Benchmade Autocrat vs Infidel: Which Otf Knife Reigns?
Choosing the right OTF (Out-The-Front) knife can be a daunting task, especially with so many high-quality options available. Two titans in the knife world often come up in the conversation: the Benchmade Autocrat and the Benchmade Infidel. Both are renowned for their rapid deployment and robust build, but which one truly deserves a spot in your collection?
The Benchmade Autocrat and Infidel represent the pinnacle of OTF technology, each boasting unique features and design philosophies. These knives are designed for those who demand the best in terms of performance and reliability. We’ll delve into the specifics of each, examining their strengths and weaknesses.
This comparison will help you navigate the nuances between the Autocrat and the Infidel. We’ll explore their build quality, blade designs, and overall user experience. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which knife is the best fit for your specific needs and preferences.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | Autocrat | Infidel |
|---|---|---|
| Blade Material | CPM-3V | CPM-S30V |
| Handle Material | Aluminum | Aluminum |
| Overall Length | 8.60″ | 8.53″ |
| Blade Length | 3.78″ | 3.50″ |
| Blade Style | Double Edge Dagger | Double Edge Dagger |
| Blade Finish | Black Cerakote | Black |
| Handle Color | Black | Black |
| Opening Mechanism | Automatic, OTF | Automatic, OTF |
| Pocket Clip | Tip-Down, Reversible | Tip-Down, Reversible |
| Weight | 4.00 oz | 3.00 oz |
| Lock Type | Button Lock | Button Lock |
| Country of Origin | USA | USA |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Blade Steel
- Benchmade Autocrat: Typically uses premium blade steels like CPM-D2 or CPM-S30V, known for excellent edge retention and corrosion resistance. However, some users may find sharpening these steels a bit more challenging.
- Infidel: Often features similar premium blade steels, such as CPM-S30V or CPM-154, offering good balance between hardness, toughness, and corrosion resistance. Like the Autocrat, sharpening can be an investment in time.
- Winner: Tie
Blade Style
- Benchmade Autocrat: Available in a variety of blade styles, including tanto, drop point, and double-edged options, offering versatility for different tasks. Double-edged blades are more restricted.
- Infidel: Commonly features a double-edged dagger blade, known for piercing and slicing capabilities. This style is not ideal for all cutting tasks and is restricted in some areas.
- Winner: Autocrat
Handle Material
- Benchmade Autocrat: Usually constructed with a durable and lightweight aluminum alloy handle, often with textured surfaces for improved grip. Aluminum can dent or scratch with heavy use.
- Infidel: Generally features an aluminum handle, similar to the Autocrat, providing a strong and secure grip. Aluminum’s vulnerability to scratches remains a factor.
- Winner: Tie
Deployment Mechanism
- Benchmade Autocrat: An automatic OTF (Out-The-Front) knife, utilizing a spring-loaded mechanism for rapid blade deployment and retraction. OTF mechanisms can be more prone to failure.
- Infidel: Also an OTF automatic knife, known for its swift and reliable blade action. OTF knives are more complex mechanisms than manual knives.
- Winner: Tie
Locking Mechanism
- Benchmade Autocrat: Integrated into the OTF mechanism. The lock is generally secure, but OTF knives can be susceptible to malfunctions.
- Infidel: The OTF design incorporates a locking mechanism, similar to the Autocrat, but with comparable potential for mechanical issues.
- Winner: Tie
Size and Weight
- Benchmade Autocrat: Typically a larger and heavier knife due to the OTF mechanism, potentially making it less pocket-friendly.
- Infidel: Generally similar in size and weight to the Autocrat, making it less practical for everyday carry for some users.
- Winner: Tie
Durability
- Benchmade Autocrat: Built with robust materials, but the OTF mechanism can be a point of potential failure. Regular maintenance is often required.
- Infidel: Similar to the Autocrat in terms of robust construction, with the OTF mechanism presenting a potential weakness.
- Winner: Tie
Legal Considerations
- Benchmade Autocrat: Automatic knives are subject to legal restrictions, varying by location. Check local laws before purchase and carry.
- Infidel: As an automatic knife, it shares the same legal limitations as the Autocrat, with strict regulations in many areas.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Blade Steel (Toughness) | Autocrat |
| Blade Steel (Edge Retention) | Autocrat |
| Weight | Infidel |
| Carryability | Infidel |
| Handle Material | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Automatic Opening: Both knives feature an Out-The-Front (OTF) automatic opening mechanism, providing rapid blade deployment with a push of a button. This makes them ideal for quick access and one-handed operation.
- Double-Edged Blade: Both the Autocrat and Infidel boast a double-edged dagger blade, offering symmetrical cutting capabilities and a piercing point. This design enhances versatility for various cutting tasks.
- Aluminum Handles: Both knives utilize aluminum for their handles, providing a balance of strength, durability, and a comfortable grip. The aluminum construction ensures a robust and reliable feel in hand.
- Reversible Pocket Clip: Both knives come equipped with a reversible pocket clip, allowing for tip-down carry and offering ambidextrous usability. This feature caters to both left- and right-handed users.
- Button Lock Mechanism: Both knives use a button lock mechanism, a secure and reliable system for blade deployment and locking. This ensures safe and controlled operation.
Benchmade Autocrat Vs Infidel Buying Guide
Blade Steel and Performance
Consider the blade steel used in both knives. The Benchmade Autocrat often features premium steels like CPM-154, known for its excellent edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening. The Infidel may use similar high-quality steels, or potentially slightly different formulations. Evaluate your intended use: if you need a blade that holds an edge for extended periods and resists wear, the Autocrat’s steel might be preferable. Think about how much you will sharpen the blade in field conditions. Factors such as the type of metal, the thickness, and the grind of the blade all impact performance.
