Apple Pencil 1 vs 2: Which Apple Stylus Should You Buy?
Are you an iPad artist, note-taker, or creative professional seeking the perfect digital stylus? Choosing between the Apple Pencil 1 vs Apple Pencil 2 can feel overwhelming. Both promise to elevate your iPad experience, but they differ significantly in features and functionality.
This in-depth comparison explores the key distinctions between the first and second-generation Apple Pencils. We’ll delve into design, charging methods, features, and compatibility to help you make an informed decision. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the stylus that best suits your needs and workflow.
Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro, this guide will provide a clear and concise overview. We’ll compare the subtle nuances, highlighting what makes each Apple Pencil unique and how they stack up against each other. Get ready to discover which Apple Pencil reigns supreme for your iPad needs.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Apple Pencil 1 | Apple Pencil 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | iPad (6th-9th gen), iPad Air (3rd gen), iPad mini (5th gen), iPad Pro 12.9-inch (1st & 2nd gen), iPad Pro 9.7-inch, iPad Pro 10.5-inch | iPad Air (4th & 5th gen), iPad mini (6th gen), iPad Pro 12.9-inch (3rd, 4th, 5th & 6th gen), iPad Pro 11-inch (1st, 2nd, 3rd & 4th gen) |
| Charging | Lightning Connector | Magnetic Wireless Charging |
| Double Tap Gesture | No | Yes (Customizable) |
| Attachment | Magnetic (for charging on some iPads) | Magnetic (for charging and storage) |
| Pressure Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Tilt Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Latency | Low | Lower |
| Tip | Replaceable | Replaceable |
| Design | Glossy, round design | Matte, flat-edge design |
| Color | White | White |
| Button | None | Double-tap gesture |
| Pairing | Lightning or Bluetooth | Magnetic & Bluetooth |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Design and Charging
- Apple Pencil 1: Cylindrical design with a glossy finish. It charges via Lightning connector, either directly from an iPad or with an included adapter. This can be inconvenient and prone to damage.
- Apple Pencil 2: Features a flat-edged design that magnetically attaches to and charges wirelessly from the side of compatible iPads. This offers a more streamlined and convenient charging experience.
- Winner: P2
Pairing
- Apple Pencil 1: Pairs with the iPad via the Lightning connector, requiring physical connection. This process can sometimes be finicky.
- Apple Pencil 2: Pairs automatically when attached magnetically to a compatible iPad. This provides a simpler and more intuitive pairing experience.
- Winner: P2
Double-Tap Gesture
- Apple Pencil 1: Lacks double-tap gesture support for quick tool switching. Users must manually select tools from the iPad’s interface.
- Apple Pencil 2: Includes a customizable double-tap gesture on the side of the pencil, allowing users to quickly switch between tools, such as the eraser and pen.
- Winner: P2
Latency
- Apple Pencil 1: Generally exhibits slightly higher latency compared to the second-generation pencil, which can result in a more noticeable delay between the pen tip and the on-screen stroke.
- Apple Pencil 2: Offers lower latency, providing a more responsive and natural writing and drawing experience.
- Winner: P2
Compatibility
- Apple Pencil 1: Compatible with older iPad models, including the iPad (6th, 7th, 8th, 9th gen), iPad Air (3rd gen), iPad mini (5th gen), and iPad Pro (1st and 2nd gen – requires Lightning connection).
- Apple Pencil 2: Compatible only with newer iPad models that support magnetic charging and pairing, including iPad Air (4th and 5th gen), iPad mini (6th gen), and iPad Pro (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th gen).
- Winner: Tie (depending on iPad model)
Pressure Sensitivity
- Apple Pencil 1: Offers excellent pressure sensitivity, allowing for nuanced control over line weight and shading. This feature is well-implemented.
- Apple Pencil 2: Maintains the same high level of pressure sensitivity as the first-generation Apple Pencil, providing a responsive and accurate drawing experience.
- Winner: Tie
Tilt Sensitivity
- Apple Pencil 1: Includes tilt sensitivity, allowing users to vary line width and shading by tilting the pencil. This feature works well.
- Apple Pencil 2: Also features tilt sensitivity, providing a natural and expressive drawing experience by detecting the angle of the pencil.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Apple Pencil 1: Generally more affordable than the second-generation Apple Pencil. It is still a good value for its features.
- Apple Pencil 2: Typically more expensive, reflecting its updated design, features, and improved functionality.
- Winner: P1 (for price)
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Charging | Apple Pencil 2 |
| Design | Apple Pencil 2 |
| Features | Apple Pencil 2 |
| Compatibility | Apple Pencil 2 (for newer iPads) |
| Convenience | Apple Pencil 2 |
What They Have in Common
- Pressure Sensitivity: Both Apple Pencils offer excellent pressure sensitivity, allowing for varied line weights and shading based on how hard you press the tip against the screen.
- Tilt Sensitivity: Both styluses support tilt sensitivity, enabling you to create shading effects by angling the pencil, mimicking the effect of a real pencil or brush.
- Compatibility with iPad Apps: Both Apple Pencils are compatible with a wide range of iPad apps designed for drawing, note-taking, and creative work.
- Low Latency: Both pencils provide low latency, ensuring a responsive and natural writing and drawing experience with minimal delay between your actions and the on-screen results.
- Replaceable Tips: Both models have replaceable tips, which are designed to wear down over time with use. Replacement tips are available for purchase separately.
Apple Pencil 1 vs Apple Pencil 2 Buying Guide
Compatibility
Understanding compatibility is crucial. The Apple Pencil 1st generation works with older iPad models, including the iPad (6th to 9th generation), iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), and the 12.9-inch iPad Pro (1st and 2nd generation), and the 9.7-inch iPad Pro. The Apple Pencil 2nd generation, however, is compatible with newer models, such as the iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad mini (6th generation), and various iPad Pro models (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation). Ensure your iPad model matches the correct Pencil generation to avoid incompatibility issues. This is your first crucial step.
