Apple Pencil 1st Generation vs 2nd Generation: Which to Buy?
Choosing the right Apple Pencil can feel a bit overwhelming, especially with two generations to consider. Are you wondering which one best suits your needs and budget? This comparison delves into the key differences between the Apple Pencil 1st generation and the Apple Pencil 2nd generation, so you can make an informed decision.
The Apple Pencil revolutionized how we interact with iPads, offering a natural and intuitive way to draw, write, and navigate. The original Apple Pencil, released in 2015, set the stage for a new era of digital creativity. The 2nd generation, introduced later, brought several improvements to the table.
We’ll examine design, features, and compatibility to help you determine which Apple Pencil is the perfect fit for your iPad. Whether you’re a seasoned artist, a student taking notes, or simply enjoy the convenience of a stylus, this guide will provide the insights you need.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Apple Pencil 1st Gen | Apple Pencil 2nd Gen |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | iPad (6th to 9th gen), iPad Air (3rd gen), iPad mini (5th gen), iPad Pro 12.9-inch (1st & 2nd gen), iPad Pro 9.7-inch, 10.5-inch | iPad mini (6th gen), iPad Air (4th & 5th gen), iPad Pro 12.9-inch (3rd to 6th gen), iPad Pro 11-inch (1st to 4th gen) |
| Charging | Lightning Connector (charges via iPad or separate adapter) | Magnetic Wireless Charging |
| Pairing | Lightning Connector (pairs via iPad) | Magnetic Attachment to iPad (pairs automatically) |
| Double Tap Gesture | No | Yes (Customizable) |
| Pressure Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Tilt Sensitivity | Yes | Yes |
| Tip | Replaceable | Replaceable |
| Length | 6.92 inches | 6.53 inches |
| Diameter | 0.35 inches | 0.35 inches |
| Weight | 0.73 ounces | 0.70 ounces |
| Color | White | White |
| Storage | Requires a cap to store | Attaches magnetically to iPad for storage |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Design and Charging
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Cylindrical design with a glossy finish. It charges via a Lightning connector (either directly into the iPad or with an included adapter). The charging method can be awkward and prone to breaking.
- 2nd Generation: Flat-edged design that magnetically attaches and charges wirelessly to the side of compatible iPads. This design is more ergonomic and convenient.
- Winner: 2nd Gen
Pairing
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Pairs via the Lightning connector, which can be somewhat cumbersome. Requires physical connection to the iPad for pairing.
- 2nd Generation: Pairs automatically when attached magnetically to the iPad. Extremely simple and seamless.
- Winner: 2nd Gen
Double-Tap Gesture
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Does not have a double-tap gesture for quick tool switching.
- 2nd Generation: Features a customizable double-tap gesture on the side of the pencil for switching between tools (e.g., pen and eraser).
- Winner: 2nd Gen
Compatibility
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Compatible with older iPad models that have a Lightning port.
- 2nd Generation: Compatible with newer iPad models that support magnetic charging and pairing (e.g., iPad Air 4th gen and later, iPad Pro 3rd gen and later).
- Winner: 2nd Gen (due to more modern iPad compatibility)
Latency
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Offers low latency, but slightly higher than the 2nd generation.
- 2nd Generation: Boasts even lower latency, resulting in a more responsive and natural writing/drawing experience.
- Winner: 2nd Gen
Pressure Sensitivity
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Offers excellent pressure sensitivity, allowing for varied line weights.
- 2nd Generation: Provides the same excellent pressure sensitivity as the first generation.
- Winner: Tie
Tilt Sensitivity
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Also features tilt sensitivity, allowing for shading effects.
- 2nd Generation: Offers the same tilt sensitivity as the first generation.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Typically less expensive than the 2nd generation.
- 2nd Generation: More expensive than the 1st generation.
- Winner: 1st Gen (if budget is a primary concern)
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Compatibility | Apple Pencil 1st Gen (Wider range of older iPads) |
| Charging Convenience | Apple Pencil 2nd Gen |
| Pairing | Apple Pencil 2nd Gen |
| Features | Apple Pencil 2nd Gen |
| Overall Experience | Apple Pencil 2nd Gen |
What They Have in Common
- Pressure Sensitivity: Both Apple Pencil generations offer excellent pressure sensitivity, allowing for varied line weights and shading based on how hard you press the tip against the screen.
- Tilt Sensitivity: Both models support tilt sensitivity, which enables you to create shading effects by angling the pencil, mimicking the effect of a traditional pencil or brush.
- Low Latency: Both pencils provide a responsive and low-latency experience, ensuring that the strokes appear instantly on the screen, creating a natural feel.
- Palm Rejection: Both generations feature palm rejection technology, allowing you to rest your hand on the screen without interfering with your drawing or writing.
- Replaceable Tips: Both Apple Pencil generations use replaceable tips, so you can continue to use the stylus even if the tip wears down.
