Apple Pencil 1 vs 2 Comparison: Which One Should You Buy?
Are you an iPad artist, note-taker, or creative professional trying to decide between the Apple Pencil 1 and the Apple Pencil 2? Choosing the right stylus can significantly impact your workflow and overall experience. This comparison breaks down the key differences to help you make the best decision.
The Apple Pencil revolutionized how we interact with iPads, offering precision and responsiveness. The original Apple Pencil, and the newer generation, both aim to enhance your digital creations. However, they have distinct features and functionalities that cater to different needs.
This detailed comparison explores design, features, and compatibility. We’ll delve into charging methods, latency, and overall user experience. You’ll discover which Apple Pencil is best suited for your specific iPad model and creative endeavors. Let’s dive into the Apple Pencil 1 vs 2 comparison!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Apple Pencil 1 | 2 Comparison |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | iPad (6th to 9th generation), iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), iPad Pro 9.7-inch, 10.5-inch, and 12.9-inch (1st and 2nd generation) | iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad mini (6th generation), iPad Pro 11-inch (1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th generation), iPad Pro 12.9-inch (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation) |
| Charging | Lightning Connector | Magnetic Wireless Charging |
| Double Tap | No | Yes, for tool switching |
| Pressure Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Tilt Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Latency | Slightly higher | Lower |
| Attachment | Magnetic (with compatible iPads) | Magnetic |
| Weight | 20.7 grams | 20.7 grams |
| Length | 175.7 mm | 166 mm |
| Tip | Replaceable | Replaceable |
| Bluetooth Pairing | Yes | Yes |
| Colors | White | White |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Design & Build
- Apple Pencil 1: Cylindrical design with a glossy finish. It has a Lightning connector for charging and pairing, which can be awkward. Lacks a flat edge, making it prone to rolling off surfaces.
- 2 Comparison: Features a flat edge for magnetic attachment and wireless charging. It has a matte finish that provides better grip. A more streamlined and modern design.
- Winner: 2
Charging & Pairing
- Apple Pencil 1: Charges via Lightning connector on the iPad, or with a Lightning adapter. Pairing is also done through the Lightning port. This method can be inconvenient and easy to lose.
- 2 Comparison: Charges wirelessly by magnetically attaching to the iPad. Pairing is automatic. A much more convenient and integrated charging and pairing experience.
- Winner: 2
Double-Tap Gesture
- Apple Pencil 1: Does not support the double-tap gesture for quick tool switching. Users must manually select tools from the iPad’s interface.
- 2 Comparison: Includes a double-tap gesture customizable to switch between tools like eraser and pen. This adds a layer of convenience and speed to the user experience.
- Winner: 2
Magnetic Attachment
- Apple Pencil 1: Does not magnetically attach to the iPad. Requires a separate cap and can be easily misplaced.
- 2 Comparison: Magnetically attaches to the side of the iPad for secure storage and charging. This design prevents loss and improves portability.
- Winner: 2
Pressure Sensitivity & Tilt
- Apple Pencil 1: Offers excellent pressure sensitivity and tilt recognition, allowing for varied line weights and shading. Performance is generally very good.
- 2 Comparison: Maintains excellent pressure sensitivity and tilt recognition, providing the same high-quality drawing and writing experience as the first generation.
- Winner: Tie
Latency
- Apple Pencil 1: Known for its low latency, providing a responsive and natural feel when writing or drawing.
- 2 Comparison: Also offers low latency, ensuring a seamless and fluid user experience. Performance is similar to the first generation.
- Winner: Tie
Compatibility
- Apple Pencil 1: Compatible with older iPad models that have a Lightning port. This limits its usability with newer iPads.
- 2 Comparison: Compatible with newer iPad models that support magnetic attachment and wireless charging. Offers broader compatibility with current iPad generations.
- Winner: 2
Price
- Apple Pencil 1: Generally more affordable than the Apple Pencil 2, making it a budget-friendly option for some users.
- 2 Comparison: More expensive than Apple Pencil 1, reflecting its advanced features and design improvements.
- Winner: 1
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Compatibility | Apple Pencil 1 (for older iPads) & 2 Comparison (for newer iPads) |
| Charging Convenience | 2 Comparison |
| Features | 2 Comparison |
| Ease of Use | 2 Comparison |
| Value | Apple Pencil 1 |
What They Have in Common
- Pressure Sensitivity: Both Apple Pencils offer excellent pressure sensitivity, allowing for varied line weights and shading based on how hard you press the tip against the screen.
- Tilt Sensitivity: Both Pencils support tilt sensitivity, which is crucial for creating shading effects, mimicking a real pencil or brush stroke depending on the angle.
- Precision: Both Pencils provide a high degree of precision, making them suitable for detailed drawing, note-taking, and navigating the iPad interface.
- Palm Rejection: Both models feature palm rejection technology, so you can comfortably rest your hand on the screen while using the Pencil without unintended marks.
- Bluetooth Connectivity: Both Apple Pencils connect to the iPad via Bluetooth, enabling features like pairing, and allowing the iPad to recognize the Pencil.
Apple Pencil 1 vs 2 Comparison Buying Guide
Compatibility
Understanding compatibility is crucial. The Apple Pencil (1st generation) works with older iPads, including the iPad (6th, 7th, 8th, 9th generation), iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), and the 12.9-inch iPad Pro (1st and 2nd generation), and 9.7-inch and 10.5-inch iPad Pro models. The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) is exclusively compatible with newer models: iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad mini (6th generation), and the 11-inch iPad Pro (1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th generation) and 12.9-inch iPad Pro (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation). Check your iPad model before purchasing.
