Pur Water Filter vs Brita: Which Filter Wins?
Tired of questionable tap water? You’re not alone! Many of us are looking for a simple, effective way to ensure clean, great-tasting water at home. The market is saturated with options, but two names consistently rise to the top: the Pur water filter and the Brita water filter.
Choosing between these two popular brands can feel overwhelming. Both promise to remove impurities and improve the taste of your water, but which one truly delivers the best results for your needs? This comparison will break down the key differences to help you make an informed decision.
We’ll explore factors like filtration performance, filter replacement costs, ease of use, and overall value. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which water filter is the perfect fit for your lifestyle and budget, whether it’s a Pur or a Brita.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | PUR | Brita |
|---|---|---|
| Filter Type | Activated Carbon & Sediment | Activated Carbon & Sediment |
| Filter Life | Up to 3 months | Up to 2 months |
| Capacity | Varies by model | Varies by model |
| Lead Removal | Yes | Yes |
| Chlorine Taste & Odor Reduction | Yes | Yes |
| Mercury Removal | Yes | Yes |
| BPA Free | Yes | Yes |
| Filter Change Indicator | Yes (electronic) | Yes (sticker/mechanical) |
| Flow Rate | Moderate | Moderate |
| Ease of Installation | Easy | Easy |
| Materials | Plastic | Plastic |
| Replacement Filter Cost | Moderate | Moderate |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Filtration Method
- Pur Water Filter: PUR filters typically use activated carbon and sometimes include a sediment filter and ion exchange resin. They effectively reduce contaminants like lead, chlorine, and certain pesticides, but may require more frequent filter changes depending on usage.
- Brita: Brita filters usually employ activated carbon and an ion exchange resin. They effectively reduce chlorine taste and odor, as well as copper, mercury, and cadmium. They generally offer a good balance of filtration and ease of use.
- Winner: Tie
Filter Life & Replacement
- Pur Water Filter: PUR filters often have a shorter lifespan, typically requiring replacement every 1-2 months or after filtering around 100 gallons, depending on the model and water quality. Replacement indicators are often included.
- Brita: Brita filters generally last longer, often requiring replacement every 2 months or after filtering around 40-100 gallons, depending on the model. They also have filter replacement indicators.
- Winner: Brita
Contaminant Reduction
- Pur Water Filter: PUR filters are effective at removing lead, chlorine, and some pesticides, along with other contaminants. Some models are certified to remove specific contaminants.
- Brita: Brita filters effectively reduce chlorine taste and odor, copper, mercury, and cadmium. The level of reduction varies depending on the specific filter type.
- Winner: Tie
Cost of Filters
- Pur Water Filter: PUR filter replacements can be moderately priced, with the overall cost depending on the specific filter type and the frequency of replacement.
- Brita: Brita filter replacements are generally affordable, making them a cost-effective option for many users.
- Winner: Brita
Ease of Use
- Pur Water Filter: PUR filters are generally easy to install and use, with various models available, including faucet-mounted and pitcher-style options.
- Brita: Brita filters are known for their user-friendliness, with simple installation and easy filter replacement in pitcher and faucet models.
- Winner: Brita
Water Flow Rate
- Pur Water Filter: PUR faucet filters often provide a decent flow rate, but pitcher models may have slower flow rates.
- Brita: Brita pitcher filters may have a slower flow rate compared to faucet-mounted options.
- Winner: Tie
Filter Availability
- Pur Water Filter: PUR filters are widely available in various retail stores and online platforms, ensuring easy access to replacements.
- Brita: Brita filters are highly accessible and available in a wide range of stores and online retailers.
- Winner: Tie
Model Variety
- Pur Water Filter: PUR offers a variety of water filter options, including faucet-mounted, pitcher-style, and countertop models, providing options for different needs.
- Brita: Brita provides a large selection of water filter pitchers, faucet filters, and water bottles, offering a wide range of choices for consumers.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Lead Removal | Tie |
| Chlorine Reduction | Tie |
| Filter Change Indicator | PUR |
| Availability | Brita |
| Variety of Models | Brita |
| Overall Value | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Filter Type: Both PUR and Brita water filters primarily use activated carbon and sediment filtration to remove impurities from tap water. They both effectively reduce chlorine taste and odor.
- Lead Removal: Both brands are designed to remove lead from water, providing an added layer of safety. This is a crucial feature for many consumers concerned about water quality.
- Ease of Use: Both PUR and Brita filters are generally easy to use and install, making them convenient options for everyday use. They require minimal setup.
- Bpa-Free Materials: Both brands offer BPA-free products, which gives consumers peace of mind regarding safety. This is a common standard in the industry.
- Common Contaminant Removal: Both filters are designed to remove common contaminants found in tap water, such as chlorine, sediment, and certain heavy metals. This improves the overall taste and quality of the water.
Pur Water Filter Vs Brita Buying Guide
Cost and Maintenance
Both PUR and Brita water filters offer affordable options for clean drinking water, but their long-term costs differ. PUR filters, especially pitcher models, can be slightly more expensive upfront. However, PUR filters often have longer lifespans, sometimes filtering up to 100 gallons, compared to Brita’s typical 40-60 gallons. Replacing the filters is a recurring expense, so consider filter costs and replacement frequency when making your decision. Brita filters tend to be readily available in most stores. PUR offers models with electronic indicators for filter replacement, adding convenience.
