Brooks Shoes vs New Balance: Which Running Shoe Reigns?
Choosing the right running shoe can feel like navigating a maze. With so many brands and models on the market, it’s easy to get lost in the details. Two of the most popular and respected names in the running world are Brooks and New Balance. But which brand is the best fit for you?
This comparison dives deep into the world of running shoes, pitting Brooks shoes against New Balance. We’ll explore the key features, performance aspects, and overall value of each brand. Whether you’re a seasoned marathoner or just starting your fitness journey, understanding the differences is crucial.
We will explore cushioning, support, and durability, and help you make an informed decision. This guide will help you determine whether Brooks or New Balance is the ultimate champion for your feet and your running goals. Get ready to find your perfect stride!
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Brooks | New Balance |
|---|---|---|
| Cushioning | DNA LOFT, GuideRails | Fresh Foam, FuelCell |
| Stability | Offers various stability options | Offers various stability options |
| Arch Support | Good arch support in many models | Good arch support in many models |
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | Typically 8-12mm | Typically 6-12mm |
| Weight | Varies by model, generally moderate | Varies by model, generally moderate |
| Upper Material | Engineered mesh | Engineered mesh, suede overlays |
| Outsole | Durable rubber | Durable rubber |
| Midsole Technology | DNA LOFT, BioMoGo DNA | Fresh Foam, FuelCell |
| Best For | Road running, everyday training | Road running, walking, casual wear |
| Pronation Control | Offers options for overpronation | Offers options for overpronation |
| Durability | Generally durable | Generally durable |
| Fit | Often true to size | Varies, consider trying on |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Cushioning
- Brooks Shoes: Brooks is known for its DNA LOFT cushioning, offering a soft and responsive feel. This provides excellent impact absorption, making them ideal for long runs and those who prioritize comfort. Some models may feel less responsive for faster paces.
- New Balance: New Balance often utilizes Fresh Foam technology, which offers a balance of cushioning and responsiveness. The specific type of Fresh Foam varies by model. They typically provide good shock absorption and energy return, suitable for a variety of activities.
- Winner: Brooks
Stability
- Brooks Shoes: Brooks offers various stability shoes with features like GuideRails to help correct pronation. These shoes provide support for overpronation, helping to keep the foot aligned. The level of stability varies across different models.
- New Balance: New Balance also has a range of stability shoes, often featuring medial posts or other technologies to control pronation. They offer good support for runners needing extra stability. The specific technology used depends on the model.
- Winner: Tie
Fit and Sizing
- Brooks Shoes: Brooks shoes often have a more traditional fit, generally running true to size. They offer a variety of widths to accommodate different foot shapes. Some runners may find the toe box to be slightly narrow.
- New Balance: New Balance is celebrated for its wide range of widths and sizes, catering to diverse foot shapes. Their shoes often provide a more accommodating fit, particularly in the toe box. The sizing can sometimes vary between models.
- Winner: New Balance
Durability
- Brooks Shoes: Brooks shoes are generally known for their durability, with uppers and outsoles that can withstand regular use. The lifespan of the shoe depends on the model and running conditions. Some users report that the cushioning may break down over time.
- New Balance: New Balance shoes also offer good durability, with robust materials used in the uppers and outsoles. The longevity varies by model and usage. Some models may have a slightly longer lifespan compared to Brooks.
- Winner: Tie
Responsiveness
- Brooks Shoes: Some Brooks models are designed with a focus on cushioning over responsiveness. While they offer good comfort, they may not feel as quick or springy as some other brands. Certain models, however, are more responsive.
- New Balance: New Balance offers a range of shoes, with some models prioritizing responsiveness. Their shoes often provide a good balance of energy return and cushioning. The responsiveness level varies by model.
- Winner: New Balance
Weight
- Brooks Shoes: The weight of Brooks shoes varies depending on the model. Some models are lighter, while others prioritize cushioning and stability, which can add to the weight. Generally, Brooks offers a variety of weights.
- New Balance: New Balance also offers a range of shoe weights. They have both lightweight and heavier models. The weight depends on the intended use and features included in the shoe.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Brooks Shoes: Brooks shoes are typically priced in the mid to high range, reflecting the quality and technology used. The price varies depending on the model and features. Sales and discounts are often available.
- New Balance: New Balance shoes also fall into a similar price range, with options available at various price points. The cost depends on the specific model and technology. Discounts and promotions are often available.
- Winner: Tie
Aesthetics & Style
- Brooks Shoes: Brooks offers a variety of styles, with a focus on performance. Their designs are often functional and less focused on flashy aesthetics. Color options vary by model and season.
- New Balance: New Balance is known for its classic and stylish designs, often incorporating retro elements. They offer a wide range of colors and designs, appealing to a broader audience. They have options for both performance and casual wear.
- Winner: New Balance
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Stability | Brooks |
| Cushioning | Tie |
| Variety | New Balance |
| Road Running Focus | Brooks |
| Casual Wear | New Balance |
What They Have in Common:
- Breathable Uppers: Both brands utilize breathable mesh uppers in many of their running shoe models, promoting airflow and keeping your feet cool.
- Durable Outsoles: Both Brooks and New Balance shoes typically feature durable rubber outsoles designed to withstand the impact of running on various surfaces.
- Cushioning Technology: Both brands invest in cushioning technologies to provide impact absorption and comfort during runs.
- Variety of Models: Both brands offer a wide variety of models catering to different foot types, running styles, and preferences.
- Neutral and Stability Options: Both Brooks and New Balance provide both neutral shoes and stability shoes to accommodate runners with different pronation needs.
- Use for Road Running: Both brands’ core products are designed for road running, offering features suitable for pavement.
