2ds Xl vs 3ds Xl: Which Nintendo Handheld Reigns Supreme?
Choosing a Nintendo handheld can feel like navigating a maze of features and options. The 2DS XL and 3DS XL, both popular choices, offer unique experiences for gamers. Deciding which one is right for you requires a closer look at their strengths and weaknesses.
The 2DS XL provides a streamlined, budget-friendly entry point into the world of Nintendo gaming. It boasts a clamshell design with a larger screen than the original 2DS and access to a vast library of games. On the other hand, the 3DS XL offers a more premium experience.
With its 3D capabilities and enhanced features, the 3DS XL presents a more immersive way to play. We’ll delve into the key differences between the 2DS XL and 3DS XL, comparing design, features, and overall value. This will help you make an informed decision and pick the best handheld for your gaming needs.
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | 2DS XL | 3DS XL |
|---|---|---|
| 3D Display | No | Yes |
| Screen Size (Top) | 4.88 inches | 4.88 inches |
| Screen Size (Bottom) | 4.18 inches | 4.18 inches |
| Weight | 10.7 ounces | 11.3 ounces |
| Built-in Stylus | Yes | Yes |
| Processor | Dual-core ARM11 | Dual-core ARM11 |
| Cameras | 2x Outer, 1x Inner | 2x Outer, 1x Inner |
| Game Compatibility | Nintendo 3DS, Nintendo DS | Nintendo 3DS, Nintendo DS |
| SD Card Slot | Yes (microSDHC) | Yes (SDHC) |
| Wireless Connectivity | Wi-Fi | Wi-Fi |
| Battery Life (estimated) | Up to 6 hours | Up to 6.5 hours |
| Design | Clamshell | Clamshell |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Design and Build
- 2ds Xl: Features a clamshell design, but lacks the 3D functionality. It’s generally lighter and more compact than the original 3DS XL, making it more portable. However, the build quality can feel slightly cheaper.
- 3ds Xl: Boasts a clamshell design with 3D capabilities. It’s built sturdier than the 2DS XL, with a more premium feel. However, it is slightly heavier and less compact when closed.
- Winner: Tie
3D Display
- 2ds Xl: Does not have a 3D display. This removes the need for the slider and eliminates the risk of accidental 3D activation. This feature caters to the younger audience.
- 3ds Xl: Features a stereoscopic 3D display that allows for a 3D effect without glasses. The 3D effect can be enjoyable but may cause eye strain for some users.
- Winner: 3ds xl
Screen Size
- 2ds Xl: Has the same screen size as the 3DS XL, meaning you get a large screen for gaming, despite the lack of 3D. This larger screen is great for enjoying games and reading text.
- 3ds Xl: Also features a larger screen, identical in size to the 2DS XL. This provides a comfortable viewing experience for extended gameplay.
- Winner: Tie
Weight and Portability
- 2ds Xl: Generally lighter and more compact due to its simpler design. This makes it slightly easier to carry around, especially for younger users or those who prioritize portability.
- 3ds Xl: Heavier than the 2DS XL due to the more complex hinge and 3D components. This can make it feel less comfortable to hold for extended periods.
- Winner: 2ds xl
Price
- 2ds Xl: Typically more affordable than the 3DS XL, making it a budget-friendly option for those new to the platform or who don’t need the 3D functionality.
- 3ds Xl: Usually more expensive than the 2DS XL due to the added 3D technology and more premium build.
- Winner: 2ds xl
Audio Quality
- 2ds Xl: Offers decent audio quality, similar to the 3DS XL. The speakers are located on the bottom and can be easily muffled.
- 3ds Xl: Delivers comparable audio quality to the 2DS XL. The speakers are located on the bottom and can be easily muffled.
- Winner: Tie
Battery Life
- 2ds Xl: Provides similar battery life to the 3DS XL. Expect around 3.5 to 6.5 hours of gameplay depending on the game and settings.
- 3ds Xl: Offers comparable battery life to the 2DS XL. Expect around 3.5 to 6.5 hours of gameplay depending on the game and settings.
- Winner: Tie
Game Compatibility
- 2ds Xl: Fully compatible with the entire library of Nintendo 3DS games (excluding those that rely heavily on 3D).
- 3ds Xl: Fully compatible with the entire library of Nintendo 3DS games, including those that utilize the 3D effect.
- Winner: Tie
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | 2DS XL |
| 3D Display | 3DS XL |
| Build Quality | 3DS XL |
| Game Selection | Tie |
| Portability | Tie |
What They Have in Common
- Game Library: Both consoles are compatible with the extensive library of Nintendo 3DS games, as well as the older Nintendo DS titles, offering a vast selection of games to choose from.
- Dual Screens: Both the 2DS XL and 3DS XL feature a dual-screen design, a hallmark of the Nintendo DS and 3DS families, providing a unique and engaging gaming experience.
- Controls: Both systems feature the standard Nintendo button layout, including a D-pad, face buttons, shoulder buttons, and an analog stick (circle pad), providing familiar and comfortable controls.
- Wireless Connectivity: Both consoles support Wi-Fi, allowing for online multiplayer gaming, accessing the Nintendo eShop, and downloading updates and game data.
