Buck 110 vs 112: Which Classic Folding Knife Reigns?
Choosing the right knife can be a tough decision, especially when you’re looking at iconic brands like Buck Knives. Two models consistently stand out in the world of folding knives: the Buck 110 and the Buck 112. Both are legendary, but which one is the better choice for you?
This comparison dives deep into the heart of these two classic knives. We’ll explore their features, from blade design and handle materials to overall size and weight. Understanding these differences is crucial to determining which knife best suits your individual needs and preferences.
The Buck 110, with its timeless design, has been a favorite for generations. The Buck 112, a slightly smaller and more compact alternative, offers its own advantages. We’ll examine both, helping you make an informed decision.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | buck 110 | 112 |
|---|---|---|
| Blade Length | 3.75 inches | 3 inches |
| Blade Material | 420HC Steel | 420HC Steel |
| Handle Material | Macassar Ebony Dymondwood | Macassar Ebony Dymondwood |
| Overall Length (Open) | 8.63 inches | 7.25 inches |
| Closed Length | 4.88 inches | 4.25 inches |
| Weight | 7.4 oz | 5.6 oz |
| Locking Mechanism | Lockback | Lockback |
| Blade Grind | Clip Point | Clip Point |
| Handle Construction | Bolsters and Rivets | Bolsters and Rivets |
| Carry Style | Pocket Clip (optional) | Pocket Clip (optional) |
| Blade Thickness | 0.12 inches | 0.12 inches |
| Blade Finish | Satin | Satin |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Blade Length
- Buck 110: The Buck 110 boasts a 3.75-inch clip-point blade, providing a good balance between cutting power and versatility. Its longer blade allows for more substantial cuts and is ideal for heavier tasks. However, it can feel slightly less compact compared to the 112.
- 112: The Buck 112 features a slightly shorter 3-inch clip-point blade. This makes it more compact and easier to carry. While still versatile, the shorter blade might be less suited for very heavy-duty cutting compared to the 110.
- Winner: 110
Overall Length (Closed)
- Buck 110: The 110 is approximately 4.88 inches long when closed. This larger size offers a more substantial grip, but also means it takes up more pocket space.
- 112: The 112 is more compact, measuring around 4.25 inches when closed. This smaller size makes it more discreet and comfortable to carry in a pocket.
- Winner: 112
Weight
- Buck 110: The 110 generally weighs around 7.2 ounces. Its larger size and heavier blade contribute to a more noticeable weight in the pocket.
- 112: The 112 is lighter, typically weighing around 5.6 ounces. This makes it more comfortable for extended carry.
- Winner: 112
Handle Material
- Buck 110: The classic 110 often features a brass bolsters and wood or phenolic handles. This combination offers a traditional aesthetic, good grip, and durability, though it can be more susceptible to wear over time.
- 112: The 112 typically uses the same handle materials as the 110. This provides a similar feel and durability, while offering a more compact package.
- Winner: Tie
Blade Steel
- Buck 110: Both knives generally utilize Buck’s 420HC steel, known for its good balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening.
- 112: Both knives generally utilize Buck’s 420HC steel, known for its good balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening.
- Winner: Tie
Carry Method
- Buck 110: The 110 often includes a leather sheath for belt carry. This is a secure and traditional method, but can be less convenient for pocket carry.
- 112: The 112 also includes a leather sheath for belt carry. This is a secure and traditional method, but can be less convenient for pocket carry.
- Winner: Tie
Locking Mechanism
- Buck 110: Both the 110 and 112 use a lockback mechanism, a reliable and secure locking system that prevents accidental blade closure.
- 112: Both the 110 and 112 use a lockback mechanism, a reliable and secure locking system that prevents accidental blade closure.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Buck 110: The Buck 110 typically costs slightly more due to its larger size and the higher materials cost.
- 112: The Buck 112 is typically more affordable due to its smaller size.
- Winner: 112
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Blade Length | buck 110 |
| Portability | 112 |
| Overall Size | 112 |
| Weight | 112 |
| Classic Design | buck 110 |
What They Have in Common:
- Blade Material: Both knives utilize 420HC steel for their blades, offering a good balance of sharpness, durability, and corrosion resistance. This makes them suitable for a variety of tasks.
- Locking Mechanism: Both the Buck 110 and 112 feature a reliable lockback mechanism, ensuring the blade stays securely open during use and preventing accidental closure. This is a key safety feature.
- Handle Material: Both models share Macassar Ebony Dymondwood handles, providing a classic and attractive look. This material also offers a comfortable grip.
- Blade Grind: Both knives feature a clip point blade grind, making them versatile for piercing, slicing, and general utility tasks. This is a common and practical blade shape.
- Handle Construction: Both knives employ bolsters and rivets in their handle construction, contributing to the knife’s overall strength and durability. This ensures the knife can withstand rigorous use.
Buck 110 Vs 112 Buying Guide
Durability and Build Quality
Both the Buck 110 and 112 are renowned for their robust construction, but subtle differences exist. The Buck 110, being the larger knife, generally feels more substantial in hand, often constructed with thicker brass bolsters and liners, contributing to its durability. The 112, while similarly built, might utilize slightly thinner materials to maintain its more compact profile. Both knives typically feature a strong lockback mechanism, ensuring a secure blade during use. Consider the intended use; heavy-duty tasks might favor the 110, while the 112 offers a balance of durability and portability.