Charging and Pairing
Charging and pairing methods differ significantly. The Apple Pencil 1st generation charges via a Lightning connector, either through the iPad itself or with a provided adapter. This method can feel somewhat clunky and prone to accidental bending. The Apple Pencil 2nd generation charges wirelessly by magnetically attaching to the side of compatible iPads. Pairing is also streamlined; simply attach the Pencil to the iPad, and it instantly connects. This is a more elegant and convenient experience.
Design and Ergonomics
The design of each Apple Pencil generation offers distinct ergonomic experiences. The Apple Pencil 1st generation features a glossy, cylindrical design with a Lightning connector cap. This design can sometimes feel a bit less comfortable for extended use. The Apple Pencil 2nd generation adopts a matte, flat-edged design that magnetically attaches to the iPad. This design feels more natural in the hand and prevents the Pencil from rolling off surfaces. The flat edge also allows for easy magnetic attachment and charging.
Features and Functionality
Both Apple Pencils provide accurate and responsive input, but the 2nd generation introduces additional features. Both support tilt and pressure sensitivity. The Apple Pencil 2nd generation introduces double-tap gestures, allowing you to quickly switch between tools or erase. The 2nd generation also offers slightly lower latency, enhancing the responsiveness of your strokes. This added functionality can significantly improve workflow for creative tasks, making the 2nd generation a more versatile tool.
Price Comparison
The price point is another important factor in the decision-making process. The Apple Pencil 1st generation is generally less expensive than the 2nd generation, often making it the more budget-friendly option. However, the price difference reflects the advanced features and improved design of the 2nd generation. When considering the price, also factor in the overall value, including compatibility, features, and the intended use. Check current prices from different retailers to make sure you get the best deal.
Performance and Latency
Performance and latency can impact your drawing and writing experience. Both Pencils offer excellent performance, but the Apple Pencil 2nd generation typically has slightly lower latency, resulting in a more immediate and responsive feel. This is particularly noticeable during fast strokes or when creating detailed illustrations. This means that the mark appears on the screen almost instantly. While both are very good, the 2nd generation offers a more fluid and less delayed experience, which benefits artists and note-takers alike.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Apple Pencil 1 If…
- You own an older iPad model that is only compatible with the first-generation Apple Pencil.
- You are on a budget and the Apple Pencil 1 is more affordable.
- You don’t need the advanced features of the second-generation Apple Pencil.
- You prefer the round design and don’t mind the Lightning connector for charging.
Buy Apple Pencil 2 If…
- You own a newer iPad model that supports the second-generation Apple Pencil.
- You want the convenience of magnetic charging and pairing.
- You want the double-tap gesture for quick tool switching.
- You prefer the flat-edge design for a more comfortable grip and easier attachment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What iPad models are compatible with Apple Pencil 1?
The Apple Pencil 1st generation is compatible with older iPad models, including the iPad (6th to 9th generation), iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), the 12.9-inch iPad Pro (1st and 2nd generation), and the 9.7-inch iPad Pro. Ensure your iPad model matches the Pencil generation to avoid compatibility issues. Check Apple’s website for an up-to-date compatibility list. This is key to a smooth experience.
Which iPads support Apple Pencil 2?
The Apple Pencil 2nd generation works with newer iPad models such as the iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad mini (6th generation), and various iPad Pro models (3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation). These iPads feature a magnetic charging strip along the side. Make sure to check the exact iPad model before purchasing to ensure compatibility.
How does the Apple Pencil 2 charge?
The Apple Pencil 2 charges wirelessly. It magnetically attaches to the side of compatible iPads, and automatically starts charging. No external charging adapters are needed. This is a significant upgrade from the first generation, which used a Lightning port and adapter. The wireless charging is much more convenient.
Can I use the Apple Pencil 1 on an iPad that supports Apple Pencil 2?
No, you cannot use the Apple Pencil 1st generation on an iPad that only supports the Apple Pencil 2nd generation. The iPads designed for the second generation Pencil lack the Lightning port and the magnetic charging capability of the first generation. This makes them incompatible by design, so make sure to check what your iPad supports.
What are the main differences in design?
The Apple Pencil 1 has a glossy, cylindrical design with a Lightning connector cap. The Apple Pencil 2 has a matte, flat-edged design that magnetically attaches to the iPad for charging and pairing. The flat edge prevents rolling and makes it easier to attach. The overall feel and grip differs between the two, with the second generation feeling more comfortable for extended use.
Does the Apple Pencil 2 have any extra features?
Yes, the Apple Pencil 2 features double-tap gestures, allowing you to quickly switch between tools or activate other functions. It also has slightly lower latency, resulting in a more responsive feel. This added functionality is not present in the first generation, making the second generation more versatile for creative tasks. These are important features.
Which Apple Pencil is better for drawing?
The Apple Pencil 2nd generation is generally considered better for drawing due to its improved design, lower latency, and double-tap gestures. These features combine to offer a more fluid and intuitive drawing experience. Both are great, but the 2nd generation offers a slight edge in performance and functionality. This makes it a great choice.
Final Verdict
Both Apple Pencils offer excellent performance for creative tasks and note-taking. However, the Apple Pencil 2nd generation distinguishes itself through its improved design, wireless charging, and added features like double-tap gestures. While the Apple Pencil 1st generation remains a viable option, the 2nd generation provides a more seamless and versatile user experience.
Winner: Apple Pencil 2