Handle Materials and Ergonomics
Handle materials significantly affect grip, durability, and overall feel. Both the Autocrat and Infidel typically employ robust handles, often made of aluminum or similar alloys. The Autocrat’s handle design might prioritize ergonomics with contoured grips and strategically placed jimping for secure handling in various conditions. The Infidel’s handle may focus on a different aesthetic, potentially with a more streamlined profile. Assess which handle design best suits your hand size and preferred grip style. Consider the handle’s resistance to wear, impact, and exposure to the elements.
Mechanism and Reliability
Both knives are automatic OTF (Out-The-Front) knives, so the mechanism is crucial. The Autocrat and Infidel’s mechanisms are designed for reliable and consistent blade deployment and retraction. However, consider the manufacturer’s reputation for build quality and customer reviews regarding the mechanism’s long-term durability. Look for features like strong springs and secure locking mechanisms. Evaluate whether the mechanism is easy to operate with one hand and in various conditions. A well-built OTF mechanism will withstand rigorous use and provide peace of mind.
Size, Weight, and Carry Options
The size and weight of a knife influence its portability and everyday carry (EDC) suitability. The Autocrat and Infidel have similar profiles, yet might vary slightly in length and weight. Consider how you intend to carry the knife: pocket carry, belt carry, or other methods. Think about how the knife will fit in your pocket or on your belt. A lighter knife might be preferred for EDC, while a larger, heavier knife might be more suitable for heavier-duty tasks. Also consider the carry system such as a pocket clip.
Aesthetics and Design Preferences
Personal preferences play a significant role in choosing a knife. The Autocrat and Infidel offer distinct designs, each with its own aesthetic appeal. The Autocrat may have a more tactical or utilitarian appearance, while the Infidel might have a more aggressive or stylized look. Consider the blade shape, handle design, and overall finish. Think about the knife’s visual appeal and how it complements your personal style. Choose the knife that you find most visually appealing and that reflects your preferences.
Legal Considerations and Local Regulations
Before purchasing either knife, research the legal restrictions regarding automatic knives in your area. Laws vary significantly by location, and some jurisdictions may prohibit the ownership, carry, or use of OTF knives. Familiarize yourself with the regulations in your state, county, and city. Ensure that possessing and carrying the chosen knife is legal in all the places you intend to use it. Failure to comply with local laws can result in legal consequences and potential confiscation of the knife.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy benchmade autocrat If…
- You prefer a slightly larger and heavier knife for a more substantial feel in hand.
- You prioritize CPM-3V steel for its exceptional toughness and edge retention.
- You value the specific aesthetics and design elements of the Autocrat.
- You want a knife with a more aggressive blade profile.
Buy infidel If…
- You prefer a lighter and more compact knife for easier everyday carry.
- You prefer CPM-S30V steel for its good balance of edge retention and corrosion resistance.
- You like the Infidel’s specific handle design and overall look.
- You desire a slightly more streamlined and discreet profile.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference between the Benchmade Autocrat and Infidel?
The main difference lies in the design, aesthetics, and sometimes the specific materials used. While both are OTF automatics, the Autocrat often emphasizes a more tactical look with a focus on ergonomics and blade steel, whereas the Infidel may have a more aggressive or stylized appearance and different handle designs. The exact specifics can vary depending on the model and production run.
Are these knives legal to carry everywhere?
No, the legality of carrying the Autocrat or Infidel depends on local laws. Many jurisdictions have restrictions on automatic knives, including OTF models. Research your local regulations before purchasing or carrying either knife. Laws can vary significantly by state, county, and even city, so it’s essential to be informed.
What kind of maintenance is required for these knives?
Regular maintenance is crucial for both knives. This includes cleaning the blade and mechanism, lubricating moving parts with a suitable knife lubricant, and periodically checking and tightening screws. Avoid harsh chemicals and ensure the knife is stored in a clean, dry environment to prevent corrosion and maintain smooth operation of the OTF mechanism. Keep the blade sharp.
What blade steel is typically used in the Autocrat?
The Benchmade Autocrat often features high-quality blade steels like CPM-154. CPM-154 is known for its excellent balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening, making it a popular choice for high-performance knives. The specific steel used may vary depending on the production run or model variant. Check manufacturer specifications.
How does the OTF mechanism work?
The OTF (Out-The-Front) mechanism involves a blade that deploys and retracts directly out of the front of the handle. This is typically achieved using internal springs and a firing button or switch. When activated, the spring rapidly pushes the blade out; retracting the blade requires another button or lever. The Autocrat and Infidel utilize robust mechanisms.
Are replacement parts available for these knives?
Yes, replacement parts may be available depending on the manufacturer and model. Benchmade, for example, often offers repair services and may provide replacement parts for certain components. Contact the manufacturer or an authorized dealer to inquire about specific replacement parts and repair services for your knife. Parts availability can vary.
Which knife is better for everyday carry?
The best choice for everyday carry depends on personal preferences and needs. Both are OTF knives. The Autocrat’s ergonomics, size, and blade steel are designed for use. Consider the size, weight, and carry options, as well as the local legal regulations. Choose the knife that best suits your daily activities and personal preferences.
Final Verdict
Both the Benchmade Autocrat and the Infidel are high-quality OTF automatic knives, each with its own strengths. The Autocrat often edges out the Infidel with its superior blade steel and ergonomic design, making it slightly more versatile for a wider range of tasks. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual needs and preferences.
Winner: Benchmade Autocrat