Choosing the right MIDI controller can be a daunting task, especially when faced with titans like the Akai MPK series and the Novation Impulse. Both are renowned for their robust feature sets and ability to enhance your music production workflow. Whether you’re a seasoned producer or just starting out, the decision between these two popular controllers often comes down to specific needs and preferences.
The Akai MPK line is celebrated for its deep integration with MPC workflows, offering a tactile and intuitive experience for beatmakers. On the other hand, the Novation Impulse is praised for its premium build quality and seamless integration with Ableton Live, appealing to a wide range of electronic music creators. Let’s dive into a detailed comparison to help you make an informed choice.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | akai mpk | novation impulse |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Pads | 16 velocity-sensitive pads | 8 velocity-sensitive pads |
| Pad Modes | Note, MPC, Smart Chord, Arpeggiator | Note, Arpeggiator, Chord, Step Sequencer |
| Number of Knobs | 8 assignable Q-Link knobs | 8 assignable knobs |
| Number of Faders | 8 assignable Q-Link faders | 8 assignable faders |
| Keybed Type | Synth-action, semi-weighted | Semi-weighted, synth-action |
| Number of Keys | 25, 49, or 61 keys | 25, 49, or 61 keys |
| Arpeggiator | Yes, with tap tempo | Yes, with tap tempo |
| Sequencer | Built-in step sequencer | Built-in step sequencer |
| Transport Controls | Yes | Yes |
| Display | LCD screen | LCD screen |
| Connectivity | USB, MIDI In/Out | USB, MIDI In/Out |
| Power | USB bus-powered | USB bus-powered |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Pads
- Akai Mpk: Typically features 16 velocity-sensitive MPC-style pads, known for their responsive and satisfying feel. They offer a good balance of tactile feedback and sensitivity for drumming and triggering samples.
- Novation Impulse: Usually comes with 16 velocity-sensitive, backlit pads that are often described as a bit firmer than Akai’s. While functional, some users find them less “playable” for complex drumming patterns compared to the MPK.
- Winner: Akai MPK
Faders and Knobs
- Akai Mpk: Offers a generous number of assignable faders and knobs, often including dedicated transport controls. The build quality is generally robust, providing a solid feel for parameter control and mixing.
- Novation Impulse: Features a good selection of assignable knobs and a few faders, with a focus on hands-on control for DAW parameters. The rotary encoders offer a smooth feel, but the limited fader count might be a drawback for some.
- Winner: Akai MPK
Keybed
- Akai Mpk: Often includes a synth-action keybed, which is lightweight and responsive for playing melodies and chords. While not weighted, it’s suitable for many electronic music production tasks.
- Novation Impulse: Generally sports a semi-weighted keybed, offering a slightly more substantial feel than a typical synth-action keybed. This can provide a more piano-like playing experience for those who prefer it.
- Winner: Novation Impulse
Arpeggiator and Step Sequencer
- Akai Mpk: Features a powerful and intuitive arpeggiator and often includes a built-in step sequencer for creating rhythmic patterns directly on the pads. These tools are highly regarded for their creative potential.
- Novation Impulse: Includes a versatile arpeggiator with various modes and pattern options. While it may not always have a dedicated step sequencer on the hardware, its integration with DAWs often allows for similar functionality.
- Winner: Akai MPK
Build Quality and Portability
- Akai Mpk: Known for its sturdy, often all-metal or robust plastic construction, making it a durable option for studio use. They can be a bit on the heavier side, impacting portability.
- Novation Impulse: Typically features a more compact and lighter design, making it a more portable option for those who travel or have limited space. The build quality is still good, but generally less “tank-like” than some Akai models.
- Winner: Novation Impulse
Software Integration and Bundles
- Akai Mpk: Comes with bundled software, often including a version of Ableton Live or Akai’s own MPC Beats, providing a comprehensive starting point for music production. Integration with popular DAWs is generally straightforward.
- Novation Impulse: Usually bundled with Ableton Live Lite and a suite of virtual instruments and effects. Its strength lies in its deep integration with Ableton Live, offering seamless control.