Apple Pencil 1st vs 2nd Generation Buying Guide
Compatibility
Understanding compatibility is crucial. The 1st generation Apple Pencil works with older iPad models that have a Lightning port, while the 2nd generation is designed for newer iPads with a USB-C port and a magnetic charging/pairing surface. Ensure your iPad model is compatible with the chosen Apple Pencil. Check Apple’s official website or your iPad’s specifications to confirm the correct generation.
Charging and Pairing
Charging and pairing methods differ significantly. The 1st generation Apple Pencil charges via a Lightning port on the iPad or with an included adapter. It pairs via Bluetooth. The 2nd generation magnetically attaches to the iPad and charges wirelessly, also pairing via magnetic connection. The 2nd generation’s charging is more convenient and streamlined.
Design and Ergonomics
The design also varies, with the 1st generation having a glossy, cylindrical design with a removable cap. The 2nd generation has a matte finish with a flat edge for magnetic attachment and a more ergonomic feel. The flat edge prevents rolling and makes it easier to attach to the iPad. The 2nd generation is generally considered more comfortable.
Features and Functionality
Both generations offer similar core functions like pressure sensitivity and tilt detection for drawing and writing. However, the 2nd generation introduces double-tap gestures to switch tools, offering a more intuitive workflow. The 2nd generation’s features provide a more seamless and efficient user experience. The user experience is therefore enhanced.
Cost and Value
The price points of each Apple Pencil generation can fluctuate. The 1st generation is often less expensive, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious users or those with older iPads. The 2nd generation, while pricier, offers advanced features and improved design. Consider your budget and the features you need when comparing the value.
Accessories and Extras
Consider any extra accessories you might need. The 1st generation Apple Pencil requires a Lightning port adapter for charging if your iPad doesn’t have a Lightning port. The 2nd generation doesn’t require any adapters for charging or pairing. Consider which accessories you might need and the total cost when making your decision.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Apple Pencil 1st generation If…
- You own an older iPad model that is not compatible with the 2nd generation.
- You are on a budget and the 1st generation is more affordable.
- You don’t need the magnetic charging or double-tap features.
Buy Apple Pencil 2nd generation If…
- You own a compatible iPad Pro or iPad Air model.
- You want the convenience of magnetic charging and pairing.
- You desire the double-tap gesture for quick tool switching.
- You prefer a more seamless and integrated experience with your iPad.
Frequently Asked Questions
What iPad models are compatible with the 1st generation Apple Pencil?
The 1st generation Apple Pencil is compatible with older iPad models, including the iPad (6th, 7th, 8th, 9th generation), iPad Air (3rd generation), iPad mini (5th generation), and iPad Pro (9.7-inch, 10.5-inch, and 12.9-inch 1st and 2nd generation). Always verify compatibility on Apple’s website.
What iPad models are compatible with the 2nd generation Apple Pencil?
The 2nd generation Apple Pencil is designed for newer iPad models. This includes the iPad Air (4th and 5th generation), iPad Pro (11-inch, 12.9-inch 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation), and iPad mini (6th generation). Check your iPad’s specifications.
How do I charge the 1st generation Apple Pencil?
The 1st generation Apple Pencil charges by plugging it into your iPad’s Lightning port directly, or with the included adapter to a Lightning cable. Remember to remove the cap. Ensure a stable connection to charge the Apple Pencil.
How do I charge the 2nd generation Apple Pencil?
The 2nd generation Apple Pencil charges wirelessly by magnetically attaching it to the side of your compatible iPad. The iPad automatically detects the pencil and begins charging. This method is more convenient than the 1st generation method.
Does the 2nd generation Apple Pencil have any extra features?
Yes, the 2nd generation Apple Pencil includes a double-tap gesture feature that allows you to quickly switch between tools, such as the eraser and pen, with a simple tap on the pencil’s barrel. This increases efficiency. This feature is a key differentiator.
Is the 2nd generation Apple Pencil more comfortable to hold?
Yes, the 2nd generation Apple Pencil features a more ergonomic design with a flat edge, making it more comfortable to hold for extended periods. The flat edge also prevents it from rolling off surfaces, improving usability and convenience. The matte finish also enhances grip.
Which Apple Pencil is better for drawing and note-taking?
Both generations are excellent for drawing and note-taking, offering pressure sensitivity and tilt detection. However, the 2nd generation’s added features, such as the double-tap gesture and improved ergonomics, make it slightly better for a more seamless and efficient experience, particularly for professional use.
Final Verdict
The 2nd generation Apple Pencil wins out due to its superior design, convenient wireless charging, double-tap gestures, and enhanced ergonomics. While the 1st generation remains a viable option for users with older iPads, the 2nd generation provides a more modern and user-friendly experience.
Winner: Apple Pencil 2nd Generation