Charging and Pairing
Charging and pairing methods differ significantly. The Apple Pencil (1st generation) charges via a Lightning connector, either directly into an iPad or using the included Lightning adapter. Pairing is also done through the Lightning port. The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) charges magnetically by attaching to the side of compatible iPads, eliminating the need for a Lightning port. Pairing is also done magnetically. This magnetic charging is a major convenience upgrade, offering a more streamlined and efficient experience, and it is also wireless.
Design and Features
The design and features vary. The Apple Pencil (1st generation) has a glossy finish and a Lightning port cap. It lacks features like the double-tap gesture. The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) features a matte finish, a flat side for magnetic attachment and wireless charging, and a double-tap gesture for quick tool switching. The double-tap allows you to switch between tools, such as the pencil and the eraser, with a simple tap on the side of the pencil. These features enhance usability.
Pressure and Tilt Sensitivity
Both generations offer excellent pressure and tilt sensitivity, crucial for natural-feeling drawing and writing. Both pencils accurately detect variations in pressure, allowing for thicker or thinner lines based on how hard you press. Tilt sensitivity enables you to shade and create various artistic effects by changing the angle of the pencil on the screen. While the core functionality is similar, the improved responsiveness of the newer pencil provides a slightly more refined experience, particularly for detailed work.
Performance in Use
In practical use, both pencils perform well. The experience is generally smooth and responsive for tasks like note-taking, sketching, and drawing. The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) often boasts slightly lower latency due to the improved internal components, leading to a more immediate and fluid feel. However, the differences are often subtle, and both pencils provide a high-quality user experience. The choice really depends on the iPad model and the features that matter most to you.
Price and Availability
Price and availability are critical considerations. The Apple Pencil (1st generation) is typically more affordable than the second generation, making it a good option if you are on a budget or own a compatible older iPad. The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) is priced higher, reflecting its advanced features and compatibility with newer iPad models. Availability can also vary; check retailers for current pricing and stock. Consider your budget and the features you need when deciding which to buy.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Apple Pencil 1 If…
- You own an older iPad model that is only compatible with the first-generation Apple Pencil.
- You are on a budget and the lower price point of the first-generation Apple Pencil is appealing.
- You primarily use your iPad for basic note-taking and sketching.
- You don’t need the advanced features like double-tap or magnetic charging.
Buy 2 Comparison If…
- You own a newer iPad model that supports the second-generation Apple Pencil.
- You want the convenience of magnetic charging and pairing.
- You want the double-tap feature for quick tool switching.
- You require the lowest possible latency for a more responsive drawing experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which iPad models are compatible with the Apple Pencil (1st generation)?
The Apple Pencil (1st generation) is compatible with the iPad (6th, 7th, 8th, and 9th generation), iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), and the 12.9-inch iPad Pro (1st and 2nd generation), and 9.7-inch and 10.5-inch iPad Pro models. Ensure your iPad model is supported before purchasing. Using the wrong pencil on your iPad will not work and is a waste of money.
Which iPad models are compatible with the Apple Pencil (2nd generation)?
The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) is exclusively compatible with the iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad mini (6th generation), and the 11-inch iPad Pro (1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th generation) and 12.9-inch iPad Pro (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation). It’s crucial to check your iPad model’s compatibility to avoid any issues or disappointment with your purchase.
How do you charge the Apple Pencil (1st generation)?
The Apple Pencil (1st generation) charges using a Lightning connector. You can plug it directly into the Lightning port of your compatible iPad or use the included Lightning adapter to connect it to a Lightning cable and a power adapter. This charging method can sometimes be inconvenient, especially if you forget the adapter.
How do you charge the Apple Pencil (2nd generation)?
The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) charges wirelessly by magnetically attaching to the side of a compatible iPad. This method is much more convenient and provides a seamless charging experience. The magnetic attachment not only charges the pencil but also allows it to pair with your iPad quickly.
Does the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) have a double-tap feature?
Yes, the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) includes a double-tap feature. This allows you to quickly switch between tools, such as the pencil and the eraser, or to access other customizable functions, depending on the app you are using. This feature is not available on the first generation Apple Pencil.
Is the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) more responsive than the 1st generation?
Generally, the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) offers slightly lower latency and improved responsiveness compared to the 1st generation. This means that the delay between your action on the screen and the response of the pencil is reduced, leading to a more natural and fluid writing and drawing experience, particularly useful for detailed work.
Which Apple Pencil is better for taking notes?
Both Apple Pencils are excellent for note-taking. However, the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) offers a more streamlined experience due to its magnetic charging and double-tap feature. The improved responsiveness in the 2nd generation might also provide a slightly better feel, but both are suitable for the task. The choice depends on your iPad model and preferences.
Final Verdict
The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) emerges as the superior choice due to its enhanced features, including wireless charging, magnetic attachment, and double-tap gesture support, all of which contribute to a more seamless and efficient user experience. However, the Apple Pencil (1st generation) remains a viable option for those with older iPads or a tighter budget. Ultimately, the best choice hinges on your iPad model and desired features.
Winner: Apple Pencil (2nd generation)