Brooks Shoes Vs New Balance Buying Guide
Cushioning and Support
Both Brooks and New Balance are renowned for their excellent cushioning and support, but they cater to slightly different preferences. Brooks often emphasizes a softer, more responsive feel, making them popular for runners seeking a plush ride. Their DNA LOFT cushioning is a prime example. New Balance, on the other hand, provides a broader range of cushioning options, from firmer, more stable models to softer, more cushioned ones. Their Fresh Foam technology is highly regarded. Consider your individual needs: do you prefer a softer, more forgiving feel (Brooks) or a more versatile approach (New Balance)?
Stability and Pronation Control
For runners who overpronate, both brands offer stability shoes designed to correct excessive inward rolling of the foot. Brooks’ GuideRails technology is a standout feature, providing targeted support to keep your foot aligned. New Balance’s stability shoes, such as the 860 series, also offer excellent medial support and often utilize a dual-density midsole. When choosing, consider the severity of your pronation and the level of support you require. Brooks tends to provide a more intuitive and less intrusive support system, while New Balance offers a wider selection of stability models.
Fit and Sizing
Fit is crucial for running shoes, and both brands have their unique characteristics. Brooks shoes generally run true to size, with a comfortable, secure fit that accommodates various foot shapes. They often have a slightly wider toe box, which can benefit those with wider feet. New Balance is known for its wide range of widths, catering to a diverse audience. They offer narrow, standard, wide, and extra-wide options, ensuring a more customized fit. Trying on shoes in person is highly recommended to determine which brand best suits your foot shape and size. Consider your foot width and arch height.
Durability and Construction
Both Brooks and New Balance shoes are built with quality materials and construction, ensuring durability for regular running. The lifespan of a running shoe depends on factors like mileage, running style, and terrain. Brooks shoes often feature durable outsoles and robust uppers designed to withstand the rigors of running. New Balance also utilizes high-quality materials, with a focus on combining performance and durability. Consider the type of running you do and the expected mileage when choosing between the two brands. Reviews frequently comment on the longevity of each brand’s models.
Performance and Running Style
Brooks and New Balance cater to various running styles and performance goals. Brooks often appeals to runners seeking a smooth, consistent ride, ideal for daily training and long distances. Their neutral shoes are often favored by marathon runners. New Balance offers a broader range, including models for speedwork, trail running, and everyday training. Their FuelCell technology is particularly popular for its responsiveness. Assess your training needs and the type of running you do when selecting a shoe. Brooks leans towards a neutral experience, while New Balance provides more specialization.
Price and Value
The price of Brooks and New Balance shoes varies depending on the model and features. Both brands offer shoes at different price points, from entry-level options to premium performance models. Generally, you can expect to pay a similar price for comparable models from both brands. Consider your budget and the features you prioritize when making your decision. Researching online reviews and comparing prices from different retailers can help you find the best value. Both brands offer excellent value for the quality and performance they provide, offering a good return on investment.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Brooks Shoes If…
- You prioritize GuideRails technology for added stability.
- You prefer a consistent fit and feel across different models.
- You are looking for a shoe specifically designed for road running.
- You need a shoe with good arch support.
Buy New Balance If…
- You prioritize a wider range of styles and color options.
- You are looking for a shoe that can transition well from running to casual wear.
- You want to explore options with FuelCell technology for a more responsive ride.
- You value the variety of models offered for different foot shapes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main differences between Brooks and New Balance shoes?
The main differences lie in cushioning, support, and fit. Brooks often emphasizes a softer, more responsive feel, while New Balance offers a broader range of cushioning and width options. Brooks is known for its GuideRails technology, while New Balance focuses on a wide selection of stability models and widths. Ultimately, it depends on individual foot shape and running style.
Which brand is better for stability shoes?
Both brands offer excellent stability shoes. Brooks uses GuideRails technology for a more intuitive approach to support, while New Balance provides a wider range of stability models, including options for varying levels of pronation. The best choice depends on your specific needs and the severity of your pronation. Try on both brands if possible.
Are Brooks shoes good for wide feet?
Brooks shoes typically have a slightly wider toe box, making them a good option for some runners with wider feet. However, New Balance is renowned for its extensive range of widths, from narrow to extra-wide. If you need a specific width, New Balance might be a better choice. Always try them on for the best fit.
Which brand offers better cushioning?
Both brands excel in cushioning, but they offer different experiences. Brooks often provides a softer, more responsive feel with its DNA LOFT cushioning. New Balance offers a wider range, from firmer to softer options with technologies like Fresh Foam and FuelCell. The best choice depends on your preference for cushioning firmness.
How do I choose the right size?
It’s crucial to try on shoes in person or use the brand’s size chart. Consider your foot length, width, and arch height. Brooks generally runs true to size. New Balance offers a variety of widths. Measure your feet and compare them to the brand’s sizing guide. Reviews often highlight the fit of specific models.
Are Brooks or New Balance shoes better for marathon running?
Both brands have shoes suitable for marathon running. Brooks’ neutral shoes are often favored for their smooth ride and consistent cushioning, ideal for long distances. New Balance offers various models designed for marathon training and racing, depending on your preferred feel and support. Consider your running style and training needs.
Which brand is more durable?
Both Brooks and New Balance use quality materials and construction, ensuring durability. The lifespan depends on mileage and running style. Reviews often comment on the longevity of specific models. Factors like terrain also influence durability. Choosing shoes with durable outsoles and uppers is essential.
Final Verdict
Both Brooks and New Balance offer excellent running shoes. Brooks excels in providing a smooth, consistent ride with intuitive support and a comfortable fit, while New Balance provides a wider range of options, including various widths and cushioning styles. The best choice ultimately depends on individual preferences and running needs.
Winner: Brooks Shoes