Cayman vs 718 Cayman: Which Porsche Sports Car Reigns?
Dreaming of a Porsche? The iconic sports car brand has a rich history of performance and design, and two models often top the list for enthusiasts: the Cayman and the 718 Cayman. But which one deserves a spot in your garage?
This comparison dives deep into the heart of the matter, pitting the classic Porsche Cayman against its modern successor, the 718 Cayman. We’ll explore the key differences, from engine performance and handling to interior features and overall value proposition, to help you make an informed decision.
Get ready to uncover the nuances that separate these two amazing sports cars. Whether you’re a seasoned Porsche aficionado or new to the world of high-performance driving, this guide will provide valuable insights into the Cayman vs 718 Cayman debate.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Cayman | 718 Cayman |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | 2.7L/2.9L/3.4L Flat-6 | 2.0L/2.5L Turbo Flat-4 |
| Horsepower (Base) | 265 hp | 300 hp |
| Transmission | 6-speed manual / 7-speed PDK | 6-speed manual / 7-speed PDK |
| 0-60 mph (Base) | 5.4 sec | 4.9 sec |
| Torque (Base) | 206 lb-ft | 280 lb-ft |
| Curb Weight (Base) | 2,954 lbs | 3,043 lbs |
| Suspension | MacPherson Strut | MacPherson Strut |
| Steering | Electro-mechanical | Electro-mechanical |
| Infotainment System | Porsche Communication Management (PCM) | Porsche Communication Management (PCM) |
| Brakes | Disc brakes | Disc brakes |
| Fuel Economy (Combined) | 24 mpg | 27 mpg |
| Body Style | Coupe | Coupe |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Engine & Performance
- Cayman: Typically features a naturally aspirated flat-six engine, delivering strong power and a visceral driving experience. Offers excellent throttle response and a distinctive engine note. May feel less refined compared to newer turbocharged options.
- 718 Cayman: Employs a turbocharged flat-four engine (with some top-tier models offering a flat-six). Provides impressive acceleration and fuel efficiency. Some enthusiasts find the engine note less engaging than the previous generation’s flat-six.
- Winner: Tie
Handling & Dynamics
- Cayman: Known for its balanced handling and precise steering, offering a rewarding driving experience. Provides excellent feedback from the road. Suspension can feel firm, especially in sportier configurations.
- 718 Cayman: Maintains the Cayman’s reputation for exceptional handling, with a slightly more refined and composed feel. Offers improved stability and grip. Some drivers find the electronic aids slightly more intrusive.
- Winner: Tie
Exterior Design
- Cayman: Features a classic Porsche design language with clean lines and a timeless aesthetic. The overall look is sporty and elegant. May appear slightly dated compared to the 718.
- 718 Cayman: Boasts a more modern and aggressive design, with updated styling cues. Offers a refreshed look with improved aerodynamics. Some find the front end design polarizing.
- Winner: Tie
Interior & Technology
- Cayman: Provides a driver-focused cockpit with high-quality materials and a well-organized layout. Features older infotainment technology. Might lack some of the latest tech features found in newer models.
- 718 Cayman: Offers a more modern interior with updated infotainment and driver-assistance systems. Features improved connectivity options. The central touchscreen may not be as intuitive as some competitors.
- Winner: 718 cayman
Transmission Options
- Cayman: Available with both a manual transmission (highly sought after) and a PDK dual-clutch automatic. The manual offers a more engaging driving experience. PDK provides rapid shifts.
- 718 Cayman: Also available with both a manual and PDK. The PDK has been further refined. Manual transmission availability is a plus for purists.
- Winner: Tie
Fuel Efficiency
- Cayman: Generally offers respectable fuel economy for a sports car, but can be less efficient than the 718. Fuel consumption varies depending on the engine and driving style.
- 718 Cayman: Often achieves better fuel economy due to its turbocharged engines and updated technology. Offers improved efficiency without significantly sacrificing performance.