- Winner: Tie
Connectivity and Power
- Akai Mpk: Primarily USB-powered, offering simple plug-and-play functionality. Some higher-end models might offer additional power options or MIDI I/O.
- Novation Impulse: Also USB-powered, ensuring ease of use and portability. It generally offers standard MIDI out for connecting to other hardware.
- Winner: Tie
Screen/Display
- Akai Mpk: Varies by model, but many feature a backlit LCD screen that provides clear visual feedback for parameters, modes, and settings. This aids in navigation and control without constantly looking at the computer.
- Novation Impulse: Often features a simpler LED display or no dedicated screen, relying more on button indicators and DAW feedback. This can make navigating complex settings less intuitive compared to models with screens.
- Winner: Akai MPK
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Pad Count & Versatility | Akai MPK |
| Knob & Fader Control | Akai MPK (due to dedicated faders) |
| Workflow Integration (Ableton) | Novation Impulse |
| Arpeggiator & Sequencer Features | Tie |
| Build Quality & Feel | Tie (Subjective) |
| Overall Value (depending on deals) | Tie |
What They Have in Common
- Pad Count and Sensitivity: Both controllers feature velocity-sensitive pads that are crucial for expressive drumming and sample triggering. The Akai MPK generally offers more pads out of the box, but both are designed to capture nuanced performance.
- Assignable Controls: Both the Akai MPK and Novation Impulse provide a generous number of assignable knobs and faders. This allows for deep integration with DAWs and virtual instruments, enabling hands-on control over parameters like volume, panning, and filter cutoff.
- Keybed Feel: Both models typically employ semi-weighted synth-action keybeds. This offers a compromise between the resistance of a piano and the lightness of a synth, making them versatile for playing both melodic lines and chords.
- Built-in Arpeggiator and Sequencer: A significant shared feature is the inclusion of an arpeggiator and a step sequencer. These tools are invaluable for quickly generating rhythmic patterns and melodic ideas, whether for live performance or studio production.
- Transport Controls: Both controllers come equipped with dedicated transport controls (play, stop, record). This streamlines the recording and playback workflow within a Digital Audio Workstation (DAW) without needing to reach for the mouse.
- USB Connectivity and Bus Power: Both units connect to a computer via USB and are typically bus-powered. This simplifies setup, reducing cable clutter and eliminating the need for external power adapters in most scenarios.
Akai MPK vs Novation Impulse Buying Guide
Build Quality and Durability
When considering the Akai MPK and Novation Impulse, the build quality is a crucial factor for longevity and performance. Both offer robust construction, but the MPK series often features a slightly more industrial feel, designed to withstand rigorous studio use or live performances. The Impulse, while also well-built, might lean towards a sleeker, more modern aesthetic. Inspecting the materials used for the faders, knobs, and pad surfaces can provide insight into their respective durability. Consider how the unit will be transported and stored, as this can influence your preference for a more rugged or a more refined build. (See Also: Adobe Pro Vs Docusign )
Keybed Feel and Responsiveness
The keybed is arguably the most important component for any keyboard controller, and both the Akai MPK and Novation Impulse offer distinct playing experiences. The MPK often features semi-weighted keys that strike a balance between synth-action and piano-like feel, catering to a wide range of playing styles. The Impulse, on the other hand, is known for its Fatar keybeds, which are highly regarded for their responsive, semi-weighted action and excellent velocity sensitivity. For pianists or those who prioritize a nuanced performance, the Impulse’s keybed might be the preferred choice. Experimenting with both is highly recommended to find the feel that best suits your playing technique.
Pad Performance and Features
For beatmakers and those who frequently use pads for drumming or triggering samples, the performance and features of the pads are paramount. The Akai MPK is renowned for its MPC-style pads, which are celebrated for their sensitivity, responsiveness, and tactile feel. These pads are often preferred for their ability to capture subtle velocity nuances and for their comfortable playing surface. The Novation Impulse also offers velocity-sensitive pads, but they may have a slightly different feel and response compared to the Akai’s iconic pads. If pad drumming is a primary use case, the MPK’s legacy in this area is a significant consideration.
