects a hard fall. These are important safety features.
- Winner: 5
Storage
- Apple Watch 3: Offers 8GB or 16GB of internal storage, depending on the model. This is enough for music, apps, and photos, but may fill up quickly if you have a lot of content.
- 5: Comes with 32GB of storage. This provides ample space for music, apps, photos, and watch faces, allowing for more flexibility.
- Winner: 5
Design and Materials
- Apple Watch 3: Features a design similar to the Series 2, with aluminum, stainless steel, or ceramic case options. While still stylish, the design is dated compared to the Series 5.
- 5: Introduces a more refined design with a larger screen and thinner bezels. Offers a wider range of materials, including aluminum, stainless steel, titanium, and ceramic.
- Winner: 5
Battery Life
- Apple Watch 3: Provides up to 18 hours of battery life with typical usage. Battery life can vary depending on usage patterns, such as GPS tracking or cellular use.
- 5: Also offers up to 18 hours of battery life with typical usage, despite the always-on display. This is due to power-saving optimizations.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Apple Watch 3: Generally more affordable, making it a budget-friendly option for those new to the Apple Watch ecosystem.
- 5: More expensive due to the advanced features and improved performance.
- Winner: 3
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Display | Apple Watch 5 |
| Performance | Apple Watch 5 |
| Health Features | Apple Watch 5 |
| Storage | Apple Watch 5 |
| Price | Apple Watch 3 |
| Overall Value | Apple Watch 5 |
What They Have in Common
- Water Resistance: Both Apple Watch models are swimproof, allowing you to track your workouts in the pool or open water.
- Gps: Both watches include built-in GPS for tracking your outdoor activities like running, walking, and cycling without needing your iPhone.
- Heart Rate Monitoring: Both offer heart rate monitoring, enabling you to track your heart rate throughout the day and during workouts.
- Notifications: Both watches receive notifications from your iPhone, keeping you connected to your messages, calls, and app alerts.
- Apple Pay: Both support Apple Pay, allowing you to make contactless payments at participating retailers.
- Fitness Tracking: Both models track your activity, including steps, workouts, and calories burned, helping you stay motivated and reach your fitness goals.
Apple Watch 3 Vs 5 Buying Guide
Performance and Speed
The Apple Watch Series 5 boasts a significantly faster processor (S5 SiP) compared to the Series 3 (S3 SiP). This translates to snappier app loading times, smoother transitions, and a more responsive overall user experience. While the Series 3 is still functional for basic tasks, the Series 5’s enhanced performance makes navigating the watch’s interface and running more demanding apps a much more pleasant experience. The difference is particularly noticeable when using apps that involve animations or require a lot of processing power.
Display Technology
A key differentiator is the always-on Retina display of the Apple Watch Series 5. This feature allows you to glance at the time, complications, and other information without raising your wrist or tapping the screen. The Series 3, on the other hand, requires you to actively wake the display. This constant-on display adds convenience and a more natural feel to the Series 5, making it a more practical choice for everyday use. The Series 5 display also offers brighter visuals.
Health and Fitness Features
Both watches offer comprehensive health and fitness tracking capabilities, including heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and workout modes. However, the Series 5 incorporates some advanced features. The Series 5 includes an ECG app for taking electrocardiograms and fall detection, providing enhanced safety and health monitoring. While the Series 3 provides core fitness functionality, the Series 5 offers added layers of health insights and emergency features that can be crucial for some users.
Design and Build Quality
Both watches share a similar design aesthetic, but there are subtle differences in materials and build quality. The Series 5 offers more premium materials options, such as stainless steel and titanium cases, along with a wider range of band options. The Series 3 typically comes with an aluminum case. While both are durable, the Series 5 feels more refined and offers greater personalization options. The Series 5’s overall design is also slightly sleeker, with thinner bezels around the display.
Battery Life Comparison
The Apple Watch Series 5 generally offers similar battery life to the Series 3, despite its more advanced features, thanks to optimizations. However, the always-on display of the Series 5 does consume some additional power, so you may notice a slight difference in battery drain depending on usage. Both watches can typically last a full day of use with moderate activity. The specific battery life will vary based on your usage patterns, including how frequently you use GPS, cellular, and other features.
Price and Value Proposition
The Apple Watch Series 3 is considerably more affordable than the Series 5, making it an excellent value for those on a budget. However, the Series 5 offers significant upgrades in performance, display, and features, justifying its higher price point for many users. Consider your needs and budget when making your decision. If you prioritize performance, the always-on display, and advanced health features, the Series 5 is the better choice. If you’re looking for an entry-level smartwatch with essential features, the Series 3 remains a viable option.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Apple Watch 3 If…
- You’re on a budget and looking for a more affordable Apple Watch.
- You primarily need basic fitness tracking and notification features.
- You don’t need the advanced health features like ECG or fall detection.
Buy Apple Watch 5 If…
- You want the always-on display for easy time and information viewing.
- You desire the latest health features like ECG and fall detection.
- You want a faster processor and more storage for improved performance.
- You prioritize having the latest Apple Watch technology and features.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the major differences between Apple Watch Series 3 and 5?
The Series 5 offers a faster processor, an always-on Retina display, and additional health features like the ECG app and fall detection. It also has a more premium design, with different case materials and a wider range of bands. The Series 3 is more budget-friendly and still includes essential features, but it lacks the performance and advanced capabilities of the Series 5.
Does the Apple Watch Series 5 have better battery life than the Series 3?
The Series 5 has a similar battery life to the Series 3, despite its more advanced features. However, the always-on display of the Series 5 can slightly impact battery life. Both watches can typically last a full day of use, but the exact duration depends on usage patterns, such as GPS, cellular, and other features.
Is the Apple Watch Series 3 still worth buying in 2024?
Yes, the Apple Watch Series 3 remains a viable option, especially for budget-conscious buyers. It still offers core smartwatch features like fitness tracking, notifications, and access to apps. However, it lacks the performance, display, and advanced health features of the Series 5, so you’ll have to consider if those are important to you.
Does the Apple Watch Series 5 have cellular connectivity?
Both the Apple Watch Series 3 and Series 5 offer cellular connectivity options, allowing you to make calls, send texts, and stream music without your iPhone nearby. This feature is available as an additional option, and requires a cellular plan from your carrier. Not all models have cellular capabilities.
What are the health benefits of the Apple Watch Series 5?
The Apple Watch Series 5 offers several health benefits, including heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and workout modes. The ECG app allows you to take electrocardiograms, while fall detection can automatically call for help if you fall and are unresponsive. These features can contribute to improved health monitoring and safety.
How does the always-on display of the Series 5 work?
The always-on display of the Series 5 allows you to see the time, complications, and other information without raising your wrist or tapping the screen. The display dynamically dims when your wrist is down to conserve battery life. This feature provides a more natural and convenient experience for checking your watch.
Which Apple Watch is better for fitness tracking?
Both watches offer fitness tracking, including heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and workout modes. However, the Series 5 has a faster processor, which can improve the experience of using fitness apps, and includes additional features like more advanced heart rate readings. Both watches are suitable, but the Series 5 gives a slight edge.
Final Verdict
The Apple Watch Series 5 clearly outshines the Series 3 in terms of performance, display technology, and health features. While the Series 3 remains a viable budget option, the Series 5 provides a more refined and comprehensive smartwatch experience. The always-on display and advanced health sensors alone make it a compelling upgrade for many users.
Winner: Apple Watch Series 5