- Winner: 718 cayman
Price & Value
- Cayman: Can be found at a lower price point on the used market, representing good value for a sports car. Depreciation varies depending on the model year and condition.
- 718 Cayman: Generally has a higher starting price. Holds its value well due to its newer technology and performance.
- Winner: cayman
Sound & Exhaust Note
- Cayman: The flat-six engine provides a distinct and engaging exhaust note, appreciated by enthusiasts. Offers a more raw and authentic sound.
- 718 Cayman: The flat-four (especially) has a different sound, often described as less characterful than the flat-six. Some models offer sport exhaust options that improve the sound.
- Winner: cayman
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Engine Sound | Cayman |
| Low-End Torque | 718 Cayman |
| Fuel Efficiency | 718 Cayman |
| Acceleration | 718 Cayman |
| Classic Porsche Experience | Cayman |
What They Have in Common
- Mid-Engine Layout: Both the Cayman and 718 Cayman feature a mid-engine layout, which contributes to their balanced handling and exceptional driving dynamics. This placement of the engine enhances cornering ability and overall performance.
- Two-Seater Coupe: Both models are designed as two-seater coupes, emphasizing a sporty and driver-focused experience. This configuration prioritizes performance and a connection between the driver and the road.
- Porsche Dna: Both cars share the same Porsche DNA, providing a high level of build quality, performance, and luxurious appointments. This means a focus on driving pleasure.
- Excellent Handling: Both offer excellent handling characteristics, with precise steering and responsive chassis, making them a joy to drive on both the road and track. This is a core Porsche value.
- Available Pdk Transmission: Both models offer Porsche’s dual-clutch PDK transmission, providing quick and seamless gear changes, enhancing both performance and driving comfort. It is an option for both cars.
Cayman Vs 718 Cayman Buying Guide
Performance and Handling
The Cayman and 718 Cayman both deliver exceptional performance, but with subtle differences. The original Cayman, particularly the S and GTS variants, often featured naturally aspirated engines, providing a linear power delivery and a raw driving experience. The 718 Cayman, however, adopted turbocharged engines, offering more immediate torque and a slightly different character. Both cars boast precise handling, thanks to their mid-engine layout and well-tuned suspensions. The 718 Cayman’s updated chassis and electronic systems often offer a marginal edge in terms of on-track performance, but both cars provide an engaging and rewarding drive.
Engine and Drivetrain
The engine options are a key differentiator. The original Cayman offered a range of flat-six engines, known for their distinctive sound and smooth power delivery. These engines were naturally aspirated, providing a responsive throttle and a thrilling high-revving experience. The 718 Cayman transitioned to turbocharged flat-four engines (with the exception of the GT4/Spyder models), which offer increased torque at lower RPMs and improved fuel efficiency. Both cars feature rear-wheel drive, providing a classic sports car feel, with options for manual or PDK transmissions. The choice largely depends on your preference for engine sound and power delivery characteristics.
Interior and Features
Inside, both cars offer a driver-focused cabin with high-quality materials and a premium feel. The original Cayman provides a classic Porsche interior design, with a focus on functionality and simplicity. The 718 Cayman received updates in its interior, including a revised dashboard layout, a more modern infotainment system, and some updated materials. Both cars offer comfortable and supportive seats, a well-placed driving position, and a range of optional features, such as premium audio systems and advanced driver-assistance technologies. The 718 often incorporates more modern tech.
Styling and Design
The exterior styling is where the two models showcase their design evolution. The original Cayman had a sleek, understated design with a classic Porsche silhouette, characterized by its flowing lines and a distinctive roofline. The 718 Cayman features a more aggressive and modern design, with updated front and rear fascias, revised headlights and taillights, and a more sculpted appearance. The 718 also incorporated design elements that enhanced aerodynamics. Both cars have a timeless appeal, but the 718 reflects a more contemporary aesthetic, though the older model holds its own.
