Apple Pencil 1st vs 2nd Gen: Which Should You Buy?
Are you an iPad artist, note-taker, or creative professional trying to decide between the Apple Pencil 1st vs 2nd gen? Choosing the right stylus can significantly impact your workflow and overall experience. Both Apple Pencils offer a premium feel and seamless integration with the iPad, but they have key differences.
The original Apple Pencil, or the first generation, was a groundbreaking accessory. It brought precision and versatility to the iPad, making it a powerful tool for various tasks. The second generation, however, brought some notable improvements and refinements based on user feedback.
This comparison will delve into the features, design, and performance of both the Apple Pencil 1st and 2nd generation. We’ll explore their charging methods, compatibility, and overall value to help you make the best decision for your needs. Get ready to find out which Apple Pencil is right for you!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | apple pencil 1st | 2nd gen |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | iPad (6th to 9th gen), iPad Air (3rd gen), iPad mini (5th gen), iPad Pro (1st & 2nd gen 12.9-inch, all 9.7 & 10.5-inch) | iPad Air (4th & 5th gen), iPad mini (6th gen), iPad Pro (3rd, 4th, 5th, & 6th gen 12.9-inch, all 11-inch) |
| Charging | Lightning Connector | Magnetic Wireless Charging |
| Pairing | Lightning Connector (plug into iPad) | Magnetic Attachment to iPad |
| Double Tap Gesture | No | Yes (Customizable) |
| Pressure Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Tilt Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Length | 6.92 inches | 6.53 inches |
| Diameter | 0.35 inch | 0.35 inch |
| Weight | 0.73 ounce | 0.70 ounce |
| Replaceable Tip | Yes | Yes |
| Color | White | White |
| Storage | Requires separate storage | Attaches magnetically to iPad |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Design & Charging
- Apple Pencil 1st: Features a glossy, cylindrical design with a Lightning connector for charging and pairing. It charges by plugging directly into the iPad (which can look a bit awkward) or via a Lightning adapter. The cap is easily lost.
- 2nd Gen: Boasts a flat-edge design that magnetically attaches to the iPad for charging and pairing. This eliminates the need for a Lightning connector and makes charging seamless and more convenient.
- Winner: 2nd gen
Pairing
- Apple Pencil 1st: Pairs via the Lightning connector, either directly into the iPad or using the included adapter. This process can be a bit clumsy.
- 2nd Gen: Pairs magnetically when attached to the iPad. This is a much simpler and more elegant pairing experience.
- Winner: 2nd gen
Double-Tap Gesture
- Apple Pencil 1st: Lacks the double-tap gesture for quick tool switching.
- 2nd Gen: Includes a customizable double-tap gesture on the side of the pencil, allowing users to switch between tools (like brush and eraser) with a simple tap.
- Winner: 2nd gen
Ergonomics
- Apple Pencil 1st: Round design might be less comfortable for extended use for some users. The glossy finish can make it a little slippery.
- 2nd Gen: Flat-edge design provides a more comfortable grip, preventing the pencil from rolling away.
- Winner: 2nd gen
Compatibility
- Apple Pencil 1st: Compatible with older iPad models that have a Lightning port.
- 2nd Gen: Only compatible with newer iPad models that support magnetic charging and pairing.
- Winner: Depends on iPad model
Pressure Sensitivity & Tilt
- Apple Pencil 1st: Offers excellent pressure sensitivity and tilt for natural drawing and writing.
- 2nd Gen: Maintains the same high level of pressure sensitivity and tilt support as the 1st generation.
- Winner: Tie
Latency
- Apple Pencil 1st: Performance is generally very good, but there can sometimes be a slight lag.
- 2nd Gen: Improved latency, providing a more responsive and fluid writing and drawing experience.
- Winner: 2nd gen
Price
- Apple Pencil 1st: Generally less expensive than the 2nd generation.
- 2nd Gen: More expensive due to the updated design, features, and technology.
- Winner: apple pencil 1st
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Compatibility | Tie (depends on iPad model) |
| Charging | 2nd gen |
| Pairing | 2nd gen |
| Features | 2nd gen |
| Design | 2nd gen |
| Value | 1st gen (for compatible iPads) |
What They Have in Common
- Pressure Sensitivity: Both Apple Pencil generations offer excellent pressure sensitivity, allowing for varied line weights based on how hard you press the tip against the screen. This feature is crucial for artists and note-takers.
- Tilt Sensitivity: Both styluses support tilt sensitivity, enabling users to create shading effects by tilting the pencil, mimicking the effect of a real pencil or brush. This adds another layer of artistic control.
- Palm Rejection: Both Apple Pencils feature palm rejection technology, allowing you to rest your hand on the iPad screen without interfering with your writing or drawing. This enhances comfort and usability.
- Replaceable Tips: Both generations utilize replaceable tips, allowing for continued use even after wear and tear. Replacement tips are readily available for purchase.
- Precision: Both pencils are designed to offer incredible precision, making them ideal for detailed drawing, sketching, and note-taking. The accuracy makes them a great tool for a variety of tasks.
- Wireless Connectivity: Both Apple Pencils connect wirelessly to the iPad, eliminating the need for a physical connection while in use. This provides freedom of movement while using the pencil.