Software Integration and Workflow
Seamless integration with your Digital Audio Workstation (DAW) and overall workflow can greatly enhance your creative process. Both the Akai MPK and Novation Impulse offer deep integration with popular DAWs, but the specifics can differ. The MPK series often boasts extensive mapping capabilities and can feel very at home within Ableton Live, Logic Pro, and other major software. The Impulse is designed with a focus on intuitive control, with dedicated buttons and encoders that map logically to DAW functions. Consider which DAW you primarily use and research the specific integration features and ease of setup for each controller within that environment.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy akai mpk If…
- You prioritize a larger number of pads for extensive drumming and sample mapping.
- You want the workflow and features inspired by Akai’s MPC series, including MPC mode.
- You need dedicated faders alongside knobs for more comprehensive mixing control.
- You are looking for a versatile controller that excels in beatmaking and performance.
Buy novation impulse If…
- You prefer a more streamlined pad layout and are comfortable with fewer pads.
- You appreciate Novation’s intuitive workflow and often use their included software bundles.
- You are heavily invested in the Ableton Live ecosystem, as Novation controllers often have deep integration.
- You desire a controller with a solid feel and reliable performance for general MIDI control.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which controller is better for beginners?
Both controllers are excellent for beginners, offering intuitive layouts and robust features. The Akai MPK might have a slight edge if you’re interested in learning beatmaking fundamentals due to its MPC-style pads, which are legendary in the hip-hop and electronic music communities. The Novation Impulse’s straightforward design and excellent DAW integration can also make it very accessible. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your primary musical interests and preferred workflow. (See Also: 40 Vs 32 Tv )
Do these controllers work with any DAW?
Yes, both the Akai MPK and Novation Impulse are designed to be highly compatible with most major DAWs, including Ableton Live, Logic Pro X, FL Studio, Cubase, and Pro Tools. They typically utilize standard MIDI communication protocols and often come with pre-mapped templates for popular software. While they work universally, the depth and ease of integration can vary slightly depending on the specific DAW and controller model.
What is the difference in keybed action?
The Akai MPK series generally features semi-weighted keys that offer a balanced feel between synth-action and piano-style keys, providing good velocity response. The Novation Impulse is known for using Fatar TP/9 keybeds, which are highly regarded for their responsive, semi-weighted action and exceptional velocity sensitivity, often favored by those who prioritize a more piano-like playing experience. Both are velocity-sensitive, but the Fatar keybeds on the Impulse are often considered a premium feature.
Are the pads on the Akai MPK better than the Novation Impulse?
The Akai MPK is famous for its MPC-style pads, which are celebrated for their sensitivity, responsiveness, and tactile feel, making them a favorite for beatmakers. The Novation Impulse also features velocity-sensitive pads that perform well, but they may have a slightly different feel. For users who prioritize a classic, highly responsive pad drumming experience, the Akai MPK’s pads are often considered superior due to their legacy and specific design.
Which controller offers better build quality?
Both controllers are generally well-built, designed for regular use. The Akai MPK often has a reputation for a more rugged, industrial build that can feel very durable. The Novation Impulse also boasts solid construction with a sleek, modern aesthetic. The “better” build quality can be subjective, depending on whether you prefer a more robust feel or a more refined finish. Both should hold up well with proper care. (See Also: Lansky Vs Work Sharp )
Final Verdict
The Akai MPK and Novation Impulse are both exceptional MIDI controllers, each excelling in different areas. The MPK shines with its legendary MPC-style pads and robust build, making it a go-to for beatmakers and those who value tactile performance. The Impulse stands out with its premium Fatar keybed and intuitive workflow, appealing to keyboardists and producers seeking seamless DAW integration. Your choice hinges on whether pad performance or keybed feel is your top priority.
Winner: Akai MPK