Xbox Elite Controller vs Elite 2: Which Should You Buy?
Are you ready to elevate your gaming experience? The world of premium controllers has a king, and it has two faces. We’re diving deep into a head-to-head comparison to determine which reigns supreme: the original Xbox Elite Controller or its successor, the Elite Series 2?
Both controllers promise a level of customization and performance that standard gamepads simply can’t match. From swappable components to advanced software, these controllers are designed for serious gamers. But with updated features and a higher price tag for the Elite Series 2, is it worth the upgrade?
This article will break down the key differences between the Xbox Elite Controller and the Elite Series 2, covering everything from design and ergonomics to performance and features. Get ready to discover which controller best suits your gaming needs and budget.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | xbox elite controller | elite 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Connectivity | Wireless, Wired | Wireless, Wired |
| Customization Profiles | Yes | Yes |
| Paddle Buttons | 4 | 4 |
| Trigger Locks | Yes | Yes |
| D-Pad | Standard | Interchangeable |
| Thumbstick Tension Adjustment | No | Yes |
| Button Mapping | Yes | Yes |
| Grip | Rubberized | Rubberized |
| Charging | AA Batteries or Play & Charge Kit | Built-in Rechargeable Battery |
| Carry Case | Yes | Yes |
| Bluetooth | No | Yes |
| Weight | Slightly Lighter | Slightly Heavier |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Customization Options
- Xbox Elite Controller: Offers interchangeable thumbsticks, D-pads, and paddles. Allows for significant personalization of the controller’s feel and button layout. However, customization is somewhat limited compared to the Elite Series 2.
- Elite 2: Boasts even more extensive customization options, including adjustable-tension thumbsticks, shorter hair triggers, and a three-profile switch for quick profile changes. Provides a more refined and nuanced level of personalization.
- Winner: Elite 2
Build Quality & Materials
- Xbox Elite Controller: Features a robust build with high-quality materials, often including a metal D-pad and thumbstick bases. Known for its durability, but some users reported issues with grip degradation over time.
- Elite 2: Improves upon the original with a refined design and enhanced materials. Includes a rubberized grip for better handling and overall feels more premium. Known for increased durability and improved grip.
- Winner: Elite 2
Paddle Design & Functionality
- Xbox Elite Controller: Includes four paddles on the back of the controller, allowing for remapping of buttons. The paddle design is functional, but the paddles could feel a bit stiff for some users.
- Elite 2: Features redesigned paddles that are shorter and easier to actuate. The paddles are also more customizable in terms of their sensitivity.
- Winner: Elite 2
Trigger Stops & Hair Triggers
- Xbox Elite Controller: Includes trigger stops to reduce trigger travel distance, allowing for faster firing. However, the trigger stops are less adjustable.
- Elite 2: Offers adjustable trigger stops with shorter hair triggers for even faster actuation. Allows for fine-tuning of trigger sensitivity.
- Winner: Elite 2
Thumbstick Tension Adjustment
- Xbox Elite Controller: Does not offer adjustable thumbstick tension.
- Elite 2: Allows for adjusting the thumbstick tension, providing a personalized feel and response to the player.
- Winner: Elite 2
Battery Life
- Xbox Elite Controller: Offers a decent battery life, but the exact time varies based on usage. Battery life can be a concern for extended gaming sessions.
- Elite 2: Provides a longer battery life compared to the original, and comes with a charging case for easy recharging.
- Winner: Elite 2
Connectivity
- Xbox Elite Controller: Connects via Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth, offering broad compatibility with various devices.
- Elite 2: Also utilizes Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth, ensuring similar connectivity options.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Xbox Elite Controller: Typically available at a lower price point compared to the Elite Series 2.
- Elite 2: More expensive than the original Elite controller due to its additional features and improvements.
- Winner: xbox elite controller
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Overall Value | xbox elite controller |
| Features | elite 2 |
| Customization | elite 2 |
| Battery Life | elite 2 |
| Build Quality | Tie |
What They Have in Common
- Customization: Both controllers offer extensive customization options, allowing players to remap buttons and adjust settings to suit their playstyle.
- Paddle Buttons: Both controllers feature four paddle buttons on the back, providing additional control options and improved ergonomics.
- Trigger Locks: Both models include trigger locks, enabling players to shorten the trigger pull for faster firing in games.
- Interchangeable Components: Both controllers come with interchangeable thumbsticks and D-pads, allowing for personalized feel and control.
- Premium Build Quality: Both controllers are constructed with high-quality materials, ensuring durability and a premium feel.
Xbox Elite Controller Vs Elite 2 Buying Guide
Price and Value
When considering the Xbox Elite Controller vs. the Elite Series 2, price is a significant factor. The original Elite Controller is often available at a lower price point, especially if purchased used or refurbished. This makes it an attractive option for gamers on a budget or those unsure if they’ll fully utilize the advanced features. The Elite Series 2, with its enhanced features and build quality, commands a higher price. It represents a more significant investment, but offers a more premium experience. Evaluate your budget and desired features to determine the best value for your needs.
Features and Customization
Both controllers offer extensive customization options, including interchangeable thumbsticks, D-pads, and paddles. The Elite Series 2 takes this further with adjustable tension thumbsticks and shorter hair trigger locks. This level of customization allows players to tailor the controller to their exact preferences and playstyles. The original Elite Controller provides a solid foundation of customization, while the Elite Series 2 offers a more refined and nuanced experience. Consider which specific features are most important for your gaming preferences.