Apple Pencil 1st vs 2nd Gen Buying Guide
Compatibility
The first-generation Apple Pencil is compatible with older iPad models, including the 6th, 7th, 8th, and 9th generation iPads, as well as the iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), and the 10.5-inch and 12.9-inch iPad Pro models. It connects and charges via a Lightning port, which is a key differentiator. The second-generation Apple Pencil works exclusively with newer iPads, such as the iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad mini (6th generation), and the 11-inch and 12.9-inch iPad Pro (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation). This generation magnetically attaches and charges wirelessly.
Charging and Pairing
Charging and pairing methods are dramatically different. The first-generation Apple Pencil charges by plugging it directly into the Lightning port of your iPad, or using a Lightning adapter. Pairing is also done through this connection. The second-generation Apple Pencil charges wirelessly by magnetically attaching to the side of compatible iPads. Pairing is also done through this magnetic attachment. This makes the second-generation pencil more convenient because you don’t need to remove it to charge.
Design and Ergonomics
The first-generation Apple Pencil has a glossy, cylindrical design with a Lightning port cap that’s easily lost. The second-generation Apple Pencil has a matte finish, a flat edge for magnetic attachment, and a more streamlined design. Both are comfortable to hold, but the flat-edged design of the second-generation pencil prevents it from rolling off surfaces. The second-gen’s design feels more premium and is easier to manage, making it a better experience overall.
Features and Functionality
Both Apple Pencils offer similar core functionality: pressure sensitivity, tilt support, and low latency for drawing and writing. However, the second-generation Apple Pencil introduces double-tap gestures, allowing you to quickly switch between tools or activate other functions. This feature enhances workflow and provides a more intuitive user experience. The first generation lacks this feature, limiting its functionality compared to the newer model.
Price and Value
The first-generation Apple Pencil is generally more affordable than the second-generation model. Consider the price difference when making your decision, especially if you’re on a budget. However, also factor in the added features and convenience of the second-generation Pencil, such as wireless charging and double-tap gestures. The value depends on your needs. For basic usage the 1st gen is still good, but for power users the 2nd gen is more beneficial.
Overall Performance
Both Apple Pencils offer excellent performance for drawing, note-taking, and other creative tasks. The choice depends on your iPad model and preferred features. The second-generation Apple Pencil offers a slightly more refined and feature-rich experience, thanks to its wireless charging, magnetic attachment, and double-tap gestures. The first-generation Apple Pencil remains a solid choice if you have a compatible iPad and prioritize cost savings. Consider your usage, iPad model and budget.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy apple pencil 1st If…
- You own an older iPad model compatible only with the 1st generation.
- You are on a tighter budget.
- You don’t need the latest features like magnetic charging or double-tap gestures.
- You prefer a pencil that plugs directly into your iPad for charging and pairing.
Buy 2nd gen If…
- You own a newer iPad model that supports the 2nd generation.
- You value the convenience of magnetic charging and pairing.
- You want the double-tap gesture for quick tool switching.
- You prefer a more streamlined design that attaches magnetically to your iPad.
Frequently Asked Questions
What iPad models are compatible with the 1st generation Apple Pencil?
The 1st generation Apple Pencil is compatible with the 6th, 7th, 8th, and 9th generation iPads, iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), and the 10.5-inch and 12.9-inch iPad Pro models. It connects and charges via the Lightning port, which is an older connection type. Ensure your iPad model is listed above before purchasing to avoid compatibility issues.
What iPad models are compatible with the 2nd generation Apple Pencil?
The 2nd generation Apple Pencil works exclusively with newer iPad models, including the iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad mini (6th generation), and the 11-inch and 12.9-inch iPad Pro (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation) models. These models all have the magnetic charging and pairing capabilities. Check your iPad’s compatibility before buying.
How does the 1st generation Apple Pencil charge?
The 1st generation Apple Pencil charges by plugging it directly into the Lightning port of your compatible iPad, or using the included Lightning adapter. This can be somewhat inconvenient, as the pencil sticks out awkwardly while charging. It’s important to keep the Lightning port clean and free of debris for proper charging.
How does the 2nd generation Apple Pencil charge?
The 2nd generation Apple Pencil charges wirelessly by magnetically attaching to the side of your compatible iPad. This method is much more convenient and eliminates the need for cables or adapters. The magnetic connection also allows for easy storage and transport of the pencil while charging. This is a significant upgrade.
Does the 1st generation Apple Pencil have any special features?
The 1st generation Apple Pencil offers pressure sensitivity and tilt support for drawing and writing. It lacks the double-tap gesture of the newer model, which limits some workflow enhancements. The core functionality is still excellent, but it does not have the convenience of quickly changing tools like the 2nd generation.
Does the 2nd generation Apple Pencil have any special features?
Yes, the 2nd generation Apple Pencil includes double-tap gestures, allowing you to quickly switch between tools or activate other functions. It also features wireless charging and a magnetic attachment for easier storage and pairing. These added features enhance the overall user experience and workflow. This provides an edge over the 1st generation.
Which Apple Pencil is better for drawing?
Both Apple Pencils are excellent for drawing, offering pressure sensitivity and tilt support. However, the 2nd generation Apple Pencil provides a more seamless experience due to its double-tap gestures, wireless charging, and magnetic attachment. The choice ultimately depends on your iPad model and personal preferences, but the 2nd gen offers more features.
Final Verdict
The second-generation Apple Pencil wins out due to its superior design, wireless charging, double-tap gestures, and streamlined magnetic attachment. While the first-generation pencil remains a viable option, the second-generation offers a more modern and convenient experience, especially for users of newer iPad models. The enhanced features of the 2nd generation make it the better choice overall.
Winner: Apple Pencil (2nd Generation)