- Backward Compatibility: Both consoles are backward compatible with Nintendo DS games, expanding the available game library even further.
2DS XL Buying Guide
Price and Availability
The 2DS XL often presents a more budget-friendly option compared to the 3DS XL, making it a great choice for cost-conscious buyers. Availability can fluctuate depending on the retailer and if it’s new or refurbished. Second-hand markets and online stores are key places to check if you’re looking for a good deal. Consider the condition and warranty when buying used, as prices can vary widely. While the 3DS XL might be pricier, it also offers more features. Always compare prices from different vendors before making a decision.
Design and Ergonomics
The 2DS XL features a clamshell design, making it more compact and portable, while the 3DS XL can feel slightly more substantial in hand. Ergonomics play a key role in comfort during extended gaming sessions. Test both consoles if possible to determine which design feels better to you, especially if you have larger hands. The 2DS XL’s flat design might be preferable for pocket storage, but the 3DS XL’s clamshell protects the screens more effectively. Consider how you intend to use it.
Screen and Display Quality
Both consoles offer similar screen sizes, but the 3DS XL features a 3D display, which is the main differentiator. The 2DS XL displays games in 2D only, which can be advantageous for players prone to motion sickness. The 3DS XL’s 3D effect can add immersion, but it’s not essential for gameplay. The 2DS XL screens might be slightly more resistant to scratches due to the lack of the 3D layer. Consider the importance of 3D to your gaming experience.
Game Library and Compatibility
Both the 2DS XL and 3DS XL are compatible with the vast library of Nintendo 3DS games. However, the 2DS XL cannot play games that require the 3D functionality. Check the game’s compatibility before purchasing, but most games are designed to work on both consoles. The Nintendo eShop provides access to digital downloads, and both consoles support physical cartridges. Consider your preferred genres and if you’re interested in titles specifically designed for 3D.
Features and Functionality
The 3DS XL includes additional features like the 3D slider and a slightly better camera. Both consoles feature Wi-Fi connectivity for online play and access to the Nintendo eShop. The 2DS XL and 3DS XL both have built-in cameras, though their quality isn’t top-tier. Features such as the StreetPass functionality are available on both, allowing you to interact with other players nearby. Consider which features are most important.
Battery Life and Performance
Battery life can vary depending on the game and screen brightness settings. The 3DS XL generally offers comparable battery life to the 2DS XL, sometimes slightly better. Performance is consistent across both consoles, as they share similar hardware. Consider how long you typically play in a single session. Always bring a charger if you play for extended periods. Consider that older models will have degraded battery life.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy 2DS XL If…
- You want a more affordable option.
- You aren’t interested in the 3D effect.
- You prefer a slightly more rugged design.
- You are buying for a younger child.
Buy 3DS XL If…
- You want the 3D display feature.
- You prefer the premium feel and build quality.
- You value the slightly longer battery life.
- You want the best possible gaming experience on a handheld.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between the 2DS XL and 3DS XL?
The primary difference is the 3D functionality. The 3DS XL features a 3D display, allowing games to be viewed in three dimensions without glasses. The 2DS XL, conversely, displays games in 2D only. Other differences include design and sometimes slightly better camera features on the 3DS XL.
Can I play all 3DS games on the 2DS XL?
Yes, you can play almost all 3DS games on the 2DS XL. However, games that are specifically designed to take advantage of the 3D effect on the 3DS XL will be displayed in 2D on the 2DS XL. So, nearly all games will work just fine.
Which console is better for younger children?
The 2DS XL might be a better choice for younger children. Its flat design is more durable, and the lack of 3D can prevent potential eye strain. The 2DS XL is also typically more affordable, which is a consideration when purchasing for children.
Does the 2DS XL feel less premium than the 3DS XL?
The 3DS XL has a more premium feel due to its clamshell design and the 3D features. The 2DS XL has a more budget-oriented design. Both are made of durable plastic. Ultimately, the feeling of “premium” is subjective and dependent on the user’s preferences.
Are there any games exclusive to the 3DS XL?
No, there are no games exclusive to the 3DS XL. All games designed for the Nintendo 3DS are playable on both the 2DS XL and 3DS XL, although the 3D effect will not be present on the 2DS XL. The selection of games is identical.
Does the 2DS XL have a better screen than the 3DS XL?
The screen size and resolution are the same on both consoles. However, the 3DS XL has a 3D display, while the 2DS XL features a 2D display. The quality of the screens is similar. The 3DS XL offers the potential for a 3D viewing experience.
Which console offers better battery life?
Battery life is comparable between the 2DS XL and 3DS XL, generally offering a few hours of gameplay. However, battery life can vary depending on the game, screen brightness, and the use of the 3D feature on the 3DS XL. It’s best to check individual game reviews.
Final Verdict
The 2DS XL offers a great value proposition for players seeking a budget-friendly and durable handheld. While the 3DS XL provides the added dimension of 3D, the 2DS XL provides a solid alternative, especially if the 3D effect is not a priority. Both systems offer access to the extensive 3DS game library.
Winner: 3DS XL