Ergodox Ez vs Moonlander: Which Split Keyboard Reigns?
Tired of wrist pain and cramped fingers from your old keyboard? You’re not alone! Many are turning to ergonomic keyboards for a more comfortable and efficient typing experience. Two popular choices in the split keyboard arena are the Ergodox EZ and the Moonlander.
These innovative keyboards promise to revolutionize your workflow. Both the Ergodox EZ and the Moonlander offer a split design, customizable layouts, and a focus on ergonomics. They aim to reduce strain and improve your overall typing posture.
But which one is right for you? This comparison delves deep into the features, pros, and cons of the Ergodox EZ vs Moonlander. We’ll explore their build quality, key layouts, software, and overall typing experience to help you make the best choice for your needs.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | ergodox ez | moonlander |
|---|---|---|
| Layout | Split, Ergonomic | Split, Ergonomic |
| Key Switches | Hot-swappable | Hot-swappable |
| Keycaps | Customizable | Customizable |
| Number of Keys | 60-76 | 60 |
| Programmability | Fully Programmable | Fully Programmable |
| Backlighting | RGB | RGB |
| Connectivity | USB-C | USB-C |
| Firmware | ZSA | ZSA |
| Thumb Clusters | Yes | Yes |
| Tent Kit | Optional | Included |
| Case Material | Plastic/Aluminum | Aluminum |
| Onboard Memory | Yes | Yes |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Layout & Ergonomics
- Ergodox Ez: The Ergodox EZ features a split, columnar layout designed for ergonomic comfort. It offers a highly customizable layout through its online configurator, allowing users to remap keys and create multiple layers. However, the learning curve can be steep for those unfamiliar with columnar layouts.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander also sports a split, columnar layout, but with a more compact design. It retains the same level of customizability as the Ergodox EZ and includes a built-in thumb cluster. Its smaller footprint may be preferable for some, but the close key spacing can be a challenge.
- Winner: Tie
Key Switches & Feel
- Ergodox Ez: The Ergodox EZ typically comes with a variety of Cherry MX-compatible key switches, offering a wide range of tactile and linear options. The hot-swappable sockets make it easy to change switches without soldering, but the switch options are typically limited to what is offered at the time of purchase.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander also features hot-swappable switches, including a wider variety of switch types available. This allows for greater customization after purchase.
- Winner: Moonlander
Build Quality & Materials
- Ergodox Ez: The Ergodox EZ is known for its solid build quality, often featuring a durable plastic or aluminum frame. It’s generally well-regarded for its overall construction, although some users find the plastic case less premium than other options.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander also boasts a robust build, with a focus on a more compact design. It utilizes a similar quality of materials, but the smaller footprint may feel more dense.
- Winner: Tie
Customization & Software
- Ergodox Ez: Both keyboards are highly customizable, but the Ergodox EZ stands out with its online configurator, which offers a user-friendly interface for remapping keys, creating layers, and customizing lighting effects. This makes the initial setup and adjustments very accessible.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander uses the same ZSA configurator, offering the same level of customization.
- Winner: Tie
Thumb Cluster
- Ergodox Ez: The Ergodox EZ has a well-designed thumb cluster, allowing you to access commonly used keys.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander has a thumb cluster with 6 keys per side, offering a wider range of thumb key options.
- Winner: Moonlander
Portability
- Ergodox Ez: While split keyboards are generally portable, the Ergodox EZ’s larger size can make it slightly less convenient for travel, even though it comes with a carrying case.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander’s smaller footprint makes it more portable and easier to fit in a bag.
- Winner: Moonlander
Backlighting
- Ergodox Ez: The Ergodox EZ offers RGB backlighting, providing ample color customization and visual feedback.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander also provides RGB backlighting, offering similar customization options.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Ergodox Ez: The Ergodox EZ is priced competitively in the premium ergonomic keyboard market.
- Moonlander: The Moonlander is priced similarly to the Ergodox EZ.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Overall Ergonomics | Tie |
| Customization | Tie |
| Portability | Moonlander |
| Build Quality | Moonlander |
| Value | Ergodox EZ |
What They Have in Common:
- Split Design: Both keyboards feature a split design, promoting a more natural and ergonomic hand position. This separation can reduce strain and improve comfort during extended typing sessions.
- Ergonomic Layout: Both keyboards are designed with an ergonomic layout, featuring columnar keys and thumb clusters to minimize wrist movement and promote better posture. This can reduce the risk of repetitive strain injuries.
- Hot-Swappable Switches: Both the Ergodox EZ and Moonlander support hot-swappable switches, allowing users to easily change key switches without soldering. This offers customization options.
- Customizable Keycaps: Both keyboards support customizable keycaps, allowing users to personalize the look and feel of their keyboards. This allows for personalized aesthetics.
- Programmability: Both keyboards are fully programmable, allowing users to remap keys, create macros, and customize their typing experience to their specific needs. This enhances productivity.
Ergodox Ez Vs Moonlander Buying Guide
Ergonomics and Comfort
The Ergodox EZ and Moonlander both prioritize ergonomics, aiming to reduce strain during extended typing sessions. The Ergodox EZ features a split design, allowing for adjustable tenting and splay, promoting a more natural hand and wrist position. Its sculpted keycaps further enhance comfort. The Moonlander builds upon this with its integrated tenting legs and fully customizable layout, enabling personalized adjustments for optimal comfort and minimizing fatigue. Both keyboards offer significant ergonomic advantages over traditional designs, but the Moonlander’s integrated features might provide a slight edge in convenience.