Filtration Performance
The core function of both PUR and Brita is to remove contaminants from tap water. Both brands effectively reduce chlorine taste and odor, improving the overall drinking experience. PUR filters, particularly those with MAXION filter technology, are often touted for their ability to remove a wider range of contaminants, including lead, mercury, and certain pesticides, as certified by third-party organizations like NSF International. Brita filters generally perform well, but the specific contaminant removal capabilities can vary depending on the filter model. Consider your local water quality and the specific contaminants you’re concerned about.
Filter Replacement and Availability
Filter replacement is a crucial aspect of water filter maintenance. Both PUR and Brita offer filters that are relatively easy to replace. PUR filters often have a longer lifespan, potentially reducing the frequency of replacements, which can be convenient. Brita filters are widely available in various retail stores and online, making them easy to purchase. However, PUR filters are also readily available. Always check the filter’s lifespan and replacement indicators to ensure optimal performance. The availability of replacement filters and the ease of the replacement process are important factors to consider for long-term use.
Design and Convenience
Both brands offer a variety of designs to suit different needs and preferences. Brita primarily focuses on pitcher-style filters, which are easy to use and store in the refrigerator. PUR also offers pitcher filters, as well as faucet-mounted and dispenser-style filters, providing more options for installation and water access. Consider your kitchen space, water usage patterns, and desired water flow rate when choosing a design. Some PUR models feature electronic indicators that alert you when it’s time to replace the filter. Brita models typically use a simpler indicator, like a sticker or a manual counter.
Water Flow Rate
The speed at which water filters is an important factor, especially if you have a household with high water consumption. Faucet-mounted PUR filters generally offer a faster flow rate compared to pitcher filters from either brand. Pitcher filters require gravity to filter the water, so the flow rate can be slower. Consider your daily water needs and how quickly you need filtered water. If you need a large quantity of filtered water quickly, a faucet-mounted PUR filter might be the better choice. Pitcher filters are sufficient for most users, but the wait time may be longer.
Environmental Impact
Both PUR and Brita offer eco-friendly options. Both brands utilize replaceable filters, reducing the reliance on single-use plastic water bottles. Consider the environmental impact of your choice. Some manufacturers, including Brita, offer recycling programs for used filters, which can help minimize waste. PUR also has initiatives to reduce its environmental footprint. Look for filters with recyclable components and research the company’s sustainability efforts. Proper disposal of used filters is also important; check local guidelines for the best way to recycle or dispose of them.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy PUR Water Filter If…
- You prioritize models with electronic filter change indicators for precise filter replacement timing.
- You want a filter that removes a wider variety of contaminants, including some that Brita might not.
- You prefer filters that are NSF certified for specific contaminant reduction.
- You need a filter for your faucet.
Buy Brita If…
- You prefer a more widely available brand with a broader range of models.
- You are looking for a more affordable initial purchase.
- You prefer a filter that is simple and easy to use.
- You are looking for a pitcher for your fridge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which filter removes more contaminants?
PUR filters, particularly those with MAXION filter technology, are often tested and certified to remove a wider range of contaminants, including lead, mercury, and certain pesticides. Brita filters also remove contaminants, but the specific capabilities vary depending on the filter model. Always check the filter’s certifications from organizations like NSF International to verify its performance claims. Consider your local water quality when making your choice.
How often do I need to replace the filter?
Filter replacement frequency varies. PUR filters often last longer, sometimes filtering up to 100 gallons. Brita filters typically need replacing every 40-60 gallons. Both brands offer filter change indicators to remind you. Adhering to the manufacturer’s recommendations is crucial for optimal filtration performance. Consider your water usage to determine how often you’ll need to replace the filter.
Are PUR and Brita filters easy to install?
Installation depends on the filter type. Pitcher filters from both brands are the easiest, requiring no installation. Faucet-mounted PUR filters are also relatively easy to install, typically attaching directly to your faucet. Brita also offers faucet-mounted filters. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for a proper fit. Some models may require tools, but most are designed for easy DIY installation.
What types of filters do PUR and Brita offer?
Both offer pitcher filters. PUR also provides faucet-mounted and dispenser-style filters. Brita primarily focuses on pitcher filters. Consider your water usage and kitchen space to determine the best type for your needs. Faucet-mounted filters offer convenience for immediate access to filtered water. Pitcher filters are ideal for storing filtered water in the refrigerator.
How do I know when to replace the filter?
Both PUR and Brita filters include indicators to signal when it’s time for a replacement. PUR often uses electronic indicators or light-up notifications. Brita typically uses a sticker or a manual counter. Always replace the filter as recommended by the manufacturer to ensure optimal filtration and prevent the growth of bacteria. Pay attention to the water flow rate, as it may slow down when the filter is nearing the end of its life.
Which brand is more cost-effective?
While both brands are affordable, the long-term cost can vary. Consider the cost of replacement filters and their lifespan. PUR filters, despite potentially being more expensive upfront, may have longer lifespans, leading to fewer replacements. Brita filters are readily available and affordable. Calculate your water usage and compare the cost per gallon of filtered water for each brand to determine the most cost-effective option.
Do these filters remove fluoride?
Neither PUR nor Brita filters are specifically designed to remove fluoride. If fluoride removal is a priority, you should look for filters specifically designed to target fluoride. These often use different filtration technologies, such as activated alumina or reverse osmosis. Check the filter’s specifications and certifications to verify its fluoride removal capabilities. Research filters that are specifically designed to remove fluoride from your water.
Final Verdict
Both PUR and Brita offer excellent water filtration solutions. While Brita provides convenient and affordable pitcher options, PUR often boasts superior contaminant removal capabilities and diverse filter types. Considering factors like filter lifespan and specific contaminant concerns is vital. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual water needs and preferences.
Winner: PUR