Ninja Grill BG500a vs DG551 – Which Should You Buy?

Choosing the right indoor grill can make a big difference in how you prepare healthy and flavorful meals at home. The Ninja Foodi Smart XL Grill DG551 and the Ninja Foodi Grill BG500A are two excellent options that cater to slightly different cooking needs. The DG551 is designed for precision with a built-in smart thermometer, while the BG500A focuses on versatile cooking performance with straightforward controls. This comparison will break down the important differences between the two so you can confidently decide which grill best suits your kitchen and lifestyle.

Side by Side Comparison

Detailed Feature Comparisons

Design and Construction: The DG551 has a slightly larger footprint with an XL capacity that suits bigger households or frequent entertainers. The BG500A is more compact, making it easier to fit on smaller countertops. Both feature a sleek matte finish and easy-to-clean ceramic-coated accessories.

Cooking Functions: The DG551 offers six cooking functions, including a dehydrate mode that allows you to make snacks like dried fruit or jerky. The BG500A covers the core grilling and air frying needs but omits the dehydrate function.

Smart Thermometer: The DG551 includes a built-in dual-sensor smart thermometer that tracks the temperature of your food and automatically adjusts cook times for perfect results. The BG500A requires manual checking, which may be better suited for experienced cooks who prefer full control.

Capacity: The DG551’s XL design accommodates more food in one batch, making it ideal for families or meal prepping. The BG500A’s capacity is slightly smaller but still works well for 2-4 servings.

Display and Controls: Both grills use a digital control panel, but the DG551 adds guided cooking programs tied to the smart thermometer. The BG500A’s panel is simpler with manual settings for temperature and time adjustments.

Performance: Both models deliver even heat distribution and quick preheat times. The DG551 stands out for its precision cooking results, particularly for meats that need specific doneness levels. The BG500A still provides excellent searing power but relies more on user monitoring.

Smoke Control: Both grills feature Ninja’s Smoke Control System that minimizes splatter and keeps kitchen air clear. The DG551’s slightly larger design handles more food without compromising smoke management.

Ease of Cleaning: Both units feature dishwasher-safe accessories like the cooking pot, grill grate, and crisper basket. The DG551’s thermometer probe also detaches for easy cleaning.

FAQ

Does the DG551 cook faster than the BG500A?
Both have similar heating elements and preheat speeds, but the DG551 can optimize cooking time based on the thermometer reading, which may lead to more consistent results.

Can I air fry in both models?
Yes, both grills include an air crisp function that allows you to air fry foods with little or no oil.

Which one is better for large families?
The DG551 is better for large families thanks to its XL capacity and ability to cook more food at once.

Is the smart thermometer removable?
Yes, the smart thermometer on the DG551 is removable and easy to clean after use.

Do both models have the same maximum temperature?
Yes, both can reach up to 500°F, which is perfect for high-heat searing and grilling.

Is there a big size difference between them?
The DG551 is slightly larger and heavier, so consider counter space if your kitchen is small.

Are the accessories interchangeable?
Some accessories may fit, but Ninja recommends using the accessories designed for each model to ensure proper performance.

Can I make jerky in the BG500A?
The BG500A does not have a dedicated dehydrate function, so jerky may not turn out as well compared to the DG551.