Customization and Layout
Both keyboards excel in customization, offering extensive options for remapping keys and creating custom layouts. The Ergodox EZ utilizes the online configurator, making layout changes user-friendly. The Moonlander takes it a step further with its integrated display and ZMK firmware, offering even more advanced customization features. This includes layers, macros, and QMK support. The Moonlander’s visual feedback on the display provides a quick overview of active layers and settings, enhancing its customization capabilities. The Ergodox EZ is still highly customizable, but the Moonlander presents a more advanced and feature-rich experience.
Build Quality and Materials
Both keyboards are known for their quality construction, but they differ slightly in their approach. The Ergodox EZ boasts a sturdy build with a focus on durability, utilizing high-quality materials for its case and keycaps. Its design is robust and designed to withstand regular use. The Moonlander also prioritizes build quality, using a solid aluminum case and premium keycaps. Its design is more compact and portable. Both keyboards are built to last, providing a premium typing experience. The Moonlander’s aluminum case contributes to a more premium feel.
Learning Curve and Usability
Both keyboards require some adjustment due to their split and ergonomic layouts. The Ergodox EZ’s online configurator simplifies the layout configuration process, making it easier to adapt to the new layout. The Moonlander’s advanced features and customizable nature might present a steeper learning curve initially. However, the benefits are worth the effort. Both keyboards offer comprehensive documentation and community support, which can help users overcome any initial challenges. The Moonlander’s integrated display can also help users keep track of their custom layouts.
Portability and Design
The Ergodox EZ’s split design makes it somewhat portable, but its overall size can be a consideration. The Moonlander, with its more compact design and integrated tenting legs, is arguably more portable and easier to transport. The Moonlander’s design is sleek and modern, appealing to users who value aesthetics and portability. The Ergodox EZ’s design is more functional, providing the necessary features for ergonomic typing. For users who frequently travel, the Moonlander’s compact form factor offers a clear advantage in terms of portability.
Price and Value
The Ergodox EZ and Moonlander are premium keyboards, reflecting their advanced features and high-quality build. The price points are similar, but vary depending on the specific configurations and options selected. When evaluating the value, consider the features, build quality, and ergonomic benefits offered by each keyboard. Both provide excellent value for those seeking a premium typing experience. The long-term benefits in terms of comfort and productivity often justify the investment. Consider what features are most important to you when deciding which is the better value.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy ergodox ez If…
- You prefer a keyboard with a slightly larger key count and more customization options.
- You want the option to choose between plastic and aluminum case.
- You’re looking for a keyboard with a proven track record and community support.
- You want a keyboard with optional tenting kit.
Buy moonlander If…
- You want an even more compact and portable ergonomic keyboard.
- You prefer a keyboard with an all-aluminum construction.
- You want a keyboard with tenting included.
- You value a sleek and modern design.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference between the Ergodox EZ and Moonlander?
The main difference lies in their design and features. The Ergodox EZ focuses on a split design with external tenting and splay options, while the Moonlander offers a more compact form factor with integrated tenting legs and a built-in display. The Moonlander also supports ZMK firmware, offering a more advanced customization experience. Both are ergonomic, but the Moonlander has additional features.
Which keyboard is better for beginners?
The Ergodox EZ might be slightly easier for beginners due to its user-friendly online configurator and simpler setup. However, both keyboards require some adaptation to their split and ergonomic layouts. The Ergodox EZ’s readily available documentation and community support provide extra help. The Moonlander has a steeper learning curve, but its advanced features can be rewarding for those willing to invest time in learning.
How customizable are these keyboards?
Both keyboards offer extensive customization options. The Ergodox EZ uses an online configurator, allowing users to remap keys, create custom layouts, and adjust settings. The Moonlander takes it further with its ZMK firmware, integrated display, and support for layers, macros, and QMK. This provides more advanced customization capabilities. Both keyboards cater to users who want a personalized typing experience.
What types of switches are available for each keyboard?
Both the Ergodox EZ and Moonlander typically offer a range of mechanical switches, allowing users to choose the feel and sound that best suits their preferences. Options include Cherry MX, Gateron, and Kailh switches. The specific switch availability may vary based on the vendor or configuration chosen. Both usually give options for linear, tactile, and clicky switches.
Is the Moonlander more portable than the Ergodox EZ?
Yes, the Moonlander is generally considered more portable than the Ergodox EZ. Its more compact design and integrated tenting legs make it easier to pack and transport. The Ergodox EZ, while split, has a larger footprint overall. The Moonlander’s form factor is a significant advantage for users who frequently travel or need to move their keyboard.
What is the build quality like for each keyboard?
Both keyboards are known for their high-quality build. The Ergodox EZ typically features a sturdy build with premium keycaps, providing durability. The Moonlander usually utilizes a solid aluminum case and premium keycaps. Both are built to last and offer a premium typing experience. The choice depends on the specific design and materials preferences of the user.
Which keyboard is better for gaming?
Both keyboards can be used for gaming, but the Moonlander’s customizable layout and responsiveness may provide a slight advantage for some gamers. The ability to create custom gaming layouts and macros can enhance the gaming experience. Both keyboards offer benefits for gaming due to their ergonomic design. The choice depends on personal preferences and the types of games played.
Final Verdict
The Ergodox EZ and Moonlander are both exceptional ergonomic keyboards, offering significant advantages over traditional designs. The Ergodox EZ provides a solid and customizable experience with a more approachable learning curve. The Moonlander elevates the experience with a more compact design, advanced customization options, and integrated display. The Moonlander’s feature set and portability ultimately give it the edge for the discerning user.
Winner: Moonlander