Blade Steel and Performance
The blade steel significantly impacts a knife’s performance. Buck knives traditionally use 420HC steel, known for its balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening. Both the 110 and 112 usually feature this steel. However, some special editions or variations might offer premium blade steels like S30V, which offers superior edge retention and toughness. Evaluate the steel based on your expected use and sharpening preferences. For general use, 420HC is a solid choice. If you prioritize edge retention and are willing to invest more in sharpening, consider a higher-end steel version.
Handle Materials and Ergonomics
The handle material impacts grip, comfort, and aesthetics. The classic Buck 110 often features a wooden handle, providing a traditional look and comfortable grip. The 112, while also available with wood, sometimes offers other materials like phenolic or even Micarta in some versions. Consider the environment you’ll be using the knife in. Wood can be susceptible to moisture, while synthetic materials offer better water resistance. Ergonomically, the 110’s larger size might be more comfortable for larger hands, while the 112’s compact design is excellent for everyday carry.
Size and Portability
Size is a crucial factor, especially for everyday carry. The Buck 110 is a larger knife, making it more suitable for demanding tasks but less discreet to carry. The Buck 112 is significantly more compact, fitting comfortably in a pocket or on a belt, making it an excellent choice for everyday carry. Consider your personal preference and how you plan to use the knife. If you need a larger blade for heavy-duty work, the 110 is preferred. If you prioritize portability and ease of carry, the 112 is the better option.
Price and Value
Both the Buck 110 and 112 offer excellent value for their price point. The Buck 110 usually commands a slightly higher price due to its larger size and potentially more material. The 112 provides similar quality and features in a more compact package, often at a slightly lower cost. Consider your budget and the features you prioritize. Both knives are built to last, making them a worthwhile investment. Evaluate the specific features, such as handle material and blade steel, to determine the best value for your needs.
Intended Use and Applications
Consider the tasks you’ll primarily use the knife for. The Buck 110, with its larger blade, excels at tasks like heavy-duty cutting, skinning, and general outdoor chores. The Buck 112, being smaller, is better suited for everyday tasks, such as opening packages, light cutting, and general utility purposes. Evaluate your needs. If you frequently handle tougher tasks, the 110 is a better fit. For everyday carry and general utility, the 112 offers a more practical and portable solution. Think about the common tasks you perform and choose the knife that best aligns with those tasks.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy buck 110 If…
- You prefer a larger blade for more demanding cutting tasks.
- You want a knife with a classic, iconic design.
- You need a knife with a robust feel and substantial weight.
- You prioritize a longer blade for tasks like skinning or detailed work.
Buy 112 If…
- You prefer a more compact and pocket-friendly knife.
- You want a lighter weight knife for easier everyday carry.
- You need a knife that’s slightly easier to handle in tight spaces.
- You value a balance of functionality and portability.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference between the Buck 110 and 112?
The primary difference is size. The Buck 110 is larger, featuring a longer blade and a more substantial handle, making it better for heavy-duty tasks. The Buck 112 is more compact and designed for everyday carry, offering a shorter blade and a smaller handle. This difference influences portability, intended use, and overall feel in hand. The 112 is easier to carry daily, while the 110 is better for more demanding work.
What type of steel do Buck 110 and 112 knives typically use?
Buck knives typically use 420HC steel for their blades. This steel is known for its good balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening. It’s a reliable choice for general use and offers a good balance of performance and affordability. Some special editions or models might feature higher-end blade steels like S30V, which offers improved edge retention and toughness.
How durable are the Buck 110 and 112 knives?
Both the Buck 110 and 112 are known for their durability. They feature a robust lockback mechanism and are built with quality materials. The 110 might feel slightly more substantial due to its larger size and thicker construction. However, both knives are designed to withstand regular use and offer long-lasting performance. Proper care and maintenance are still essential to ensure their longevity.
What are the handle materials used in Buck 110 and 112 knives?
The Buck 110 and 112 often feature wooden handles, providing a classic look and comfortable grip. However, they can also come with other materials, such as phenolic or Micarta in some versions. These synthetic materials offer better water resistance and durability. The choice of handle material influences grip, aesthetics, and resistance to environmental factors like moisture and wear. Consider your preferred feel and the conditions you’ll be using the knife in.
Which knife is better for everyday carry: the Buck 110 or 112?
The Buck 112 is generally better for everyday carry. Its more compact size allows it to fit comfortably in a pocket or on a belt without being overly bulky. The 110, being larger, can be more challenging to carry discreetly. The 112 offers a balance of functionality and portability, making it a convenient choice for everyday tasks. The 110 is better suited for situations where a larger blade is needed.
How do I sharpen a Buck 110 or 112 knife?
Sharpening a Buck 110 or 112 is straightforward. Use a sharpening stone, a sharpening rod, or a sharpening system. Maintain a consistent angle while sharpening to achieve a sharp edge. Regularly strop the blade to maintain its sharpness. If you’re unfamiliar with sharpening, consider watching tutorials or consulting a professional sharpener. Proper sharpening is essential to keep the knife performing at its best.
Are there any special editions or variations of the Buck 110 and 112?
Yes, both the Buck 110 and 112 have special editions and variations. These can include different handle materials, blade steels (like S30V), and aesthetic enhancements. Buck frequently releases limited-edition models with unique features and finishes. These variations can offer improved performance, different aesthetics, or collector’s value. Check Buck’s website or authorized dealers to find the latest available special editions.
Final Verdict
Both the Buck 110 and 112 are excellent knives, each with its strengths. The 110 offers a larger blade and more robust construction, ideal for heavy-duty tasks. The 112 provides a more compact and portable design, perfect for everyday carry and general utility. The choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. Consider the intended use, size preference, and desired level of portability when making your decision. Both represent great value and quality.
Winner: Buck 112