Cost of Ownership
The cost of ownership involves multiple factors. Both models are known for their reliability, but the 718 Cayman, being the newer model, might have slightly lower maintenance costs in the short term, due to its newer components. Insurance premiums may vary based on the specific model year, trim, and engine. Fuel efficiency is generally better in the 718 Cayman due to its turbocharged engines. However, the initial purchase price of the 718 Cayman will likely be higher than a comparable original Cayman. Consider all these factors when making your decision.
Resale Value
Resale value is a crucial factor. Both the Cayman and 718 Cayman generally hold their value well, as they are desirable sports cars. The original Cayman, especially well-maintained and low-mileage examples, can retain their value, as the naturally aspirated engines are highly sought after. The 718 Cayman also commands a strong resale value, influenced by its newer features and performance improvements. Factors such as the car’s condition, mileage, optional extras, and market demand will influence the final resale price of either vehicle. Consider the depreciation rate as a key factor in your decision.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Cayman If…
- You prefer the sound and feel of a naturally aspirated engine.
- You value the classic Porsche engine sound.
- You are looking for a slightly more affordable Porsche experience.
- You appreciate the gradual evolution of the Cayman design.
Buy 718 Cayman If…
- You desire more low-end torque and quicker acceleration.
- You prefer a more modern engine with turbocharging technology.
- You are looking for the latest technological advancements in a sports car.
- You enjoy the improved fuel efficiency of the 718.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main differences between the Cayman and 718 Cayman?
The primary differences lie in the engine and styling. The original Cayman featured naturally aspirated flat-six engines, while the 718 Cayman uses turbocharged flat-four engines (with the exception of GT4/Spyder models). Styling changes include revised front and rear fascias, and interior updates. The 718 Cayman often incorporates more modern technology and features. These updates reflect the evolution and advancements in the Porsche lineup.
Which car is faster?
The 718 Cayman, in many trims, offers slightly quicker acceleration due to its turbocharged engines and increased torque. However, the performance difference is not always significant, and performance depends on the specific engine and trim level. The GT4/Spyder models of the 718 provide a significant performance boost. Both cars deliver exhilarating performance, with the edge typically going to the 718 variants.
Which car is more fuel-efficient?
The 718 Cayman is generally more fuel-efficient, especially in city driving, due to its turbocharged engines. Turbocharging allows for greater efficiency under certain driving conditions. While the original Cayman’s fuel economy is decent, the 718 models often offer a slight advantage. Fuel economy depends on driving habits and the specific engine configuration.
Which car has a better interior?
The 718 Cayman features a more modern interior with a revised dashboard layout and a more up-to-date infotainment system. However, both cars offer high-quality materials and a driver-focused cabin. The choice depends on your preference for classic vs. modern Porsche design. The 718 also incorporates slight material upgrades. Both offer comfortable and supportive seats.
Which car is more expensive to maintain?
While both cars are generally reliable, the 718 Cayman, being the newer model, might have slightly lower maintenance costs in the short term, due to its newer components. However, this can vary based on the specific model year, trim, and how the car is driven. Maintenance costs depend on the car’s age, mileage, and the availability of parts.
Which car has better resale value?
Both cars hold their value well. However, the original Cayman, especially well-maintained and low-mileage examples, can retain their value due to the appeal of its naturally aspirated engines. The 718 Cayman also commands a strong resale value, influenced by its newer features and performance improvements. Resale value depends on condition and demand.
Which car is better for track use?
Both cars are excellent on the track. The 718 Cayman, particularly the GT4 and Spyder models, offers a slight advantage due to its updated chassis, performance upgrades, and improved electronic systems. The original Cayman, with proper modifications, can also perform exceptionally well on the track. The choice depends on the specific model and your track driving experience.
Final Verdict
Both the Cayman and 718 Cayman are exceptional sports cars, offering exhilarating performance and engaging driving experiences. The 718 Cayman provides a more modern feel with its turbocharged engines and updated technology, while the original Cayman offers a classic Porsche experience with its naturally aspirated engine. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences regarding engine sound, styling, and budget.
Winner: 718 Cayman