Build Quality and Durability
Both controllers are built with premium materials, but the Elite Series 2 boasts improvements in durability. The original Elite Controller was known to experience issues with grip degradation and button failures over time. The Elite Series 2 addresses these concerns with revised materials and a more robust design. This is particularly important for gamers who play frequently or are prone to aggressive button mashing. Evaluate the expected lifespan and warranty coverage when making your decision. Consider how much you play and how rough you are on your gear.
Battery Life and Connectivity
The Elite Series 2 offers a significant advantage in battery life, with up to 40 hours compared to the original Elite Controller, which relies on AA batteries. This extended battery life reduces the need for frequent charging or battery swaps, enhancing the overall gaming experience. Both controllers connect via Bluetooth and the Xbox Wireless protocol for seamless integration with Xbox consoles and PCs. However, the Elite Series 2 also features a charging dock, adding convenience. Think about how important battery life is to your gaming sessions and whether you prefer wired or wireless play.
Performance and Gaming Experience
Both controllers provide a superior gaming experience compared to standard controllers. The customizable paddles and enhanced ergonomics contribute to improved performance and control. The Elite Series 2 further elevates this experience with its adjustable tension thumbsticks, which allow for more precise aiming and movement. The shorter hair trigger locks also help to improve reaction times. Consider the types of games you play and whether these advanced features would significantly enhance your performance. The Elite Series 2 generally offers a more refined and responsive experience.
Compatibility and Ecosystem
Both controllers are fully compatible with Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One consoles, and Windows PCs. They seamlessly integrate with the Xbox ecosystem, providing access to a wide range of customization options and features. However, the Elite Series 2 benefits from ongoing software updates and refinements, which may introduce new features or improve performance over time. Consider how important it is to have the latest features and software support. Both controllers can be used with a variety of games, and their compatibility is not a major differentiating factor, but the Elite 2 has a slight edge here.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy xbox elite controller If…
- You want a premium controller without the highest price tag.
- You prefer using AA batteries and don’t want to worry about charging.
- You primarily play on the original Xbox One or a PC.
Buy elite 2 If…
- You want the most advanced features and customization options available.
- You value a built-in rechargeable battery and longer battery life.
- You want thumbstick tension adjustment and Bluetooth connectivity.
- You want a more refined and updated design.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main differences between the Xbox Elite Controller and the Elite Series 2?
The Elite Series 2 boasts several improvements, including adjustable tension thumbsticks, shorter hair trigger locks, a built-in rechargeable battery with longer life, and a charging dock. It also features a more durable build and refined ergonomics. The original Elite Controller offers a more affordable entry point, while the Elite Series 2 provides a more premium and feature-rich experience. The Elite 2 has more advanced features and improved build quality.
Which controller is better for competitive gaming?
The Elite Series 2 is generally considered better for competitive gaming due to its adjustable tension thumbsticks, shorter hair trigger locks, and improved ergonomics. These features allow for more precise control and faster reaction times, providing a competitive edge. The original Elite Controller is still a capable option, but the Elite Series 2 offers a more refined and responsive experience, especially for demanding competitive play. The Elite 2 offers more customization options.
Does the Elite Series 2 have a better battery life than the original Elite Controller?
Yes, the Elite Series 2 has a significantly better battery life. It features a built-in rechargeable battery that can last up to 40 hours on a single charge. The original Elite Controller uses AA batteries, which require frequent replacement or the use of a rechargeable battery pack. The Elite 2’s charging dock also adds convenience. The battery life is significantly better, making the Elite 2 the winner.
Are the paddles on the Elite Series 2 improved compared to the original Elite Controller?
The paddles on the Elite Series 2 are similar in design and function to those on the original Elite Controller. Both controllers offer customizable paddles that can be mapped to various buttons, providing additional control options. The placement and feel of the paddles are largely the same. However, the Elite Series 2’s overall enhanced ergonomics contribute to a more comfortable and responsive gaming experience. Both controllers offer paddles.
Can I use the Elite Series 2 with my PC?
Yes, both the original Elite Controller and the Elite Series 2 are fully compatible with Windows PCs. They connect via Bluetooth or the Xbox Wireless protocol, allowing you to enjoy all the customization and features on your PC. You’ll need the Xbox Accessories app to customize the controller settings on your PC. Both controllers are compatible across platforms, including PC gaming. They are versatile.
What if the Elite Series 2 breaks after the warranty?
The Elite Series 2, like the original Elite Controller, has a limited warranty. If it breaks after the warranty period, you’ll need to consider repair options or replacement. Repair options might include contacting Microsoft support, third-party repair services, or attempting repairs yourself. Replacement will be necessary. Proper care and maintenance are recommended to extend the controller’s lifespan. Consider protecting your investment.
Is the Elite Series 2 worth the higher price?
Whether the Elite Series 2 is worth the higher price depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you’re a serious gamer who values advanced features, improved durability, and extended battery life, the Elite Series 2 is a worthwhile investment. If you’re on a budget or only play casually, the original Elite Controller may be a better option. Evaluate your budget and the importance of specific features.
Final Verdict
The Elite Series 2 emerges as the superior controller due to its enhanced features, improved build quality, and extended battery life. While the original Elite Controller offers a solid foundation and remains a viable option, the Elite Series 2 provides a more premium and refined gaming experience. The Elite 2 caters to hardcore gamers and those seeking ultimate customization.
Winner: Xbox Elite Series 2